QUOTE(Norseman82 @ Nov 25 2005, 06:59 PM)
There are some very troubling attitudes I've found among Catholics about marriage - some due to creeping Calvinistic influences, some due to suburban snotty cliquishness, some due to the lesbo-feminazi heresy that was born in the advent of the "contraception culture" of the 1960s and 1970s. I will debunk several of them here from scripture, official church teaching, and from personal stories I've been told.
1) First, I AM A CATHOLIC, NOT A CALVINIST. I don't believe in a micromanaging God; He gave me free will. See Sirach 15:11-20. Therefore, I'm getting a little tired of being second-guessed for wanting to get married or being told that I need to wait for a girl that God specially prepared for me. What official evidence does anyone have that God chooses who our spouses are or if we will even get married (I'm not talking about knowing who we will eventually marry or if we will get married). Such manipulation is dangerous in two senses:
a) Using religion to micromanage and manipulate, or to think you have some private line to God as far as to what He wants for everyone's lives, is a hallmark of religious cults, not the true Church;
b) Constantly second-guessing can lead to a loss of confidence and inability to make a decision and paranoia and who knows what other mental problems. I don't know if that's acceptable for females, but for MALES that can be deadly.
Besides, as someone once posted here, as long as a person is not sinning or going against Church policy, WHO IS ANYONE TO QUESTON WHETHER OR NOT THEY ARE FOLLOWING GOD'S WILL????
Also, CCC 2230: "When they become adults, children have the right and duty to choose their profession and state of life. They should assume their new responsibilites within a trusting relationship with their parents, willingly asking and receiving their advice and counsel. Parents should be careful not to exert pressure on their chidlren either in the choice of a profession or in that of a spouse". Get it? Our state of life and who we marry is LEFT TO OUR CHOICE. This comes straight from the Cathechism! If anyone has a problem with that, it is the Church they have a problem with, not me.
2) YOU NEED TO BE CALLED TO MARRIAGE??? If we start to adopt a policy that only certain people are called to be married, that leads to elitism. One of my friends calls it "marriage Jansenism". Besides, the Cathechism of the Catholic Church paragraph 1603 states that "The vocation of marriage is written in the very nature of man and woman as they came from the hand of the Creator". Marriage is part of human nature, and people who try to restrict it are messing with human nature. If you disagree with this, you are not disagree with me but with the Church, whether out of lack of knowledge or outright heresy.
3) THE WHOLE "THAT IS NOT A VALID REASON TO GET MARRIED" CONROVERSY (see previous posts in this thread). Excuse me, but who appointed anyone the official arbitrer of what is not a good reason to get married? It was said that "loneliness" or "fear of dying alone" is not a reason to get married. BALONEY!!!!!! IT MOST CERTAINLY IS!!!!! Here are the reasons:
a) I wonder how many people who say such hurtful things themselves have families and are in no danger of dying alone? They should put themselves in the other person's shoes and learn what life is like on the other side of the tracks, otherwise they are being hypocritical. Besides, who are they to impose the burden of loneliness and dying alone on another person who is eligible to marry in the Church? Laying heavy burdens on people and not lifting a finger to carry them is a characteristic not of a Christian, but of a pharisee (Mt. 23:3-4). Remember what Christ said about pharisees? Read the rest of Matthew 23. He called them "frauds" (v. 15), "blind guides" (v.24), "whitewashed tombs" (v. 27), "vipers nests" and "brood of serpents" (v. 33).
b) I remember a seminarian stating that the hard part about celibacy is not the physical part, but projecting yourself into your 40s and 50s and seeing other people in your age group with children and grandchildren. So if loneliness and lack of family is something to consider when discerning a vocation to a religious state of life (and whether or not to be a non-religious single, since both have to practice celibacy) , then why would anyone deny it as a factor in wantng to get married???? Such illogic astounds me!!!!!!! Yes, Paul said that the unmarried can serve the Lord better (1 Cor. 7:32-35), but he also said that it is better to be married than to be on fire if one cannot exercise self-control (1 Cor. 7:8-9). Did not Christ Himself say that "not everyone is given to do so" regarding accepting the teaching of being better not to marry (Matthew 19:10-11)? Did he not refer to people who FREELY embrace celibacy (I'm paraphrasing here due differing translations of Matthew 19:12)? So if Christ and Paul acknowledge that not everyone can handle celibacy, then why can't people today realize that? It boggles my mind!!!
Now, I'm not saying that loneliness can lead to hasty decisions, but it is quite another thing to fault a person for taking steps to prep themselves for marriage because they don't want to be alone for the rest of their lives.
4) YOU'RE DESPERATE. While I agree that it can lead to hasty decisions, I need to ask the following:
a) What is the Christian response to someone in a desperate situation? Is it avoidance? Mocking? Or is it to meet their needs? See Acts 6:1-6.
b) Just as we cannot complain that a child's stomach is grumbling from hunger if we haven't fed him/her, I really wonder how much desperaton in other people is caused by us by our ignoring and rejecting them and whether it is really valid to complain about it????
[right][snapback]800380[/snapback][/right]
You made a lot of valid points, it's sad to see how some people have the "Marriage is for me, and not for you" attuide. Of course, we should pray for one another that we all will make the right decisions.