Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Jackpot!
phatmass phorum > The Pharm Yard > Debate Table
be_thou_my_vision
Check THIS out! Franciscan communities from all around the world! WOW!
And THIS has information about all orders of all spiritualities... can you tell I'm bored?
Have fun!
AlterDominicus
Bored? You? HA! lol_pound.gif













Yeahhhhh......happens to me allllll the time. snore.gif snore.gif
Scholastica
happy.gif Happy vocation hunting
Veritas
QUOTE(be_thou_my_vision @ Apr 21 2007, 07:52 PM) [snapback]1252133[/snapback]
Check THIS out! Franciscan communities from all around the world! WOW!
And THIS has information about all orders of all spiritualities... can you tell I'm bored?
Have fun!


+

Sad to say, there are a lot of unfaithful religious communities here. I would approach this link with great caution and stick with the CMSWR at: http://www.cmswr.org/ and the list of other faithful religious communities, who are not CMSWR members, compiled previously on phatmass.

Blessings in Jesus and Mary,
V
csj
QUOTE(Veritas @ Apr 21 2007, 09:29 PM) [snapback]1252327[/snapback]
+

Sad to say, there are a lot of unfaithful religious communities here. I would approach this link with great caution and stick with the CMSWR at: http://www.cmswr.org/ and the list of other faithful religious communities, who are not CMSWR members, compiled previously on phatmass.

Blessings in Jesus and Mary,
V


Unfaithful? I looked at the list quickly and don't see any that are not in communion with the church. What makes you so sure that they are unfaithful, they are more conservative, more liberal then you? I'm sure they're more conservative or liberal then the Vatican, local diocese & members of thier own community. Yet none of them have deemed them unfaithful. What are you basing this on?

As a member of a community not in CMSWR, I am very offended by the implication you've made. Each community that is in communion with the church has many varied gifts to offer to God's world. I would not presume to judge anyone of them unfaithful.
williamb
As the editor of Catholicism/Orders on ODP, I am very careful not to add orders which are not in communion with the church, however if you are in communion with the church I cannot discriminate over who has the lowest hemline on their habit or the veil with least hair showing. So get over it. In fact if you want to know the truth in the 7 years I have edited this I have received very little comments of praise or criticism from the catholic religious community. It tends to be hangers on and oddball wannabes who cause trouble if anything. I have asked for help and input many times over the years and have received very little.
puellapaschalis
Veritas, those two congregations everyone here is always on about are USA congregations. Some of us aren't in the USA and aren't looking at orders in the USA, and thus those websites aren't particularly helpful. A page like this from dmoz, however, is actually worldwide, and a sight moreso. Please try to be a little bit more positive.

PP
Jennirom
QUOTE(be_thou_my_vision @ Apr 22 2007, 01:52 AM) [snapback]1252133[/snapback]
Check THIS out! Franciscan communities from all around the world! WOW!
And THIS has information about all orders of all spiritualities... can you tell I'm bored?
Have fun!



Thank you forsharing..........I cannot imagine that you are ever bored !!! lol_sign.gif
Cathoholic Anonymous
I second PP. It's always good to see directories of orders that aren't based in America. I used to be quite jealous of the American PMers as you all seem to have much more choice when it comes to religious communities. Now I've realised that there are several excellent communities in England and on the Continent that just don't get publicity, so I'm always glad to see them making an appearance. smile.gif
puellapaschalis
QUOTE(Cathoholic Anonymous @ Apr 22 2007, 03:56 PM) [snapback]1252851[/snapback]
I second PP. It's always good to see directories of orders that aren't based in America. I used to be quite jealous of the American PMers as you all seem to have much more choice when it comes to religious communities. Now I've realised that there are several excellent communities in England and on the Continent that just don't get publicity, so I'm always glad to see them making an appearance. smile.gif


Perhaps we ought to make more of an effort to help williamb in his efforts, especially with the websites that aren't in English.

PP
alicemary
personally, I enjoy reading any websites that are around. I always seem to obtains something positive from it and so many times, with an open mind, I find a useful kernel or two of wisdom. It matters little to me if their habit is short or long, their hair shows, they pray in Dutch or hopscotch on Saturday night for fun. As to overseas websites, I look at them too with the same interest. We all need to remember that charity is foremost on this board.
Incarnate Word Postulant
I want to say that in a certain way I understand the sadness you feel when members of religious communities act against Church teachings. It is sad that by their actions they choose to not be in communion with the Church. However, as an individual I can not judge a whole community, a whole congregation, order, or council.

Do I pray for these people? I sure do, but I pray that God's will be done, not my own. I pray that their public actions of rebellion, or ignorance, or hurt, do not affect my heart. In the end, my vocation rests in God's hands.

I also want to say that when we have not lived in community it is very easy to idealize religious life. But religious life is hard! We are not perfect, whether we wear a habit or not. Let's ask ourselves what good it does to our vocations to rant in anger for the errors or suppossed errors of others? It is not good for our hearts. It is not good for our vocations. It is not good for our world.

I pray for each one of you, that you will love like Jesus and that you will use your youth and your fire for God, that you pray uncesantly and love with a love that never says enough .

I will not be coming back to phatmass. If anybody wants to write to me please do so at:
helgaleija@yahoo.com.mx or

Sr. Mary Helga
2930 S. Alameda
Corpus Christi, TX 78404

And remember to act justly, to love tenderly and to walk humbly with our God
be_thou_my_vision
QUOTE(Incarnate Word Postulant @ Apr 22 2007, 02:54 PM) [snapback]1253172[/snapback]
I want to say that in a certain way I understand the sadness you feel when members of religious communities act against Church teachings. It is sad that by their actions they choose to not be in communion with the Church. However, as an individual I can not judge a whole community, a whole congregation, order, or council.

Do I pray for these people? I sure do, but I pray that God's will be done, not my own. I pray that their public actions of rebellion, or ignorance, or hurt, do not affect my heart. In the end, my vocation rests in God's hands.

I also want to say that when we have not lived in community it is very easy to idealize religious life. But religious life is hard! We are not perfect, whether we wear a habit or not. Let's ask ourselves what good it does to our vocations to rant in anger for the errors or suppossed errors of others? It is not good for our hearts. It is not good for our vocations. It is not good for our world.

I pray for each one of you, that you will love like Jesus and that you will use your youth and your fire for God, that you pray uncesantly and love with a love that never says enough .

I will not be coming back to phatmass. If anybody wants to write to me please do so at:
helgaleija@yahoo.com.mx or

Sr. Mary Helga
2930 S. Alameda
Corpus Christi, TX 78404

And remember to act justly, to love tenderly and to walk humbly with our God

I will miss your charitable words and gentle presence on this phorum.
God Bless you, Sister.
Jenny
Veritas
+

For Example (and forgive me if it sounds terse, I just want to present the material directly):

Let me tell you about the non-habited LCWR sisters in my diocese:

They sponsor the "NEW WAYS" conference, which is totally heretical
They host the V-Monologues, which is an affront to modesty, decency, and women's dignity
They sponsor pro- GLBT events on their campuses and parishes
They support women's "ordination" on their campuses and parishes
They advocate abortion
They support contraception on their campuses
They persist in liturgical abuses like giving homilies
They supress Eucharistic Adoration
The speak-out publically against the bishop, pope, and magisterium
They incite dissent
They laugh in the face of their disobedience

Do these sound like good religious sisters to you? (these sisters were linked above)

They are the Sisters of Saint Joseph of Carondelet
The Sisters of Saint Benedict of Saint Benedict Monastery in Maplewood, MN
The Sisters of Saint Benedict of the College of Saint Benedict
The Franciscan Sisters of Perpetual Adoration in LaCrosse, WI
The Franciscan Sisters of Little Falls
Others

In my extensive experience, faithful LCWR sisters are the EXCEPTION, not, the rule. This is a horrific sadness and a travesty. But let us call things by their proper names. Innocent young women should not be ignorant of the agendas of these communities and that is why I am naming them above. They are well-developed, extensive, and heretical. Again, they have "good intentions" in their disobedience, but this is not enough. Ill-formed consciences are not an excuse when one does not do the proper work to form them. Ultimately, we must defer to the teachings of the Church! Let us pray for a return to authentic religious life in the vein of CMSWR communities.

In an English interview given in 2003, Pope Benedict, then Josef Cardinal Ratzinger, Prefect of the Congregation of Divine Faith, stated the greatest danger to the Church today: Becoming merely a social institution. In other words, it is good to provide the corporal works of mercy, but it is not enough to merit the carte blanche acceptance of the LCWR and its members
Veritas
QUOTE(csj @ Apr 22 2007, 12:21 AM) [snapback]1252645[/snapback]
Unfaithful? I looked at the list quickly and don't see any that are not in communion with the church. What makes you so sure that they are unfaithful, they are more conservative, more liberal then you? I'm sure they're more conservative or liberal then the Vatican, local diocese & members of thier own community. Yet none of them have deemed them unfaithful. What are you basing this on?

As a member of a community not in CMSWR, I am very offended by the implication you've made. Each community that is in communion with the church has many varied gifts to offer to God's world. I would not presume to judge anyone of them unfaithful.



+

It is not a question of being "liberal" or "conservative" that is a usurpation of political ideology and political terms. Religious communities are either corporately, and individually among their members, faithful or unfaithful to the teachings of the Church. MANY of these communities are corporately and indivdividually, unfaithful.

Do you really want us to start pointing everthing out? The name of this phorum is PHATmass for Preaching Holy Apostolic Truth. There are a bunch of communities linked above, that aren't doing that.

I think it is great that we post communities within a wide range of spiritualities and with a wide range of apostolates from all over the world. However, all should be orthodox communities living and teaching inline with the Pope and the Magisterium. That is what Vocation Station is about.
shortnun
QUOTE(Veritas @ Apr 22 2007, 08:33 PM) [snapback]1253536[/snapback]
+

For Example (and forgive me if it sounds terse, I just want to present the material directly):

Let me tell you about the non-habited LCWR sisters in my diocese:

They sponsor the "NEW WAYS" conference, which is totally heretical
They host the V-Monologues, which is an affront to modesty, decency, and women's dignity
They sponsor pro- GLBT events on their campuses and parishes
They support women's "ordination" on their campuses and parishes
They advocate abortion
They support contraception on their campuses
They persist in liturgical abuses like giving homilies
They supress Eucharistic Adoration
The speak-out publically against the bishop, pope, and magisterium
They incite dissent
They laugh in the face of their disobedience

Do these sound like good religious sisters to you? (these sisters were linked above)

They are the Sisters of Saint Joseph of Carondelet
The Sisters of Saint Benedict of Saint Benedict Monastery in Maplewood, MN
The Sisters of Saint Benedict of the College of Saint Benedict
The Franciscan Sisters of Perpetual Adoration in LaCrosse, WI
The Franciscan Sisters of Little Falls
Others

In my extensive experience, faithful LCWR sisters are the EXCEPTION, not, the rule. This is a horrific sadness and a travesty. But let us call things by their proper names. Innocent young women should not be ignorant of the agendas of these communities and that is why I am naming them above. They are well-developed, extensive, and heretical. Again, they have "good intentions" in their disobedience, but this is not enough. Ill-formed consciences are not an excuse when one does not do the proper work to form them. Ultimately, we must defer to the teachings of the Church! Let us pray for a return to authentic religious life in the vein of CMSWR communities.

In an English interview given in 2003, Pope Benedict, then Josef Cardinal Ratzinger, Prefect of the Congregation of Divine Faith, stated the greatest danger to the Church today: Becoming merely a social institution. In other words, it is good to provide the corporal works of mercy, but it is not enough to merit the carte blanche acceptance of the LCWR and its members

Veritas, haven't you posted this exact same post in another thread here? I do believe that many people have commented that we post charitably here. I would add that we do so prudently as well. I have difficulty seeing your recent posts as done out of charity or prudence.
Veritas
QUOTE(Incarnate Word Postulant @ Apr 22 2007, 03:54 PM) [snapback]1253172[/snapback]
I want to say that in a certain way I understand the sadness you feel when members of religious communities act against Church teachings. It is sad that by their actions they choose to not be in communion with the Church. However, as an individual I can not judge a whole community, a whole congregation, order, or council.

Do I pray for these people? I sure do, but I pray that God's will be done, not my own. I pray that their public actions of rebellion, or ignorance, or hurt, do not affect my heart. In the end, my vocation rests in God's hands.

I also want to say that when we have not lived in community it is very easy to idealize religious life. But religious life is hard! We are not perfect, whether we wear a habit or not. Let's ask ourselves what good it does to our vocations to rant in anger for the errors or suppossed errors of others? It is not good for our hearts. It is not good for our vocations. It is not good for our world.

I pray for each one of you, that you will love like Jesus and that you will use your youth and your fire for God, that you pray uncesantly and love with a love that never says enough .

And remember to act justly, to love tenderly and to walk humbly with our God


+

Sister makes several very good points. And, realizing, to discern tone via posts is difficult, I wish to make clear my good intentions for the holiness of all and the eternal home of heaven for all religious. I think it is important to address a few others, however:

1. The Holy Father has asked religious sisters to wear an identifiable habit, so yes, when sisters do not, that does reflect poorly on them.

2. That is not to say they do not do good social work.

3. Authentic religious life is about much more than social work.

4. No one is condemning anyone else to hell, that is the judgement we are not to make. However, in assessing the positives and negatives of individual and communal actions of religious, especially when they are seeking new membership on this board, we not only have the right, but the duty to be honest and direct in that assessment when those individuals and communities are teaching against the Church, often under the guise of "diversity" or "conscience". Dissent and subsequently sin, are two very serious things! And, as we are talking about communities of women, who are in leadership and formation roles of other women, children, and parish communities, we must call a spade a spade, even when it is unpleasant to do so.

5. Precisely because religious life is hard, religious women need to be grounded in prayer and glued to Jesus, Mary, the Saints, the Vicar of Christ and the Magisterium of the Church. We have seen the fruits of religious life when divorced from the above.

6. Now, what I have done by bringing all of this up, is only 1/2 of it, the other half is to pray, surrender, and love. We must not be deceived into thinking, however, that somehow it is not appropriate to discern, speak, and spread the truth about the agendas of certain groups of people, including religious. The enemy loves this kind of silence and young women and men deserve to know the truth.

Veritas
QUOTE(shortnun @ Apr 22 2007, 08:49 PM) [snapback]1253574[/snapback]
Veritas, haven't you posted this exact same post in another thread here? I do believe that many people have commented that we post charitably here. I would add that we do so prudently as well. I have difficulty seeing your recent posts as done out of charity or prudence.


+

Do you wish to address the content of what I have posted? I am simply stating the facts. Discerning women deserve to know the truth. That is not uncharitable. These sisters and the LCWR have been public dissenters and they have been publically admonished. If what I am is doing is somehow uncharitable, I ask for your charity and perhaps you can pm me a few suggestions. Again, I speak directly, and I know that does not often come across well via posting. I pray you will understand my intent is the salvation of souls ending in eternal happiness with Christ and that is the only reason I am posting.

The post you referenced was in response to the CSJ post. I can only assume she did not see it. Realizing what CSJ stands for, there is not doubt she will be offended because many of the CSJ works are completely incompatible with Church teaching. However, that is their defense against God, not mine.
be_thou_my_vision
Umm I think it would be a good idea to either move this thread to the debate portion of the phorum or close the thread.
I'm sorry this thread had to develop into this debate... I was just trying to expose some religious orders.


How do I move or close a thread anyway?


God Bless.
Veritas
QUOTE(be_thou_my_vision @ Apr 22 2007, 09:20 PM) [snapback]1253641[/snapback]
Umm I think it would be a good idea to either move this thread to the debate portion of the phorum or close the thread.
I'm sorry this thread had to develop into this debate... I was just trying to expose some religious orders.
How do I move or close a thread anyway?
God Bless.


+

A mod has to do it. But, yes, let's continue the debate! It is important to get at the truth of this, I think! We all need to be savy Catholics and that requires information and thinking logically. There is nothing to be sorry about in having an honest intellectual discussion. The Church says Fides et Ratio smile.gif Let's get some other pm'ers into it!
be_thou_my_vision
Okay, then I would like to move this to the debate section... smile.gif
stlmom
Jenny, first of all, thanks for starting this thread in the first place. You contributed a useful resource. Yes, some of the links include orders whose reforms have gone flat. The natural consequences to them will be that their survival as a community will fade over time. We're already seeing this happen. The need of "exposing the truth", as stated in another's post, is unnecessary and unproductive here, and does not fit with the focus of VS. A few of you on this phorum need to get a life.
Maggie
QUOTE
A few of you on this phorum need to get a life.


Ouch! stretcher.gif
EJames
QUOTE(Veritas @ Apr 22 2007, 04:33 PM) [snapback]1253536[/snapback]
+

For Example (and forgive me if it sounds terse, I just want to present the material directly):

Let me tell you about the non-habited LCWR sisters in my diocese:

They sponsor the "NEW WAYS" conference, which is totally heretical
They host the V-Monologues, which is an affront to modesty, decency, and women's dignity
They sponsor pro- GLBT events on their campuses and parishes
They support women's "ordination" on their campuses and parishes
They advocate abortion
They support contraception on their campuses
They persist in liturgical abuses like giving homilies
They supress Eucharistic Adoration
The speak-out publically against the bishop, pope, and magisterium
They incite dissent
They laugh in the face of their disobedience

Do these sound like good religious sisters to you? (these sisters were linked above)

They are the Sisters of Saint Joseph of Carondelet
The Sisters of Saint Benedict of Saint Benedict Monastery in Maplewood, MN
The Sisters of Saint Benedict of the College of Saint Benedict
The Franciscan Sisters of Perpetual Adoration in LaCrosse, WI
The Franciscan Sisters of Little Falls
Others

In my extensive experience, faithful LCWR sisters are the EXCEPTION, not, the rule. This is a horrific sadness and a travesty. But let us call things by their proper names. Innocent young women should not be ignorant of the agendas of these communities and that is why I am naming them above. They are well-developed, extensive, and heretical. Again, they have "good intentions" in their disobedience, but this is not enough. Ill-formed consciences are not an excuse when one does not do the proper work to form them. Ultimately, we must defer to the teachings of the Church! Let us pray for a return to authentic religious life in the vein of CMSWR communities.

In an English interview given in 2003, Pope Benedict, then Josef Cardinal Ratzinger, Prefect of the Congregation of Divine Faith, stated the greatest danger to the Church today: Becoming merely a social institution. In other words, it is good to provide the corporal works of mercy, but it is not enough to merit the carte blanche acceptance of the LCWR and its members

'He who is not with me, is against me"...by you know who..(not George Bush)
The catholic Church Fullness of Truth THE Body of Christ,living on earth
Staretz
I would love to see more links and info regarding monastic communities outside North America. It is good to see flourishing communities anywhere smile.gif
Veritas
QUOTE(Staretz @ Apr 23 2007, 05:58 AM) [snapback]1253967[/snapback]
I would love to see more links and info regarding monastic communities outside North America. It is good to see flourishing communities anywhere smile.gif


+

Is there a special thread anywhere for non North American communities? Maybe we could start one smile.gif
Veritas
QUOTE(stlmom @ Apr 22 2007, 10:46 PM) [snapback]1253766[/snapback]
The need of "exposing the truth", as stated in another's post, is unnecessary and unproductive here, and does not fit with the focus of VS.


+

Who says?
be_thou_my_vision
Dear Moderators,
Please close this thread.
Love,
Jenny
Lil Red
moved to debate table
Veritas
QUOTE(Lil Red @ Jun 29 2007, 01:12 AM) *
moved to debate table


+

I didn't know we were going to talk about it again. It's been a couple months, hasn't it?
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.