Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='FutureCarmeliteClaire' timestamp='1351702296' post='2501193']
38. ...In certain circumstances, it is morally permissible for a Catholic to vote for a candidate who supports some immoral practices while opposing other immoral practices. Catholic moral teaching refers to actions of this sort as material cooperation, which is morally permissible when certain conditions are met. With respect to the question of voting, these conditions include the following: [b]1) there is no [color=#ff0000]viable[/color] candidate who supports the moral law in its full integrity;[/b]
[/quote]
This is all I've been saying the whole time. Romney and Obama are the only [color=#ff0000][b]viable[/b][/color] candidates.

Posted

[quote name='dUSt' timestamp='1351707524' post='2501247']
This is all I've been saying the whole time. Romney and Obama are the only [color=#ff0000][b]viable[/b][/color] candidates.
[/quote]

[size=8]YOU.[/size]
[size=8]DO.[/size]
[size=8]NOT.[/size]
[size=8]KNOW.[/size]
[size=8]THAT.[/size]

[size=8]OUR VOTE CAN CHANGE WHO IS VIABLE.[/size][size=8] STOP IT.[/size]

Posted

[quote name='arfink' timestamp='1351707774' post='2501252']

[size=3]YOU.
DO.
NOT.
KNOW.
THAT.

OUR VOTE CAN CHANGE WHO IS VIABLE. STOP IT.[/size]
[/quote]
Dude. Chill.

Yes, I do know that. Common sense man. Obama and Romney are the only viable candidates. The church tells us that you must use prudence. It's reality.

Yes, our vote can change who is viable--but that needs to happen WAY BEFORE one week before the election. At this point, Obama and Romney are the [b]only viable candidates[/b]. To deny this is to ignore prudence and deny reality. Period.

Posted (edited)

How do you not recognize that you are being one of the many enforcers of that rule of viability? You are enforcing it, right here right now by appealing to the "common sense" that dictates the two party system, you are the essence of the self-fulfilling prophecy. your line of reasoning is exactly what keeps it happening, your line of reasoning is the PROBLEM, the people you're arguing against are the SOLUTION.

Prudence does not mean that you're required to follow along with the more viable way, anyway. A prudential judgment is simply a reasoned approach towards seeking the best path to take, the conflation of that with the two-party-doctrine that has become so indoctrinated into people is absolutely wrong. Just because you have reasoned that the most prudential course of action is to choose one of the two-parties does NOT mean that your judgment is correct, and the idea that either Obama or Romney is extremely likely to be the winner of this election does NOT equate with choosing one of the two as the most prudential judgment. sometimes the most prudential judgment is to refuse to allow yourself to be tainted by either scumbag; to say to hell with it and refuse to join either the Nazis or the Red Army, but to instead jump on a horse and grab a sword and go down fighting against tanks no matter how unlikely you are to lose. Prudence and Courage are two things to consider here.

As regards voting for Obama, I wouldn't recommend it. I also wouldn't recommend voting for Romney, but I'd recommend stronger against a vote for Obama. There are various lines of reasoning that an informed conscience could used to justify a vote for either of the two, though; I think the lines of reasoning justifying a vote for Romney are slightly more viable than the lines of reasoning justifying a vote for Obama; but especially with such little difference between the two, we should absolutely refrain from using the power of the unity of the Church to shame or ostracize anyone for choosing either of those two paths. To do so would be incredibly sinful IMO.

Edited by Aloysius
PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

[quote name='Anomaly' timestamp='1351696511' post='2501122']
There has been lot's of discussion regarding voting for Romney, voting third Party, or obstaining from voting as viable moral choices for Catholics. It's been touched on, but not really discussed.
Can Catholics morally justify voting FOR Obama? Why or why not?
[/quote]

I'm sure some can TRY to morally justify it, they may even believe themselves to be right. Now the larger question ( and better IMHO) is Can a well informed Catholic legitimately vote for Obama and not violate their consciences? Then perhaps yes, as we can not know truly the status of an individual's heart and understanding, it their level of cooperation with sin is something that must be judged by God. In short CAN a Catholic vote for him...sure we can do whatever we want, we have the ability...should a Catholic vote for him...NO.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1351710532' post='2501315']
How do you not recognize that you are being one of the many enforcers of that rule of viability? You are enforcing it, right here right now by appealing to the "common sense" that dictates the two party system,
[/quote]
Lots of words, but nothing has convinced me that Obama and Romney are not the only two viable candidates. Sorry. You can keep going on and on about how voting for a viable candidate makes other candidates non-viable, but I simply don't agree with that logic.

If there was a viable third party candidate, I'd consider a vote for that candidate.

You and the people who think like you failed this go-around at producing a viable third party candidate. Take it as a loss. Charge it to the game. Whatever. The fact is, as it stands today, Obama and Romney are the only viable candidates. Nothing you can say or do will change this [b]fact.[/b]

Get over it and face reality. The third-party team has lost this election. Now be a good loser and vote for one of the only two teams left.

Posted

[quote name='dUSt' timestamp='1351711804' post='2501342']

Get over it and face reality. The third-party team has lost this election. Now be a good loser and vote for [s]one of the only two teams left.[/s] the dismemberment of Iranians using drone attacks.
[/quote]

fxd

Posted

[quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1351712004' post='2501345']

fxd
[/quote]
:spam:

Posted

Just truthifying. Romney's wardrums have been booming his entire campaign. He can't wait to oversee the deaths of foreign children. Because 'Merica gots to be safe!

Posted

[quote name='dUSt' timestamp='1351711804' post='2501342']
Lots of words, but nothing has convinced me that Obama and Romney are the only two viable candidates. Sorry. You can keep going on and on about how voting for a viable candidate makes other candidates non-viable, but I simply don't agree with that logic.

If there was a viable third party candidate, I'd consider a vote for that candidate.

You and the people who think like you failed this go-around at producing a viable third party candidate. Take it as a loss. Charge it to the game. Whatever. The fact is, as it stands today, Obama and Romney are the only viable candidates. Nothing you can say or do will change this [b]fact.[/b]

Get over it and face reality. The third-party team has lost this election. Now be a good loser and vote for one of the only two teams left.
[/quote]
I do recognize that I lost, I didn't attempt to set up a third party, I am a Republican and I remain a Republican, I was actually a delegate to the Republican National Convention, I faced directly up to lying and cheating and fraud at all sorts of levels, blatant violations of the rules, blatant power-grabs by the Romney Campaign to utterly freeze out future grassroots people, to blatantly attempt to freeze out any pro-life influence in the Republican Party, all in all a pretty ugly affair; but I will be a Republican next time around when I fight in the primaries again.

The fact that we lost the Republican Party to a man like Mitt Romney means to me that we lost the general election. I already did my part, I did my civic duty, and I already lost. My subsequent vote was not a support for either Romney or Obama because I find no reason to support either one over the other.

What I am saying is that you have to break free of this mindset that we must lend our support to one of the two. It is a self-fulfilling prophecy; the only reason it's true is that people like you SAY that it is true. We all have real power here, and so many have used that power to be pawns of the corrupt system, that's what you're doing by making that argument that we should just smell of elderberries it up and pick someone from the 2 party system. So long as we have that mindset, they will exploit us and treat us like pawns. We will never have any real influence. If we are not willing to withhold our support from a candidate as disastrously bad as Mitt Romney, the Republicans will take us for granted and ignore us.

You have the short-sighted goal in mind of winning this election; and to succeed at this goal, you sell out the future of the pro-life movement. But what is even more disconcerting is that many people with this short-sighted goal are willing to go even further: in order to win this one particular election, as if this one singular election was so important, they are willing to sell out people's faith, using their desire for communion in the Church as a weapon to pressure them into the action of voting one way or another. It's short sighted for the long-term game of politics, but what is worse is that it's short sighted in the very serious game of the salvation of souls. And that's why the Pope doesn't tell everyone to vote for Mitt Romney (lol I know, that's another thread, right?)--this one particular election is far less important than people make it out to be.

eagle_eye222001
Posted

For those who believe that Romney is a "viable" candidate...

Do remember that Romney's people and the RNC ensured that by blatantly cheating at the convention.

[url="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B39W91O-rUg"]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B39W91O-rUg[/url]

I mean....when you make DARN sure NO one else has a chance by replacing voters to make sure they vote a certain way...



Ron Paul lost, not because he legit lost, but because Romney's people and the RNC legit cheated to ENSURE that he lost before he could even lose legit.



The RNC and Romney's people knew Ron Paul was a threat and acted. Everyone knows Ron Paul's chances were not good. So I suppose next time there is a play-off series for the World series and one team is leading 3 games to 1, we should just call the rest of the games for the team in the lead, right?

eagle_eye222001
Posted

[quote name='dUSt' timestamp='1351711804' post='2501342']
...

Get over it and face reality. The third-party team has lost this election. Now be a good loser and vote for one of the only two teams left.
[/quote]


No, the RNC changed the rules illegally to suit their game and replaced voters whom they didn't like.

I will be a good loser when there is a legit game.

Posted

Ron Paul was a distant second at the time of the convention and had no chance to get the nomination.

Posted

Yeah, Ron Paul was not going to get the nomination. There was a lot of fraud and cheating over the course of the primary season by the Romney campaign both against the Santorum people and the Paul people; the fraud that took place at the convention was more aimed at the Romney campaign's unprecedented changing of the rules to make future challenges to the establishment favorites like those that were posed both by Ron Paul AND by Rick Santorum to be less possible in the future.

Unfairly unseating the Paul delegates like they did was a whole other issue; that was petty heavy handed tactics to prevent the mention of Paul's name and the official tallying of his votes during the nominating process. We actually submitted a five state plurality anyway even without the delegates they had illicitly removed, but they ignored that as well.

The Romney Team's thuggish tactics as the future of the Republican Party will pretty much assure you that you are not going to see a plausible sincere pro-life or conservative candidate have a chance at the Republican Nomination for a very long time.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1351723434' post='2501447']
The Romney Team's thuggish tactics as the future of the Republican Party will pretty much assure you that you are not going to see a plausible sincere pro-life or conservative candidate have a chance at the Republican Nomination for a very long time.
[/quote]And will aiding the likelyhood of Obama's re-election and bolstering the political power of the Democratic Power provide any hope that we would see a plausible sincere pro-life or conservative candidate have a chance at the [s]Republican[/s] Democratic Nomination? Wouldn't that shift the political power that's a reality of being the incumbent politician to the political agents who are pro-abortion?

Edited by Anomaly
Posted (edited)

If we really want a viable 3rd party candidate, then we need to go out and lobby for him starting November 7th, 2012 for the 2016 election. That means town hall meetings, donating dollars, starting websites/blogs, posting about it on facebook, sending letters to possible donors, speaking at universities etc.

Starting 11/1 when election day is 5 days away will not make a candidate viable by any means.

Edited by Slappo
Posted

pro-lifers don't have a snowball's chance in hell at the democratic convention. the few that went to the DNC this year tried to get a bone throne to them in the party platform basically acknowledging some wider ranges of opinion on the abortion issue... they were crushed pretty easily.

actually, the direction of rules changes that the Romney Campaign worked so hard to get in at the RNC this time around have been in place in some form for the DNC for quite some time... making the Democratic Party even harder to work within than the Republican Party is... but don't worry, the RNC is doing its best to make it hard to work within them either... maybe the Romney era of the Republican Party could eventually be the kick in the pantaloons that leads to a real third party revolt... heck, even Sarah Palin said she thought the Republicans needed to go the way of the whigs after that whole disastrous display of power-grabbing by the Romney campaign in the RNC.

Posted

[quote name='Slappo' timestamp='1351793832' post='2502097']
If we really want a viable 3rd party candidate, then we need to go out and lobby for him starting November 7th, 2012 for the 2016 election. That means town hall meetings, donating dollars, starting websites/blogs, posting about it on facebook, sending letters to possible donors, speaking at universities etc.

Starting 11/1 when election day is 5 days away will not make a candidate viable by any means.
[/quote]
THIS.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1351799438' post='2502137']
pro-lifers don't have a snowball's chance in hell at the democratic convention. the few that went to the DNC this year tried to get a bone throne to them in the party platform basically acknowledging some wider ranges of opinion on the abortion issue... they were crushed pretty easily.[/quote]
What's really sad is the last pro-life Democratic senator was a huge sellout to Obama's other policies.

He even went to the Vigil Mass for Life at the National Shrine his first year as a senator. :( :ohno:

Posted

[quote name='kujo' timestamp='1351704190' post='2501220']

Have you been following the Freedom threads? Pretty sure she wears Romney pajamas.
[/quote]

Yo, I am not a shill for Romney. His record is just way better than Obamas. I want to vote Obama [u][b]OUT[/b][/u] and the only way to do that is to vote for Romney. I'm pretty sure you don't have to mention to anyone who you voted for, it's private.

Besides, it's nunya business what I wear to bed.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...