Vincent Vega Posted December 11, 2011 Posted December 11, 2011 [quote name='Lil Red' timestamp='1323278086' post='2346564'] well, blaspheming the Virgin Mary & the Eucharist I think is the source of many swear words. Marc Barnes (at Bad Catholic blog) had a post on this awhile back. here it is: [url="http://www.patheos.com/blogs/badcatholic/2011/10/like-relativism-you-know.html"]http://www.patheos.c...m-you-know.html[/url] [/quote] [quote]Les zombies [i]sont* [/i]dans l'école.[/quote]
tinytherese Posted December 11, 2011 Posted December 11, 2011 (edited) I recall one professor who talked about how sometimes people who use swear words practically in their every sentence really don't have much of a vocabulary. They can bend the words to be used for advectives, verbs, nouns, etc. when they weren't meant to be. Certain swear words used to describe a lower body female reproductive organ such as c*** and p**** really get to me. Constantly referring to women in general as b words is irritating too. Also, what's with people putting mother before the f word? Edited December 11, 2011 by Lil Red
Guest Posted December 12, 2011 Posted December 12, 2011 The f word is my favorite. Right or wrong its my go to.
Ice_nine Posted December 20, 2011 Posted December 20, 2011 the sounds of a given word and its meaning are completely arbitrary. I don't think words have any inherent power to them. It's all how you use them. I say dammit a lot, but I don't literally want to beaver dam something to hell. The phrase has become rather empty of any substantial meaning, it's more often used as an intensifier or an adjective to express contempt, whether serious contempt or more in a joking manner. I don't think it's sinful unless it's accompanied with anger or some other sinful quality Obviously I try to watch my mouth in certain groups of people. But with friends and family I'd need a bleep machine if someone were filming
tinytherese Posted May 26, 2012 Posted May 26, 2012 [quote name='IcePrincessKRS' timestamp='1282145381' post='2159519'] What I was taught in Theology 101 is that swearing (or vulgarities, that is, f-bomb, sh-word, and others) [i]could be[/i] an occasion of sin (if used in anger, or because it could cause scandal) but were not sinful in and of themselves if you said it. (Being juvenile 18 year olds we all laughed and said how it was totally fine to drop F-bombs because it wasn't a sin. lol) But that "beaver dam" always is because it refers to wanting something damned to hell, literally cursing something or someone. I know that's not how the majority of people use it, and so I believe it would only be venial. Our professor made a distinction between oaths/swearing, vulgarities, and cursing. The first was to take an oath, as in court when you swear to tell the truth. The second is what we think of as "the bad words." And the last, most specifically, the word "beaver dam," or wishing something to hell. [/quote] What source(s) did he derive these views from? Before PM I had always been told that foul language was always a sin.
Odin Posted May 26, 2012 Posted May 26, 2012 I think we are all called to be more aware of our attitudes and our moods (mixed with what we say). Words, however, are only deemed offensive when a society deems them such. It is similar to the middle finger...some other locations have a different finger or hand gesture to suggest the same meaning that we use. I feel it matters more about intent and feeling rather than the words themselves. For example I usually curse more when I am around my friends (not like a sailor but more often). If I notice that we are say near a family or in a theater with kids near us I censor myself (as I do when I work summer camp). The only word(s) I can say with some certainty that are bad would be anything using the Lord's name in vain since that is specified. I do believe, however, that one could argue it would also be sinful to use certain other words in a certain context...but perhaps not the words in themselves. Words by themselves only mean what we give them.
Spem in alium Posted May 27, 2012 Posted May 27, 2012 In the end, words are just words. As Odin says, we provide the meaning. Swearing, for me, is something that should be avoided. It's not necessary, and can definitely act as an occasion for sin or for demeaning others. We should speak as Christ taught us, not as society teaches us. What interests me is hearing people swear and then apologise for doing so - almost as if it's some kind of unconscious, involuntary thing that can't be controlled. I'm sure that for some people this would be the case. One of my friends does this very thing - he will swear (using words such as "f---" and "s---") and then apologise for his language. I do not swear very much, and the words I use are more or less colloquial here and have lost a great deal of their profanity. "Bugger", "holy moly", "croutons", "bloody hell", or "bloody" on its own are the most common ones for me. "beaver dam", "hell" and "heck" do slip out from time to time also, though I try to limit my use of those ones. A lot of words once considered very bad (attacking the Virgin Mary, Christ and so on) are now more or less accepted. Meanings and implications change. Though I do think some words will never lose their strength and wrongfulness.
Laudate_Dominum Posted May 27, 2012 Posted May 27, 2012 'Tis always fun seeing old threads. [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' timestamp='1323298717' post='2346863'] Lately I'm pretty indifferent to the lower-tier swear words. Meh. Insignificant and nonsensical words. [/quote] You go girl.
tinytherese Posted May 27, 2012 Posted May 27, 2012 I see swearing as something that can be habit forming. If you're used to doing it, it can be harder to even remember or try to be aware of who is around when you swear.
beatitude Posted May 27, 2012 Posted May 27, 2012 Tonight I was on a train with a group of foul mouths whose every other word was f***. It made me really uncomfortable. I can't dismiss swearing with 'oh, it doesn't really mean anything', because while some people might be desensitized to it, there are many others who won't be and who won't enjoy being around you if they hear you using language like that. Swearing shows a lack of concern for others. I see it like this: I receive Jesus in the Eucharist through my mouth and I want to keep my mouth 'clean'. Thinking of this makes me a [i]lot[/i] more careful of what I say to other people.
Lilllabettt Posted May 28, 2012 Posted May 28, 2012 I think its best to reserve swear words for when the **** really hits the fan. That way they are effective. if you say ***** every time you stub your toe, what can you say when your hand gets blown off, or you see a semi jack-knifing in your direction on the highway?
Archaeology cat Posted May 28, 2012 Posted May 28, 2012 [quote name='Lilllabettt' timestamp='1338229310' post='2436453'] I think its best to reserve swear words for when the **** really hits the fan. That way they are effective. if you say ***** every time you stub your toe, what can you say when your hand gets blown off, or you see a semi jack-knifing in your direction on the highway? [/quote]There was actually a study showing that swearing only when you hurt yourself provided some pain relief, but it didn't have the same effect if you swore regularly.
IcePrincessKRS Posted May 28, 2012 Posted May 28, 2012 [quote name='tinytherese' timestamp='1338060781' post='2435187'] What source(s) did he derive these views from? Before PM I had always been told that foul language was always a sin. [/quote] I honestly couldn't tell you. I took Theology 101 over ten years ago. But I do know that he wasn't one to just throw ideas out there. Everything he taught was thoroughly researched, and re-researched year after year. He had been teaching for a good 20+ years at that point. My college was one of the ones that takes oaths of fidelity to the Magisterium every year. Not just the Theology profs, but every professor on staff. I have no doubt that what I learned from those men and women is 100% in line with Church teaching.
Papist Posted May 29, 2012 Posted May 29, 2012 I prefer not to swear or hear it. I fail miserably. It is something I constantly confess and work on. Fortunately, I have freed my self from swearing in front off my wife and children. I really struggle around my brothers and driving home from work.
Lil Red Posted May 29, 2012 Posted May 29, 2012 [quote name='Papist' timestamp='1338311455' post='2437157'] I prefer not to swear or hear it. I fail miserably. It is something I constantly confess and work on. Fortunately, I have freed my self from swearing in front off my wife and children. I really struggle around my brothers and driving home from work. [/quote] you should try a road-rage preventer. (mine's a crucifix on my dash, right in front of my steering wheel.)
Papist Posted May 29, 2012 Posted May 29, 2012 [quote name='Lil Red' timestamp='1338311613' post='2437158'] you should try a road-rage preventer. (mine's a crucifix on my dash, right in front of my steering wheel.) [/quote] Sadly I do have one in the same spot as yours. I guess I need a bigger one. Or one that will respond to me expletives.
sixpence Posted May 29, 2012 Posted May 29, 2012 If I swear you will know its something mega-serious; on the other hand, I heard SO much cursing in high school and undergrad that it doesn't phase me if other people do it, unless it one of the ones like tinytherese mention that are generally disrespectful to women.
Ice_nine Posted May 29, 2012 Posted May 29, 2012 Just sayin, I don't like when people throw out the "only less intelligent/less educated people swear and have a poor vocabulary and/or are stupid" So? It's ok to look down on folks who are less smarter and less schooled than the rest of us? Isn't this argument a veiled case of classist thinking? Lots of words that referred to the "common" people have now been denigrated to have a negative connotation (the word vulgar being the prime example). I just really don't like that attitude. hollaz $^*#!@
Papist Posted May 29, 2012 Posted May 29, 2012 I forgot to add. What has helped me around the kids and wife is to make up words that do not exist. Such as, KEYKRUM, pronounced key-crumb. This is a 'word' from my first son when he first started to say words. He would always say, "What's this keykrum?". Now I say WTK. If I see something weird, I'll go "what the keykrum".
qfnol31 Posted May 29, 2012 Posted May 29, 2012 I have thought a lot about this topic over the past several years. It's never come up in any of my moral theology classes or any of my ethics courses either. I suspect that a large reason none of my professors mentioned anything is because they themselves used a bit of profanity. I have only heard two things ever said against the practice of cussing/swearing/profanity in my life. One was an internet site I encountered almost a decade ago when I was looking. The other was my youth director in high school. Furthermore, I have known good priests with really foul mouths (some of which came out in their homilies) and am certain that people higher up in the Church use profanity from time to time. If we want to talk about profanity being immoral, we should begin by distinguishing between nasty speech towards a person and general foul language (as IcePrincess and her prof both did). I don't think that such language directed toward an individual an ever be legitimately justified, and I think it is a sin against charity. Calling someone this or that, or wishing/calling for their damnation really isn't kind (even if it is legitimately deserved), and I doubt too many people would try to argue in favor of it. Then we're left with general foul language. I suppose that if one were to argue against the use of foul language not directed toward anyone s/he would have to talk about it as a misuse of speech in general. As with any good, speech can also be misused. I gave an example above of when speech is misused. Therefore, a person would have to go into the proper use of speech, how it is meant to convey something (a feeling, thought, etc.) and should convey it in the best manner possible. Does foul language do this? If not, then its probably an immoral action. But what about language's arbitrary nature? Well, (and I posted this elsewhere), there are a few things that are arbitrary or culturally determined--like modesty--but that doesn't mean that a person can simply escape immorality in this context. For example, though modesty is culturally determined, there is still such a thing as modesty and we are to live as such. In Iraq, modesty is very strongly established and not to follow it is probably an immoral act (granted, they go to the extreme compared to the US, but I think that the point still stands). The idea of modesty is whether or not we are respecting our sexuality, treating ourselves appropriately, and leading others to good action as well. The same holds true for speech. Does foul language constitute poor use of speech, or does it have an appropriate context? Just a last couple of thoughts: even among people who readily use profanity, there seems to be a limit beyond which decency has been violated. A few years ago some friends took me and my wife out to dinner. The restaurant's owner came up to us and constantly used words that I shan't repeat. Even though my friends have said some of the nastier words, they were very apologetic that my wife had to live through the owner's language. This seems to say that there is something shameful about speech. Also, I know many people who are embarrassed to cuss in Church (and I hear it all the time). I asked my wife yesterday if she'd be comfortable using foul language around Jesus and she said no. Many other people have expressed a similar point of view. (Side note: I've been asked in response if I'd be confortable having coitus in front of Jesus or drinking in front of Him - to the former, no because that's a private act; to the latter yes because I treat drinking responsibly). If we're not comfortable cussing in these situations, why not? Do we feel that cussing has become a misuse of language? Or is it just unbecoming of people in a particular instance, like picking your nose/ears in public? Anyways, these are just some (longer-winded than I intended) thoughts on profanity and people's reaction to it.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now