Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

What Religion Makes The Least Amount Of Sense?


What religion makes the leat amount of sense??  

231 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

ThePenciledOne
Posted

I say Catholicism as well.


I mean, it clashes entirely with our nature as human beings or at least our fallen human nature.

Praise God, that we have been brought into divine revelation with the Light of Christ!

Praise Him!

(And I second Jamie's statement.)

Posted

I understand why people want to say Catholicism in a Chestertonian/paradoxical sense, but I don't agree. From a purely logical standpoint maybe, but I believe that the Catholic faith resonates very clearly on a phenomenological and spiritual level for many people. I know that's how it is for me.

Posted

[quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1057481211' post='1537']
And you're asserting that passage means God created a post-Christian religion which denies the divinity of Christ, the Triune God and the sacramental nature of marriage? Do you have some documentation that the Church supports this interpretation? Does this mean the Muslim religion is the religion to join, or has God fallen into the habit of establishing contradictory religions?

A man founded Mohammedanism. A pagan man who misunderstood the teachings of the Catholic Church. Not a prophet, not really even a remarkable theologian. A decent military leader, since his army managed to slaughter their way into decent land holdings, but just a man.
Of course, he may have had some aid from Satan, but not, I think, with his knowledge. Mohammed may have been theologically stunted, but I believe he was seeking truth, not the Prince of Lies.
[/quote]
Brilliant.

Posted

[quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1057537320' post='1663']
It is a proper term for a religion that follows Mohammed. If some consider it a slur, then I'm sorry that invoking the name of their religious founder is considered demeaning. It is not in any way an insult to the religion, and has been used for some time.
I shall endeavour to force myself to use the term "Islam" or "Muslim".



Alright.
Submitting that Islam is a religion made by God is an attack on Catholicism. When I was confrimed, I became a soldier of Christ, the Son of God; God made man, a person of the Holy Trinity. Mohammed made the allegation that Christ was not the Son of God, he denied my Lord's divinity. Being the Lord's soldier, annointed by chrism, I take my duty fairly seriously. I believe it is worth defending.
Hyper's reaction may be extreme, but it is his personal opinion. He stated "I", and it is quite amusing that people cannot tolerate his opinion as well as InDeed's since InDeed's insults the divinity of Christ, and Hyper's insulted the theology of an Arab bigamist.
I stated the historical and theological facts of Mohammed's religion, and juxtaposed them to what a Catholic MUST believe. I cited three Articles of Faith that Mohammed's religion rejects.
Yes, I am upset when someone tells me my religion is wrong. However, God is upset when we allow people to spread lies. God scares me far more than any of you, and I think with good reason.
We will be paralyzed from speech if we cannot tell others they are wrong. There will be no discourse, and if there be no discourse, then this site is useless, for it is made nealry entirely of words.

I am sorry InDeed is quitting the field. I am worried he will persist in this erroneous notion of the divine origin of Islam, though I am pleased he did not find it truthful enough to defend with any vigour.
[/quote]
Good stuff.

ThePenciledOne
Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1295942693' post='2204112']
I understand why people want to say Catholicism in a Chestertonian/paradoxical sense, but I don't agree. From a purely logical standpoint maybe, but I believe that the Catholic faith resonates very clearly on a phenomenological and spiritual level for many people. I know that's how it is for me.
[/quote]

It depends on your perspective I guess.

:saint:

Posted

[quote name='ThePenciledOne' timestamp='1295987722' post='2204252']
It depends on your perspective I guess.

:saint:
[/quote]
I suppose so. :)

Posted

i am glad Scientology is winning

Posted

[quote name='sixpence' timestamp='1295993968' post='2204303']
i am glad Scientology is winning
[/quote]

You and I both...

Posted

I said other, meaning agnosticism. I think it's dumb.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

I"m changing my vote to Scientology. My vote from years back is wrong.

Mark of the Cross
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1296002931' post='2204382']
I said other, meaning agnosticism. I think it's dumb.
[/quote]

There are many people who are in a spiritual desert. I pray for them all the time. I would put down every dumb version of every other religion before agnosticism. Many agnostics I know are just not aware that they are Christians.
Woa! I just looked up the definition. It's more complicated than I thought. I've always thought it to mean those who are searching, but can't find it. My preceding statement applies to them. ([i]weak agnostic[/i]) About the others I still think an aggressive evil religion would be worse. Scientology, Many Islamic versions and even bent versions of Catholicism/Christianity. Convolution of the truth which is a lie is worse than denial. At least a '[i]strong agnostic[/i]' is not bringing disrepute to truth, unlike some Catholics who may even be impostors that bring our beloved lady to disrepute.

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' timestamp='1296003487' post='2204387']
I"m changing my vote to Scientology. My vote from years back is wrong.
[/quote]

It's too late ya stuck with awesome!

[img]http://i584.photobucket.com/albums/ss282/mho_owen/laugh.jpg?t=1296007028[/img]

A Cat-a-holic.

Edited by Mark of the Cross
Posted

[quote name='Mark of the Cross' timestamp='1296006833' post='2204408']
There are many people who are in a spiritual desert. I pray for them all the time. I would put down every dumb version of every other religion before agnosticism. Many agnostics I know are just not aware that they are Christians.
Woa! I just looked up the definition. It's more complicated than I thought. I've always thought it to mean those who are searching, but can't find it. My preceding statement applies to them. ([i]weak agnostic[/i]) About the others I still think an aggressive evil religion would be worse. Scientology, Many Islamic versions and even bent versions of Catholicism/Christianity. Convolution of the truth which is a lie is worse than denial. At least a '[i]strong agnostic[/i]' is not bringing disrepute to truth, unlike some Catholics who may even be impostors that bring our beloved lady to disrepute.



It's too late ya stuck with awesome!

[img]http://i584.photobucket.com/albums/ss282/mho_owen/laugh.jpg?t=1296007028[/img]

A Cat-a-holic.
[/quote]
I should clarify that I mean apathetic agnosticism. :)

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Mark of the Cross' timestamp='1296006833' post='2204408']
[img]http://i584.photobucket.com/albums/ss282/mho_owen/laugh.jpg?t=1296007028[/img]

A Cat-a-holic.
[/quote]
:sweat: I love this pictcha!

  • 4 weeks later...
Posted (edited)

I just went ahead and took this stuff about [i]God making little sense[/i] and [i]not having to answer to no one[/i], and turned it around myself!

What I think is that Love is profoundly meaningful even though apparently absurd and emptying, and that the Church teaches us that.

When people started sounding like it was just ok and cool to have the perspective that [b][i]God was above petty human things like "making sense" (for real?)[/i][/b], I started thinking about it myself and found out that could be a [b]huge mistake[/b]. I think it's a huge pitfall if we start thinking that God is ridiculous and absurd. Such ideas about the Divine are what actually kept other civilizations far behind in scientific research (even the Islamic) and Christianity to best favor its growth. This is a hugely relevant issue for today's understanding of faith and reason and will be even more so in the future.

So [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=111156&st=0&gopid=2213407&#entry2213407"][b]I made this post and placed it on an appropriate thread[/b][/url]., which I highly recommend to be joined in by dUSt, Winchester, jaime (the artist formerly known as hot stuff), ThePenciledOne and everyone else for that matter. ;)

Edited by ExCorde
Hinter dem Horizont
Posted

Mormonism is absolutely ridiculous to me. Atheism is too, but that isn't a religion. It's lack of belief.

Posted

How about Transhumanism? It's a few ages ahead of Scientology in weirdness and have their own version of "life after death"!

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GLyXeXH_igI[/youtube]

Mark of the Cross
Posted

[quote name='ExCorde' timestamp='1297995930' post='2213461']
How about Transhumanism? It's a few ages ahead of Scientology in weirdness and have their own version of "life after death"!

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch? v=GLyXeXH_igI[/youtube]
[/quote]
HAL 9000's sister!

Ash Wednesday
Posted

[img]http://www.tvsa.co.za/mastershowimages/1463_heavens_gate_468.jpg[/img]

infinitelord1
Posted (edited)

If I were to choose someone to date or get married to, and I had the choice between a Mormon, Atheist, Protestant, Muslim, and Catholic here is what my precedence would be....


1) Catholic
2) Atheist (Only in the Case that the person wouldn't distract Me from God)
3) Protestant
4) Mormon
5) Muslim

If the Atheist distracted me from the Catholic Faith then I would have to end the relationship. But if the Atheist didn't distract me, then I would rather date or marry that person than any of the others. It would be a fun challenge to debate with the Atheist about God's existence.

Edited by infinitelord1
Posted

[quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1057378747' post='977']
I voted Catholicism, the only religion courageous and truthful enough to not make sense.

And that is why it must be true.
[/quote]

That says it best. I voted for other myself, since VooDoo wasn't on the list.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...