Laudate_Dominum Posted June 25, 2012 Author Posted June 25, 2012 If it's helpful at all here is a summary of some of the issues. The idea of a single breeding pair at the base of a human family tree is not plausible. We come from populations of prehistoric Homo sapiens that never numbered below several thousand. Also, it is highly likely that some human lineages have interbred with cousin species (subspecies if you prefer). For example, based on the Human and Neanderthal genome projects, non-Africans are basically a few percent Neanderthal. Similarly, Melanesians appear to be 4-6% Denisovan. And genetically speaking, there is no sharp line between humans and non-humans.
Papist Posted June 25, 2012 Posted June 25, 2012 (edited) If this is of God's doing, can it not be plausible? I remember reading, about 10 years ago, that a geneticist, analyzed DNA from people in all regions of the world found all humans alive today are descended from a single man who lived in Africa around 60,000 years ago. I am trying to find the who that was. Edited June 25, 2012 by Papist
Laudate_Dominum Posted June 25, 2012 Author Posted June 25, 2012 (edited) You're referring to Y-chromosomal Adam. Very razzle dazzle and fascinating stuff. However, Y-chromosomal Adam is just the patrilineal most recent common ancestor (incidentally, I think the best research puts the date at around 140 ka ago; I'm pretty sure 60 ka was the lower bound derived from the first rounds of research but it's since been worked out with more accuracy). The matrilineal most recent common ancestor lived much earlier. Making a connection with either of these ancestors and the biblical Adam and Eve is unfounded. There have been now dead human lineages with no connection to the MRCA of today's populations. I would again recommend Wade's [url="http://www.amazon.com/Before-Dawn-Recovering-History-Ancestors/dp/1594200793"][i]Before the Dawn[/i][/url] for an excellent light read on these topics. edit: minor typo. Edited June 25, 2012 by Laudate_Dominum
Papist Posted June 25, 2012 Posted June 25, 2012 Some times I think we humans think too much and put too much importance of such matters. Then, I also think God made things for us to discover. Some things easier to discover than others. Many times I have to catch myself becoming impatient when I want to the the answers to such mysteries.
Laudate_Dominum Posted June 25, 2012 Author Posted June 25, 2012 [quote name='Papist' timestamp='1340655501' post='2448767'] Some times I think we humans think too much and put too much importance of such matters. Then, I also think God made things for us to discover. Some things easier to discover than others. Many times I have to catch myself becoming impatient when I want to the the answers to such mysteries. [/quote] Amen, brother. Makes things interesting, at least. :-D
Papist Posted June 25, 2012 Posted June 25, 2012 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' timestamp='1340657578' post='2448784'] Amen, brother. Makes things interesting, at least. :-D [/quote] That's for sure. What I love is that the more we dig and discover the more we discover there is more to discover than we ever imagined. Friggin amesome.
Laudate_Dominum Posted June 25, 2012 Author Posted June 25, 2012 [quote name='Papist' timestamp='1340662898' post='2448806'] That's for sure. What I love is that the more we dig and discover the more we discover there is more to discover than we ever imagined. Friggin amesome. [/quote] Yeah, I'm super curious to see what's out in the universe, on other planets and all that. I'm actually pretty into space stuff.
Papist Posted June 25, 2012 Posted June 25, 2012 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' timestamp='1340664348' post='2448812'] Yeah, I'm super curious to see what's out in the universe, on other planets and all that. I'm actually pretty into space stuff. [/quote] Yes. I am so captivated by Saturn and it's rings. But now, I'm into putting my kids to bed.
Hubertus Posted June 26, 2012 Posted June 26, 2012 (edited) I once read a genetics thing that said that at one point in history, all humans alive were the ancestors of every single living being today.. meaning every one of the 7 billion people in the world today has the genes of Bob of X thousand years ago, and also Sally of X thousand years ago, and basically the rest of the population of X thousand years ago. Doesn't this lend to the fact that everyone alive today has a soul that was inherited from our ancestors? It may have been only one couple with souls at the time, but eventually, on down the line, it became the whole living population. Where's the conflict in that? I may have grossly misinterpreted what I read, though.. Genetics confuse me.. Edit: I just reread what I wrote, and I don't think I made any sense... Again, genetics confuse me.. Edited June 26, 2012 by Hubertus
qfnol31 Posted June 26, 2012 Posted June 26, 2012 I'm still being lazy, but I think Robert Grosseteste has some great stuff on how genetics might work, even though that's not his point. His book [i]De cessatione legalium[/i] was just released in English translation. I'll see if I can find the reference.
Laudate_Dominum Posted June 26, 2012 Author Posted June 26, 2012 [quote name='Hubertus' timestamp='1340684805' post='2448957'] I once read a genetics thing that said that at one point in history, all humans alive were the ancestors of every single living being today.. meaning every one of the 7 billion people in the world today has the genes of Bob of X thousand years ago, and also Sally of X thousand years ago, and basically the rest of the population of X thousand years ago. Doesn't this lend to the fact that everyone alive today has a soul that was inherited from our ancestors? It may have been only one couple with souls at the time, but eventually, on down the line, it became the whole living population. Where's the conflict in that? I may have grossly misinterpreted what I read, though.. Genetics confuse me.. Edit: I just reread what I wrote, and I don't think I made any sense... Again, genetics confuse me.. [/quote] We all have one father and thus a continuous chain of patrilineal ancestors, one in each generation. So-called Y-chromosomal Adam is the most recent common ancestor of all human lineages patrilineally. However, for each hundred or so patrilineal ancestors there are millions of non-patrilineal ancestors that you are connected with. The simplified version is that in each generation you more or less have twice as many ancestors as in the previous generation. Go back just a few centuries and you have millions, maybe tens of millions of ancestors. Basically, it becomes increasingly probable that famous people from just centuries ago (so long as they reproduced) are ancestors of everyone alive today. And geography is deceptively compartmental; genes get around. We all have quite recent ancestors from all parts of globe. Part of why racism is so dumb. Anyway, my short reply is no; I don't think these things lend credibility to the idea of first parents. Yes, if you go back far enough, and not that far really, every human lineage has either since spread globally or gone extinct. What does this have to do with original sin? If you happened to inherit some "original sin" alleles you're a "true man?" While the lineage of any particular historical couple was going global there would have been many parallel lineages of presumably non-fallen humans. And then, technically, there have been isolated groups of humans that are relatively cutoff from the rest of the world, especially in prehistoric times. Becoming a son of Adam and inheriting original sin, thus being fully human, sounds like coming in contact with a new disease. Congratulations, that invading army that raped your women has incorporated your descendants into Adam. You are now fully human and have an immortal soul. Maybe the Tasmanians inherited the "stain of sin" from the Koori, who were infected by the Murri, who were infected from a chain of trade going back to New Guinea. The Papuans were infected by Austronesians who picked up the SNP of Adam's sin from contact with mainland people. And so on, all the way back to the Fertile Crescent, or wherever Eden might have been. But this all arseumes a physical/genetic basis of original sin, which I think is confusing and probably untenable.
Laudate_Dominum Posted June 26, 2012 Author Posted June 26, 2012 Did the fiddlers seriously replace "as.sumes" with arseumes? smh
Laudate_Dominum Posted June 26, 2012 Author Posted June 26, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Hubertus' timestamp='1340684805' post='2448957'] I once read a genetics thing that said that at one point in history, all humans alive were the ancestors of . . . Doesn't this lend to the fact that everyone alive today has a soul that was inherited from our ancestors? It may have been only one couple with souls at the time, but eventually, on down the line, it became the whole living population. Where's the conflict in that? [/quote] In case my last post was a bit too haphazard you can think of it this way. Your mom has a pyramid of ancestors under her, and your dad has his own pyramid of ancestors under him. They coupled and produced you, who are at the top of a tree of ancestors that includes both of their pyramids/trees (which increasingly overlap as you go back in time). Of course the numbers would become so extreme in the distant past that it would greatly exceed the number of people who have ever lived (simple binary tree / exponential growth [i]ad infinitum[/i]), but in reality this does not happen because of such things as inbreeding and pedigree collapse. How one might reasonably base the idea of soul inheritance on this is beyond me. The idea of a huge prehistoric population bottleneck roughly coinciding with a "great leap forward" of behavioral modernity would be more reasonable, but still dubious, and far removed from the idea of Adam and Eve as literal first parents. In other words, perhaps behavioral modernity is what pas.sed through the bottleneck of extreme selection pressures over relatively few generations tens of thousands of years ago (I don't actually think this is the case btw). If such a scenario were likely one might still have to tack on the gratuitous as.sumption of miraculous ensouling of this polygenistic Adam & Eve, or else consider the soul to be something that can emerge naturally yet inexplicably. It seems a rather problematic line of speculation in any case. And I don't know that anyone would stop you from thinking that the soul and original sin are things that are acquired mystically when one is conceived by at least one parent who has Adam and Eve in their genealogy. I just find this to be a bizarre idea with some still stranger implications (some of which are touched upon in my previous post.) edit: had to add periods to thwart the fiddler. wth. Edited June 26, 2012 by Laudate_Dominum
Laudate_Dominum Posted June 26, 2012 Author Posted June 26, 2012 (edited) And the fiddlers replace mas.sive with marseive. This is irksome. Testing... Bass fishing. arseistance. arseociate. Parseamamarsey. Parseamashloddy... Parseamaquoddy. Interesting. You can say bass but not Marseachusetts. Edited June 26, 2012 by Laudate_Dominum
Laudate_Dominum Posted June 26, 2012 Author Posted June 26, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1330433015' post='2393991'] I think I'm sounding dangerously close to the polygenism condemned by Pius XII [/quote] Polygenism in the sense of different human races having evolved from distinct ape ancestors is completely false based on overwhelming scientific evidence. But I know that you're referring to the idea that Adam is not an historical person but perhaps symbolizes a group of early humans. I think corporate symbolism is clearly the case in much of Genesis, but this doesn't rule out polyvalent symbolism. I think considerations of the genre alone make the corporate-symbolic reading very plausible and the "historical breeding pair" reading difficult. I've encountered multiple sources that claim that Humani Generis does not actually condemn this viewpoint but says that it's not yet (c. 1950) apparent how it might be reconciled with Catholic theology. Some claim that exploring the question and trying to reconcile the two is a legitimate theological project. I'm not really sure what to think. The real rain on my parade is the insight from genetics and related fields. And yet here it is: "When, however, there is question of another conjectural opinion, namely polygenism, the children of the Church by no means enjoy such liberty. For the faithful cannot embrace that opinion which maintains either that after Adam there existed on this earth true men who did not take their origin through natural generation from him as from the first parents of all, or that Adam represents a certain number of first parents. Now, it is in no way apparent how such an opinion can be reconciled that which the sources of revealed truth and the documents of the teaching authority of the Church proposed with regard to original sin which proceeds from a sin actually committed by an individual Adam in which through generation is parseed onto all and is in everyone as his own" Pope Pius XII - Humani Generis 37 edit: please forgive the mauling by PM fiddlers. smh Edited June 26, 2012 by Laudate_Dominum
Hubertus Posted June 27, 2012 Posted June 27, 2012 Thanks for edifying me while confusing me and making me not know what to think anymore all at the same time, Laudate. Maybe I'll just go back to Young Earth Creationism.
Laudate_Dominum Posted June 27, 2012 Author Posted June 27, 2012 [quote name='Hubertus' timestamp='1340780062' post='2449361'] Thanks for edifying me while confusing me and making me not know what to think anymore all at the same time, Laudate. Maybe I'll just go back to Young Earth Creationism. [/quote] If it makes you feel any better the whole story has hardly been presented in this thread so far. When I spent some time looking into the topic last year (around the time this thread came into being) I did come across some good stuff. Not that the issues are resolved or anything. I'm hoping for an official update to, and elaboration of [i]Humani Generis[/i] in the not too distant future.
Laudate_Dominum Posted June 29, 2012 Author Posted June 29, 2012 I wonder what's up with this document. In my reading of it some form of polygenism is taken to be an open question. [url="http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/cti_documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20040723_communion-stewardship_en.html"]Communion and Stewardship: Human Persons Created in the Image of God[/url] "63. According to the widely accepted scientific account, the universe erupted 15 billion years ago in an explosion called the “Big Bang†and has been expanding and razzle dazzleing ever since. Later there gradually emerged the conditions necessary for the formation of atoms, still later the condensation of galaxies and stars, and about 10 billion years later the formation of planets. In our own solar system and on earth (formed about 4.5 billion years ago), the conditions have been favorable to the emergence of life. While there is little consensus among scientists about how the origin of this first microscopic life is to be explained, there is general agreement among them that the first organism dwelt on this planet about 3.5-4 billion years ago. Since it has been demonstrated that all living organisms on earth are genetically related, it is virtually certain that all living organisms have descended from this first organism. Converging evidence from many studies in the physical and biological sciences furnishes mounting support for some theory of evolution to account for the development and diversification of life on earth, while controversy continues over the pace and mechanisms of evolution. While the story of human origins is complex and subject to revision, physical anthropology and molecular biology combine to make a convincing case for the origin of the human species in Africa about 150,000 years ago in a humanoid population of common genetic lineage. However it is to be explained, the decisive factor in human origins was a continually increasing brain size, culminating in that of homo sapiens. With the development of the human brain, the nature and rate of evolution were permanently altered: with the introduction of the uniquely human factors of consciousness, intentionality, freedom and creativity, biological evolution was recast as social and cultural evolution." "Catholic theology affirms that that the emergence of the first members of the human species (whether as individuals or in populations) represents an event that is not susceptible of a purely natural explanation and which can appropriately be attributed to divine intervention. Acting indirectly through causal chains operating from the beginning of cosmic history, God prepared the way for what Pope John Paul II has called 'an ontological leap...the moment of transition to the spiritual.'"
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now