Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Best Catholic Dating Site


Recommended Posts

Posted

I met my wife on AveMariaSingles.com I was also a member of catholicmatch.com (a fair number of people had accounts on both sites). I was never a member of any other dating sites, Catholic or otherwise. I was on there for quite a few years before meeting my wife, though I really wasn't a very active member most of the time. Did get a lot of contacts from women, and a fair number of dates before finally meeting my wife.

AveMaria and catholicmatch are virtually identical in terms of their content and the orthodoxy of their administration, though AveMaria is the original, and prides itself on being "most Catholic" by on doing the most to try to limit their membership to serious orthodox Catholics (though there are unorthodox members on both sites, of course). If I recall, both of them allow you to set search parameters to narrow searches to people who are really Catholic (such as asking whether they agree with the Church on abortion, contraception, pre-marital sex, etc.).

While catholicmatch has more members, I actually got more "action" on AveMaria - probably the smaller membership helps keep you from getting "lost in the crowd" - though other people have reported the opposite.

Unfortunately, you'll probably have to deal with plenty of girls on those sites who are more into flirting or playing games than serious.

Orginally, catholicmatch had technically better site, with fewer technical issues and more features, but by the time I was dating my wife, AveMaria had significantly improved in those areas, and had everything catholicmatch did. As I haven't visited either site in over three years, I can't speak as to their current status. AveMaria was constantly changing its features and terms of contract in the time I was on there.

From what I've heard, Catholicsingles and other Catholic dating sites aren't really as solidly Catholic, and have lots of Catholic-in-name-only members.

Anyway, that's my $.02.


Merry Christmas!

(the usually-scheduled bashin' o' the liberals shall resume sometime after Christmas)

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' timestamp='1324523400' post='2355655']
I also liked the idea that you pay once. The idea being that you shouldn't feel rushed.
[/quote]
That system didn't last long. As of when I left, they had changed to a yearly renewal payment system. Just a fyi.

Posted (edited)

Paladin,

If you are stationed here in the US, try finding a Mass at a Traditional Latin Mass, Opus Dei, or otehr parish that has a young adult Mass and go in uniform?

Also, if you can get leave toward the end of next month, try the National Catholic Singles Conference in Denver:

[url="http://www.nationalcatholicsingles.com/"]http://www.nationalc...licsingles.com/[/url]

It is run by orthodox Catholics, and you will not have the "single vocation" or "you need to be comfortable being single before you can get married" nonsense shoved in your face.

I did meet one prospect (a nice Góral girl) at the last one in Chicago. Based on that experience, I will give you this one bit of advice: find out early on if they are still discerning convent.

Edited by Norseman82
eustace scrubb
Posted

i'm politically liberal, but theologically conservative. which site would be best for me?

Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' timestamp='1324772577' post='2357129']
I did meet one prospect (a nice Góral girl) at the last one in Chicago. Based on that experience, I will give you this one bit of advice: [b] find out early on if they are still discerning convent.[/b]
[/quote]

Oh boy, totally.

Posted

I know I haven't posted on here in a while but was just browsing and saw this thread...I like Catholic Match. I can't speak to the others because I haven't tried them. I found it very easy to use and a good place to meet good women.

I would recommend that site to anyone.

Posted

Thanks for the info everyone, think I'll be sticking with CatholicMatch.com . :)

i<3franciscans
Posted

[quote name='JoyfulLife' timestamp='1324585274' post='2355995']
:yahoo: A w esome. Lemme know if they do discounts and how much, just for the future...
[/quote] :rolleyes:

Posted

Hahaha! Hey, it's good to know. You never know..

Posted

I could introduce you to a couple of nice Canadian girls.

eustace scrubb
Posted

Just one question: Do they enjoy the weather up there?

Posted

[quote name='eustace scrubb' timestamp='1325132907' post='2359124']
Just one question: Do they enjoy the weather up there?
[/quote]

The weather is great 6 months of the year. There's no snow this year, and we're getting above freezing tomorrow. Neither of us has put anything more than a hoodie on so far this year. My Canada born friends are all into cross country skiing or ice skating, so this weather is natural for them.

eustace scrubb
Posted

Thanks, but I'll pass.

Posted

[quote name='Paladin D' timestamp='1325120782' post='2358887']
Thanks for the info everyone, think I'll be sticking with CatholicMatch.com . :)
[/quote]

Met my husband there, two dear friends met their husbands there, my BIL met his soon-to-be fiancee there, and my husband's family is great friends with one of the founders (and he's a great Catholic guy) :) So I definitely think CatholicMatch is a great way to go :)

Posted (edited)

Just wanted to add that I contacted ava maria as a first try, just to see what they say, and told them about my disabilities and low income, and they gave me a promo code for a reduced join fee. So, good news for you Mater! I imagine CatholicMatch would, too.


I'm NOT joining any site right now as I'm discerning two orders. But if I discern marriage in the future, I'll be ready to go...

Edited by JoyfulLife
Posted

Blah. Does anyone want to contribute to the "MCTS really wants to join CatholicMatch but is broke so we're giving her money" fund?

Posted

[quote name='Paladin D' timestamp='1324514811' post='2355524']
Does anyone have any recommendations or information regarding the various Catholic dating sites? I've never used them, and was curious. So far the ones I know of are:

Catholicsingles.com
Catholicmatch.com
AveMariaSingles.com


Thought I broaden my horizons a little bit.
[/quote]

I'd recommend you check out the member statistics of AMS before joining: [url="http://www.avemariasingles.com/Ave-Maria-Catholic-Singles-member-statistics.cfm"]http://www.avemarias...-statistics.cfm[/url]

I joined and found that there weren't any guys in my state, and hardly any within a couple hundred miles. You might be closer to other members than I am, but for me, any relationship I might have with any of the members would be long distance, and I don't do long distance very well... Plus, there are hardly any members to begin with.

Posted

Well, it only takes one person to be a match for you...but yes, I see your point about numbers and location. It is my impression that Catholic Match is the larger site, so it should have a bigger pool to choose from....but people will be more likely to notice you on Ave Maria. So, either way could work to your advantage! Catholic Match is decently international; don't know about Ave Maria.


[b]Joyful[/b], discern [i]one vocation at a time[/i]! :P


And as for the discounts....you all do realize that dating costs money, right? If you're going to be the traditional chivalrous guy, that means you pay for the whole thing - so even if it's just dinner and a movie, that's 2 movie tickets plus 2 meals, and easily you're looking at $50 for a first date. If the two of you aren't in the same state, then factor in travel expenses for when you do finally decide to meet. It is strongly, strongly recommended that the first time you meet someone from online be in public, not at anyone's house (no one has any business knowing your street address right off the bat). So, even if you have a more low key meeting, you're still going to be spending some money on it. Just pointing out that this *isn't* free once you sign up, even if communication on the site is free to members.

That being said, there's often deals offered on CM if you're willing to pay for 6 mo. all at once up front, rather than the monthly fee. So, if you're interested...save up and then purchase a six month subscription while they're having a deal.

Posted

Yeah, I saw AMS advertised on TV, so I thought there'd be more members. It wasn't until after I joined that I learned that there were very few members and that you're expected to date long distance or not at all. That doesn't work for me. I've tried it, and it's a disaster.

I gather it works for other people though. So if someone is up for it, they should try it.

I am, however, trying to give people who can't do long distance the warning that I didn't get. You only pay one time, but it was a total waste of money for someone like me.

Posted

But I should add that my mother found her husband on AMS. She's a trucker, so almost nowhere in this country is really long distance to her. :)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...