Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Sorry, this is another mandate-related topic.

My friend recently put to me this question, "What about the instances in which birth control is used not for contraception, but for health/medical reasons by an individual?"

This was her reason for "not seeing a problem" in the mandate.

It's my understanding that the Church allows the use of birth control-type medicine for non-contraceptive purposes. So how do I tell her that it's still wrong to force the Church to provide it?

Posted

For the record, the most I was able to give her was that birth control has been shown to increase the risk of lots of health problems, including cancer, so I'm not sure how it could be considered healthy to take it...

Posted

Somebody posted a link to an interview with Archishop (soon to be Cardinal) where he said this may be allowed in some cases. But this hardly justified a blanket requirement to give it out at will. Most contraceptives are not going for this use I think it safe to say.

missionseeker
Posted

Why just birth control?

There other medicines that are way more expensive that are not required to be "free"


I don't get it.

Posted

[quote name='missionseeker' timestamp='1329505476' post='2388570']
Why just birth control?

There other medicines that are way more expensive that are not required to be "free"


I don't get it.
[/quote]

Excellent point!

Posted

Yeah, right. The pill is the cure for acne.

Your question I believe falls under the double effect. The pill is prescribed and purpose is to help acne. However, the girl is still bound to live as though to not use the pill as a birth control mechanism. It would good, but not required, for the couple to still use NFP to postpone pregnancy.

Doctors are much to quick to prescribe the pill to girls, especially acne. The girl/woman/parents should always ask the doctor what is the alternative(s). Diet and/or supplements can make a big difference in someone's acne. e.g. Derma Cleanse by ZENMED.

We need more Pro-life doctors, especially Ob/Gyns.

Posted

[quote name='missionseeker' timestamp='1329505476' post='2388570']
Why just birth control?

There other medicines that are way more expensive that are not required to be "free"


I don't get it.
[/quote]

It's not just Birth Control. But Birth Control is a very basic health service for the vast majority of Americans who don't share the same very strict sexual ethics that you all entertain.

Strictlyinkblot
Posted

I used the pill on two occasions because of dysmenorrhea and menorrhagia which is a problem for many women. I then and still live a completely celibate life. It does have other medical uses. As for acne, with very bad acne often the only other alternative may be very powerful medication that has bad side effects, including inducing psychosis. Diet may help but I know of quite a few people with acne for whom diet has made no difference.

I'm not saying this should be used as an argument for providing contraception for free. If that was the case then why has contraception been singled out when there are so many commonly used drugs, like asthma medication that more people would benefit from if they were made available at no charge.

Joan Marie Wandel
Posted

I took birth control for a short time, for health reasons. My mentral peroids were very bad. So bad that I often felt like i was gonna pass out. Sp I thought it might help me, well it made me feel worst. But i see nothing wrong with it if its for health reasons

missionseeker
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1329506093' post='2388576']
It's not just Birth Control. But Birth Control is a very basic health service for the vast majority of Americans who don't share the same very strict sexual ethics that you all entertain.
[/quote]

My inhaler is pretty basic and common, but I can't afford it.

Generally people should be able to breathe. Sometimes I can't. so, I adjust the way I live and avoid certain things that cause triggers.

It's a choice, not something that we are entitled to, whether we adhere to strict rules or whether we are hedonistic. My choice is no, if someone else chooses yes, they can pay for it themselves.

Edited by missionseeker
missionseeker
Posted

Also, why is the burden of birth control on women? This I also don't understand. Why not pay for condoms? Or reduce the need for pills and pay for vasectomies?

Posted

Any such compromise of supporting these drugs for medical purposes would be rejected immediately because of "privacy concerns."

Posted

[quote name='missionseeker' timestamp='1329507233' post='2388589']
Also, why is the burden of birth control on women? This I also don't understand. Why not pay for condoms? Or reduce the need for pills and pay for vasectomies?
[/quote]

If you want condoms, just go down to your nearest public high school and you can get all you can carry for free.

Joan Marie Wandel
Posted

[quote name='missionseeker' timestamp='1329507233' post='2388589']
Also, why is the burden of birth control on women? This I also don't understand. Why not pay for condoms? Or reduce the need for pills and pay for vasectomies?
[/quote]

Condows aren't always the problem if its health related

missionseeker
Posted

[quote name='Papist' timestamp='1329507610' post='2388595']
If you want condoms, just go down to your nearest public high school and you can get all you can carry for free.
[/quote]

you know what's funny and ironic? There is a class action lawsuit commercial for certain birth control pills on TV right now.

Posted

[quote name='missionseeker' timestamp='1329506961' post='2388587']
My inhaler is pretty basic and common, but I can't afford it.

Generally people should be able to breathe. Sometimes I can't. so, I adjust the way I live and avoid certain things that cause triggers.[/QUOTE]

That strikes me as unfair. Maybe the solution should be to fight to get insurance companies to stop screwing over their customers rather than helping them screw over other customers as well.

[QUOTE]It's a choice, not something that we are entitled to, whether we adhere to strict rules or whether we are hedonistic. My choice is no, if someone else chooses yes, they can pay for it themselves.
[/quote]

Having a basic sex life isn't hedonism.

missionseeker
Posted

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1329508437' post='2388604']
That strikes me as unfair. Maybe the solution should be to fight to get insurance companies to stop screwing over their customers rather than helping them screw over other customers as well.



Having a basic sex life isn't hedonism.
[/quote]

well, honestly $30 for inhaler isn't bad. I don't feel screwed over. I just feel poor.

I wasn't saying that anyone who has a sex life is a hedonist. I'm saying that all the way from one end of the spectrum to the other, it's a choice.

Posted

Very influential lobbies cause certain procedures-services-devices to be covered by insurance. If you don't have a powerful lobby, chances are it's not going to be covered by insurance. If you do have a powerful lobby, chances are good that insurance providers are going to have to include the coverage.

Hearing aids are much less expensive than cochlear implants (devices, surgery, adjustments, and speech therapy can run around $100,000). Cochlear implants are covered by many insurance policies, hearing aids generally are not.

The birth control industry (pharmaceutical companies, Planned Parenthood, OB/Gyns, etc.) are a powerful lobby. Therefore, they want birth control covered by insurance.


I want tattoos covered by insurance. I want you to pay for it. Tattoos are a normal and natural part of my life, even if they don't fit neatly with your opinion of morality.

I want those facial-body implant things like Lady Gaga has covered by insurance. I want you to pay for it. Implants are a normal and natural part of my life, even if they don't fit neatly with your opinion of morality.

I want breast augmentation and butt-tucks covered by insurance. I want you to pay for it. Breast augmentation and butt-tucks are a normal and natural part of my life, even if they don't fit neatly with your opinion of morality.


Lastly, insurance companies will provide coverage for anything and everything, IF the customer wants to pay for it. If you really want birth control covered by insurance, accept the insurance policy I'm offering you as employer to employee and then pay out of [i]your own pocket [/i]for a birth control rider on your policy.

In other words, let the market resolve the issue, not the government.

Archaeology cat
Posted

There are also other hormonal treatments. I was put on the pill at 17 for dysmenorrhea and menorraghia. When I later stopped and charted, I found the underlying cause for the irregular cycles. I also found a non-hormonal treatment for the pain, since my problem wasn't hormonal. My sister suffered from endometriosis, which is hormonal. She, too, was put on the pill, but it didn't help. Now, after multiple surgeries culminating in a complete hysterectomy, she's found a doctor that uses bio identical hormones and tests her hormone levels to make sure the dosing is exactly what she needs. I know doing that requires more time and effort, but I wish more doctors did that for when hormonal treatment is needed.

Posted

Whatever. Then why do we ALL have to pay for someone else's good time?

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1329506093' post='2388576']
It's not just Birth Control. But Birth Control is a very basic health service for the vast majority of Americans who don't share the same very strict sexual ethics that you all entertain.
[/quote]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...