Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

What A Discusting Bunch Of.....


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

I'm not trying to discount your offense. I don't think his satire was well done. He didn't really effectively scathe Santorum and he offended a lot of people in the process. I don't think he should apologize as I'm just generally sick of people apologizing because somebody on the internet got their feelings hurt. But you chalking up a poorly done satire of a Presidential candidate as 'awful hatred' seems almost hysterical. And It just gives fuel to people like Brother Adam who is setting up to point out how uniquely and cruel Catholics in this country are persecuted. It was bad. It was offensive. But you're an adult and there's no rule that anybody has to respect your particular sensitivities. This is a fee country. You don't have to read shiitake mushroom satire on a third rate news site by a fourth rate writer if you don't want to. I'm just sick of people looking for reasons to be offended. Santorum shouldn't apologize for his idiotic claim that Obama's environmental policies amounted to a 'phony theology.' He should be mocked and not taken seriously for it, but his idiotic opinion does not constitute 'hate speech' against Obama. Franklin Grahm should have to apologize or pointing out that Obama is a Christian. I mean, who really believes that Obama's 'faith' is a centerpiece of his life?

People just need to grow up and get over it. If you want to live in a free country with the free exchange of ideas then you are going to offend people. I'm personally offended that you believe that homosexuality is a grave disorder of human nature and that gay relationships are unnatural. I also find it offensive that you think that I, and everyone else, am deserving of hell and will arrive their upon my death unless I am included in your Church. You hold a lot of opinions that I find offensive. But I don't ask you to apologize for it. Because you have a right to hold those views and as long as you're not going to try to trample on my rights, the ay your Church is currently attempting to trample on the rights of gay people everywhere, I really don't care what you believe or have any compulsion to apologize for it. I'd rather just argue with you over those beliefs or ignore them. But I wouldn't dream of making you apologize for them.

Edited by Hasan
Posted

Haters gonna' hate. So what? If he wants to be wrong and make a fool of himself, than so be it. Why should I take offense? What he says is obviously wrong, so why be bothered? I know the Truth that is the Church, and if he doesn't want to accept that, then it's his loss. If anything, I feel sorry for the guy.

Posted

[quote name='BigJon16' timestamp='1330566413' post='2394794']
Haters gonna' hate. So what? If he wants to be wrong and make a fool of himself, than so be it. Why should I take offense? What he says is obviously wrong, so why be bothered? I know the Truth that is the Church, and if he doesn't want to accept that, then it's his loss. If anything, I feel sorry for the guy.
[/quote] I pity the fool.

Posted

[quote name='Hubertus' timestamp='1330566823' post='2394798']
I pity the fool.
[/quote]

Precisely, my dear Watson.

Posted

[img]http://images.channelone.com/img/life/sports/track-discus-photos.jpg[/img]

Posted

I don't think he should apologize as I'm just generally sick of people apologizing because somebody on the internet got their feelings hurt.
[b]But that sixteen-year-old girl who got her feelings hurt by looking at a banner in a high school can ask for not only an apology but to have the offending speech removed, huh? Sauce for the goose, sauce for the gander. It's got to work both ways or it's discriminatory. [/b]

But you chalking up a poorly done satire of a Presidential candidate as 'awful hatred' seems almost hysterical.
[b]About like a sixteen-year-old girl getting her panties all up in a knot over the words "Heavenly Father," and "Amen," huh? Sauce for the goose, sauce for the gander. Hysteria breeds hysteria. [/b]

But you're an adult and there's no rule that anybody has to respect your particular sensitivities.
[b]Unless you're an atheist in a public high school, or any other person who holds liberal beliefs. Sauce for the goose, sauce for the gander. If lack of respect is gonna be the ground rule, then it's got to work both ways and nobody has to respect anybody else's beliefs or lack thereof. [/b]

This is a fee country. You don't have to read shiitake mushroom satire on a third rate news site by a fourth rate writer if you don't want to.
[b]Like that sixteen-year-old girld didn't have to read the banner in her high school, huh? Sauce for the goose, sauce for the gander. Ignoring disagreeable writing has to work both ways or it's discriminatory. [/b]

[b]Furthermore, whether I read it or not, I have to live with the fallout from the people who [i]do[/i] read it, repeat it, act on it, take it to the next level, etc. The damage is done whether I read it or not. [/b]

I'm just sick of people looking for reasons to be offended.
[b]Me, too. I think we all are. [/b]

People just need to grow up and get over it. If you want to live in a free country with the free exchange of ideas then you are going to offend people.
[b]In which case, nobody should be able to take anyone else to court for what they've said, which means 'hate speech' is just another invention of the left to shut up the right. Sauce for the goose, sauce for the gander - everybody's got to grow up, or nobody does. The writer offended us, we're offending him in return - fair's fair, right? [/b]

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Luigi' timestamp='1330580177' post='2394865']
I don't think he should apologize as I'm just generally sick of people apologizing because somebody on the internet got their feelings hurt.
[b]But that sixteen-year-old girl who got her feelings hurt by looking at a banner in a high school can ask for not only an apology but to have the offending speech removed, huh? Sauce for the goose, sauce for the gander. It's got to work both ways or it's discriminatory. [/b]

But you chalking up a poorly done satire of a Presidential candidate as 'awful hatred' seems almost hysterical.
[b]About like a sixteen-year-old girl getting her panties all up in a knot over the words "Heavenly Father," and "Amen," huh? Sauce for the goose, sauce for the gander. Hysteria breeds hysteria. [/b]

But you're an adult and there's no rule that anybody has to respect your particular sensitivities.
[b]Unless you're an atheist in a public high school, or any other person who holds liberal beliefs. Sauce for the goose, sauce for the gander. If lack of respect is gonna be the ground rule, then it's got to work both ways and nobody has to respect anybody else's beliefs or lack thereof. [/b]

This is a fee country. You don't have to read shiitake mushroom satire on a third rate news site by a fourth rate writer if you don't want to.
[b]Like that sixteen-year-old girld didn't have to read the banner in her high school, huh? Sauce for the goose, sauce for the gander. Ignoring disagreeable writing has to work both ways or it's discriminatory. [/b]

[b]Furthermore, whether I read it or not, I have to live with the fallout from the people who [i]do[/i] read it, repeat it, act on it, take it to the next level, etc. The damage is done whether I read it or not. [/b]

I'm just sick of people looking for reasons to be offended.
[b]Me, too. I think we all are. [/b]

People just need to grow up and get over it. If you want to live in a free country with the free exchange of ideas then you are going to offend people.
[b]In which case, nobody should be able to take anyone else to court for what they've said, which means 'hate speech' is just another invention of the left to shut up the right. Sauce for the goose, sauce for the gander - everybody's got to grow up, or nobody does. The writer offended us, we're offending him in return - fair's fair, right? [/b]
[/quote]

Honest to God, I don't know what about this you find elusive. A school is a state institution. The author here is a private citizen. If a school displayed a banner that had the text of this article on it alone then you could sue the have it removed, and you would be quite within your constitutional rights to do so and any attempt to intimidate you from petitioning the courts by atheists groups would be the same sort of thuggery that I find repulsive. There is an immense difference constitutionally between an endorsement or disparagement of religion by the state and the endorsement or disparagement of religion by a private citizen. I pointed this out to you numerous times in the other thread and you seem like a perfectly smart man so the only conclusion that I can come to is that for some reason you don't want to understand the distinction.

Edited by Hasan
Posted

Honest to [b]GOD[/b]? But I thought... oh, never mind.

Posted

[quote name='Luigi' timestamp='1330581964' post='2394871']
Honest to [b]GOD[/b]? But I thought... oh, never mind.
[/quote]

It's a colloquialism.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

The problem with his original piece is that many Catholics experience exactly that kind of treatment, in all seriousness, from people who have a very perverted view of Catholicism. So even if it is intended as satire, it's easy to see how many Catholics can be so offended by it, because it's NOT as clear as it should be that it's satire.

What disgusts me is his "apology." A decent human being could have taken a step back, realized that what he wrote was pretty much the same thing loads of people write in all seriousness, and at least ACKNOWLEDGED that fact. He doesn't have to be sorry. It'd just be nice if he'd actually acknowledge that loads of people actually mean those things he said.

The worst part? Yeah, his article was satire, but if you read the comments section, most people who find it funny don't find it funny because of satire, they find it funny because Catholics are crazy, cannibalistic child abusers. THEY don't get it either.

I don't like Santorum, and my palm hits my face whenever he opens his mouth. He very much reminds me of a person who's just starting to do apologetics on the internet - what he believes is pretty good, but how he says it is terrible and opens the door wide open for his opposition, especially for organizations like the Huffington Post.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1330564192' post='2394791']
I also find it offensive that you think that I, and everyone else, am deserving of hell and will arrive their upon my death unless I am included in your Church.
[/quote]

That's not true, Hasan. At least, any decent Catholic doesn't believe that anyone is deserving of hell and will go there unless he or she joins the Church.

Posted

[quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1330640324' post='2395088']


That's not true, Hasan. At least, any decent Catholic doesn't believe that anyone is deserving of hell and will go there unless he or she joins the Church.
[/quote]

We're all deserving of hell. That's why we need grace. And last time I checked extra ecclesiam nulla salus was still dogma

Basilisa Marie
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1330647164' post='2395123']
We're all deserving of hell. That's why we need grace. And last time I checked extra ecclesiam nulla salus was still dogma
[/quote]

And last time I checked, no one is condemned to hell for simply not being a Christian, and Lumen Gentium affirms the possibility of salvation for non-Catholics.

But whatever. I was just trying to be kind, lol.

Edited by Basilisa Marie
Posted

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1330647164' post='2395123']
We're all deserving of hell. That's why we need grace. And last time I checked extra ecclesiam nulla salus was still dogma
[/quote] Christ does say that the only way into His Church (and to salvation) is through baptism, but have you not heard of baptism of desire? I thought this was a pretty basic understanding; but maybe that's only because I've memorized so much Baltimore Catechism in the past. lol

Baptism of desire is the teaching that, basically, those who follow the Truth as they come to know it to the best of their abilities may be spiritually baptized by God's grace upon death, and thus saved. In other words, there's an exemption at death for people who never truly got the opportunity to come to know the Church and therefore never had the chance to enter it.

Posted

[quote name='Hubertus' timestamp='1330669717' post='2395257']
Christ does say that the only way into His Church (and to salvation) is through baptism, but have you not heard of baptism of desire? I thought this was a pretty basic understanding; but maybe that's only because I've memorized so much Baltimore Catechism in the past. lol

Baptism of desire is the teaching that, basically, those who follow the Truth as they come to know it to the best of their abilities may be spiritually baptized by God's grace upon death, and thus saved. In other words, there's an exemption at death for people who never truly got the opportunity to come to know the Church and therefore never had the chance to enter it.
[/quote]

I know about Baptism of desire and it doesn't contradict what I said.

Posted

[quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1330666953' post='2395253']
And last time I checked, no one is condemned to hell for simply not being a Christian, and Lumen Gentium affirms the possibility of salvation for non-Catholics.

But whatever. I was just trying to be kind, lol.
[/quote]

I apologize. I was grumpy and without sleep when I responded to you. I think people are condemned to hell for not being Christian. Non-Catholics can be saved but they can only be saved through membership in the Church. I think both you and Herbertus have given more liberal than merited views of this issue. Baptism by desire is, according to the Catechism, I believe, for Catechumens or other who actively want to be baptized. Invincible ignorance is for those who are not actively seeking the Church but meet a very high standard of having no knowledge of the Church.

Posted

So basically, anything can be written without rebuke or condemnation just as long as it is written in jest. Gotcha :like2:

Posted

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1330674533' post='2395267']
I apologize. I was grumpy and without sleep when I responded to you. I think people are condemned to hell for not being Christian. Non-Catholics can be saved but they can only be saved through membership in the Church. I think both you and Herbertus have given more liberal than merited views of this issue. Baptism by desire is, according to the Catechism, I believe, for Catechumens or other who actively want to be baptized. Invincible ignorance is for those who are not actively seeking the Church but meet a very high standard of having no knowledge of the Church.
[/quote]
It's important to remember that the Church is but the conduit. It's like the wire between the generator and the outlet.

Most discussions seem to neglect culpability. Rejection of Christ and His church would have to be rejection within the context of that person's flawed understanding of the world. We are not gnostics. It stands to reason that since we do not believe in salvation through knowledge, we cannot believe in condemnation through ignorance, or through human limits on intelligence. A formal rejection of the Church would have to involve a correct concept of what one was rejecting.

Nola Seminarian
Posted

[quote name='Annie12' timestamp='1330544890' post='2394573']
[url="http://newsbusters.org/blogs/tim-graham/2012/02/29/bozell-and-other-leaders-protest-vicious-anti-catholic-huffington-post-a"]http://newsbusters.o...ffington-post-a[/url]
[/quote]

May God bless our wayward brother, and may he be given the grace to repent of the vitriol he uttered against Holy Mother Church.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1330674533' post='2395267']
I apologize. I was grumpy and without sleep when I responded to you. I think people are condemned to hell for not being Christian. Non-Catholics can be saved but they can only be saved through membership in the Church. I think both you and Herbertus have given more liberal than merited views of this issue. Baptism by desire is, according to the Catechism, I believe, for Catechumens or other who actively want to be baptized. Invincible ignorance is for those who are not actively seeking the Church but meet a very high standard of having no knowledge of the Church.
[/quote]

No worries. :) Just as I believe that you have a far more conservative view than merited on this issue. We can't hold the doctrine of universal reconciliation to be true, but I personally believe that it should be our hope that it is, more or less.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...