Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

lol, Groo.

rhetor4christ
Posted

I saw it last night, and I liked it. It does stray from the book a bit here and there, and there are parts that I thought were kinda cheesy, but over all it was good.
I read the first book, and I'm 30% through the second book. So far, so good.

And yes. Katniss was right on. I was surprised to see how big/old Gale looked. :P

Posted

The second book was my least favorite in the series. It was...just like the first one. :|

Basilisa Marie
Posted

[quote name='Annie12' timestamp='1332619177' post='2407157']
SOOOO, isn't this like, a really violent movie? I just know that a lot of people die. Does it have a christian message at least?
[/quote]

I think so. Katniss's little sister is randomly picked to go fight in the "games", and she volunteers in her place to save her (not really a spoiler - this part is in all the trailers). Katniss isn't a perfect Christian hero - she's much more willing to do whatever it takes to survive instead of being like Peeta, who is trying to stay true to what he believes is right. But she learns, and grows a bit, and fights for those she loves.

It's violent, but not gory, if that makes any sense. The violence only happens in the second half of the movie, and even then it's not constant. It's about kids being forced to kill each other on national television for the entertainment of the rich, materialistic people living in the Capital, and a way of keeping the other, poorer districts from rising against the ruling class, because they have a yearly reminder of how the Capital is powerful enough to even make their children kill each other year after year. The violence is only glorified by people who are supposed to be "villains" in the story, and the games are opposed by people who are supposed to be the heroes.

Posted

[quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1332638436' post='2407337']
Capital
[/quote]

y u no spell it ryt?!
:bash:

Just joking. But seriously, next time your fan-status is being demoted.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

[quote name='Ice_nine' timestamp='1332673015' post='2407805']
y u no spell it ryt?!
:bash:

Just joking. But seriously, next time your fan-status is being demoted.
[/quote]

Of course I know it's Captiol. But if I say "Capital," non-fans will better understand what I'm talking about and not think that I can't spell. :hehe2:

Posted

[quote name='EmilyAnn' timestamp='1332620012' post='2407166']
I want to see it SO BADLY but my friends are losers and won't go see it with me. :(
[/quote]
I'll fly over to you and go! We could have fun. :P

Posted

[quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1332600869' post='2407019']
I would ask the people who have read the books and seen the movies about that. They seem to say that the violence is toned down in the movies.
[/quote]

The violence is pretty in your face in the movie, but most of it is implicit rather than head-on. You see more blood splatter and than actual inflicting of wounds. But they did stay pretty true to the books when it came to violence.

Posted

[quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1332638436' post='2407337']
I think so. Katniss's little sister is randomly picked to go fight in the "games", and she volunteers in her place to save her (not really a spoiler - this part is in all the trailers). Katniss isn't a perfect Christian hero - she's much more willing to do whatever it takes to survive instead of being like Peeta, who is trying to stay true to what he believes is right. But she learns, and grows a bit, and fights for those she loves.

It's violent, but not gory, if that makes any sense. The violence only happens in the second half of the movie, and even then it's not constant. It's about kids being forced to kill each other on national television for the entertainment of the rich, materialistic people living in the Capital, and a way of keeping the other, poorer districts from rising against the ruling class, because they have a yearly reminder of how the Capital is powerful enough to even make their children kill each other year after year. The violence is only glorified by people who are supposed to be "villains" in the story, and the games are opposed by people who are supposed to be the heroes.
[/quote]

I think we could have some really interesting conversations about who was more moral, between Katniss and Peeta. I think there's a good argument on both sides. Peeta is fighting for the well-being of a crush, Katniss for her family... different things speak for both of them.

Vincent Vega
Posted

It bored me.

Brother Adam
Posted

There are worse movies to spend $25 on in the theater. I enjoyed the time out with my wife with no kids...except the other 498 tweens in the theater.

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' timestamp='1332711148' post='2408218']
There are worse movies to spend $25 on in the theater. I enjoyed the time out with my wife with no kids...except the other 498 tweens in the theater.
[/quote]
That's why I usually wait a little while to go see the movies. Less tweeny-herds present.

filius_angelorum
Posted

I was pleasantly surprised by the movie. I think the message, however, is social rather than political. It was also probably lost on the audience that I saw it with.

Part of the point of the whole movie is that the Capitol population is so glutted with luxury goods, entertainment, technology, and fashion that it takes a bloodbath to even raise an eyebrow. In the meanwhile, the government uses its power to keep the poor, poor so that they can continue to keep the Capitol population entertained. Honest hard work just doesn't sell.

It reminds me a lot of Tertullian's description of the young boy at the gladiator games. At first, he went, promising himself that he would keep his eyes shut. Then the spectacle and shock of the thing makes him peek. Finally, he is hoopin' and hollerin' just like the rest of the pagan crowd around him.

The violence in this movie is unique in that it is never glamorized. Beautiful, precious children die and other characters grieve existentially for them. Vengeance is bitter and hollow. The greater fear of death, at least for the main character, comes from starvation and poverty on the part of her family than for herself. I have rarely seen a movie targeted at young people that spent more time critiquing the values that most of them act on. I say bravo.

This is not a movie for young children, or children under the age of 14, in my opinion, but might just be a good discussion starter with a consumption-crazed teen.

Posted

[quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1332711274' post='2408225']
Less tweeny-herds
[/quote]

Want to repeat that? :|

Posted

I still got to see the movie! Stupid Committee Meeting!!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...