Jesus_lol Posted March 31, 2012 Posted March 31, 2012 pretty sure my grandfather wasnt abused by his nuns/teachers in a public school.
cmotherofpirl Posted March 31, 2012 Posted March 31, 2012 I don't want my grandbaby in a school that promotes homosexuality as normal, religion is seen as non PC and threatening, where Christmas and Easter are dirty words, where masturbation is explained to small children as a fun activity or if kids can be whisked by nurses to abortion facilities behind the parents back. I want my my grandbaby to receive a rigorous academic education, not a PC political and secular indoctrination.
Ice_nine Posted April 1, 2012 Posted April 1, 2012 [quote name='Maggie' timestamp='1333213411' post='2411183'] They ARE your competition, though - and when you are supporting a family they'll be glad Dad learned how to play to win. In capitalist societies that's just the way it is, for the foreseeable future. The middle class is disappearing and not coming back any time soon. My husband works in high level banking and it's SCARY some of the social changes that are coming down the pike. Not fielding yourself as competitive in the marketplace wouldn't affect you getting into Heaven of course. Or your children. It would affect if they get to eat though. [/quote] This doesn't sound right to me. But if it ever comes down to choosing between starvation and seeing everyone as cutthroat competition I hope I make the right choice. Maybe I'm not that righteous, and I like food, but I should also look at people, primarily as people, and not as opponents.
Annie12 Posted April 1, 2012 Posted April 1, 2012 [quote name='Jesus_lol' timestamp='1333221456' post='2411223'] pretty sure my grandfather wasnt abused by his nuns/teachers in a public school. [/quote] So whats the deal-ee-oh with abusive nuns!!!!! Nuns are just people!!! They have their faults like everyone, but to lump all the nuns and make it plural is biased and I don't like it considering I'm going to be a nun some day!!!! Its like one man insults me so I am going to say men are abusive!!! Not true!!!! There are some really nice nuns that go un-noticed and some that probably used discipline too much but that doesn't make all nuns bad!! I feel like they deserve respect if anything because of their sacrifice for God. when everyone else does that they you can have a say!
Ice_nine Posted April 1, 2012 Posted April 1, 2012 J_lol wasn't saying all nuns are abusive. I think he was trying to illustrate that parochial schools are not the safe haven of goodness that they're purported to be. Things are probably better now, but abuse seemed to be more systematic and widespread back in the day.
LaPetiteSoeur Posted April 1, 2012 Posted April 1, 2012 [quote name='Ice_nine' timestamp='1333239673' post='2411311'] J_lol wasn't saying all nuns are abusive. I think he was trying to illustrate that parochial schools are not the safe haven of goodness that they're purported to be. Things are probably better now, but abuse seemed to be more systematic and widespread back in the day. [/quote] Little known fact: students were hit by rulers in public school, too. Corporeal punishment wasn't just a Catholic school thing.
MissScripture Posted April 1, 2012 Posted April 1, 2012 When I was in school, I did not like the public school kids. They were mean to me on the bus and they messed with our desks on CCD nights. Then I got to 5th grade, and one of the girls who was a PUBLIC SCHOOL KID came to our school. And WE BECAME BEST FRIENDS! I KNOW! CRAZY! So I realized that maybe they weren't all jerks. In high school that friend went back to the public school. So, I got to hear about the crazy things that kids did there, and I thought there were a lot more troublemakers there. Looking back, I have realized that there were probably more troublemakers, but also more of every other kind of kid, too, because there was just a larger population. Additionally, the kids at the Catholic school were also more likely to have parents who had the money and connections to minimize the consequences of whatever they had done, and there was a LOT of those sorts of politics going on at my school. Now, looking at the way either private or public schools are run, I have issues with the schools themselves, and the people who run them, not the people who attend them.
FutureCarmeliteClaire Posted April 1, 2012 Posted April 1, 2012 We love you, 171, and you are an amazing public schooler, especially to put up with persecution at school and all that. You are so strong, keep it up.
Jesus_lol Posted April 1, 2012 Posted April 1, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Ice_nine' timestamp='1333239673' post='2411311'] J_lol wasn't saying all nuns are abusive. I think he was trying to illustrate that parochial schools are not the safe haven of goodness that they're purported to be. Things are probably better now, but abuse seemed to be more systematic and widespread back in the day. [/quote] Exactly. all i know is, between my grandfathers abuse at the hands of austrian nuns and what he saw of the catholic church aiding the nazis during ww2, he still has a long standing hatred for the catholic church.(sorry for tangent) but i think thats a pretty concrete sample of why not all private catholic schooling is superior to public. it certainly didnt help him out. no not all nuns are terrible. but i dont think they would've have gotten a reputation for abusive behavior at schools if there wasnt somewhat of a history of that occuring. Edited April 1, 2012 by Jesus_lol
dominicansoul Posted April 1, 2012 Posted April 1, 2012 i transferred from an outstanding catholic school run by a group of beautiful Religious Sisters, (who did apply corporeal punishment, btw, but sometimes brats really needed it)--- to public school in the 4th grade. i.was.devastated. down here in texas, racism was raging wild in the public schools at that time. I had attended a catholic school with blacks, germans, polish and hispanics....and guess what? I NEVER KNEW WE WERE DIFFERENT. it wasn't until public school where racism reared its ugly head that i first realized: its a huge world out there, and people hate people, and its going to be a long 8 years until i get out of this terrible public school system.... at the same time, my catholic education helped me not to generalize... white people were not all the same, despite the whole lot of them being prejudiced, hateful, sadistic bastards at the time. To generalize the white race would be wrong... this was tough, but by the grace of God, i didn't come out of the public school system joining racially motivated socialists groups like LULAC and LA RAZA. lol today, i love white people...my best friend is the whitest, palest canadian in all of north america, so TAKE THAT, PUBLIC SCHOOL!!!
vee Posted April 1, 2012 Posted April 1, 2012 [img]http://christwire.org/wp-content/uploads/no-mexican.jpg[/img]
Lisa Posted April 1, 2012 Posted April 1, 2012 Public school my whole life, except for a Christian preschool. There was no Catholic school available, and we couldn't have afforded it anyway.. When a brand-new Catholic high school started up about 30 miles away, I secretly wanted to go, but I didn't bring it up with my parents because I knew they would be really hurt that they couldn't afford to send me and there was no way that I could get there daily. I continued going to my high school, where I did follow the wrong ideals in many ways... but I'm not sure if the school environment would have made the difference. My choices were not a product of the school; they were a product of my own sin and weakness. Alternatively, I developed my passion for agriculture, participated in lots of FFA activities that wouldn't have been available at a private school, and subsequently earned scholarships that are currently allowing me to graduate college debt-free. God has a plan Now I'm at a public university with a strong campus ministry, and it's been amazing!
vee Posted April 1, 2012 Posted April 1, 2012 We have a Catholic school system here but it is free and run by lay teachers. I attended this from kindergarten to grade six, then for gr six to graduation I attended public school. The biggest difference I noticed was in terms of charity and the attitude of the teachers. In the Catholic school they at least had teachers who tried to teach Catholic values and morality, in public school that was not important. Standards make the difference.
Ice_nine Posted April 1, 2012 Posted April 1, 2012 [quote name='LaPetiteSoeur' timestamp='1333240380' post='2411314'] Little known fact: students were hit by rulers in public school, too. Corporeal punishment wasn't just a Catholic school thing. [/quote] But were public school teachers supposed to be ambassadors of Christ and ministers to His Church and the world? That is the crux of the issue.
vee Posted April 1, 2012 Posted April 1, 2012 [quote name='Ice_nine' timestamp='1333294647' post='2411469'] But were public school teachers supposed to be [u]ambassadors of Christ and ministers to His Church and the world?[/u] That is the crux of the issue. [/quote] We all are, yet we are all human and fail, that is why we have the sacrament of Confession. The problem isnt in the failing and falling so much as it is in the not even bothering to try or simply reufsing to get up after falling. All teachers are humans not angels but that is not an excuse to do whatever. There are very good and very bad teachers in Catholic schools and public schools, just as there are anywhere that is why standards are important. Quality control. Good management.
Annie12 Posted April 1, 2012 Posted April 1, 2012 [quote name='Jesus_lol' timestamp='1333263687' post='2411418'] Exactly. all i know is, between my grandfathers abuse at the hands of austrian nuns and what he saw of [b]the catholic church aiding the nazis during ww2, he still has a long standing hatred for the catholic church.[/b](sorry for tangent) but i think thats a pretty concrete sample of why not all private catholic schooling is superior to public. it certainly didnt help him out. no not all nuns are terrible. but i dont think they would've have gotten a reputation for abusive behavior at schools if there wasnt somewhat of a history of that occuring. [/quote] What do you mean by this? From what I know Catholics were victims of the Nazi's along with the Jewish people. So, that wouldn't make much sense. can you explain what you mean?
Jesus_lol Posted April 1, 2012 Posted April 1, 2012 [quote name='Annie12' timestamp='1333303456' post='2411509'] What do you mean by this? From what I know Catholics were victims of the Nazi's along with the Jewish people. So, that wouldn't make much sense. can you explain what you mean? [/quote] you would have to talk to him, he was the one conscripted into the german army, who actually was alive and there when all this was happening.
dominicansoul Posted April 1, 2012 Posted April 1, 2012 i'm pretty sure a lot of German groups, including local churches, aided the nazis... ...not to speak with any disrespect about your grandfather, Jlol, but you admitted he hates the Catholic church. I don't think i would trust his judgement of what happened there. People are prone to exaggerate, especially against groups they hate. that's why we can't trust what we read in History books half the time... The church in Germany had its bad apples who went along with the nazi machine. But its totally wrong to say "the Catholic Church aided the Nazis." No the Catholic church did not aid the nazis. We have plenty of proof that the Church was an enemy of a long list of enemies the Nazis had. If a few parishes in Germany went along wiht Hitler, they went on their own, not wiht the blessing of the Catholic church. If one member of the Catholic Church goes around spewing hatred of the Jews it doesn't mean the Church condones anti-semitism. If one member goes around bashing homosexuals, it doesn't mean the Church condones physical abuse of those suffering with SSA. The Church will always have her Judases. But don't judge the Church for the actions these Judases take...
elizabeth09 Posted April 1, 2012 Posted April 1, 2012 There been an increasing number of students who are being home-school today then ever. If they are going to school, the parents will pull their children and then home school them. If you do not know already, the school, but mostly the Catholic school, are the ones that been suffering the most because parents can not affable it every school year.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now