Basilisa Marie Posted May 18, 2012 Posted May 18, 2012 Nah, I'd rather have a real ending than a happy ending. I thought the ending made the most sense with the characters. Plus it shows that tragedy has lasting, permanent scars and consequences, which helps to not trivialize the events of the series.
PhuturePriest Posted May 18, 2012 Posted May 18, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1337313227' post='2432070'] Nah, I'd rather have a real ending than a happy ending. I thought the ending made the most sense with the characters. Plus it shows that tragedy has lasting, permanent scars and consequences, which helps to not trivialize the events of the series. [/quote] I don't care about the long-lasting scares. She could've written those and I wouldn't have cared. But [b]Finnick. Died. [/b]He just got married and had a baby on the way, and yet non-important characters that could've been thrown away easily like Katniss' makeup squad didn't! As you can tell I feel very passionate about my distaste for his death. I'm going to drink some tea... Edited May 18, 2012 by FuturePriest387
Papist Posted May 18, 2012 Posted May 18, 2012 [quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1337303869' post='2432002'] In what? In the way that Lionsgate hyper-promoted the movie, launched a line of Capitol-inspired nail polish, and generally encouraged everyone to be a spectator for kids killing each other? In the way that half of my theater cheered when one of the "baddies" in the arena was killed by another kid, completely missing the point that both of them were victims of a disgusting culture? Nearly all of the media frenzy around the story has completely missed the point of the books. Well, for what it's worth, I don't think the kids-murdering-kids thing is meant to be glorified, but rather portrayed in a way to display the sheer horror of the situation. I think this was done a tad bit better in the books than in the movie. It's not really a theme, but more so a tool to show how desensitized the wealthy elite are to true human dignity, and that all they care about is being entertained. We're meant to sympathize with the characters who promote human dignity and fight against those who celebrate the games. [/quote] No. Nothing like that. I know that even though the book has children killing children as the backdrop of the story, it is not [u]the[/u] story. As I understand, the story is very good. What I am commenting on is the author choosing the children killing children as the backdrop and how us as a society/culture don't give it a second thought. Idk, perhaps the author chose children killing children to draw young people into the story/books. Are these books targeted to teens?
Papist Posted May 18, 2012 Posted May 18, 2012 Also, Hollywood usually never get it right according to the books
Katiebobatie94 Posted May 18, 2012 Posted May 18, 2012 i read an article on lifeteen.com about the catholic symbolism in the movie, it was pretty good! [url="http://lifeteen.com/why-i-hope-we-devour-the-hunger-games/"]http://lifeteen.com/why-i-hope-we-devour-the-hunger-games/[/url] check it out!
LaPetiteSoeur Posted May 18, 2012 Posted May 18, 2012 [quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1337313724' post='2432077'] I don't care about the long-lasting scares. She could've written those and I wouldn't have cared. But [b]Finnick. Died. [/b]He just got married and had a baby on the way, and yet non-important characters that could've been thrown away easily like Katniss' makeup squad didn't! As you can tell I feel very passionate about my distaste for his death. I'm going to drink some tea... [/quote] I think she killed Finnick just for that point. Those who die in wars are typically those who are married and have children. War creates orphans. JK Rowling wrote a similar thing (or at least, I've seen it on tumblr), that discusses why certain people died. They weren't killed because they were not necessary to the story, but to make a point. And Katniss' makeup squad was important: they showed that not everyone in the capitol was bad, and that they were capable of actual human emotion.
Basilisa Marie Posted May 18, 2012 Posted May 18, 2012 [quote name='Papist' timestamp='1337341859' post='2432155'] No. Nothing like that. I know that even though the book has children killing children as the backdrop of the story, it is not [u]the[/u] story. As I understand, the story is very good. What I am commenting on is the author choosing the children killing children as the backdrop and how us as a society/culture don't give it a second thought. Idk, perhaps the author chose children killing children to draw young people into the story/books. Are these books targeted to teens? [/quote] Hmm. I think I see the irony that you mean. I hadn't thought of that...and it's a really interesting point. Yes, the books are targeted toward older teens. The protagonist is 16, I think.
PhuturePriest Posted May 18, 2012 Posted May 18, 2012 (edited) [quote name='LaPetiteSoeur' timestamp='1337372811' post='2432306'] I think she killed Finnick just for that point. Those who die in wars are typically those who are married and have children. War creates orphans. JK Rowling wrote a similar thing (or at least, I've seen it on tumblr), that discusses why certain people died. They weren't killed because they were not necessary to the story, but to make a point. And Katniss' makeup squad was important: they showed that not everyone in the capitol was bad, and that they were capable of actual human emotion. [/quote] That's great and all, but certainly there was a different character with children to kill? If you ask me she did it because she knew Finnick would become one of the favorite characters so she decided to cause some drama. To be honest, I would have preferred it if Katniss or Peeta died. I was never too attached to those characters anyway. But didn't she already prove not everyone in the capital was bad with Cinna in the first place? All in all, I did not like the third book as a whole. Collins killed off many huge characters like Primrose and I feel like she did that simply for drama. There may have been more to it, but I didn't sense as if there was a deep meaning behind it. Then again, what I think does not matter, because I hate the third book anyway so I'm biased with my opinions on it. Edited May 18, 2012 by FuturePriest387
Basilisa Marie Posted May 25, 2012 Posted May 25, 2012 [quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1337380723' post='2432392'] That's great and all, but certainly there was a different character with children to kill? If you ask me she did it because she knew Finnick would become one of the favorite characters so she decided to cause some drama. To be honest, I would have preferred it if Katniss or Peeta died. I was never too attached to those characters anyway. But didn't she already prove not everyone in the capital was bad with Cinna in the first place? All in all, I did not like the third book as a whole. Collins killed off many huge characters like Primrose and I feel like she did that simply for drama. There may have been more to it, but I didn't sense as if there was a deep meaning behind it. Then again, what I think does not matter, because I hate the third book anyway so I'm biased with my opinions on it. [/quote] Hmm, I think she left the prep team live not because they aren't bad, but because they're super ignorant. Cinna is very aware of how evil the Hunger Games are, which is why he works with the rebels. The prep team genuinely has no idea. So in a different way, they're also victims of the evil of the Capitol, and when they come to live with the rebels they face a lot of maltreatment just because of where they're from. Their survival helps show how the rebels aren't all-good, either. I think Prim represented everything Katniss was living for. All of her motivations for all of her actions can be traced back to Prim, in some way. I think by killing her, Collins showed that the war really did take away everything that was important to Katniss before the games. I think Prim also represents a certain kind of innocence or whole-ness, and killing her symbolically showed how broken Katniss was by the events. Katniss idealized Prim, and killing her off showed that nothing is too sacred or immune from the ravage of war. But then I LOVE to over-analyze evrything.
Rowan d'Alexandre Posted May 26, 2012 Posted May 26, 2012 I've read all three books, watched the movie and debated whether or not Christians should be reading these books on a few other forums. I've never really looked at them through a Catholic viewpoint, so this is all real interesting. =) @Catholic symbolism: I think the first page pretty much covered most of the Catholic parallels. In my opinion, Collins didn't intend to draw subtle elements of Christianity into the series. But that makes it so much more intriguing -- the fact that parallels to Christ, love and truth will show up in writing aimed at secular audiences. [quote name='Papist' timestamp='1337341859' post='2432155'] What I am commenting on is the author choosing the children killing children as the backdrop and how us as a society/culture don't give it a second thought. Idk, perhaps the author chose children killing children to draw young people into the story/books. Are these books targeted to teens? [/quote] Amen. This is why I wouldn't recommend the trilogy to younger teens, or even some older. Collins gives us a horrifically gritty, bloody setting, and then gives us a heroine who's trapped in this society with little chance of escape. The element of minors being forced to kill each other is meant as a warning, IMHO, and not some gladiator-like entertainment. But [i]since [/i]Katniss is so helpless in her situation, and Collins doesn't give us a black-and-white distinction of Bad Guys and Good Guys, I think these books should be saved for kids/teens who can fully understand how the violence is truly being portrayed. [quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1337313724' post='2432077'] I don't care about the long-lasting scares. She could've written those and I wouldn't have cared. But [b]Finnick. Died. [/b]He just got married and had a baby on the way, and yet non-important characters that could've been thrown away easily like Katniss' makeup squad didn't! [/quote] **SPOILERS** But that's why Collins is such a great author. You don't throw away the non-important characters. You kill the characters your readers are attached to. Yeah, everyone loves Finnick because he's freakin epic. And you [i]cared[/i] when he died. It might make you mad, but at least that's emotion. No emotion = bad storytelling.
PhuturePriest Posted May 27, 2012 Posted May 27, 2012 [quote name='Rowan d'Alexandre' timestamp='1338050672' post='2435158'] I've read all three books, watched the movie and debated whether or not Christians should be reading these books on a few other forums. I've never really looked at them through a Catholic viewpoint, so this is all real interesting. =) @Catholic symbolism: I think the first page pretty much covered most of the Catholic parallels. In my opinion, Collins didn't intend to draw subtle elements of Christianity into the series. But that makes it so much more intriguing -- the fact that parallels to Christ, love and truth will show up in writing aimed at secular audiences. Amen. This is why I wouldn't recommend the trilogy to younger teens, or even some older. Collins gives us a horrifically gritty, bloody setting, and then gives us a heroine who's trapped in this society with little chance of escape. The element of minors being forced to kill each other is meant as a warning, IMHO, and not some gladiator-like entertainment. But [i]since [/i]Katniss is so helpless in her situation, and Collins doesn't give us a black-and-white distinction of Bad Guys and Good Guys, I think these books should be saved for kids/teens who can fully understand how the violence is truly being portrayed. **SPOILERS** But that's why Collins is such a great author. You don't throw away the non-important characters. You kill the characters your readers are attached to. Yeah, everyone loves Finnick because he's freakin epic. And you [i]cared[/i] when he died. It might make you mad, but at least that's emotion. No emotion = bad storytelling. [/quote] I'm just saying I wish Katniss had died instead. She's so annoying as opposed to Finnick who was a really razzle dazzle guy.
PadrePioOfPietrelcino Posted May 27, 2012 Posted May 27, 2012 I enjoyed the story and had only three real things I didn't like about the last book, and they were all at the end. 1) She killed coin and they had a trial, but she never spoke about why she did it to anybody. Collins went through such length to show how even district 13 wasn't all good, and the people never find out 2) Katniss voted FOR another hunger games..."for Prim" when she had already "vindicated" Prim 3) Coin from District 13 who never participated in the Hunger Games was the one who wanted another Hunger Game??? what sense does that make? That being said. I liked the books. The scars of killing/war I think are realistically portrayed for extreme cases (which this was), but even somebody like me who is still functional and not suffering from PTSD still carry around some bad war time experiences. I relate to the victors in a personal way and I like that. I think I understand the characters in another way whether intentionally written that way or not.
Ice_nine Posted May 29, 2012 Posted May 29, 2012 [quote name='PadrePioOfPietrelcino' timestamp='1338096668' post='2435645'] 1) She killed coin and they had a trial, but she never spoke about why she did it to anybody. Collins went through such length to show how even district 13 wasn't all good, and the people never find out [/quote] It's not stated that the people never found out. Keeping in mind the first-person narration, Katniss seems to be in an almost amnestic state following the execution. But seeing as she was cleared of all charges, people must have known. [quote]2) Katniss voted FOR another hunger games..."for Prim" when she had already "vindicated" Prim[/quote] This really bothered me at first too, but after re-reading it and discussing it with some folk the general consensus was this: she had figured out the same machine that ran the hunger games was being set-up again (sound familiar? Let me interest you to the new boss, just the same as the old boss). Moreover she was still working out whether it was Snow or Coin who killed Prim. And remember she was deciding why Coin would send Prim to the Capitol? (to either finally break Katniss OR get her on her side). Well, showing resistance to Coin at that point would not have been beneficial or strategic, AND having another Hunger Games would be a clear way to show that the new leader (Coin) was just as evil. There's no way Katniss really wanted another Hunger Games. Remember the little girl in the yellow coat being cut across by Rebel gunfire and how deeply that affected her? I think she was merely playing to Coin's hope that Prim's death would solidify her alliance. And it was a good hope because Katniss was really a vengeful and violent person. The good and the bad were always warring loud within her in, and the good finally inched out (tho not by much). [quote]3) Coin from District 13 who never participated in the Hunger Games was the one who wanted another Hunger Game??? what sense does that make?[/quote] District 13 suffered at the hands of the Capitol. They were driven underground, almost to extinction. Coin was interested in revenge and humiliating the enemy as to exert control.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now