Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Lost Art Of Catholic Drinking


Recommended Posts

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[url="http://www.catholiceducation.org/articles/catholic_stories/cs0558.htm"]http://www.catholiceducation.org/articles/catholic_stories/cs0558.htm[/url]

MissScripture
Posted

Hey, I was going to post that! :P

missionseeker
Posted

I'm doing my best to keep this art alive

fides' Jack
Posted

It's not lost. It's at my house. :|

Posted

If it is art, then I am the Van Gogh of drinking.

Posted

razzle dazzle, did "Catholic drinking" last night then by discussing theology over Long Islands. :)

Posted

I rarely drink. I haven't had any alcohol in like 3-4 years.. I'm a horrible Catholic :(

fides' Jack
Posted

[quote name='Papist' timestamp='1334771115' post='2420291']
If it is art, then I am the Van Gogh of drinking.
[/quote]

Interesting analogy. Because if you're the Van Gogh of drinking, then I think I'm the Picasso of drinking.

The former starts to get just a little fuzzy, but the latter is so trashed you can't even tell what it is anymore!


j/k I haven't been a big drinker the last couple years. A beer or glass of wine occasionally. I just don't have time anymore.

Posted

For a minute I thought this was about drinking Catholics....as in guzzling CATHOLICS as cocktails. :paperbag:

Posted

[quote name='AnneLine' timestamp='1334782529' post='2420379']
For a minute I thought this was about drinking Catholics....as in guzzling CATHOLICS as cocktails. :paperbag:
[/quote]

Catholic zombies?

Posted

[quote name='fides' Jack' timestamp='1334779899' post='2420369']
Interesting analogy. Because if you're the Van Gogh of drinking, then I think I'm the Picasso of drinking.

The former starts to get just a little fuzzy, but the latter is so trashed you can't even tell what it is anymore!


j/k I haven't been a big drinker the last couple years. A beer or glass of wine occasionally. I just don't have time anymore.
[/quote]
I don't think you understand Van Gogh's genius. He developed the impressionist style for a purpose. When his painting stop being blurry, you stop drinking.

fides' Jack
Posted

[quote name='Papist' timestamp='1334787894' post='2420407']
I don't think you understand Van Gogh's genius. He developed the impressionist style for a purpose. When his painting stop being blurry, you stop drinking.
[/quote]

I'm sure I don't. A lot of people consider him to have been a genius. And maybe he was.

I'm not saying that his work wasn't good. I'm just making the obvious observation that his more famous works are just a little bit fuzzy. Does that mean that I don't appreciate the art? I'm sure I don't. But that doesn't make it less fuzzy.

Pablo Picasso, on the other hand, is truly bad art. I'm sure some people appreciate his style, but I just think it's hideous. And that other guy, with the paintings of the drippings - it just seems beneath our nature.

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

Moscato FTW

Posted

[quote name='fides' Jack' timestamp='1334857897' post='2420685']
I'm sure I don't. A lot of people consider him to have been a genius. And maybe he was.

I'm not saying that his work wasn't good. I'm just making the obvious observation that his more famous works are just a little bit fuzzy. Does that mean that I don't appreciate the art? I'm sure I don't. But that doesn't make it less fuzzy.

Pablo Picasso, on the other hand, is truly bad art. I'm sure some people appreciate his style, but I just think it's hideous. And that other guy, with the paintings of the drippings - it just seems beneath our nature.
[/quote]
People think Picasso is art b/c they are told it is art. I truly believe people wouldn't think Picasso was good if never trained to think so.

Posted

[quote name='Groo the Wanderer' timestamp='1334857944' post='2420687']
Moscato FTW
[/quote]
dude, it's called a wine cooler.

CatholicCid
Posted

Apparently, I'm a Protestant when it comes to drinking :disguise:

Vincent Vega
Posted

[quote name='Papist' timestamp='1334858436' post='2420708']
People think Picasso is art b/c they are told it is art. I truly believe people wouldn't think Picasso was good if never trained to think so.
[/quote]
Who gets to make that call? Are you the authority on what is and isn't art?

Art is sometimes not about pleasantness. True art involves at least some aspect of novelty. Until Picasso came along, nobody had ever seen the world through the lens that he provided. It is gorgeous? Not all of it, for sure. But he attempted (and succeeded) in communicating his view of the world in a novel fashion. You don't have to like it, but you don't get to decide that it isn't art.

It would be like saying this: People think Chinese is a language because they are told it is a language. I truly believe that people wouldn't think it was a language if never trained to think so.
Just because one can't/doesn't/is unwilling to understand something doesn't grant him the power to declare it void of merit.

fides' Jack
Posted

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' timestamp='1334863125' post='2420756']
Who gets to make that call? Are you the authority on what is and isn't art?

Art is sometimes not about pleasantness. True art involves at least some aspect of novelty. Until Picasso came along, nobody had ever seen the world through the lens that he provided. It is gorgeous? Not all of it, for sure. But he attempted (and succeeded) in communicating his view of the world in a novel fashion. You don't have to like it, but you don't get to decide that it isn't art.

It would be like saying this: People think Chinese is a language because they are told it is a language. I truly believe that people wouldn't think it was a language if never trained to think so.
Just because one can't/doesn't/is unwilling to understand something doesn't grant him the power to declare it void of merit.
[/quote]

We all make that call. Art is almost entirely subjective. So, unfortunately, some people like Picasso get famous from other people wanting to look like intellectuals; "Look at this exquisite piece! It's so... abstract!" But, art for one person might not be art for another. It's all about opinion.

Now, I do think that some "art" is not really art due to the moral barriers that are broken. And if that is "art" then it's necessarily evil art and should be avoided by artists and spectators.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...