Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

fides' Jack
Posted

So, I've been here long enough now that I recognize that absolutely everything has already been debated on PM (gay, straight, too much holding hands, not enough holding hands, galileo, inquisition, all of history, what the Pope meant by using the word "the" in his sentence, etc...).

What I'm wondering is how the people who have been here forever respond to all the rehashes of old arguments? Like, how many times have you seen debates about "gay this" and "gay that"? Do you just leave the debate table alone, or do you keep going back to try to defend your opinion or the Church or whatever, just to have to do it again another day? Is it a cycle, in which you give up for a while, and then go back and start debating the same debates again after a few months?

It seems to me that the only original board left is the lame board. Maybe I should just take a PM break...

Posted

[quote name='fides' Jack' timestamp='1338402917' post='2437886']
Maybe I should just take a PM break...
[/quote]
We all do this at times...perhaps you should consider it.

fides quarens intellectum
Posted

No, you don't.

Posted

[quote name='fides' Jack' timestamp='1338402917' post='2437886']
So, I've been here long enough now that I recognize that absolutely everything has already been debated on PM (gay, straight, too much holding hands, not enough holding hands, galileo, inquisition, all of history, what the Pope meant by using the word "the" in his sentence, etc...).

What I'm wondering is how the people who have been here forever respond to all the rehashes of old arguments? Like, how many times have you seen debates about "gay this" and "gay that"? Do you just leave the debate table alone, or do you keep going back to try to defend your opinion or the Church or whatever, just to have to do it again another day? Is it a cycle, in which you give up for a while, and then go back and start debating the same debates again after a few months?

It seems to me that the only original board left is the lame board. Maybe I should just take a PM break...
[/quote]

it seems like Aloysius is one of the only ones left who has the kind of energy and patience to re-hash the same debates over and over again, with an abundance of charity. i only wish i could do the same.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

After 10 years I pretty much just ignore most debates and enjoy the rest of the phorum.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

[img]http://www.isky.co.nz/content_providers/turner_international/images/single/the_flintstones_ps/files/3276/Flintstone-PS.jpg[/img]

We'll have a gay old time!

Posted

[quote name='fides quarens intellectum' timestamp='1338403065' post='2437890']
No, you don't.
[/quote]
you talkin to me?

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='fides' Jack' timestamp='1338402917' post='2437886']
So, I've been here long enough now that I recognize that absolutely everything has already been debated on PM (gay, straight, too much holding hands, not enough holding hands, galileo, inquisition, all of history, what the Pope meant by using the word "the" in his sentence, etc...).

What I'm wondering is how the people who have been here forever respond to all the rehashes of old arguments? Like, how many times have you seen debates about "gay this" and "gay that"? Do you just leave the debate table alone, or do you keep going back to try to defend your opinion or the Church or whatever, just to have to do it again another day? Is it a cycle, in which you give up for a while, and then go back and start debating the same debates again after a few months?

It seems to me that the only original board left is the lame board. Maybe I should just take a PM break...
[/quote]

It depends on the topic, the poster, and my current sense of humor.

edit: I think we need a phatmass project to keep us fresh, any suggestions?

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' timestamp='1338405243' post='2437922']
It depends on the topic, the poster, and [b]my current sense of humor.[/b]
[/quote]

or lack thereof, amirite?

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' timestamp='1338405243' post='2437922']
It depends on the topic, the poster, and my current sense of humor.

edit: I think we need a phatmass project to keep us fresh, any suggestions?
[/quote]

love that idea

Posted

This actually came up at the meet-up. I submit that it is not a particular bad thing b/c PM as a lot of lurkers and newbs that may be new to the such redundant topics, which may benefit from the current debate. The downside is that the newbs will probably not understand some people's tongue-in-cheek posts that references the past or think someone is being mean/hurtful.

Posted

I tried a fun new debate topic, but I got shot down.

I have another idea, but I don't want things to get too rough so I haven't proposed it yet: Star Trek vs. Star Wars.


Actually, though the debates we have now might feel repetitive, I feel like they go in cycles. Years ago it was a slew of different topics. Now it's what we have. It really depends on what's going on. Politics, however, are always in vogue.

Posted

[quote name='qfnol31' timestamp='1338410146' post='2438048']
I tried a fun new debate topic, but I got shot down.

I have another idea, but I don't want things to get too rough so I haven't proposed it yet: Star Trek vs. Star Wars.


Actually, though the debates we have now might feel repetitive, I feel like they go in cycles. Years ago it was a slew of different topics. Now it's what we have. It really depends on what's going on. Politics, however, are always in vogue.
[/quote]

nerds vs nerds? :huh:

:|

Posted

[quote name='Papist' timestamp='1338408100' post='2437988']
This actually came up at the meet-up. I submit that it is not a particular bad thing b/c PM as a lot of lurkers and newbs that may be new to the such redundant topics, which may benefit from the current debate. The downside is that the newbs will probably not understand some people's tongue-in-cheek posts that references the past or think someone is being mean/hurtful.
[/quote]

I think people who make inside jokes from the past are butthats

Posted (edited)

nerds lose

[quote name='jaime' timestamp='1338410386' post='2438055']
I think people who make inside jokes from the past are butthats
[/quote]
That seems familiar.

Edited by Papist
Posted

[quote name='jaime' timestamp='1338410386' post='2438055']
I think people who make inside jokes from the past are butthats
[/quote]
w/e hot stuff

homeschoolmom
Posted

That's as lame as pork-based eggs.

Posted

[quote name='fides' Jack' timestamp='1338402917' post='2437886']
So, I've been here long enough now that I recognize that absolutely everything has already been debated on PM (gay, straight, too much holding hands, not enough holding hands, galileo, inquisition, all of history, what the Pope meant by using the word "the" in his sentence, etc...).

What I'm wondering is how the people who have been here forever respond to all the rehashes of old arguments? Like, how many times have you seen debates about "gay this" and "gay that"? Do you just leave the debate table alone, or do you keep going back to try to defend your opinion or the Church or whatever, just to have to do it again another day? Is it a cycle, in which you give up for a while, and then go back and start debating the same debates again after a few months?

It seems to me that the only original board left is the lame board. Maybe I should just take a PM break...
[/quote]Depends upon why you debate. Some of it is a learning experience. Occasionally you may learn something new to bolster your opinion, or even change your opinion.

Posted

[quote name='Anomaly' timestamp='1338417655' post='2438154']
Depends upon why you debate. Some of it is a learning experience. Occasionally you may learn something new to bolster your opinion, or even change your opinion.
[/quote]Good point. I find it helpful to clarify what I believe and to look at a topic in a new way.

Rowan d'Alexandre
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Papist' timestamp='1338408100' post='2437988']
This actually came up at the meet-up. I submit that it is not a particular bad thing b/c PM as a lot of lurkers and newbs that may be new to the such redundant topics, which may benefit from the current debate. The downside is that the newbs will probably not understand some people's tongue-in-cheek posts that references the past or think someone is being mean/hurtful.
[/quote]

-newb stamp of approval-
:P

Yes. I've read through a lot of old PM debate topics already. Great stuff, most of it, and quite thought-provoking.

EDIT: Inside jokes are a part of joining Internet communities, like it or not. I don't have an opinion. Whonk each other to your heart's delight if you so wish. :P

Edited by Rowan d'Alexandre

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...