Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

P R E N D A (bill To Outlaw Abortion For Gender Selection)


Recommended Posts

Posted

WASHINGTON (AP) — House Republicans lost an attempt to pass legislation making it a federal crime to carry out gender-based abortions.
In a campaign year when [url="http://features.rr.com/topic/Democrats"]Democrats[/url] are accusing [url="http://features.rr.com/topic/Republicans"]Republicans[/url] of waging a war against women, Republicans sought to portray the Prenatal Nondiscrimination Act as a women's rights issue.
But the legislation required a two-thirds majority for passage, because of procedural rules, and had no future in the Democratic [url="http://features.rr.com/topic/Senate"]Senate[/url].
The bill would have would make it a federal offense to perform or coerce a woman into a sex-selection abortion.
Opponents said it would subject doctors to criminal charges and discriminate against Asian-American women. Abortions of female fetuses are an issue in some Asian countries where families prefer sons.

Yes to pass bill: 226 Republicans, 20 Democrats
No to reject bill: 7 Republicans, 161 Democrats
Voting Details [url="http://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/112-2012/h299"]http://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/112-2012/h299[/url]

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Seriously? SERIOUSLY? There are people who OPPOSE this bill?

And these people call themselves feminists.

Posted

Sad that this has to be put into law.

Posted

[quote name='Papist' timestamp='1338560147' post='2439297']
Sad that this has to be put into law.
[/quote]

More sad that it got shot down.

Posted

[quote name='BG45' timestamp='1338560812' post='2439310']
More sad that it got shot down.
[/quote]

Indeed.

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

all part of the culture of death

attack the unborn - check
attack marriage - check
attack women - check
attack families - check
attack the Church - in progress

Posted

And peopl[quote name='Anomaly' timestamp='1338558725' post='2439289']
WASHINGTON (AP) — House Republicans lost an attempt to pass legislation making it a federal crime to carry out gender-based abortions.
In a campaign year when [url="http://features.rr.com/topic/Democrats"]Democrats[/url] are accusing [url="http://features.rr.com/topic/Republicans"]Republicans[/url] of waging a war against women, Republicans sought to portray the Prenatal Nondiscrimination Act as a women's rights issue.
But the legislation required a two-thirds majority for passage, because of procedural rules, and had no future in the Democratic [url="http://features.rr.com/topic/Senate"]Senate[/url].
The bill would have would make it a federal offense to perform or coerce a woman into a sex-selection abortion.
Opponents said it would subject doctors to criminal charges and discriminate against Asian-American women. Abortions of female fetuses are an issue in some Asian countries where families prefer sons.

Yes to pass bill: 226 Republicans, 20 Democrats
No to reject bill: 7 Republicans, 161 Democrats
Voting Details [url="http://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/112-2012/h299"]http://www.govtrack....s/112-2012/h299[/url]
[/quote]
And people wonder why some of us are so opposed to the Democratic Party.

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

Socrates is writing a twenty page long paper about this as we speak. The introduction, I assume, will go something like "Well, the damned liberals are at it again with their crazy shenanigans..."

In all reality this is terrible. I'm still trying to figure out the logic (Or lack thereof): Republicans fighting for the lives of women that were killed for sexist reasons makes us chauvinistic?

Edited by FuturePriest387
Posted

Well to be fair this was simply a symbolic vote anyway...which is probably why Republicans (like Ron Paul) voted against it. There is no chance it would have made it in the Senate and instead of making political moves during an election year we should see some real work to fix our economy, etc. I do support the bill in principle though.

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

Whoa, whoa, whoa, Ron Paul, Mr. I'm so much more pro-life than everyone else on the planet since I am after all a doctor, voted [i]against [/i]this bill? Set up for failure or not, you always try because if there is any chance innocent lives may be saved it is worth it.

Edited by FuturePriest387
Posted (edited)

[quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1338589826' post='2439674']
Whoa, whoa, whoa, Ron Paul, Mr. I'm so much more pro-life than everyone else on the planet since I am after all a doctor, voted [i]against [/i]this bill? Set up for failure or not, you always try because if there is any chance innocent lives may be saved it is worth it.
[/quote]


No. You don't use silly partisan politics when our country is far from recovering and as recent data has shown may even be going into another recession. If this vote was actually thought to be going anywhere it would be one thing. This was a simple campaign attack manufactured by Republicans to make Obama and the Dems look bad. I want abortion abolished, but I do NOT want the issue of life being used as a political ploy. Anyone who does should seriously step back and take a better look at the situation.

Edited by Odin
Posted

[quote name='Odin' timestamp='1338590085' post='2439676']



No. You don't silly partisan politics when out country is far from recovering and as recent data has shown may even be going into another recession. If this vote was actually thought to be going anywhere it would be one thing. This was a simple campaign attack manufactured by Republicans to make Obama and the Dems look bad. I want abortion abolished, but I do NOT want the issue of life being used as a political ploy. Anyone who does should seriously step back and take a better look at the situation.
[/quote]So really the was a prolife point in voting against this bill? I'm kinda slow .. Could ya point it out to me?

Posted

[quote name='Anomaly' timestamp='1338593501' post='2439711']
So really the was a prolife point in voting against this bill? I'm kinda slow .. Could ya point it out to me?
[/quote]

My point is that Ron Paul does not play partisan politics and that is why I really like him as a politician....he is anything but. The whole point of this vote was in reaction to a video released on PP and to make a political move. I would rather a REAL effort be made to abolish something rather than a half assed knew it was going to fail anyway political stunt....it was nothing more.

Posted

Nevertheless, it was voted against because it would have been at least an incremental restriction on abortion even if political motivations were a part.

Posted

[quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1338559165' post='2439291']
Seriously? SERIOUSLY? There are people who OPPOSE this bill?

And these people call themselves feminists.
[/quote]


You're a smart person. You know perfectly well that feminists in the US have been very vocal about sex based abortion in Asia. This bill is a stunt designed to

a- test the waters for further legislation to limit abortion

b-embarrass anybody who refuses to participate in this political theater.

Of course feminists oppose it.

Posted

For some yes. But for some others it was voted against because of its political existence.

Posted

[quote name='Odin' timestamp='1338594847' post='2439721']
For some yes. But for some others it was voted against because of its political existence.
[/quote]


I don't speak Norse.

ardillacid
Posted

[quote name='Odin' timestamp='1338590085' post='2439676']
recent data has shown
[/quote]fail

Posted

I actually think unrealistic sham law regulations against abortion do more harm to the pro-life movement than good. for two reasons: one, they obfuscate the reality of who is really committed to pro-life causes and who is not, by giving the politicians who pay lip service to the pro-life movement something to talk about in their campaign speeches; and two, because they increase inefficient government interference into the procedure in a way that doesn't actually stop any abortions, but infuriates anti-life pro-choicers enough that they double down and dig their heels in all the more... not exactly the best way to move towards ending abortion IMO.

and in case anyone wondered, yes, I think federally banning "gender-based" abortions is an unrealistic sham law. you might as well ban people from having an abortion if they believe the devil told them to have an abortion. then you could have every doctor in the U.S. ask a woman "do you believe the devil told you to have an abortion?" before they got one, and the woman would say "no", and they'd get the abortion.

do people sometimes get abortions for gender selection? absolutely. can you really actually prove that in any given individual case? no. would this law have stopped people who do that from actually doing it, or even punished them after they had done it? no. how can we stop gender-based abortions? by banning abortion, there is no other way to do it.

I think Ron Paul was on the right track in voting against this bill. it's overreaching of the federal government in a stupid partisan way that in the end would harm the pro-life movement just to advance some politicians' carreers.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1338594999' post='2439723']
I don't speak Norse.
[/quote]

Let me state this more clearly:

Yes there are plenty of pro choice pro abortion liberals who voted against this bill because they believe that abortion should be allowed in every circumstance. This is why many Dems voted against the bill and this is true.

But this does NOT mean anyone who voted against it is a pro choice pro abortion liberal. That is like saying if someone voted against a bill that fixed the economy but also had a provision that said a million puppies would be slaughtered....yes this is an extreme example, but it works in this case, Just because the content of the bill might be good does NOT mean that the reasoning behind the bill is just as good and noble.

This bill was obviously thrown together in response to a recent video released about PP. It is a pure political ploy for the Republicans to use during this election year....this is angering and ridiculous. I do not know about you but I am personally offended when an important issue such as the issue of life is used as a political statement.

The Senate was never going to approve it...ANYONE knew that before making this bill and putting it to the floor....so why try? To use it as a political ploy.

Thank God for people like Ron Paul who refuse to play political games and instead want to focus on serious issues and work on serious bills instead of playing the political games and folly that has become our political structure.

Edited by Odin

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...