4588686 Posted June 2, 2012 Posted June 2, 2012 [quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1338591239' post='2439684'] As some of you may know, I was elected as a delegate to the Republican National Convention, and I intend to vote for Ron Paul and support his influence on the platform. There is a high cost involved in attending the convention, I am currently accepting donations to help defray that cost: [url="http://delegatepa18.blogspot.com/"]http://delegatepa18.blogspot.com/[/url] So if you want to help a phatmasser help Ron Paul, you can chip-in whatever small amount you can spare, every little bit helps. And I know, it is a long shot to hope for a brokered convention, but it's the only shot we've got (and the media reports about TX clinching it for Romney have actually ignored many of Paul's delegate takeovers in other states), especially if you, like I, do not believe one iota of Romney's flip flop to be supposedly "pro-life". Paul is the only true pro-lifer left standing. [/quote] Since when are you a Ron Paul supporter?
qfnol31 Posted June 2, 2012 Posted June 2, 2012 [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1338595741' post='2439727'] Since when are you a Ron Paul supporter? [/quote]
PhuturePriest Posted June 2, 2012 Posted June 2, 2012 (edited) Well, no matter who is the party pick, we can't vote for Gary Johnson. Not only is that a proverbial bullet to the head in terms of winning the election, but he wants to make abortion illegal after you can visibly see that it is a baby, so you can have an abortion before that. It would stop millions of abortions, but one abortion under his regime is simply one too many. If Ron Paul is truly pro-life and vows to make it illegal, I'll support him. But I want a true pro-life candidate, not someone that claims he is pro-life but doesn't do anything to make it illegal. Edited because I said I would vote for him and then later remembered I can't vote for anyone anyway. Edited June 2, 2012 by FuturePriest387
Aloysius Posted June 2, 2012 Author Posted June 2, 2012 since 2008, actually ultimately I'm an independent thinker about these things, I'm not actually a full fledged unfettered free market capitalist per se, you won't find me at an aynn rand book club, but I choose this side because I think it's the best direction for our country at present, and it's largely right.
Aloysius Posted June 2, 2012 Author Posted June 2, 2012 [quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1338596342' post='2439732'] Well, no matter who is the party pick, we can't vote for Gary Johnson. Not only is that a proverbial bullet to the head in terms of winning the election, but he wants to make abortion illegal after you can visibly see that it is a baby, so you can have an abortion before that. It would stop millions of abortions, but one abortion under his regime is simply one too many. If Ron Paul is truly pro-life and vows to make it illegal, I'll vote for him. But I want a true pro-life candidate, not someone that claims he is pro-life but doesn't do anything to make it illegal. [/quote]how about someone who claims he's pro-life when that will get him elected, but has previously said abortion is a woman's right? ie Mitt Romney. Mitt Romney is actually one of the most consistent men in the race. Mitt Romney has consistently supported every position that advances the political carreer of Mitt Romney. as far as Gary Johnson goes, I know he's the Libertarian Party's ticket but I've never looked too in depth into him or his positions on pro-life issues. but as far as you not wanted to support pro-life in name only folk, well, in my opinion that covers a large majority of the Republican establishment candidates.
Laudate_Dominum Posted June 2, 2012 Posted June 2, 2012 [quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1338596406' post='2439733'] since 2008, actually ultimately I'm an independent thinker about these things, I'm not actually a full fledged unfettered free market capitalist per se, you won't find me at an aynn rand book club, but I choose this side because I think it's the best direction for our country at present, and it's largely right. [/quote] Amen, brother.
Winchester Posted June 2, 2012 Posted June 2, 2012 [quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1338596406' post='2439733'] since 2008, actually ultimately I'm an independent thinker about these things, I'm not actually a full fledged unfettered free market capitalist per se, you won't find me at an aynn rand book club, but I choose this side because I think it's the best direction for our country at present, and it's largely right. [/quote] Ayn Rand did not favor fully free markets.
PhuturePriest Posted June 2, 2012 Posted June 2, 2012 [quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1338596645' post='2439735'] how about someone who claims he's pro-life when that will get him elected, but has previously said abortion is a woman's right? ie Mitt Romney. Mitt Romney is actually one of the most consistent men in the race. Mitt Romney has consistently supported every position that advances the political carreer of Mitt Romney. as far as Gary Johnson goes, I know he's the Libertarian Party's ticket but I've never looked too in depth into him or his positions on pro-life issues. but as far as you not wanted to support pro-life in name only folk, well, in my opinion that covers a large majority of the Republican establishment candidates. [/quote] I'm not saying all or even most Republicans are true pro-lifers, and I really respect you, by the way. I'm simply saying if I'm going to throw my support behind a guy I want him to match my beliefs as closely as possible, and I want to believe with concrete evidence he has hope in actually winning. Unfortunately Romney is a bit of a fish, what with his flip flopping and all that, and I'm not denying that. And do I think he will make abortion illegal? Honestly, that's going to be the most hard-fought battle since the battle of Waterloo, and it will be very difficult to even get half of what we want. But I'm not fully convinced Ron Paul is going to try to make abortion illegal and I'm not fully convinced he has the support, either. I do think, however, he at least tries to do what he says he'll do and he has a pretty great record.
PhuturePriest Posted June 2, 2012 Posted June 2, 2012 (edited) I think one of the worst things during this election is that all everyone cares about is the economy and what this guy did during this period and what that guy did during that period. Honestly, I don't care if I have to read books for entertainment and half the day is guided by candlelight so long as lives and souls no longer have to be lost. The economy is important, but I do not think at all that it is the most important issue, and the fact almost the entire population thinks it is really says something about our horrible society. People won't be able to eat lobster when they want to? Oh, boo hoo. What about the fifty million lives lost in America alone that never had the chance to even know what a lobster is? Edited June 2, 2012 by FuturePriest387
Aloysius Posted June 2, 2012 Author Posted June 2, 2012 [quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1338596844' post='2439739'] Ayn Rand did not favor fully free markets. [/quote]indeed, from a certain perspective. I was just listing the ways I'm not necessarily a cliche Ron Paulite, though everything about cliche Ron Paulites I am absolutely sympathetic to. But I go to GK Chesteron book clubs instead of Ayn Rand book clubs , and don't describe myself as favoring unfettered free markets. I absolutely support what I call Ron Paul's "Liberty Agenda", of course. and also think he's got the best realistic pro-life plan, which I'd like to see the Republican Party adopt as a practical way forward.
Amppax Posted June 2, 2012 Posted June 2, 2012 When I write Aloysius down on my ballot, do you think they will realize I mean you? I'm seriously considering adopting L_D's shtick.
homeschoolmom Posted June 2, 2012 Posted June 2, 2012 [quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1338597439' post='2439741'] I think one of the worst things during this election is that all everyone cares about is the economy and what this guy did during this period and what that guy did during that period. Honestly, I don't care if I have to read books for entertainment and half the day is guided by candlelight so long as lives and souls no longer have to be lost. The economy is important, but I do not think at all that it is the most important issue,[b] and the fact almost the entire population thinks it is really says something about our horrible society[/b]. People won't be able to eat lobster when they want to? Oh, boo hoo. What about the fifty million lives lost in America alone that never had the chance to even know what a lobster is? [/quote] The fact that you think our society is horrible for thinking the economy is important says a lot about you: It's says: Someone else is paying for your lodging and food Someone else is paying for your insurance, electricity and water bills and the gas for the vehicle that totes you around Someone else is paying for your education Someone else will figure out how to pay for any medical bills you rack up if you are injured or sick You pay little to nothing in taxes You don't have a mortgage or kids heading off to college You have plenty of years to figure out your retirement plans You don't have elderly parents to help support Don't get me wrong, I *do* believe that social issues are very imporatant, but in the day to day worries, the economy is #1 for most people. Do you *really* think people are lamenting that the economy is so bad that they can't eat lobster any time they want to? That was a *really* stupid statement-- you should rethink it.
PhuturePriest Posted June 2, 2012 Posted June 2, 2012 (edited) [quote name='homeschoolmom' timestamp='1338639293' post='2439868'] The fact that you think our society is horrible for thinking the economy is important says a lot about you: It's says: Someone else is paying for your lodging and food Someone else is paying for your insurance, electricity and water bills and the gas for the vehicle that totes you around Someone else is paying for your education Someone else will figure out how to pay for any medical bills you rack up if you are injured or sick You pay little to nothing in taxes You don't have a mortgage or kids heading off to college You have plenty of years to figure out your retirement plans You don't have elderly parents to help support Don't get me wrong, I *do* believe that social issues are very imporatant, but in the day to day worries, the economy is #1 for most people. Do you *really* think people are lamenting that the economy is so bad that they can't eat lobster any time they want to? That was a *really* stupid statement-- you should rethink it. [/quote] edit Edited June 2, 2012 by FuturePriest387
Winchester Posted June 2, 2012 Posted June 2, 2012 [quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1338598175' post='2439745'] indeed, from a certain perspective. I was just listing the ways I'm not necessarily a cliche Ron Paulite, though everything about cliche Ron Paulites I am absolutely sympathetic to. But I go to GK Chesteron book clubs instead of Ayn Rand book clubs , and don't describe myself as favoring unfettered free markets. I absolutely support what I call Ron Paul's "Liberty Agenda", of course. and also think he's got the best realistic pro-life plan, which I'd like to see the Republican Party adopt as a practical way forward. [/quote] I love Chesterton. Apart from his delusions about empowering government to punish businesses that get too big as the solution to certain people having too much power. Distributism amounts to this: "Businesses can get too powerful. Let's invest a governing body with power to destroy that power. That will solve things."
Aloysius Posted June 2, 2012 Author Posted June 2, 2012 ehhh distributism's a tricky subject, what you described is not how I'd describe Chesterton's solution, Chesterton is decidedly against big government as much as he's against big business. In "A Misunderstanding About Method" in Chesterton's [i]Outline of Sanity,[/i] he lists the following as things which not every distributist would agree with, but which might be a general direction towards distributism. There may be some things to disagree with them about, but they don't exactly fit your charecterization IMO: [quote](1) The taxation of contracts so as to discourage the sale of small property to big proprietors and encourage the break-up of big property among small proprietors. (2) Something like the Napoleonic testamentary law and the destruction of primogeniture. (3) The establishment of free law for the poor, so that small property could always be defended against great. (4) The deliberate protection of certain experiments in small property, if necessary by tariffs and even local tariffs. (5) Subsidies to foster the starting of such experiments. (6) A league of voluntary dedication, and any number of other things of the same kind.[/quote] The essence of distributism is that it is the libertarianism of the economic sphere; the libertarianism of the political sphere wants to get rid of big centralized governments as it infringes upon liberty, distributism says that big centralized businesses act in much the same way and ought to also be limited the way we limit government. but I'm certainly not going to the RNC with any plans to convert them to distributism I shall be engaging in my political libertarianism only, fighting against the overreach of Washington... I shall save for another day my fight against the overreach of Walmart.
Winchester Posted June 2, 2012 Posted June 2, 2012 (edited) I likely have that, in some of my GK stuff. I might have to read it. Tariffs are an overrreach of power. This is the problem with distributism: It advocates small government, but still seeks to invest in one group a right of commanding the private lives of other groups in the name of fairness. It will simply lead to where we are now. Protectionism for "small business" will benefit one person at the expense of another. Edited June 2, 2012 by Winchester
Winchester Posted June 2, 2012 Posted June 2, 2012 I likely have that, in some of my GK stuff. I might have to read it.
KnightofChrist Posted June 2, 2012 Posted June 2, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1338598175' post='2439745'] and also think he's got the best realistic pro-life plan, which I'd like to see the Republican Party adopt as a practical way forward. [/quote] His States Rights plan on the issue of abortion is more relativistic than realistic, as well as single minded and tyrannical in nature. Relativistic because in one state a child would be a person, in another a child would not be a person. Single minded because it looks at the issue of abortion as more of a procedure or action rather than the actual greater issue of the most basic Right we have, the Right before all other rights, the Right that no other right can exist without, the Right that every single State, or Civil Authority is duty and morally bound to recognize. It is tyrannical in nature because it would allow the Federal government to continue to deny the recognition of the most basic and fundmental Right, and allow the states to deny its recognition. If the Federal government or any government denies this recognition and allows for the murder of its people, no matter who they are, then we should not be surprised or shocked when it comes to deny, or allows us to be denied this most basic inalienable of Rights. Failure to recognize this Right is the makings of a tyrannical and heartless government. The Federal and state governments, (and every civil authority that ever was or will be upon the earth) are dutifully and morally bound to recognize, honor and respect the Right of Life, the Right of the people to exist, to have life and to live that life. Leaving it up to the states is a dereliction of duty on part of the Federal government and the states. There wouldn't be any need for the Federal or state governments to ban abortion, if both would simply honor and recognize the Right above all other rights, the Right of the people to exist, to Life and to live that life in peace and freedom from oppression. Edited June 2, 2012 by KnightofChrist
Winchester Posted June 2, 2012 Posted June 2, 2012 [quote name='KnightofChrist' timestamp='1338669274' post='2440027'] His States Rights plan on the issue of abortion is more relativistic than realistic, as well as single minded and tyrannical in nature. Relativistic because in one state a child would be a person, in another a child would not be a person. Single minded because it looks at the issue of abortion as more of a procedure or action rather than the actual greater issue of the most basic Right we have, the Right before all other rights, the Right that no other right can exist without, the Right that every single State, or Civil Authority is duty and morally bound to recognize. It is tyrannical in nature because it would allow the Federal government to continue to deny the recognition of the most basic and fundmental Right, and allow the states to deny its recognition. If the Federal government or any government denies this recognition and allows for the murder of its people, no matter who they are, then we should not be surprised or shocked when it comes to deny, or allows us to be denied this most basic inalienable of Rights. Failure to recognize this Right is the makings of a tyrannical and heartless government. The Federal and state governments, (and every civil authority that ever was or will be upon the earth) are dutifully and morally bound to recognize, honor and respect the Right of Life, the Right of the people to exist, to have life and to live that life. Leaving it up to the states is a dereliction of duty on part of the Federal government and the states. There wouldn't be any need for the Federal or state governments to ban abortion, if both would simply honor and recognize the Right above all other rights, the Right of the people to exist, to Life and to live that life in peace and freedom from oppression. [/quote] [quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1338592812' post='2439697'] his approach is to strip the federal courts of jurisdiction to overturn roe, and to [i]support a personhood amendment to establish the rights of the unborn. [/i] (emphasis mine)[/quote]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now