Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Aquinas Arguments For God Don't Work


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' timestamp='1339711874' post='2444758']
I think Aquinas's arguments, while valid, simply go over the head of most modern atheists, who lack the philosophical background to understand them. .
[/quote]

It's not an atheist objection. The most damnin. Criticism I can think of pre-Frege came from Kant who was a theist and quite well grounded in philosophy. But he's probably a Christain of theliberal kitty cat persuasion to you so instead I point you to GEM Anscombe. Cambridge Professor who as an undergraduate blew CS Lewis out of the water and caused him to rewrite the section of 'Miricles' that intended to refute naturalism and a very devout Catholic. She was twice arrested for protesting abortion and wrote about the evils of contraception. She makes the same basic argument that Kant, and so many others, have made against the first cause argument only she does the service of translating the argument into modern predicate calculus and demonstrating mathematically how the argument fails. She was a Tomist so I somehow doubt that her problem was that she just couldn't grasp the subtlety of his thought.

tinytherese
Posted (edited)

My brain is in pain as I read this thread.

Edited by tinytherese
Laudate_Dominum
Posted

How's the mini-debate going, eagle dude?

Posted

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1339845624' post='2445318']
It's not an atheist objection. The most damnin. Criticism I can think of pre-Frege came from Kant who was a theist and quite well grounded in philosophy. But he's probably a Christain of theliberal kitty cat persuasion to you so instead I point you to GEM Anscombe. Cambridge Professor who as an undergraduate blew CS Lewis out of the water and caused him to rewrite the section of 'Miricles' that intended to refute naturalism and a very devout Catholic. She was twice arrested for protesting abortion and wrote about the evils of contraception. She makes the same basic argument that Kant, and so many others, have made against the first cause argument only she does the service of translating the argument into modern predicate calculus and demonstrating mathematically how the argument fails. She was a Tomist so I somehow doubt that her problem was that she just couldn't grasp the subtlety of his thought.
[/quote]I thought she converted.

Her work is interesting...from what I remember she was very good at critiquing everything, but rarely offered good, solid alternatives.

Posted

[quote name='qfnol31' timestamp='1339988480' post='2445672']
I thought she converted.

Her work is interesting...from what I remember she was very good at critiquing everything, but rarely offered good, solid alternatives.
[/quote]

she did convert. She converted to Catholicism. I don't understand your comment. She was good at critiquing. She made several important contributions to philosophy but I'm not sure I could offer a breakdown of her critiques to positive solutions ratio. But even if she never did anything but critique the work of others that wouldn't change the fact that the first cause argument of Aquinas makes a very basic and fundamental error of logic. She obviously didn't have anything against Aquinas as she was part of the Tomist revival, but his argument is pretty obviously wrong. Maybe a valid first cause argument could be presented. But the one presented by Aquinas most definitly isn't

Posted

Shooting down arguments is easy work. Coming up with your own system is real work.

Your point is well taken, though, and I've known several Thomists or medievalists who agree with Anscombe.

Posted

Anscombe sounds very interesting.. I'll have to read more about her. I'm still having difficulty finding a thorough and non-hand-waving refutation of Aquinas' arguments (from anyone), though.

eagle_eye222001
Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' timestamp='1339933448' post='2445494']
How's the mini-debate going, eagle dude?
[/quote]





[quote]
[color=#333333][font=arial, sans-serif][size=3][left][background=rgba(255, 255, 255, 0.699219)]How does one access/process absolute/external truths using non-absolute/non-external means? How would someone justify this verificational method?[/background][/left][/size][/font][/color]
[color=#333333][font=arial, sans-serif][size=3][left][background=rgba(255, 255, 255, 0.699219)]Feser seems to be assuming that Aquinas's work hasn't been dealt with... when it most certainly has for CENTURIES now; what do you think hasn't been addressed by Dawkins and others? ...[/background][/left][/size][/font][/color]
[/quote]

Basically, I need to learn more philosophy, read Aquinas....
Argument is winding down because I'm unable to respond with finely tuned answers and youtube has limited space.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1340018028' post='2445739']
she did convert. She converted to Catholicism. I don't understand your comment. She was good at critiquing. She made several important contributions to philosophy but I'm not sure I could offer a breakdown of her critiques to positive solutions ratio. But even if she never did anything but critique the work of others that wouldn't change the fact that the first cause argument of Aquinas makes a very basic and fundamental error of logic. She obviously didn't have anything against Aquinas as she was part of the Tomist revival, but his argument is pretty obviously wrong. Maybe a valid first cause argument could be presented. But the one presented by Aquinas most definitly isn't
[/quote]
Since I can't seem to find her comments anywhere online, would you mind explaining her critique? I guess I thought there's was an argument over naturalism (this was in reference to his book Miracles), not the cosmological argument.

Edited by thedude
Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='eagle_eye222001' timestamp='1340062255' post='2446041']
Basically, I need to learn more philosophy, read Aquinas....
Argument is winding down because I'm unable to respond with finely tuned answers and youtube has limited space.
[/quote]
Oh my God, it's a youtube debate? Run.

Just about the worst forum for an intelligent debate of all time. Props for giving it a go.

Posted

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1339845624' post='2445318']
It's not an atheist objection. The most damnin. Criticism I can think of pre-Frege came from Kant who was a theist and quite well grounded in philosophy. But he's probably a Christain of theliberal kitty cat persuasion to you so instead I point you to GEM Anscombe. Cambridge Professor who as an undergraduate blew CS Lewis out of the water and caused him to rewrite the section of 'Miricles' that intended to refute naturalism and a very devout Catholic. She was twice arrested for protesting abortion and wrote about the evils of contraception. She makes the same basic argument that Kant, and so many others, have made against the first cause argument only she does the service of translating the argument into modern predicate calculus and demonstrating mathematically how the argument fails. She was a Tomist so I somehow doubt that her problem was that she just couldn't grasp the subtlety of his thought.
[/quote]
As St. Thomas's "Uncaused Cause" is not a mathematical proof, I failed to see how it could be mathematically disproven. It's metaphysical rather than mathematical. In the book I mentioned earlier, Fr. Spitzer gives a spin on the argument involving "conditioned" and "unconditioned reality," noting that the word "cause" has been interpreted by philosophers in overly-narrow ways. Unfortunately, I don't have time or space to rehash it here, but you can read the book if you're interested.

I'm not a huge fan of Kant, but I'm hardly a philosophy expert. From what I've read, Aquinas is more sane and reasonable. I hardly think bad philosophy is the exclusive property of atheists.

But my point is that typical pop-atheists like the one Eagle's debating generally don't have much philosophical depth at all, and just avoid the deep metaphysical questions of being, by limiting all possible being to material things. Saying that we have a functioning anthropic universe "just because that's the way it is" really doesn't answer anything.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Socrates' timestamp='1340145756' post='2446464']
As St. Thomas's "Uncaused Cause" is not a mathematical proof, I failed to see how it could be mathematically disproven. It's metaphysical rather than mathematical. In the book I mentioned earlier, Fr. Spitzer gives a spin on the argument involving "conditioned" and "unconditioned reality," noting that the word "cause" has been interpreted by philosophers in overly-narrow ways. Unfortunately, I don't have time or space to rehash it here, but you can read the book if you're interested.
[/quote]
Sounds like a fun read. Must remember to scoop up a copy. . .

eagle_eye222001
Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' timestamp='1340108010' post='2446229']
Oh my God, it's a youtube debate? Run.

Just about the worst forum for an intelligent debate of all time. Props for giving it a go.
[/quote]

Yeah, I am aware it's a terrible forum to debate stuff. Was responding to the Fuzz Bunnycall on Fr. Pontifex's new video on atheism. I have been quite reminded why I hate debating there.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...