Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SXcGF2qv2CY[/media]

fides' Jack
Posted

[quote name='arfink' timestamp='1339620798' post='2444378']
OK, in no particular order here:

@everybody: Obviously college is good for some things. The studies that actually relate to your field are great tools and often completely necessary. Obviously. I'm not arguing against that.

What I'm considering problematic is the idea that somehow the obtaining of a degree- any degree- somehow confers something extra upon you besides the actual skill training you got.

@Slappo- do you think that the difference in [b]character quality[/b] (NOT SKILL SET) is something that college students have placed into them in college, or do you think it's something that you wind up with as an end-product after all the "losers" are isolated and "weeded out" by colleges?

@Lillabett: I know you love hating on people who love to embrace the latest hype in hater-ness, but bear with me. I do not believe that college will continue to be a good investment for young people to be making. Job placement for recent graduates is at an all-time low since the introduction of the GI bill. I will not deny that the status quo absolutely demands you have a college degree, everybody knows that. What I rail against is the idea that something like that can be demanded when it's a comparatively ineffective measure of worker competence, and because it's far far more expensive than it ought to be.

As for learning for its own sake: great. We'll always have higher education for that. But why should everyone be forced to attend institutes of higher learning? (and I do mean forced, being made to have a degree in order to get a job is a brilliant coercion)

Literacy and numeracy are great things. Higher learning is a great thing. But for many people it's not only unnecessary, it's extremely costly as well.
[/quote]

I think I agree with everyone here. For certain, the benefits of college will change depending on the field.

With anything technical, college is an absolute must. And you can say that the rate of hiring college graduates is at an all-time low, but the same goes for non-college graduates (and if that's not all-time low, it's in the general area).

In general, I agree with the sentiment. Someone who does well in college is more likely to be more intelligent and more hard-working. More conformist? I don't know about that.

I have the benefit of landing a good job without having a degree. But I don't think I could have gotten the job without at least saying that I am attending college. So I work a solid 40 hour week and have been keeping 12 credit semesters. Yeah, it takes all my time. In my field, it's necessary. I will end up having taken classes for 6 or 7 years, but in the end it will help me provide an income for my family.

It may be true that in some fields employers don't care as much about a college education. In technical fields, that's never been more inaccurate, simply because the number of people applying is so great, one of the first steps taken is just looking at the education section of the resume. That weeds out a lot of people and still leaves plenty of qualified applicants.

Finally, I will say that timing has a lot to do with it, too. A college education - and doing well in college - speaks a lot more to someone who [i]just[/i] got a degree that to someone who got one 20 years ago. And employers will take that into account, also.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...