Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Breaking The Seal Of Confession


Recommended Posts

fides' Jack
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' timestamp='1340050929' post='2445963']
Edited to Add: Also, our absolution is not dependent on doing our penance. When we receive absolution grace is returned to our soul right then and there, immediately.
[/quote]

It should be added that absolution [i]is[/i] dependent on a sincere intention to fulfill the penance given by the confessor.

That's why it's included in most forms of the act of contrition: "I firmly intend, with the help of Thy grace, to confess my sins, to do penance, and to amend my life. Amen."

fides' Jack
Posted

[quote name='Slappo' timestamp='1340051998' post='2445978']
A penance is not assigned as a requirement of forgiveness or absolution (anymore). If I rememeber correctly, penances used to be assigned and fulfilled before absolution was given (early centuries when penance was public). Now we receive absolution before ever leaving the confessional. Whether or not we fulfill our penance we are forgiven of our sins. Failure to fulfill the penance though can result in sin, so penances can't just be ignored either.
[/quote]

Thanks for the clarification - I really didn't word it correctly.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

So if I murdered my sister and went to confession, could the priest give me the penance of turning myself in?

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1340060650' post='2446030']
So if I murdered my sister and went to confession, could the priest give me the penance of turning myself in?
[/quote]

No. He would be ordering you to break the seal of confession.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' timestamp='1340064729' post='2446049']
No. He would be ordering you to break the seal of confession.
[/quote]

Huh. Interesting.

For the record, I'm not planning on murdering my sister. :P

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1340067014' post='2446070']
Huh. Interesting.

For the record, I'm not planning on murdering my sister. :P
[/quote]

Hmm...good.

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' timestamp='1340064729' post='2446049']
No. He would be ordering you to break the seal of confession.
[/quote]

I think you have that wrong. The seal of confession means priests cannot divulge what THEY hear in confession.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' timestamp='1340070747' post='2446087']
I think you have that wrong. The seal of confession means priests cannot divulge what THEY hear in confession.
[/quote]

Nah, I think the difference is that no one can force you to say what you told a priest in confession (including a court of law), but you have the freedom to voluntarily divulge that information.

Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' timestamp='1340070747' post='2446087']
I think you have that wrong. The seal of confession means priests cannot divulge what THEY hear in confession.
[/quote]

The priest also cannot force you to divulge what you confess in confession under pain of sin.

Brother Adam
Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' timestamp='1340070747' post='2446087']
I think you have that wrong. The seal of confession means priests cannot divulge what THEY hear in confession.
[/quote]

Did you just tell a church scholar they are wrong?

[media=]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IhJQp-q1Y1s[/media]

PilgrimageOfGrace
Posted

I want them to try -- it will force the lukewarm Clergy to make a choice..will they or will they not collaborate?

Strictlyinkblot
Posted

[quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1340067014' post='2446070']
Huh. Interesting.

For the record, I'm not planning on murdering my sister. :P
[/quote]

That's good to know.

Noel's angel
Posted

It's kinda old news over here. It all seems to have blown over.

Posted

The "Seal" which applies to the confessor does not apply in the same way to the penitent, even if the penitent is a priest. A person can reveal he contents of his own confession and what the priest says.

That said, it is probably better for the penitent not to speak too much about what occurs in the confessional under normal circumstances. The less said about concrete instances of the sacrament of penance the better.

There are some exception to this, if a priest gave a particularly good piece of advice, perhaps that might be shared if you were not also going to reveal your own sins as a result. Otherwise, if a priest were to do something outrageously stupid or attempt a crime or the like, the penitent could and should address himself to the priest’s superior about what happened. The difficulty is, of course, that the priest remains bound by the seal and it could wind up being a matter of the word of penitent "A" against Fr. "B".

So, a penitent can speak of his own confession and the advice and penance received, but in normal circumstances it is better to leave it for the most part in silence.

fides' Jack
Posted

I saw this and thought "Oh! Cappie weighed in on this one - I want to see what he said!"

Brother Adam
Posted

Yes. Also, the canonical penalty is different if you hear someone else's confession, are not the priest, and break the seal, rather than if you are a priest and break the seal.

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' timestamp='1340228383' post='2446837']
Yes. Also, the canonical penalty is different if you hear someone else's confession, are not the priest, and break the seal, rather than if you are a priest and break the seal.
[/quote]

Now all of us know that the seal of the confessional is absolutely inviolable for the priest who hears the confession (c. 983). The seal binds the confessor under threat of excommunication [i]latae sententiae[/i] (c. 1388.1). Not so for an interpreter present at the confession, or for someone who overhears a confession, or who comes to a knowledge of sins from a confession. The latter are bound, under pain of sin and of penalty (c. 1388.2), to observe secrecy. But the difference is really a technical one. The direct divulging of the secrets of the confessional by others is punishable by a penalty not excluding excommunication because it’s a nefarious thing to do. Even if unpunished by ecclesiastical authority for whatever reason, to divulge what someone has confessed in the sacrament remains matter for sin. Obviously, the priest who hears, judges and absolves the penitnent has the greatest responsibility. In practical terms, however, that secrecy also affects everyone else.

[url="http://musingsofacanonist.wordpress.com/2012/05/15/forgive-me-father-for-i-have-sinned/"]http://musingsofacanonist.wordpress.com/2012/05/15/forgive-me-father-for-i-have-sinned/[/url]

Posted

so putting my ear up to the door is not ok?

RandomProddy
Posted

[quote name='Strictlyinkblot' timestamp='1339798493' post='2445200']
Within that speech he insisted that any priest who learnt of a child being abused under the seal of confession had to break that seal.

The government is now trying to put this into law.
[/quote]

If a lawyer learns that his client has abused a child is he compelled to make that public?

Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' timestamp='1340116266' post='2446270']
Did you just tell a church scholar they are wrong?
[/quote]

Just as I would tell someone with a PhD in mathematics that he would be wrong if he said that 2+2=5.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...