Winchester Posted July 1, 2012 Posted July 1, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Maggie' timestamp='1341166721' post='2451193'] I know, I know. If only the American people would listen to the emo hipsters who have never read [i]The Lord of the Flies.[/i] Clearly it's the fault of the evil fascists that you haven't made personal economic progress in decades, so that when a tax relief program expires AS PLANNED it makes a big dent in your charitable efforts and you can't maintain the same standard of living for your family. The people who HAVE gotten ahead in the last 10 years? They're surely in bed with the fascist pigs. Hard work and effort have nothing to do with it I'm sure. The head of my household has improved its lot by about 40% in the last 5 years - even with the increase in taxes, we have way more left over than we did back then. But that's probably due to higher levels of education, which was obtained at an Evil State University and paid in part by Evil State grants and Evil State subsidized loans. Oink, oink. It's rough living in a UNFREE society where the state attempts to guarantee access to the basics of human survival, like food and clean water. [url="http://www.ohiohistorycentral.org/entry.php?rec=1642"]The free market does it so much better.[/url] [/quote] Wasn't the Cuyahoga public property? If you think we had a free market in 1969, you're beyond hope. The state spends 5 dollars to get 1 dollar of aid, and your fabulous politicians aren't poor. But gee whiz, they're not really in it for the money! Maybe you should look into who actually writes regulations. Edited July 1, 2012 by Winchester
Winchester Posted July 1, 2012 Posted July 1, 2012 https://www.facebook.com/pages/Statianity/356040437750697
Annie12 Posted July 1, 2012 Posted July 1, 2012 [quote name='Maggie' timestamp='1341168779' post='2451209'] Why do you think that? [/quote] Because the obama administration want abortion on all levels. Abortion is their agenda (it's under the radar for a reason.)
Winchester Posted July 1, 2012 Posted July 1, 2012 [quote name='Annie12' timestamp='1341183105' post='2451279'] Because the obama administration want abortion on all levels. Abortion is their agenda (it's under the radar for a reason.) [/quote] Annie, that's dumb. Don't you know they're just trying to provide services? You're lucky the gubbmint taxes us. You would just waste the money on dumb stuff you like. A charity doesn't employ many people, but bureaucracies create thousands of jobs to accomplish very little, thus bringing us closer to total employment! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ABB-lScOoSk
Maggyie Posted July 2, 2012 Posted July 2, 2012 [quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1341180671' post='2451268'] Wasn't the Cuyahoga public property? If you think we had a free market in 1969, you're beyond hope. The state spends 5 dollars to get 1 dollar of aid, and your fabulous politicians aren't poor. But gee whiz, they're not really in it for the money! Maybe you should look into who actually writes regulations. [/quote] The Cuyahoga was certainly public property. Industry violated no laws in dumping their waste in the river, to the extent that it killed all life in the stretch between Cleveland and Akron. That's because their dumping was UNREGULATED. You see, a company has one primary objective: make money. So of course they used the easiest, cheapest way to get rid of their waste. Exactly what incentive did they have to dispose of it in a safer, more expensive way way? The goodness of their cherubic little hearts? Their love for their fellow man? Give me a break. Everyone knew what was happening to the river. The people who lived on the river would always make jokes about "wow the river is shiny today." Because the topmost layer of filth was reflecting the sun as it floated along. Still these companies kept it up for decades because NOBODY could make them stop. Even if the locals had organized a boycott it wouldn't have made a difference - because these were large (inter)national organizations and they had plenty of customers elsewhere who didn't give a carp about northeast Ohio. But lucky for us the fascists in Washington decided to make them stop. Our saviors in the capital swooped in and regulated the carp out of them (since again they had ZERO incentive to self-regulate in a meaningful way). It's more expensive, and it eats into profits. It allows the companies to reinvent themselves as community heroes (I'm looking at you Sherwin Williams) but if the regulations were relaxed they'd go right back to polluting the river. Because that's the whole point of their existence. Make more money. For now, the Evil Burdensome Fascist regulations make it more expensive to dump in the river, what with the huge fines. But barring regulation, there will never be a cheaper way for them to get rid of their waste than just throwing it out their back door. The free market does not have human dignity as its primary object and that's where it breaks down. If given true 100% liberty, it can eat humans alive, for instance in the pornography industry. If men were angels it would work great. Again see the works of William Golding. Right now it's popular to whine and moan about how the politicians stink, and they do stink at their jobs in many ways, but in other ways they have been extremely effective. In fact most scholars would agree that this is probably the best time in history for a human being to be alive, in terms of affordable access to food and healthcare, declining crime and war, and other measures of quality of life. And that's largely because humans have developed more effective ways of governing themselves and regulating the use of resources, not because of any magic performed by the free market.
Maggyie Posted July 2, 2012 Posted July 2, 2012 [quote name='Annie12' timestamp='1341183105' post='2451279'] Because the obama administration want abortion on all levels. Abortion is their agenda (it's under the radar for a reason.) [/quote] Well just so you know, doctors being paid for "quality of care" means they will be paid for performance. In other words, if a surgeon takes care of 1 patient per 30 minutes and they really take their time to make sure the patient gets a good outcome, they will be paid more than if they rush 3 patients through the 30 minutes and 2 of the patients get an infection and die. I encourage you to google "evidence based medicine" and learn about it.
arfink Posted July 2, 2012 Posted July 2, 2012 Well, this will be the last 2 cents I pitch this way for the time being: The idea that you can justify authoritarianism by arseerting that "men are not angels" is as old as dirt. The idea stinks because it expects men to behave like little devils, and thus encourages men to act in such a way whenever it's expedient or whenever a mistake on the part of the regulators occurs. We also know that regulatory mistakes and loopholes happen very frequently, and that our current system of regulation has only increased business' desire to find loopholes as quickly as possible. This of course doesn't even consider what happens when you take regulatory power away from the people who should be most equipped to dole it out and centralizes it.
Winchester Posted July 2, 2012 Posted July 2, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Maggie' timestamp='1341195157' post='2451339'] The Cuyahoga was certainly public property. Industry violated no laws in dumping their waste in the river, to the extent that it killed all life in the stretch between Cleveland and Akron. That's because their dumping was UNREGULATED. [/quote] So the laws regarding public property permitted harm to come to others. And this is a failure of the free market. And I've read William Golding. It's fiction. Thanks. Ever read "Paper Men"? Good book. Edited July 2, 2012 by Winchester
Tab'le De'Bah-Rye Posted July 2, 2012 Posted July 2, 2012 It must be hard being a good politician, why not start asking GOD to protect all the good politicians from evil that his will may be done in there lifes more effecitively. And don't even mention a name, just let GOD choose and do his thing.
Annie12 Posted July 2, 2012 Posted July 2, 2012 Sorry for speaking my mind. I just thought people would see that a president who's in favor of infanticite would use code language to get his agenda pushed onto the people. What I say is NOT "stupid" and should be listened to. I'm all for good care!!! But if obama makes the rules he WILL find a way to include abortion. We need to protect life! ITS NOT DESPOSABLE! Obama doesn't see why life in the womb is sacred so he is going to implament policies that he sees are right. He doesn't see. I feel it is very niave to arseume Obama is innocently trying to help people with their healthcare. Let me remind you that he is a politician. Why else would he be changing the way doctors get paid?? They seem fine righg now! This way is the best way to filter out doctors who don't do abortions. He can define what "quality of care mean"(and stick aborting as a requirement for doctor to practice medicine) and therefore weed out the pro-life doctors. This is just my speculation based on Obama's past but until you read to 2000 page bill don't say what I say is stupid. When you say that I think of all the unborn babies that get torn limb from limb in the mothers womb ever second in the US.
Maggyie Posted July 2, 2012 Posted July 2, 2012 [quote name='Annie12' timestamp='1341202407' post='2451377'] Sorry for speaking my mind. I just thought people would see that a president who's in favor of infanticite would use code language to get his agenda pushed onto the people. What I say is NOT "stupid" and should be listened to. I'm all for good care!!! But if obama makes the rules he WILL find a way to include abortion. We need to protect life! ITS NOT DESPOSABLE! Obama doesn't see why life in the womb is sacred so he is going to implament policies that he sees are right. He doesn't see. I feel it is very niave to arseume Obama is innocently trying to help people with their healthcare. Let me remind you that he is a politician. Why else would he be changing the way doctors get paid?? They seem fine righg now! This way is the best way to filter out doctors who don't do abortions. He can define what "quality of care mean"(and stick aborting as a requirement for doctor to practice medicine) and therefore weed out the pro-life doctors. This is just my speculation based on Obama's past but until you read to 2000 page bill don't say what I say is stupid. When you say that I think of all the unborn babies that get torn limb from limb in the mothers womb ever second in the US. [/quote] Winchester was being sarcastic when he said your statement was stupid. He meant you had a good point. We may very well get to the point that abortion training is required to practice medicine (God forbid it) but that's not what paying for quality means. The current system for paying doctors does not work well at all. It's bankrupting the United States! It's a fee-for-service system that encourages moving patients through like an arseembly line to max out reimbursement. Instead, doctors will now be reimbursed based on the results they get instead of the number of patients they see. Only problem is, there is a limited supply of doctors and this could turn into a wait-time issue. But in theory it's a much better approach to paying for healthcare.
Winchester Posted July 2, 2012 Posted July 2, 2012 [quote name='Maggie' timestamp='1341203385' post='2451379'] We may very well get to the point that abortion training is required to practice medicine (God forbid it) [/quote] Who would have the power to compel that?
Winchester Posted July 2, 2012 Posted July 2, 2012 [quote name='Annie12' timestamp='1341202407' post='2451377'] Sorry for speaking my mind. I just thought people would see that a president who's in favor of infanticite would use code language to get his agenda pushed onto the people. What I say is NOT "stupid" and should be listened to. I'm all for good care!!! But if obama makes the rules he WILL find a way to include abortion. We need to protect life! ITS NOT DESPOSABLE! Obama doesn't see why life in the womb is sacred so he is going to implament policies that he sees are right. He doesn't see. I feel it is very niave to arseume Obama is innocently trying to help people with their healthcare. Let me remind you that he is a politician. Why else would he be changing the way doctors get paid?? They seem fine righg now! This way is the best way to filter out doctors who don't do abortions. He can define what "quality of care mean"(and stick aborting as a requirement for doctor to practice medicine) and therefore weed out the pro-life doctors. This is just my speculation based on Obama's past but until you read to 2000 page bill don't say what I say is stupid. When you say that I think of all the unborn babies that get torn limb from limb in the mothers womb ever second in the US. [/quote] The State-worshiper was right. I was being sarcastic.
4588686 Posted July 2, 2012 Posted July 2, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Maggie' timestamp='1341195157' post='2451339'] The Cuyahoga was certainly public property. Industry violated no laws in dumping their waste in the river, to the extent that it killed all life in the stretch between Cleveland and Akron. That's because their dumping was UNREGULATED. You see, a company has one primary objective: make money. So of course they used the easiest, cheapest way to get rid of their waste. Exactly what incentive did they have to dispose of it in a safer, more expensive way way? The goodness of their cherubic little hearts? Their love for their fellow man? Give me a break. Everyone knew what was happening to the river. The people who lived on the river would always make jokes about "wow the river is shiny today." Because the topmost layer of filth was reflecting the sun as it floated along. Still these companies kept it up for decades because NOBODY could make them stop. Even if the locals had organized a boycott it wouldn't have made a difference - because these were large (inter)national organizations and they had plenty of customers elsewhere who didn't give a carp about northeast Ohio. But lucky for us the fascists in Washington decided to make them stop. Our saviors in the capital swooped in and regulated the carp out of them (since again they had ZERO incentive to self-regulate in a meaningful way). It's more expensive, and it eats into profits. It allows the companies to reinvent themselves as community heroes (I'm looking at you Sherwin Williams) but if the regulations were relaxed they'd go right back to polluting the river. Because that's the whole point of their existence. Make more money. For now, the Evil Burdensome Fascist regulations make it more expensive to dump in the river, what with the huge fines. But barring regulation, there will never be a cheaper way for them to get rid of their waste than just throwing it out their back door. The free market does not have human dignity as its primary object and that's where it breaks down. If given true 100% liberty, it can eat humans alive, for instance in the pornography industry. If men were angels it would work great. Again see the works of William Golding. Right now it's popular to whine and moan about how the politicians stink, and they do stink at their jobs in many ways, but in other ways they have been extremely effective. In fact most scholars would agree that this is probably the best time in history for a human being to be alive, in terms of affordable access to food and healthcare, declining crime and war, and other measures of quality of life. And that's largely because humans have developed more effective ways of governing themselves and regulating the use of resources, not because of any magic performed by the free market. [/quote] You can see graffiti all over this town (Zenica) demanding that the local metal factory put fiddlers on its chimneys. The factory is owned by an Indian man currently living in the UK. The fiddlers have not been given. Probably because there is no free market incentive for an Indian billionair living in the UK to give the slightest duck about some Bosnians and their health. On the plus side, this factory did provide a market incentive for the rather large respratory wing of the local hospital. I guess unregulated industry works itself out in the end after all. Yay blind faith in markets! Edited July 2, 2012 by Hasan
4588686 Posted July 2, 2012 Posted July 2, 2012 Strangely enough, Ive developed a chronic cough ever since getting here. Probably because my state worshiping body is continually choking on the sweet fumes of economic freedom. To head off one rebuttal, obviously on a system level Bosnia is not a free market state. But the power of this particular local industry allows it to operate without fear of the state taking serious action against it. While on a system level Bosnia needs more free industry its important to remember that industry is not a benevolent force. It is a ruthless force and when you are talking about large, multinationals the power of the state is the only potential resort that ordionary people have. Bosnia needs more free industry but it also needs more effective, coherent government.
Winchester Posted July 2, 2012 Posted July 2, 2012 [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1341237023' post='2451443'] You can see graffiti all over this town (Zenica) demanding that the local metal factory put fiddlers on its chimneys. The factory is owned by an Indian man currently living in the UK. The fiddlers have not been given. Probably because there is no free market incentive for an Indian billionair living in the UK to give the slightest duck about some Bosnians and their health. On the plus side, this factory did provide a market incentive for the rather large respratory wing of the local hospital. I guess unregulated industry works itself out in the end after all. Yay blind faith in markets! [/quote] When property rights are not enforced, there is no free market. There is no right to harm the property of others. How to deal with multinationals operating in a free market setting that benefit from corporatism in a different country (subsidy makes it easier for corporations to overcome economies of scale. Violence is how governments overcome this, and their actions on behalf of privately held companies is corporatism) is a serious and difficult question. Do you think that the state is not just another ruthless corporate body intent on enlarging its power? Private companies seek profit, which comes in the form of money. Money is useful to the functionaries of the State, and private companies use it to purchase the power of the State. The more power you vest in the State, the more you diminish the power of the individual, the more private corporations will be able to use the State like a mercenary. There's no Utopia, so centralizing power in some regulatory body with a monopoly on legalized violence appears to me to be blind faith in just another ruthless corporate body. States are no less interested in profit than any other human organization, so I don't see the point in attempting to make them the final arbiter.
Anomaly Posted July 2, 2012 Posted July 2, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Maggie' timestamp='1341195157' post='2451339'] The Cuyahoga was certainly public property. Industry violated no laws in dumping their waste in the river, to the extent that it killed all life in the stretch between Cleveland and Akron. That's because their dumping was UNREGULATED. You see, a company has one primary objective: make money. So of course they used the easiest, cheapest way to get rid of their waste. Exactly what incentive did they have to dispose of it in a safer, more expensive way way? The goodness of their cherubic little hearts? Their love for their fellow man? Give me a break. Everyone knew what was happening to the river. The people who lived on the river would always make jokes about "wow the river is shiny today." Because the topmost layer of filth was reflecting the sun as it floated along. Still these companies kept it up for decades because NOBODY could make them stop. Even if the locals had organized a boycott it wouldn't have made a difference - because these were large (inter)national organizations and they had plenty of customers elsewhere who didn't give a carp about northeast Ohio. But lucky for us the fascists in Washington decided to make them stop. Our saviors in the capital swooped in and regulated the carp out of them (since again they had ZERO incentive to self-regulate in a meaningful way). It's more expensive, and it eats into profits. It allows the companies to reinvent themselves as community heroes (I'm looking at you Sherwin Williams) but if the regulations were relaxed they'd go right back to polluting the river. Because that's the whole point of their existence. Make more money. For now, the Evil Burdensome Fascist regulations make it more expensive to dump in the river, what with the huge fines. But barring regulation, there will never be a cheaper way for them to get rid of their waste than just throwing it out their back door. The free market does not have human dignity as its primary object and that's where it breaks down. If given true 100% liberty, it can eat humans alive, for instance in the pornography industry. If men were angels it would work great. Again see the works of William Golding. Right now it's popular to whine and moan about how the politicians stink, and they do stink at their jobs in many ways, but in other ways they have been extremely effective. In fact most scholars would agree that this is probably the best time in history for a human being to be alive, in terms of affordable access to food and healthcare, declining crime and war, and other measures of quality of life. And that's largely because humans have developed more effective ways of governing themselves and regulating the use of resources, not because of any magic performed by the free market. [/quote]Maggie, you're half right. Yes, the Free Market is not solely about human dignity, it's the efficient allocation of resources and effort to produce what people need want and desire. Yes, the Government is not all about human dignity, it the efficienty allocation of 'public' resources and effort to produce whtat people need want and desire. There can't ever be a social/economic system that is pure free market or pure government control. We have to have both to provide balances for the different aspects that allow a sophisticated economy to work. The realistic arguments are the practical limits and freedoms that each are allowed to weild within the societal framework. The standard of living has improved because of entrepenourship fostered by and sometimes limited by, governmental policy and regulation. Both are needed. Too much limitation of or by either free market or government regulation aspect will collapse the entire system. People need to pay attention to the votes they put in the ballot box and cash register. Edited July 2, 2012 by Anomaly
Annie12 Posted July 2, 2012 Posted July 2, 2012 [quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1341208898' post='2451403'] The State-worshiper was right. I was being sarcastic. [/quote] Sorry! I couldn't tell.After I posted my response I read your post again and was wondering if you were being sarcastic but wasn't sure. SORRY!!!!!!! MY BAD!!!!!!!!
Annie12 Posted July 2, 2012 Posted July 2, 2012 [quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1341181065' post='2451271'] https://www.facebook.com/pages/Statianity/356040437750697 [/quote] This is RAZLE DAZLE X 100000000000! LOVE the sarcasm of it!
Anomaly Posted July 2, 2012 Posted July 2, 2012 [quote name='Annie12' timestamp='1341242525' post='2451468'] Sorry! I couldn't tell.After I posted my response I read your post again and was wondering if you were being sarcastic but wasn't sure. SORRY!!!!!!! MY BAD!!!!!!!! [/quote]The default Winnie translation is Sacarstic. But he is talented, so there is almost always an element of truth in his sarcasm. (I'm fishing for a prop from Winnie.)
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now