Jake Huether Posted May 17, 2004 Posted May 17, 2004 The website for Santa Clara University, a Catholic University in California, had an article on one of the Law Professors who had recently attended the "March for Women's lives". The article praised her and then linked the ACLU. So, I wrote the president of the University, the Dean of the Law School (who's website this was on), as well as the web-master: I am a graduate of San Jose State University, and I was considering a Masters Degree at Santa Clara University. As a devout Catholic, the fact that Santa Clara U. is a Catholic School made this University a very nice choice. However, upon scanning through this web site, I fell upon the homepage of the School of Law. I regret to inform you that there is an article which praises a professor for attending the "March for Women's lives". The "March for Women's lives" is in fact a March for the death of unborn women. It is the antithesis of the March for Life and simply seeks to rebel against this in the guise of a women's rights plea. As a Catholic School, Santa Clara University is obliged to conform to Catholic Teaching. And Catholic Teaching is that abortion is wrong no matter what. In fact, abortion is currently such a pressing issue that the Church has made several statements in regard to it; in particular in regards to lawmakers and politicians supporting abortion while claiming to be Catholic. The direct support or performance of an abortion is cause for excommunication from the Church, and any Catholic who publicly supports abortion cannot partake in the Holy Eucharist. I cannot judge the heart of Professor Margaret M. Russell. However, it is using the Name of God in vain to claim to be a Catholic School, and yet presume to support a very anti-Catholic entity such as abortion. I humbly request that you, at the very least, remove this link from the website. Thank you, and may God bless you. Sincerely, Mr. Jake Huether And here is the Dean's response: Dear Mr. Huether: thank you for your email note and your concerns about our website and our faculty member's participation in a national conference on women's issues. The article on our website linked viewers (such as yourself) to the national website of the American Civil Liberties Union and contained a reflection by the law faculty member, a nationally know expert on gender and race issues in America, on her participation in the conference and its meaning to her personally. As a law school, and as an educational component at a Jesuit university, we support and promote diversity of opinion and viewpoints on all issues of contemporary importance because we believe that openness of ideas and viewpoints is the best way of preparing our students for the societies they face and, we hope, lead. I certainly understand your personal disagreement with some of the topics of the women's conference. Again, thank you for writing to express your concerns. Donald J. Polden, Dean Please pray for him, and for the faculty of this school.
Phazzan Posted May 17, 2004 Posted May 17, 2004 Pfft, Catholic universities and colleges aren't bound by Catholic teaching. If they are independently run, there is no way to control what goes on there.
cmotherofpirl Posted May 17, 2004 Posted May 17, 2004 I would write back to him and ask if they ever heard of the mandatum.
Colleen Posted May 17, 2004 Posted May 17, 2004 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='May 17 2004, 09:22 AM'] I would write back to him and ask if they ever heard of the mandatum. [/quote] Yeah, do it. This is very sad, though I can't say it's surprising. But it's wonderful that you wrote to them. Maybe it'll at least make them think.
Jake Huether Posted May 17, 2004 Author Posted May 17, 2004 Okay, so I wrote back... Dear Mr. Polden, I greatly appreciate your response. I agree with the need to support and foster an openness and diversity of opinion among our community. But if this openness of opinion creeps beyond the bounds of Catholic Teaching, that is, beyond the bounds of Truth, it doesn't belong in a Catholic University. G.K. Chesterton said, "The object of opening the mind, as of opening the mouth, is to shut it again on something solid." And I can't help but wonder why so many people these days wish to promote an openness to lies and falsities. Worldwide nearly 45 million babies are killed each year at the hands of their mothers, and the doctors who perform the murder. Since the late 1960's 45 million unborn babies have died in the United States alone. That's more than the death toll for all US wars combined! Although, I'm sure you are familiar with these numbers. This isn't a matter of opinion. Modern science has proven beyond doubt, beyond opinion, that life begins upon conception. Opinions are a thing of the past when it comes to life in the womb. Really the only thing left to debate, now, is whether or not it is moral to kill an unborn baby. And as Catholics, we know the answer to that question. But at the risk of forfeiting her own future, a pregnant woman would like to keep the idea open that it just might be "moral". Although, the thought of simply waiting to have sex is simply out of the question, for whatever reason. It doesn't matter what "good" the ACLU might promote through it's policies and promotions in regards to gender and race. As long as it supports this atrocity, it should not be condoned on any website, let alone a Catholic website! And although Professor Margaret M. Russell may be a nationally known expert on gender and race issues in America, it would behoove her to learn about Margaret Sanger, the founder of Planned Parenthood, an ally of the ACLU (and vice versa), and her stance on gender and race issues. [url="http://www.geocities.com/kekogut/miscellaneous/Ppracism.pdf"]http://www.geocities.com/kekogut/miscellaneous/Ppracism.pdf[/url] Professor Russell must understand that by attending the "March for Women's Lives" she has supported the extermination of her own race, her own gender! These are the very things she is an expert on. Forgive me for sounding so much like a fanatic. I don't want to come across like an irrational, close minded extremist. I openly admit I am no expert on gender and race issues in America. But I can boast of being an expert in Christ Jesus, through His Catholic Church. And God has spoken through His Holy Church against abortion, and against the support of this abomination. I will once again humbly request, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, please remove this link from your website. Or, if you believe that the ACLU is a good organization with the exception of this one flaw, then it might be as simple as adding a disclaimer to the article stating how Santa Clara University and the Catholic Church do not support or promote abortion. But if in the name of openness of opinion and diversity of viewpoint you continue to promote the ACLU and their stance on abortion "rights" I humbly request that you pray before the Blessed Sacrament, who is Jesus Himself, and ask Him what He thinks. May the Love of the Father, the Peace of Jesus Christ, and the guidance His Holy Spirit fill your heart. God be with you. Mr. Jacob Huether
CreepyCrawler Posted May 17, 2004 Posted May 17, 2004 way to go jake! you're my hero! let us know if he writes back. that's so awesome that you wrote them. wow! sorry... i just think that's so cool.
Ash Wednesday Posted May 17, 2004 Posted May 17, 2004 Humph. A Jesuit University. Big surprise there. I think one of my h.s. friends went to that school. *sigh*
Jake Huether Posted May 17, 2004 Author Posted May 17, 2004 Hey thanks ya'll for your comments. I will be sure to post any replies. It's a shame because it really really misrepresents Catholicism. You know, use up Catholic money to build a school that promotes less than pagan principles. Yeah, good plan.
traichuoi Posted May 17, 2004 Posted May 17, 2004 Jake...thanks for teaching us how to continue to be Church Militant
Jake Huether Posted May 18, 2004 Author Posted May 18, 2004 All praise and glory to God. I have a little prayer card from Priests for Life. And every morning (or at least almost every morning) I pray this prayer saying that I promise never to be passive and to defend the lives of ALL my brothers and sisters. And so when I saw that link on the Santa Clara U website I really knew I had to say something. I guess God just put me in the right place at the right time. Let us pray that this professor's heart is touched. Thank you Pham!
annie Posted May 18, 2004 Posted May 18, 2004 Jake, Wow, you are very articulate AND faithful. I have a half-sister who taught at Santa Clara. SHE is an ATHEIST and I always wondered how she could have 'fit in' in a 'Catholic' school like that---hmm, guess I know how. I tell ya, I have three kids, two of whom will most likely attend college, and I sure as shootin' don't want them at a Catholic University (save the handful which have signed the mandatum). Better to be cast into the secular university environment, KNOWING the environment is NON-Catholic, then be surrounded by PSEUDO-Catholics, who dabble in the world's view of morality and call it "Catholic"....
Jake Huether Posted May 18, 2004 Author Posted May 18, 2004 [quote name='annie' date='May 18 2004, 08:16 AM'] Jake, Wow, you are very articulate AND faithful. I have a half-sister who taught at Santa Clara. SHE is an ATHEIST and I always wondered how she could have 'fit in' in a 'Catholic' school like that---hmm, guess I know how. I tell ya, I have three kids, two of whom will most likely attend college, and I sure as shootin' don't want them at a Catholic University (save the handful which have signed the mandatum). Better to be cast into the secular university environment, KNOWING the environment is NON-Catholic, then be surrounded by PSEUDO-Catholics, who dabble in the world's view of morality and call it "Catholic".... [/quote] Thank you Annie! I totally agree. I'd rather be able to tell my kid, this is the Catholic faith, and this is not. Make it clear, you know. These Universities make it unclear what is Catholic and what is not. They are guilty of taking the Lords name in vain.
Dave Posted May 18, 2004 Posted May 18, 2004 Jake, when you die, the Church should canonize you and make you the new patron saint of the unborn and of the Church! I know St. Joseph is already the patron saint of the Church, but that's ok -- nothing wrong with having 2 of 'em.
Jake Huether Posted May 18, 2004 Author Posted May 18, 2004 [quote name='Dave' date='May 18 2004, 09:54 AM'] Jake, when you die, the Church should canonize you and make you the new patron saint of the unborn and of the Church! I know St. Joseph is already the patron saint of the Church, but that's ok -- nothing wrong with having 2 of 'em. [/quote] Thanks Dave! But I'm far from being a Saint. LOL! Quite possibly the furthest... But I found the email address of the Professor who went to the March for Women's "life", and I wrote her. Please send your prayers with this letter. Professor Russell, May the Peace and Love of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ fill your heart! I recently visited the website for the School of Law at Santa Clara University, and my eye immediately was caught by the title "March for Women's Lives". The reason this caught my eye was that, being Catholic, I know that this conference is in direct opposition to Catholic Teaching on abortion. Now I want to make sure that it is very clear, I am a huge advocate of women's rights. In fact the scope of my advocacy actually goes far beyond that of the ACLU, because I advocate the rights of the unborn women, and the unborn women of color. I believe that a woman does indeed have a choice in reproduction. But the choice must be made prior to conception, because after conception, there is a new life whose rights must not be violated. And modern science has proven beyond doubt, beyond opinion, that life begins upon conception. Opinions are a thing of the past when it comes to life in the womb. Therefore the choice for a woman must be between having intercourse or not. It's actually a very simple choice, compared to the alternative. I'd much rather make a choice between pleasure and the neutral "non-pleasure", than to have to decide between keeping a life and taking one. You see, then, that by supporting abortion, the ACLU actually contradicts itself, because it supports the extermination of not only women of color, but all unborn women who's mothers choose that they do not wish to have them. But now I am veering off course. The reason I wanted to write to you was because of my concern for those who will visit the Santa Clara University School of Law website. Regardless of our own personal beliefs, which we are entitled to since we live in a free country, it is simply a misrepresentation of the Catholic faith to have a link to a pro-abortion organization on a website which is run by a pro-life organization, namely a Catholic University. This may not have been your intention, in fact, you may not have even been the one to post the link to the article, but nevertheless this link may misinform an individual who may not fully understand the Catholic position on abortion. Thus, reading the website for the School of Law, which is run by a Catholic School, one might draw the conclusion that the Catholic Church supports the ACLU as well as the March for Women's lives, which it certainly does not. And so my letter to you is a humble petition to remove the link to the ACLU from the Santa Clara University website. An alternate solution also might be simply to post a disclaimer under the link, stating that the Catholic Church does not support the ACLU's stance on abortion. Professor Russell, you are a child of God, and regardless of your response to this email, I will bring you before our Lord in the Blessed Sacrament, who is He Himself that made us. My prayers are with you. I would also like to be very open about my communication with the Dean of the School of Law, as well as the President of Santa Clara University. I have written them also with my concern, and the Dean has written me back. Since this dialogue concerns you, then I will include it here if you wish to read. And I then included the letters that I wrote to the Dean as well as his response. May God bless this lady.
CatholicAndFanatical Posted May 18, 2004 Posted May 18, 2004 werd! dude you said it well..very impressive. Please post what they respond..im anxiously waiting..
Thy Geekdom Come Posted May 18, 2004 Posted May 18, 2004 Sweetness! Good job, Jake! Let 'em have it! I have a feeling, though, that they will not fulfill your requests.
Confessionator741 Posted May 18, 2004 Posted May 18, 2004 Huether, that is all simply amazing. prayers and props. mad prayers and mad props. B
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now