Socrates Posted July 31, 2012 Posted July 31, 2012 [quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1343598661' post='2460037'] Well if you insist... 1. This is the kind of article that only serves to reinforce the opinions of those who already agree with the author's original statement. 2. It's full of logical fallacies. But if the article gets a discussion going, then by all means, it can be useful. [/quote] [quote name='beatitude' timestamp='1343604326' post='2460077'] I agree with Basilia Marie. In addition to being full of logical holes, it also has a very chilling tone, stemming from its basic premise that something has to be in the interests of the state in order for the state to permit it. There are many beautiful things in life that don't have a clear utilitarian purpose - cloistered religious life is the first thing that springs to mind - and we start going down a dangerous road if we decide that legal recognition should be conferred on something only if it's 'useful' to the state as a whole. That almost sets the state up as a god. Marriage in the Catholic view is first and foremost a sacrament between a man and a woman that mirrors the creative love of the Trinity. It doesn't matter whether the state is 'interested' in the marriage or not, as marriage existed long before there were any states - it's not the state that confers legitimacy in the eyes of God. [/quote] Actually, the arguments in this article are similar to some of those given against homosexual "marriage" and "civil unions" by our current Holy Father in this CDF document: "[url="http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20030731_homosexual-unions_en.html"]Considerations Regarding Proposals to Give Legal Recognition to Unions Between Homosexual Persons[/url]" (which is not popular with the phatmass crowd either, though I'd strongly suggest every Catholic read it). The main logical fallacy here is that of you and others who falsely equate the government [i]permitting[/i] a type of activity with the government granting it special legal benefits and recognition. As I've pointed out before, in states where so-called "gay-marriage" continues to not be legally recognized, homosexuals are free to live together, sodomize one another, and even have church "marriage" ceremonies with rings and such if they wish. The state simply does not give any legal recognition to their sodomitic housekeeping as a "marriage." The state legally recognizes marriage between a man and a woman, because that is the most fundamental building unit of human society, and is absolutely essential to having a functional human society, as it provides the best framework for the procreation and raising of children. Thus it is in everyone's best interest to recognize and support it. That's what both the author of this article and the Church recognize. Two (or more) persons of the same sex simply does not serve this indispensable role in human society, and is not and cannot be an actual marriage. Thus, there is absolutely no need for the state to treat it as such. Our country managed to last well over two centuries without state recognition of "gay marriage." Catholics acting as though continuing to legally recognize only marriages between a man and a woman, as it always has, presents some kind of new threat to Catholic marriage is just silly and illogical.
Socrates Posted July 31, 2012 Posted July 31, 2012 [quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1343774151' post='2460872'] Sodomy laws also apply to oral sex. Gay or not. [/quote] That is a different issue than "gay marriage."
PhuturePriest Posted July 31, 2012 Posted July 31, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1343774151' post='2460872'] Sodomy laws also apply to oral sex. Gay or not. [/quote] Also, this is hardly a good comparison since oral sex is allowed by the Church, there are simply restrictions and some obvious possible dangers to it. Edited July 31, 2012 by FuturePriest387
Vincent Vega Posted August 1, 2012 Posted August 1, 2012 [quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1343776042' post='2460880'] Also, this is hardly a good comparison since oral sex is allowed by the Church, there are simply restrictions and some obvious possible dangers to it. [/quote] Adult content follows: [spoiler]Oral-genital contact is permitted, but oral sex in its strictest sense is not.[/spoiler]
Ice_nine Posted August 1, 2012 Posted August 1, 2012 well, looks like I agree with something Soc said. Lookie that. [quote name='Socrates' timestamp='1343773659' post='2460865'] The main logical fallacy here is that of you and others who falsely equate the government [i]permitting[/i] a type of activity with the government granting it special legal benefits and recognition. [/quote] which is why I asked for what "gay-marriage" entails? I believe people simply want to use government as a vehicle for shaping (or perhaps coercing) moral law. The government says X is just like Y, so if you believe in Y, you must believe in X, lest you be a backward hillbilly, for the almighty state has spoken! Again, I personally don't look to the state to tell me what's right and wrong, but I think a sizable portion of people find this affirmation/validation/acknowledgement from the state essential to normalizing homosexuality. I'd say they are barking up the wrong tree a bit, because for people of a religious persuasion do not (I hope to God) view the gov't as a moral arbiter. Then again, nominal religious folk on the fence WOULD most likely be converted via a government declaration on what marriage [i]is[/i]. Over time or course. Now other than a semantic dictate handed by the government (gay marriage is a marriage just like straight marriage), and tax exemptions, what other benefits of marriage are "not permitted" by not recognizing gay marriage? Cause so far I don't think homosexual unions are being barred from anything, they're just not being given something that 95% of other social relationships aren't being given.
PhuturePriest Posted August 1, 2012 Posted August 1, 2012 [quote name='USAirwaysIHS' timestamp='1343792258' post='2460980'] Adult content follows: [spoiler]Oral-genital contact is permitted, but oral sex in its strictest sense is not.[/spoiler] [/quote] I have no clue what that means and unfortunately you can't explain without being more explicit, and I wouldn't want to do that in case there is a younger reader following this thread.
tojo Posted August 1, 2012 Posted August 1, 2012 [quote name='fides' Jack' timestamp='1343759643' post='2460716'] IFrom what I can see, he's trying to get the state to view marriage as a possible benefit to the state. If this were the case, we would have little to worry about, since it would fall into place with our own morals. Currently, the state views marriage as something that can help Gov. X get re-elected. And that's how it uses marriage. [/quote] Very true; unfortunately, in our political culture long-term good is almost never pursued at the expense of a short term benefit - especially if the short-term benefit leads to even brief political gain.
Socrates Posted August 2, 2012 Posted August 2, 2012 [quote name='Ice_nine' timestamp='1343793862' post='2460984'] well, looks like I agree with something Soc said. Lookie that. [/quote] Oh please. The whole "I'm so shocked I agree with Socrates on something!" line is getting so old on here, especially when it's from people I generally agree with. [quote]which is why I asked for what "gay-marriage" entails? I believe people simply want to use government as a vehicle for shaping (or perhaps coercing) moral law. The government says X is just like Y, so if you believe in Y, you must believe in X, lest you be a backward hillbilly, for the almighty state has spoken! Again, I personally don't look to the state to tell me what's right and wrong, but I think a sizable portion of people find this affirmation/validation/acknowledgement from the state essential to normalizing homosexuality. I'd say they are barking up the wrong tree a bit, because for people of a religious persuasion do not (I hope to God) view the gov't as a moral arbiter. Then again, nominal religious folk on the fence WOULD most likely be converted via a government declaration on what marriage [i]is[/i]. Over time or course. Now other than a semantic dictate handed by the government (gay marriage is a marriage just like straight marriage), and tax exemptions, what other benefits of marriage are "not permitted" by not recognizing gay marriage? Cause so far I don't think homosexual unions are being barred from anything, they're just not being given something that 95% of other social relationships aren't being given.[/quote] You're exactly right. The government isn't the ultimate arbitrator of what is right and wrong, but according to Catholic social teaching, the law should reflect and be in accord with natural law morality, rather than be contrary to it. The widespread confusion on this issue shows how desperately we need a widespread return to Thomistic based social teaching.
4588686 Posted August 3, 2012 Posted August 3, 2012 [quote name='Socrates' timestamp='1343945225' post='2461715'] Oh please. The whole "I'm so shocked I agree with Socrates on something!" line is getting so old on here, especially when it's from people I generally agree with. [/quote] I don't think it's a line so much as people generally don't like to agree with your posts because you come off like a huge d...Hey! Look at that cat! razzle dazzle! Anyway, what was I saying? I think it was something about how maybe to unravel this mystery you should go back to MarieTheresa's enlightening (and comprehensive) post on this vary subject.
Ice_nine Posted August 3, 2012 Posted August 3, 2012 [quote name='Socrates' timestamp='1343945225' post='2461715'] Oh please. The whole "I'm so shocked I agree with Socrates on something!" line is getting so old on here, especially when it's from people I generally agree with. [/quote] Sorry. I didn't mean anything by it. It's not even that I disagree a lot of the times with what you say, but [i]how[/i] you say it. It's sometimes the spirit behind what you say appears to be . . . less than pleasant [quote] The government isn't the ultimate arbitrator of what is right and wrong, but according to Catholic social teaching, the law should reflect and be in accord with natural law morality, rather than be contrary to it.[/quote] So do you think that a reasonable compromise would be for "the state to get outta the marriage business"? Or are you more in line with KoC that the state should promote the "traditional definition of marriage" I tend to think this entanglement of the state and morality is part of the reason for the mess we are in now. You wouldn't have people crying for the state to approve gay marriages if they didn't think it [i]meant[/i] something, or had some moral value. If the state stopped granting any recognition for marriage period (but recognized contracts made between any number of people) it may not be exactly encouraging "legit" marriages, but at least it wouldn't be actively counter-acting natural law. Thomistic based social-morality? Don't know as much Aquinas as I should. #badcatholic
Amory Posted August 3, 2012 Posted August 3, 2012 [quote name='Ice_nine' timestamp='1343969426' post='2461884'] Sorry. I didn't mean anything by it. It's not even that I disagree a lot of the times with what you say, but [i]how[/i] you say it. It's sometimes the spirit behind what you say appears to be . . . less than pleasant So do you think that a reasonable compromise would be for "the state to get outta the marriage business"? Or are you more in line with KoC that the state should promote the "traditional definition of marriage" I tend to think this entanglement of the state and morality is part of the reason for the mess we are in now. You wouldn't have people crying for the state to approve gay marriages if they didn't think it [i]meant[/i] something, or had some moral value. If the state stopped granting any recognition for marriage period (but recognized contracts made between any number of people) it may not be exactly encouraging "legit" marriages, but at least it wouldn't be actively counter-acting natural law. Thomistic based social-morality? Don't know as much Aquinas as I should. #badcatholic [/quote] According to Thomistic political thought, the state is responsible for promoting the common good, which includes the moral good of the community. There are all sorts of instances where the government is not required to criminalize a particular sin because it would cause greater harm than good; however, saying the government should as a rule refrain from "legislating morality" has no part in a Thomistic political worldview.
4588686 Posted August 3, 2012 Posted August 3, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Socrates' timestamp='1343773659' post='2460865'] As I've pointed out before, in states where so-called "gay-marriage" continues to not be legally recognized, homosexuals are free to live together, sodomize one another, and even have church "marriage" ceremonies with rings and such if they wish. The state simply does not give any legal recognition to their sodomitic housekeeping as a "marriage." [/quote] It's so strange that with people like you out there so many homosexuals are just totally repelled by Christianity and Christians. Edited August 3, 2012 by Hasan
Amppax Posted August 3, 2012 Posted August 3, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1344021410' post='2462254'] It's so strange that with people like you out there so many homosexuals are just totally repelled by Christianity and Christians. [/quote] You seem cranky, want a hug? Edited August 3, 2012 by Amppax
Socrates Posted August 5, 2012 Posted August 5, 2012 [quote name='Ice_nine' timestamp='1343969426' post='2461884'] So do you think that a reasonable compromise would be for "the state to get outta the marriage business"? Or are you more in line with KoC that the state should promote the "traditional definition of marriage" I tend to think this entanglement of the state and morality is part of the reason for the mess we are in now. You wouldn't have people crying for the state to approve gay marriages if they didn't think it [i]meant[/i] something, or had some moral value. If the state stopped granting any recognition for marriage period (but recognized contracts made between any number of people) it may not be exactly encouraging "legit" marriages, but at least it wouldn't be actively counter-acting natural law.[/quote] I'm in line with the teaching of the Church that "The common good requires that laws recognize, promote and protect marriage as the basis of the family, the primary unit of society," and that we as Catholics are morally obligated to oppose any legal recognition of homosexual "unions." "The Church teaches that respect for homosexual persons cannot lead in any way to approval of homosexual behaviour[b] or to legal recognition of homosexual unions.[/b]" In fact, for Catholic politicians to vote in favor of legal recognition of homosexual unions is condemned as gravely immoral. "When legislation in favour of the recognition of homosexual unions is proposed for the first time in a legislative assembly, [b]the Catholic law-maker has a moral duty to express his opposition clearly and publicly and to vote against it. To vote in favour of a law so harmful to the common good is gravely immoral.[/b]" [url="http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20030731_homosexual-unions_en.html"]http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20030731_homosexual-unions_en.html[/url] The mess we're in now is not because of the "entanglement" of government and morality, but a lack of morality in both the government and the voting citizenry. Removing all moral considerations from law and government will bring neither justice nor freedom, but simply immoral government and immoral laws. The regimes of Stalin, Mao, and Pol Pot or prime examples of government "unentangled" by morality. [quote]Thomistic based social-morality? Don't know as much Aquinas as I should. #badcatholic[/quote] [quote name='Amory' timestamp='1343973475' post='2461905'] According to Thomistic political thought, the state is responsible for promoting the common good, which includes the moral good of the community. There are all sorts of instances where the government is not required to criminalize a particular sin because it would cause greater harm than good; however, saying the government should as a rule refrain from "legislating morality" has no part in a Thomistic political worldview. [/quote] Exactly. The idea that the law or government must have nothing to do with morality is bogus. Certain moral evils may be[i] tolerated[/i] by the state if the process of enforcing against them would likely result in greater evil, but the state must never actively condone or reward evil. For instance, one could oppose anti-sodomy laws on that ground, but a Thomist would never support the state actively supporting or rewarding immoral behavior by such things as granting special legal recognition to sodomitic "unions."
4588686 Posted August 5, 2012 Posted August 5, 2012 [quote name='Socrates' timestamp='1344203329' post='2463095'] Exactly. [b] The idea that the law or government must have nothing to do with morality is bogus. Certain moral evils may be[i] tolerated[/i] by the state if the process of enforcing against them would likely result in greater evil, but the state must never actively condone or reward evil. For instance, one could oppose anti-sodomy laws on that ground, but a Thomist would never support the state actively supporting or rewarding immoral behavior by such things as granting special legal recognition to sodomitic "unions."[/b] [/quote] Right. And this is why the idea that you are actually a small-government conservative is a joke.
Anomaly Posted August 6, 2012 Posted August 6, 2012 [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1344211001' post='2463166'] Right. And this is why the idea that you are actually a small-government conservative is a joke. [/quote]I think Soc has certain principles as a higher importance than a slavish fawning desire to meet your stereotypes.
4588686 Posted August 6, 2012 Posted August 6, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Anomaly' timestamp='1344221894' post='2463280'] I think Soc has certain principles as a higher importance than a slavish fawning desire to meet your stereotypes. [/quote] Right. Well it is my irrational prejudice that in the American context when somebody says that they are a small government conservative they mean something less akin to the theoretical framework of the Islamic Republic of Iran (only with the Church rather than the Supreme Leader refereeing to ensure that no 'democratic' action exceeds the limits) and something more akin to Barry Goldwater or Ron Paul. Edited August 6, 2012 by Hasan
Amory Posted August 6, 2012 Posted August 6, 2012 [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1344211001' post='2463166'] Right. And this is why the idea that you are actually a small-government conservative is a joke. [/quote] And why isn't a mixture of different legal responses an acceptable response? One doesn't need to apply an abstract principle all the way across the board without consideration for the common good. One can argue that government in general should be smaller but in particular instances should be larger or stay where it is. Perhaps certain areas should be relatively free of government control (such as the market) while others should involve government action (such as public morals). Also, perhaps the problem isn't so much a large government as it is a large [i]federal[/i] government, with more active state governments being desirable.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now