Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Y'all, I have summer reading. I haven't finished it yet, and I do not think I will. The book has explicit sex scenes and it is just terrible. I struggle with my own purity as well as memories from my own past. I go to a Catholic school for God's sake!! I didn't go to catholic school to read books with sex scenes and this croutons. (there are like four) Should I not continue reading this book and explain that it was just not possible to my teacher or do I smell of elderberries it up and read it? Y'all, I'm already scared because I am a new student trying to find some sort of normalcy in a new school. Now I'm scared my teacher will hate me! I'm calling the chaplain tomorrow to tell him about this. Please give advice and, more than anything, pray for me.

Posted

[quote name='the171' timestamp='1344835592' post='2466754']
Y'all, I have summer reading. I haven't finished it yet, and I do not think I will. The book has explicit sex scenes and it is just terrible. I struggle with my own purity as well as memories from my own past. I go to a Catholic school for God's sake!! I didn't go to catholic school to read books with sex scenes and this croutons. (there are like four) Should I not continue reading this book and explain that it was just not possible to my teacher or do I smell of elderberries it up and read it? Y'all, I'm already scared because I am a new student trying to find some sort of normalcy in a new school. Now I'm scared my teacher will hate me! I'm calling the chaplain tomorrow to tell him about this. Please give advice and, more than anything, pray for me.
[/quote]

What's the book?

PhuturePriest
Posted

I will definitely pray for you.

I cannot tell you what to do, but I can tell you what I would do. Not to shock anyone and give them a heart attack, but I am not shy around giving my opinion about things, and if I were in theory told to read a book with explicit sex scenes, I would tell the teacher where he/she could put that book. I would never put myself under such temptation, even if it meant failing. I would talk to the teacher about it and see if anything could be done. And if it was mandatory, I would simply drop out of the class or fail. But again, I am not recommending this to you. This is merely what I would do and you can take from it what you please. If there is anything I would recommend it would be to call the chaplain, but I imagine the chaplain will say much the same.

Posted

The Tortilla Curtain. I have to annotate the whole book.

PhuturePriest
Posted

I looked it up. It looks to me like the usual weird book people obsess about, only there are a million other books like it. Certainly your teacher could choose one of the books out of the large selection of terrible boring books that have to do with racial tension and what-not that does not involve sex?

Posted

I just propped your post, FP. Feel proud.

PhuturePriest
Posted

[quote name='the171' timestamp='1344836845' post='2466770']
I just propped your post, FP. Feel proud.
[/quote]

I felt proud even before I saw your post. I'm not even joking. :proud:

Posted

This thread no longer pleases me. You could probably just skip the sex scenes and not miss anything serious of the plot. Sex is part of life. It's going to be in a lot of books. Thus have I ruled.

PhuturePriest
Posted

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1344837333' post='2466773']
This thread no longer pleases me. You could probably just skip the sex scenes and not miss anything serious of the plot. Sex is part of life. It's going to be in a lot of books. Thus have I ruled.
[/quote]

She has to annotate the whole book, which includes the sex scenes. I'm not sure how you would even annotate those anyway, but from what I gather annotating them is expected.

Pax_et bonum
Posted (edited)

Can you try to read around the sexual parts? If I were a teacher, I would think you were just making up an excuse for being lazy and not reading it (not that that's what I really think you're doing). There is a mature way to handle things of a sexual nature sometimes, but if what you're reading is pornographic, then just skip it. I had to read Brave New World in which promiscuity is a virtue for class, but it wasn't pornographic that I can remember so not that big of a deal. There's a big difference between BNW and say, 50 Shades of Grey. If it comes down to your teacher asking why you didn't annotate a sex scene, then you can explain that you don't want to be tempted and what have you.

Edited by Pax_et bonum
Posted (edited)

Sex is great! I would love to skip but I can't because the author decided to put conversation about major incidents in there while they are having sex. I'm probably just a prude. I know. But this ticks me off.


Edit: like I said, I'm just a prude.

Edited by the171
PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

[quote name='the171' timestamp='1344837816' post='2466778']
Sex is great! I would love to skip but I can't because the author decided to put conversation about major incidents in there while they are having sex. I'm probably just a prude. I know. But this ticks me off.
[/quote]

I'm with you. I would tell them to stick it, like I said, and I know for a fact I am not a prude. I read theology of the body quite a bit, and am mature enough to even talk about it in detail as the Pope himself did, but there is a difference between glorifying sex and objectifying it. If these scenes are pornographic, the author is objectifying it, and the Catechism says something about not reading or watching pornography, whether it is real or fictional.

Edited by FuturePriest387
Basilisa Marie
Posted (edited)

Are your objections to the material enough that you'd be willing to accept a zero on the assignment? Either figure out a way to read the book, or be willing to accept a failing grade for the assignment. Those are really your only two options.

Edited by Basilisa Marie
Posted

Being that confession was necessary after just catching an accidental glimpse of a scene while trying to catch conversation about the stupid dead dog that apparently has some sort of importance in the story, I think I am going to take the zero and call the chaplain. I emailed the teacher and said I would do an replacement assignment like an essay, but I just couldn't read the book. This year already feels like it is going to be great... *insert sarcasm here* I should've just stayed in public school.

LaPetiteSoeur
Posted

I'm surprised your school picked a book with sex scenes in it. There are tons of books on the subject of illegal immigration and the
'people issues" involved. That said, hopefully your chaplain can help you out (if it's who i think it is, then he can!)
Let me know how it goes and good luck! You'll love the school once you get started, I'm sure!

Posted

If it is extremely difficult to skip around the sex scenes, I think you have a legit excuse to be excused. I think you are approaching it the right way to go through the chaplain. I went to a high school run by the LaSalle brothers, but not all the teachers were Catholic, don't be surprised about encountering things that don't fall in line with the Church, and don't be afraid to call the teacher out on it after class.

Maybe you could ask to be assigned some other book to make up for it?

Posted

THERE WAS AN ALTERNATIVE ASSIGNMENT!! THE GRAPES OF WRATH!! Yipp-ee! I LOVE STEINBECK! Seriously. THANK YOU JESUS!!

Posted

Yay! I'm glad you've found a good way around the first assignment. :)

Posted

Two days to do it. Challenge accepted.

LaPetiteSoeur
Posted

The Grapes of Wrath is AMAZING! If you are eager for more steinbeck once school starts, read [i]East of Eden[/i]. It is one of my all time favorite books!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...