Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I've noticed a few people on this forum who are labelled "non-Catholic" but mention that they used to be members of the Church. We hear a lot about conversion stories, but maybe it would be interesting to hear your "de-conversion" story. Not for the sake of arguing but just so us Catholics can understand what things cause people to leave the Church.

ThePenciledOne
Posted

One I've heard the most is: People.

Posted

[quote name='ThePenciledOne' timestamp='1345487251' post='2470677']
One I've heard the most is: People.
[/quote]

Yeah, I can see that. It was the main reason I left Judaism. Looking back, it's not a good reason. But it's certainly understandable.

ThePenciledOne
Posted

[quote name='curiousing' timestamp='1345496315' post='2470773']
Yeah, I can see that. It was the main reason I left Judaism. Looking back, it's not a good reason. But it's certainly understandable.
[/quote]

Doesn't have to be a good reason. Faith shows through the fruits and if you only deal with pricks from that particular religion than its hard to justify staying with that Faith.

I used to struggle sometimes with my own Faith, because of the other Catholics I came into contact with.

Posted

God revealed to me that the Catholic Church was false.

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1345501497' post='2470852']
God revealed to me that the Catholic Church was false.
[/quote]

The prince of Lies CAN alter his appearance you know...

Posted (edited)

NVM!

Edited by Hasan
Posted

[quote name='Groo the Wanderer' timestamp='1345502150' post='2470865']
The prince of Lies CAN alter his appearance you know...
[/quote]

No he can't. That is a falsehood perpetuated by the Church.

LittleWaySoul
Posted

95% positive Hasan is trolling again... ;)

This thread is a really good idea, though! I'd like to hear people's reasons. Can we all agree not to try to judge or correct, however? I want others to feel safe about telling their story without feeling like the Catholics will jump down their throats about it.

ThePenciledOne
Posted

[quote name='LittleWaySoul' timestamp='1345502822' post='2470875']
This thread is a really good idea, though! I'd like to hear people's reasons. Can we all agree not to try to judge or correct, however? I want others to feel safe about telling their story without feeling like the Catholics will jump down their throats about it.
[/quote]

It's more like human nature will do it. Being Catholic has nothing to do with it.

Posted

Moral theology teaches that the number one reason why people are atheist (or leave the Church) is. . . .BAD CHRISTIANS! :cry:

Posted (edited)

[quote name='LittleWaySoul' timestamp='1345502822' post='2470875']
95% positive Hasan is trolling again... ;)[/quote]
Hasan wrote, like, an article, sometime ago explaining in depth why he left the Church. It included a whole bunch of stuff from Church Fathers I think, but I never really read it. Way too long. These days he has developed a passion for phatmassing under the influence so he probably doesn't even remember that he wrote it.

Basically, I'm not sure I ever really had this whole faith thing. I'm mean, I thought did. I was once quite a devote Catholic. As a teen I said my Rosary, went to Daily Mass, watched EWTN even thought I wanted to become a priest. But as I got older, my "faith" started to weaken slowly, and eventually I just suddenly thought to myself. "My God, I have been such a flooping didgeridoo my whole life. How can I be so certain that there even is a God?" That was a couple years ago I came to that moment.

These days I blame teenage hormones on it all. I understand that's not everyone's experience with the Catholic Church, and faith and I respect that, but that's where I ended up it.

Edited by r2Dtoo
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Egidio' timestamp='1345511659' post='2470996']
Moral theology teaches that the number one reason why people are atheist (or leave the Church) is. . . .BAD CHRISTIANS! :cry:
[/quote]
That's a rather interesting reason. Why would someone leave the Catholic Church just because of "bad Christians". I mean, if you had faith wouldn't you be able to see that the Church isn't these "bad Christians"?

Edited by r2Dtoo
Posted

Two years ago I went to take RCIA, however I chose to go back to the United Church temporarily due to unresolved issues I had with certain church teachings. However I eventually was led back to Catholicism by God and will be completeing RCIA this year =). Relevance to this post, I left before because I was struggling between Protestantism and Catholicism, as my former church was almost the opposite of Catholicism, so some teachings were beyond my understanding and at times I blatantly disagreed without seeking to learn. Now that I have sought answers I feel happy about my choice to complete RCIA. It may have taken two years, but the journey was worth it.

Posted

[quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1345511887' post='2471000']
Hasan wrote, like, an article, sometime ago explaining in depth why he left the Church. It included a whole bunch of stuff from Church Fathers I think, but I never really read it. Way too long. These days he has developed a passion for phatmassing under the influence so he probably doesn't even remember that he wrote it.[/QUOTE]

I did write that. It was entitled My Fall from Grace or something stupid like that. I actually drunk phatmass much less than people think. I'm just naturally besotted and hilarious.

Posted

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1345513316' post='2471010']
I did write that. It was entitled My Fall from Grace or something stupid like that. I actually drunk phatmass much less than people think. I'm just naturally besotted and hilarious.
[/quote]
[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1345362216' post='2470065']
It wasn't extreme. Because my initial response was in rebuttal to your claim that the features you listed supported your claim that FDR was a fascist. Your boyish charms won't save you this time. Even if you do somehow make rightism seem intellectually respectable with your thoughtful commentary and wit. You flooping panda. You giant flooping Panda. I like whiskey. Hollaz!
[/quote]
Outted. :like2:

Posted

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1345513316' post='2471010']
I did write that. It was entitled My Fall from Grace or something stupid like that. I actually drunk phatmass much less than people think. I'm just naturally besotted and hilarious.
[/quote]I give you the benefit of the doubt and assume that all your posts are made after 15-25 shots of Jack Daniels.

Posted

[quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1345512152' post='2471002']
That's a rather interesting reason. Why would someone leave the Catholic Church just because of "bad Christians". I mean, if you had faith wouldn't you be able to see that the Church isn't these "bad Christians"?
[/quote]

Yes. So I guess the underlying, "real" reason people leave is that they don't have faith.

I hope no one feels like I was slamming people who leave because of bad Catholics. The whole purpose of my admitting that I left Judaism was to indicate that I've done that myself: i.e., judged a religion by its people. (Although, in the case of Judaism, it was slightly more complicated than that.)

I do think that, when someone is first getting really involved in the Church, or any religion for that matter, the people embody that religion for the person. You can sorta' see what a religion teaches, what effects it has on people, by the way adherents to that religion behave. At least, that's the initial approach, I think. Not everyone jumps straight into heavy theology (or [i]ever[/i] jumps into heavy theology, for that matter). And I think we all know this. It is, after all, why we talk about good/bad witness so often.

Posted

[quote name='curiousing' timestamp='1345513794' post='2471015']
Yes. So I guess the underlying, "real" reason people leave is that they don't have faith.

I hope no one feels like I was slamming people who leave because of bad Catholics. The whole purpose of my admitting that I left Judaism was to indicate that I've done that myself: i.e., judged a religion by its people. (Although, in the case of Judaism, it was slightly more complicated than that.)

I do think that, when someone is first getting really involved in the Church, or any religion for that matter, the people embody that religion for the person. You can sorta' see what a religion teaches, what effects it has on people, by the way adherents to that religion behave. At least, that's the initial approach, I think. Not everyone jumps straight into heavy theology (or [i]ever[/i] jumps into heavy theology, for that matter). And I think we all know this. It is, after all, why we talk about good/bad witness so often.
[/quote]
Is not faith supposed to be a gift, however?

Posted

I guess, also, I did once leave Catholicism. I started CCD classes at age 12, because I felt strongly drawn to the Church, but when someone gave me a pro-life bumper sticker to take home with me (I had no idea what it meant at that age), my older brother bashed it, implying that only backwards, ignorant, intolerant people are pro-life. I desperately wanted his approval at that age, so I stopped going.

Possibly those external pressures (/psychological insecurities) cause some other people to leave, too.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...