PadrePioOfPietrelcino Posted August 21, 2012 Posted August 21, 2012 So today I was told that 1) since I am a man and 2) since I oppose abortion 3) as a man I can have no idea what it is like to be pregnant 4) as a man I can have no idea what it is like to be raped and then become pregnant 5) since I have an opinion on abortion that does not allow me to support women killing their babies I am therefore a man who wants to abuse women and put them in the corner or the kitchen and treat them as property. I am not hwppy about this, although I recognize it as false all around I m just amazed that some people can be so blind about their own positioon that they can not even see the point of the others. When/ how do we move past gender when discussing this topic? arggg...irritated.
missionseeker Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 My friend had this happen to him on fb today He responded that since he is a member of the human race and a potential victim of abortion it is imperative for him to have an opinion. Then he said that saying a man cannot speak against abortion is like saying that a non black or non Jew shouldn't speak on the tragedy of slavery and the holocaust
Luigi Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 PadrePioOfPietrelcino said ...[quote]I m just amazed that some people can be so blind about their own positioon that they can not even see the point of the others.[/quote] How long have you been on this board......?
PadrePioOfPietrelcino Posted August 22, 2012 Author Posted August 22, 2012 [quote name='Luigi' timestamp='1345594318' post='2471578'] PadrePioOfPietrelcino said ... How long have you been on this board......? [/quote] LOL long enough to know youor your point, but short enough to still be amazed...since 2004?
FutureCarmeliteClaire Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 (edited) I can't really give you very good advice because I'm a woman who hasn't had to deal with that. But I was once cussed out on a pro-life fb page, all the words in the sentence were profanities except "Your" and "sweetheart". Yeah. Lol. Edited August 22, 2012 by FutureCarmeliteClaire
arfink Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 I don't like that people treat men that way. We're human beings too. It also gets under my skin that young unmarried men are always assumed to be a child molestation risk too. What's up with that?
PhuturePriest Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 Don't you just love it when us men are discriminated against like that? Women say they are the ones discriminated against, but the tables are turning and I find men are more discriminated against than women. We can't have a say in abortion, the way a child is raised, we rarely get the children during a divorce even if the wife is completely incompetent and will be harmful in the child's upbringing, all men amount to these days are alimony and child molestation risks, as Arfink suggests above. It's simply ridiculous. People get so caught up in women's rights that they completely disregard men's rights. I am all for women's rights, but I would prefer it if we could even our rights out, and this includes the children the women happen to require us in the process to have.
PadrePioOfPietrelcino Posted August 22, 2012 Author Posted August 22, 2012 [quote name='Brother Adam' timestamp='1345606697' post='2471759'] Spend a week at a 40 Days campaign. [/quote] 40 days campaign? This is new to me please explain.
Ice_nine Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 [quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1345602971' post='2471694'] Don't you just love it when us men are discriminated against like that? Women say they are the ones discriminated against, but the tables are turning and I find men are more discriminated against than women. We can't have a say in abortion, the way a child is raised, we rarely get the children during a divorce even if the wife is completely incompetent and will be harmful in the child's upbringing, all men amount to these days are alimony and child molestation risks, as Arfink suggests above. It's simply ridiculous. People get so caught up in women's rights that they completely disregard men's rights. I am all for women's rights, but I would prefer it if we could even our rights out, and this includes the children the women happen to require us in the process to have. [/quote] I always have to laugh when men run their mouths about how "oppressed" they are. Certainly there are cases of discrimination against men (against whites, rich people, and other historically powerful groups) but to put those cases on the same level as the parties who have historically faced unjust discrimination on a massive scale is simply laughable. It's ignorant, which isn't a terrible thing, but I would recommend to educate yourself and perhaps look at the world through "the other" before so hastily levying complaints of misandry. You want to see rights even out between men and women? That's laudable. But it would first behoove you to recognize how lopsided things are, and then take a crack at the bigger, much more hegemonic problems before tackling these tangential ones that spring up from said core issues.
jazzytakara Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 (edited) The thing is, a lot of pro-choice individuals forget two things. First of all, the baby although grows within the women is still apart of the man, it is his child as well as hers, and he has the right to have a say in regards to the life of his unborn child. Secondly , they forget that pro-life individuals have the same rights as they do to speak their opinion. Also when it comes to some pro-choice people they will make up every excuse in the book to counter a pro-life opinion, when that no longer works, they will hurl insults and accuse everyone of abusing women and taking away their rights. I am a women, I have been sexually assaulted. I regret taking plan-b, but I was a scared college freshman. I was told that it wouldn't cause an aboriton (apparently making a fertized egg unable to attach to the uterus isn't killing life), I only learned this recently. I have used it a couple of times before I found out and found my faith to choose abstinance. But I figured at first after that event back in my freshman year, that I couldn't carry a child that was a part of someone who took away my right to say no to him. But then I thought about it, it wouldn't have been the child's fault that someone had harmed me and I realized that if plan-b didn't work and I conceived anyway, I would carry the child to term, adoption is a valid option for unwanted pregnancies rather than murder. I just wish I had known what planb really was. But the thing is many pro-choice women say I am wrong in my decision to eb pro-life, despite living through one of their conditions they use as a reason why the world should be pro-choice. Edited August 22, 2012 by jazzytakara
PhuturePriest Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 [quote name='Ice_nine' timestamp='1345608158' post='2471773'] I always have to laugh when men run their mouths about how "oppressed" they are. Certainly there are cases of discrimination against men (against whites, rich people, and other historically powerful groups) but to put those cases on the same level as the parties who have historically faced unjust discrimination on a massive scale is simply laughable. It's ignorant, which isn't a terrible thing, but I would recommend to educate yourself and perhaps look at the world through "the other" before so hastily levying complaints of misandry. You want to see rights even out between men and women? That's laudable. But it would first behoove you to recognize how lopsided things are, and then take a crack at the bigger, much more hegemonic problems before tackling these tangential ones that spring up from said core issues. [/quote] I am very glad you posted. I knew you would be prompted to respond. I would have been disappointed had you not replied. I still stand by what I said, but I would have been disappointed had you not replied all the same. But in actually replying to your post, how about you take a crack at looking at the world through the others' eyes? I have no doubt it is hard to be a woman in this day and age, when women are ogled and turned into sexual play things. But the [i]same things [/i]are starting to happen to men. Being ogled isn't just reserved for girls now. I will admit it is worse for girls on the grand scale, but it is starting to rise when it comes to the opposite spectrum. Do you know what it is like to know that everybody assumes that since you are a guy all you are after is meeting a girl and having sex? I'm not some animal that listens to his instincts. I am an intelligent, thinking, loving human being who is capable of self-control and in fact has no interest in dating or sex whatsoever. But what is more frustrating is when you tell people these things and they don't believe you, and when they laugh and think it is a joke, and will not listen to you even after you try to explain further. It's not easy being a guy either. I agree that I should look more into this, especially since I love this type of thing, but I do think you are a little biased. Women have been discriminated against for much longer, but that doesn't mean anything. Discrimination is wrong no matter who has been discriminated against the longest.
Brother Adam Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 [quote name='PadrePioOfPietrelcino' timestamp='1345608014' post='2471772'] 40 days campaign? This is new to me please explain. [/quote] 40 Days for Life, witnessing outside an abortion site. I have been spit on, nearly run over,cursed out more times than I can remember, but never by women seeking an abortion. Most are deeply hurting and confused. I have seen a loving smile and kind word lead to many saves. The "you are not a woman" argument is complete bunk and really common.
Nihil Obstat Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 (edited) Meh, nvm. Edited August 22, 2012 by Nihil Obstat
Ice_nine Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 and pio, I know it smells of elderberries to be accused of such terrible things. Even as a woman it's been more or less insinuated that I'm under some sort of spell that's stifling my self-discovery or emancipation or some the essence of cow like that. Of course it's not been said that I hate women or want to oppress them, which I can imagine doesn't feel all that great. As a generally compassionate person, or someone who tries to be, accusations of bigotry (particularly when dealing with homosexual marriage and such) are particularly hurtful, especially because I feel I can relate to the painful experiences of identity-crisis and all of that. But I digress . . . My only advice to you is to practice compassion to those who find themselves in crisis pregnancies if the opportunity is ever presented to you, pray for the women who find themselves in these situations, respect women in general (I know it's always fun to make the aptly-timed "go make me a sammich" joke, but repeated micro-aggressions, even in good humor, can precipitate negative effects on the self-esteem of women). In other words, be kind to those who are in the situations that are being debated if and when you come across them. Sometimes a shouting match is only dealing with abstractions, and while there's no sure-fired way to make people stfu and see the error of their ways, they're not really the problem. In fact I think these debates can sometimes become a distraction. It probably won't help stem the allegations of chauvinism when these conversations arise, but by your Christlike conduct towards others, you will be blameless, and there words will be nothing more than petty slander. A wrong which you will have to bear patiently I guess. Hope that at least helps somewhat!
4588686 Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 [quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1345608738' post='2471779'] I am very glad you posted. I knew you would be prompted to respond. I would have been disappointed had you not replied. I still stand by what I said, but I would have been disappointed had you not replied all the same. But in actually replying to your post, how about you take a crack at looking at the world through the others' eyes? I have no doubt it is hard to be a woman in this day and age, when women are ogled and turned into sexual play things. But the [i]same things [/i]are starting to happen to men. Do you know what it is like to know that everybody assumes that since you are a guy all you are after is meeting a girl and having sex? I'm not some animal that listens to his instincts. I am an intelligent, thinking, loving human being who is capable of self-control and in fact has no interest in dating or sex whatsoever. But what is more frustrating is when you tell people these things and they don't believe you, and when they laugh and think it is a joke, and will not listen to you even after you try to explain further. It's not easy being a guy either. I agree that I should look more into this, especially since I love this type of thing, but I do think you are a little biased. Women have been discriminated against for much longer, but that doesn't mean anything. Discrimination is wrong no matter who has been discriminated against the longest. [/quote] Reading this made my uterus hurt.
PadrePioOfPietrelcino Posted August 22, 2012 Author Posted August 22, 2012 Thank Brother Adam and Ice_nine I know it's a minor insult I faced, but it's nice to know that at least here people understand. BTW even tho we all recognize the "your a man so you have no idea" argument is hooky is there any way to respond other than take it on the chin? If you stay silent this accomplishes what they want if you respond then it just blowing air... catch 22
jazzytakara Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 The world seems to practice a lot of reverse discrimination these days. "x group" wasn't discriminated in the past the way "y group was" thus they have no reasons to complain that it happens to them now, they also have no say. This isn't a good way to look at the situation. Discrimination is discrimination and it changes over time. We should make amends for the pain inflicted in the past on marginalized groups, but we should also work to not inflict the same or similar on another group. I once went to a conference where a female speaker spoke about her former porn addiction and how many men claim that women don't deal with lust, and they couldn't understand her ministry. At no point did she rebuttle with 'men don't know anything as they aren't female' instead she would explain that although women deal with lust differently than men, it is an increasing problem with many young women today. She would also point out in her lectures about how women objectify men daily without realizing it and gave advise on how to treat men and women equally and as brothers and sisters in Christ. How the way a women can dress can impact a man to fall to temptation and how when we oggle a man for his looks and stop thinking of them as a person, we're treating them as an object. Men can be treated unfairly and discriminated against, just because that wasn't the case in the past, doesn't mean that it isn't the case now.
Brother Adam Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 [quote name='PadrePioOfPietrelcino' timestamp='1345609440' post='2471795'] Thank Brother Adam and Ice_nine I know it's a minor insult I faced, but it's nice to know that at least here people understand. BTW even tho we all recognize the "your a man so you have no idea" argument is hooky is there any way to respond other than take it on the chin? If you stay silent this accomplishes what they want if you respond then it just blowing air... catch 22 [/quote] Men don't breastfeed, can they be concerned about a womans right to breastfeed without intimidation? Men don't get ovarian cancer, can they be concerned about curing this womens problem? Men are fathers, they have a right to be concerned to be concerned about their children. The idea that men cannot be concerned about women is totally absurd.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now