Adrestia Posted August 30, 2012 Posted August 30, 2012 Feminists For Life has a lot of good resources that show how being pro-life is being pro-woman. [url="http://www.feministsforlife.org/"]http://www.feministsforlife.org/[/url] The organization is non-religious and non-political. Check out the recommended reading here: "[url="http://www.feministsforlife.org/FFL_topics/index.htm"]http://www.feministsforlife.org/FFL_topics/index.htm[/url]"
God the Father Posted August 30, 2012 Posted August 30, 2012 The world is not overpopulated, and it's not even close. Overcrowding and overconsumption are economic realities that become inconvenient and could stand some innovation, but when it comes to population, most nations are experiencing the opposite problem.
jazzytakara Posted August 30, 2012 Author Posted August 30, 2012 [quote name='God the Father' timestamp='1346360301' post='2476393'] The world is not overpopulated, and it's not even close. Overcrowding and overconsumption are economic realities that become inconvenient and could stand some innovation, but when it comes to population, most nations are experiencing the opposite problem. [/quote] I remember speaking to an exchange student once from China, he said that he had never seen so much open spaces before. Some places do suffer from over crowding, but in North America in particular the open spaces are mainly a result of the economy, so many people own land and multiple houses, yet complain that there isn't enough space for the homeless. No,there is enough space, we are not over populated, consumption drives greed and people want to own more and more, yet are unwilling to help out those who are unable to afford even the necesseties to life. Overcrowding is an excuse for a society of excess, people want more and more, they don't want to share, they don't want consequences. Excuses such as "A baby would be an inconvenience, less time and money for myself" or "why should I abstain when I can just get rid of the negatives, I shouldn't have to stop what feels good", etc. we live in a selfish culture that rather than taking responsibilty, places blame on those who cannot defend themselves, those who have done nothing wrong. You are most definently right, we are no where close to being overpopulated and we have plenty of resources we just need to start distributing rather than hoarding.
4588686 Posted September 2, 2012 Posted September 2, 2012 [quote name='jazzytakara' timestamp='1346268929' post='2475939'] I really have trouble understanding where these people are coming from. To me restricting abortion isn't destroying women's rights, its preventing murder. I have heard some say that it ensures 'life, liberty, freedom, and the pursuit of happiness' but how can something that destroys the life of an unborn child be for life. Also I have noticed a double standard in this debate too, why does only the women get to make the decision that effects three people (the father and the child). There are many cases where the father of the baby wants to keep the child, but the mother always wins the battle as its 'her' body. Yes it is, but it is 'his' child too. I just don't think it is fair that only one person gets a choice in the matter, she chooses for her unborn child who can't voice his.her opinion, and she gets to choose over the father because its her body. If you didn't want to have a child, than practice safe sex at the very least if you can't abstain. I understand rape is a different situation, but just because a child was born out of hate, doesn't mean it should die, adoption is a viable reason. And its sad that so many children are being aborted, yet many couples struggle desperately to conceive. Abortion is simply a product of a sexually liberalized culture, many seem to be wanting all of the pleasure but none of the 'consquences' or results of this behaviour. No one should have to die because of someone elses irresponsibility. It isn't right.. Can anyone help me understand this and advise me on what to do when people attack me for being pro-life? What should a catholic-christian do in today's society when our beliefs are being attacked? [/quote] You have the religious right fighting for abstinence only education, against abortion, and against contraceptives. That's not good for women. I'm not saying that you won't find women who are fine with the policies. I'm saying that on a macro level women having less reproductive freedom (from not being properly educated about contraceptives, to not having access to contraceptives, to not having access to abortion) is immensely detrimental to women's political and economic status. Can you find women who have raised 5 kids and are still superstars in their field? Yes. Again, I'm talking about macro trends. And on a macro level the link between reproductive freedom and socio-economic status is undeniable.
4588686 Posted September 2, 2012 Posted September 2, 2012 [quote name='phatcatholic' timestamp='1346272759' post='2475992'] Abortion isn't about a woman being able to make a choice about her body. She made that choice when she had sex. Abortion is about making a choice about [i][b]another person's body,[/b][/i] the one in the womb. The problem is, no one wants to ever live with the consequences of their actions. They want the sexual gratification without the responsibility. They want to have their cake and eat it too. The whole "my body, my choice" line is just a red herring. [/quote] In who owns the womb? Abortion is a tricky ethical question. That's why the solution has been to side with given women the power over their own bodies. The fetus is not yet a citizen, or even a person at the early stages, and therefore the preponderance of legal protections goes to the women. That's a pretty good compromise for a very tricky situation. And it's not a red herring. It is a woman's body. The women is being forced to carry a fetus in her body against her will.
Anomaly Posted September 2, 2012 Posted September 2, 2012 [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1346590838' post='2477568'] In who owns the womb? Abortion is a tricky ethical question. That's why the solution has been to side with given women the power over their own bodies. The fetus is not yet a citizen, or even a person at the early stages, and therefore the preponderance of legal protections goes to the women. That's a pretty good compromise for a very tricky situation. And it's not a red herring. It is a woman's body. The women is being forced to carry a fetus in her body against her will. [/quote]Citzenship is not a factor as you well know. The problem is how you define personage in clear not circumstantial terms. Is it a matter of cognitive or physical ability? Level of dependence on others? Overall contribution to society?
4588686 Posted September 2, 2012 Posted September 2, 2012 [quote name='Anomaly' timestamp='1346592326' post='2477573'] Citzenship is not a factor as you well know. The problem is how you define personage in clear not circumstantial terms. Is it a matter of cognitive or physical ability? Level of dependence on others? Overall contribution to society? [/quote] Yes it is. If the fetus were a citizen then abortion would not be legal.
Anomaly Posted September 2, 2012 Posted September 2, 2012 [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1346597037' post='2477580'] Yes it is. If the fetus were a citizen then abortion would not be legal. [/quote]We can't arbitrarily kill mon-citizens here. Even if they're gram a country we couldn't give a croutons about. Even so, you need to be recognized as a person first to be a citizen.
God the Father Posted September 2, 2012 Posted September 2, 2012 [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1346590838' post='2477568'] In who owns the womb? Abortion is a tricky ethical question. That's why the solution has been to side with given women the power over their own bodies. The fetus is not yet a citizen, or even a person at the early stages, and therefore the preponderance of legal protections goes to the women. That's a pretty good compromise for a very tricky situation. And it's not a red herring. It is a woman's body. The women is being forced to carry a fetus in her body against her will. [/quote] It's a tricky ethical question where the pregnancy threatens the life of the mother. It's a tricky ethical question in cases of rape. It's actually an easy ethical question in most cases, when you balance nine months of inconvenience for one party, who consented to the precipitating behavior, against the lifetime of the other. How anyone can perceive the justice of abortion in these cases is far, far beyond my understanding. I agree with your other argument. The fetus is not a citizen, and therefore cannot vote, which is why politicians in a deomcracy will never, [i]ever[/i] side with him/her at the risk of alienating a portion of their constituency. It's just the way it is for the "little guy" in this country.
Lilllabettt Posted September 2, 2012 Posted September 2, 2012 This is the great evil of our time, having taken the power for ourselves to deem a class of biological human being "non-people." In doing so we have chosen to follow the fascists and the socialists whom once we saw walk the way to perdition.
Ice_nine Posted September 3, 2012 Posted September 3, 2012 well that's your basic formula for killing off swaths of people and getting to act like a moralist. Rationalize that x group of people, aren't really people at all, but coming up with some rather arbitrary criteron (e.g. they're not "self-aware," they're too sick to live a productive "human" experience, the Negroid skull is clearly subhuman) and then killing them is ok. Quite simple really. I wouldn't say that's the evil of "our time," it seems to be an old trick or loophole once societies generally started caring about silly things like "human rights."
4588686 Posted September 3, 2012 Posted September 3, 2012 [quote name='Ice_nine' timestamp='1346690477' post='2477883'] well that's your basic formula for killing off swaths of people and getting to act like a moralist. Rationalize that x group of people, aren't really people at all, but coming up with some rather arbitrary criteron (e.g. they're not "self-aware," they're too sick to live a productive "human" experience, the Negroid skull is clearly subhuman) and then killing them is ok. Quite simple really. I wouldn't say that's the evil of "our time," it seems to be an old trick or loophole once societies generally started caring about silly things like "human rights." [/quote] Being self aware isn't arbitrary. A fetus in the early weeks of pregnancy has no memories, no sense of self, and it never has had these things. There is no question that it would not be considered a person except for religious claims. Even Aquinas did not believe that the fetus had a soul the second conception occurred (although he believed abortion was wrong even before that time).
Lilllabettt Posted September 3, 2012 Posted September 3, 2012 It is dangerous Hasan to take the power for yourself to decide if another human being is sufficiently "self aware." People before you have used their best judgment in that matter and come to the conclusion that human beings who are mentally ill, developmentally disabled or very old lack self-awareness and can be exterminated. I was wrong in my first post about one thing. This is not the great evil of our time. In fact, its America's original sin. Personhood in the United States 1787 - black human beings count as 3/5ths of "all other persons" 1868- black human beings count as "whole" persons 1973 - fetal human being is declared "non-person" ? - fetal human being counts as 3/5ths of a person
Lilllabettt Posted September 3, 2012 Posted September 3, 2012 I'm surprised Hasan and frankly find it quite ironic that you, like so many others, support "the Human Rights Campaign" and yet are not interested in the extension of full human rights to all human beings, regardless of the age of their cell division.
Adrestia Posted September 4, 2012 Posted September 4, 2012 [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1346692079' post='2477896'] There is no question that it would not be considered a person except for religious claims. [/quote] From a purely biological standpoint, it is an individual person. "Fetus" is just a word that describes the stage of development.
Ice_nine Posted September 4, 2012 Posted September 4, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1346692079' post='2477896'] Being self aware isn't arbitrary. A fetus in the early weeks of pregnancy has no memories, no sense of self, and it never has had these things. There is no question that it would not be considered a person except for religious claims. Even Aquinas did not believe that the fetus had a soul the second conception occurred (although he believed abortion was wrong even before that time). [/quote] don't be such a doofus. It is arbitrary to say "you are not self-aware, ergo, you shouldn't have legal protection" Making "consciousness" a criterion for personhood is arbitrary. Your point is irrelevant. Edited September 4, 2012 by Ice_nine
4588686 Posted September 4, 2012 Posted September 4, 2012 [quote name='Lilllabettt' timestamp='1346714486' post='2478008'] I'm surprised Hasan and frankly find it quite ironic that you, like so many others, support "the Human Rights Campaign" and yet are not interested in the extension of full human rights to all human beings, regardless of the age of their cell division. [/quote] I don't believe in an immortal soul. So I don't see any basis for prizing the rights of a division of cells over that of a woman. I think it gets more difficult once you start to get into the later months of pregnancy. And you do begin to run into the sort of issues that you are raising. But in the first few weeks I don't see how your arguments works since nobody could really make the case that a three week old fetus is a person worthy of the same rights as a developed woman.
4588686 Posted September 4, 2012 Posted September 4, 2012 [quote name='Ice_nine' timestamp='1346736089' post='2478177'] don't be such a doofus.[/QUOTE] No. [QUOTE]It is arbitrary to say "you are not self-aware, ergo, you shouldn't have legal protection" Making "consciousness" a criterion for personhood is arbitrary. [/QUOTE] Why? What makes a person a person that does not involve the unprovable assertions of your religious faith? [QUOTE]Your point is irrelevant. [/quote] Well, you have a sock on your head.
jazzytakara Posted September 4, 2012 Author Posted September 4, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1346739114' post='2478190'] Why? What makes a person a person that does not involve the unprovable assertions of your religious faith? [/quote] I think before my faith developed and before my parents had a certain talk with me about all things life related, I just had a hard time differentiating between say my new born baby sister and what she was inside my mother's womb. To me a person a person in all stages of development. But abortion isn't a black and white issue, there are certain instances where a woman became pregnant due to no fault of her own (rape, not improper birth control use) that blurs the issues of what is right and what isn't. I would never push my opinion on someone else, if its brought up I will defend it, but I would never force someone to do something they didn't want to do. I may be pro-life and I may state my opinions on the topic, but I don't think being Christian is about harassing people into having faith. I know Canada (where I am from) is at least working on making late term (third and I think second trimester as well) abortions illegal. That is a start to me, for as soon as the baby has reached a developmental state that it can live outside of the womb, it should not be aborted regardless of religious beliefs. Edited September 4, 2012 by jazzytakara
Lilllabettt Posted September 4, 2012 Posted September 4, 2012 (edited) Hasan, I think if you are playing dumb it is not really funny. Recongizing that a human fetus is a human being has nothing to do with whether they have an immortal soul. Biological scientists identify human beings by looking at chromosomal DNA. They refer to a human fetus as "human." A lot of them (most of them) don't believe in a soul either. From a pure science persepctive, a soul is not what makes a human being a human being. Its DNA. That is just hard science , like gravity. I think all human beings, regardless of age, gender, race, religion, sexual orientation should be recongized as people. All human beings deserve equal human rights. Some people think we should get to pick and choose which human beings count as people. (Nazis, the KKK ... you apparently?) Edited September 4, 2012 by Lilllabettt
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now