Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

missionseeker
Posted

[quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1346445912' post='2476879']
And before Vatican II, Protestants weren't real Christians either. I'm not denying that Mormons have a very strange theology. These differences are extremely important. But if we don't even call them Christian when they call themselves Christian, how are we supposed to engage in any real, respectful dialogue?
[/quote]

Christian scientists consider themselves Christian, too. As do Jehovas witnesses.
None of them believe Christ is God. That is the fundamental pillar of Christianity. You cannot reject the Cornerstone of a religion and still claim to be a part of it.

Vincent Vega
Posted

[quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1346445912' post='2476879']
And before Vatican II, Protestants weren't real Christians either. I'm not denying that Mormons have a very strange theology. These differences are extremely important. But if we don't even call them Christian when they call themselves Christian, how are we supposed to engage in any real, respectful dialogue?
[/quote]
So if a non-trinitarian group like the Mormons get to be Christian, who next? Unitarians? Baha'i? Muslims (they, after all, believe him to the be Messiah)?

Posted

I always thought that the creed was the standard that Christian agreed upon

Posted

[quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1346446279' post='2476882']
This is seriously what Mormons believe:

[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7q6brMrFw0E[/media]

According to Jimmy Akin on Catholic Answers Live there is some theological debate over whether or not they will get a planet to rule over or a universe. Patrick Coffin said something like "I'm a universe person myself."
[/quote]

Interesting video. I knew their beliefs were different from ours but I didn't realize just how different they were!!!

PhuturePriest
Posted

[quote name='Annie12' timestamp='1346471406' post='2477028']
Interesting video. I knew their beliefs were different from ours but I didn't realize just how different they were!!!
[/quote]

It's pretty scary. It clearly shows that they aren't Christian in any way. They deny the trinity and they believe there are other Gods, which is a clearly pagan belief.

Posted (edited)

yeah...but most of all this explains EVERYTHING with my bff!!! If I was her and believed this, I would act the same way!

Edited by Annie12
Posted

Instead of spending a lot of time postulating different theories as to why she might get uncomfortable when you talk about religion, why don't you just ... ask her. I'm sure she would know a lot better than we do, and if you are good friends with her then you should be able to just talk about it with her, and she should be able to be honest with you about it. Just be like, "I've noticed recently that you tend to shut down whenever I begin to talk about religion. Is there any reason why?" Sometimes, the best thing to do is just communicate.

Posted

[quote name='Annie12' timestamp='1346432682' post='2476748']
But it's not that she doesn't like to talk about her faith. She does that a lot. She doesn't like it when I talk about mine. I was just curious why that might be. I wasn't planning on being confrontational about it or anything. I suppose that is her business. I was just hoping to understand why... But I think I'll just leave it a lone because it's no biggy.
[/quote]

Leave it alone or just ask her, like Phatcatholic said? if she were trying to convert you, I wouldn't really blame her, because if I believed I had the truth and a friend didn't, I'd hope I'd act the same way (not saying she is, or that she has the Truth, because she definitely doesn't have that).

Posted

[quote name='Annie12' timestamp='1346422375' post='2476676']
So, One of my friends isn't catholic and every time I talk about religious stuff even if it's not Catholic (even if it's just Christian) she goes from her bubbly talkative self to just becoming completely not interested. She is LDS (Mormon) and claims to be Christian but doesn't like to talk about religion unless it's her's. I'm confused why this is, because [u]She is a supper great friend [/u]and it just seems a bit odd that she is so religious yet doesn't want to even mention God, or Christianity ever. Any insight? I'm just confused. I rarely even mention it because she clearly don't want to talk about it. Do you think it's against her religion to talk about others religions (but at the same time she says she's christian and yet doesn't want to mention Christianity)?
[/quote]


Pray for her conversion.

Posted

Okay...I see what everyone is saying. I think I'll just leave it alone for now. I don't want to hurt her by mistake or something. (not that I would).

I guess I thought there was a black or white answer here, but I suppose there isn't until I talk to her.

Posted

Praying for you. And may you be an instrument for your friend's conversion.

Posted

Annie, a gentle thought...

Maybe she feels scared or uncomfortable by what you say? I know you're very passionate about your faith, and she may be taking the conversations as you pushing too hard.

Religion is a difficult, sticky topic sometimes. Especially when it's not your own.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='MissyP89' timestamp='1346508881' post='2477128']
Annie, a gentle thought...

Maybe she feels scared or uncomfortable by what you say? I know you're very passionate about your faith, and she may be taking the conversations as you pushing too hard.

Religion is a difficult, sticky topic sometimes. Especially when it's not your own.
[/quote]

I'm only like that on the internet. lol! I rarely even mention religion in our conversations! We talk about girls stuff like fashion, guys and music. I don't really talk about religion with any of my friends because it would be too awkward for them. I just try to avoid it.

I'm not offended by the fact that we don't talk about religion, but I really am just curious. But, I'll just leave it alone for now. It's not really a big deal.

Edited by Annie12
Posted

[quote name='Annie12' timestamp='1346504036' post='2477115']
Okay...I see what everyone is saying. I think I'll just leave it alone for now. I don't want to hurt her by mistake or something. (not that I would).

I guess I thought there was a black or white answer here, but I suppose there isn't until I talk to her.
[/quote]
So, why don't you want to just ask her about it?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1346446279' post='2476882']
This is seriously what Mormons believe:

[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7q6brMrFw0E[/media]

According to Jimmy Akin on Catholic Answers Live there is some theological debate over whether or not they will get a planet to rule over or a universe. Patrick Coffin said something like "I'm a universe person myself."
[/quote]

I think I finally understand the themes in [i]The Twilight Series[/i].

Edited by jazzytakara
Posted

Annie: I know this wasn't the intent in your OP, but maybe get a green scapular to her somehow and pray for her daily.

Mormons, as some have said, often shame us Christians by acting way more Christ-like than we do. They have their reasons though, which I won't expand on since some of you already know and because this is not a Mormon tell-all thread.

If the Church sets a standard for who is Christian, then I'm sticking with that. The Church also says that we should trust God's loving mercy.. We can trust Him to take care of Mormons and every other Christian 'fringe' group.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...