Archaeology cat Posted September 4, 2012 Posted September 4, 2012 I agree religion is important, but, being a convert, I have to say I dislike it when people say not to date non-Catholics. I wasn't Catholic when I started dating my husband, and in fact had no intention of becoming Catholic before we started dating. After, I decided to research, as I knew this would be an important factor, and I did convert (no, I did not convert for him; he never asked it of me, but I brought it up first). obviously it won't always go like that, so that's something that must be discerned.
Nihil Obstat Posted September 4, 2012 Posted September 4, 2012 For me I could not have handled a long term relationship with a non-Catholic. Lots of people can, and I admire that because it takes a lot of strength and sensitivity, but for me it would have been a clear deal breaker.
Nihil Obstat Posted September 4, 2012 Posted September 4, 2012 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1346768719' post='2478248'] For me I could not have handled a long term relationship with a non-Catholic. Lots of people can, and I admire that because it takes a lot of strength and sensitivity, but for me it would have been a clear deal breaker. [/quote] Actually that's not 100% true. I probably could have handled dating someone who was Orthodox. Before I got serious about Katy, I briefly considered asking out a girl I knew who was Coptic Orthodox. Nothing ever came of it, but it might have been fine.
Slappo Posted September 4, 2012 Posted September 4, 2012 I think when it comes to education and jobs it really depends on if you are being too picky or not. Any wide range "won't date a non-college graduate" type non-negotiable would be too picky I think. It doesn't matter what level their secular education is. What matters is: Can they provide for a family? Can they engage you in intellectually stimulating conversations or does everything you say go way over their head? It doesn't take college education to be brillian or succesful, although the education can certainly help.
Norseman82 Posted September 4, 2012 Posted September 4, 2012 [quote name='TheUbiquitous' timestamp='1346737280' post='2478184'] [url="http://catholicexchange.com/a-vocation-to-the-single-life/"]Not the whole truth[/url]. At least, not how the term gets thrown around. But this would be getting off-topic. [/quote] Mesely Luis does not carry magisterial weight. The CCC does.
missionseeker Posted September 4, 2012 Posted September 4, 2012 The whole courting dating thing is stupid. people's lives are different. If you can/want to court. GREAT. Nobody else really cares what you call your path of discerning marriage together. If you can't/ don't want to court. THAT'S FINE TOO. Honestly, as long as two people aren't sinning, who cares how they discern marriage. Preferences are preferences. Also, if someone took me to adoration on my first date, I'd probably never go out with them again. Not because I don't like adoration. Because I don't like to go to Adoration in groups or with other people. I find it weird and awkward because prayer is really private. Maybe after a couple months dating, I'd be ok with it. But not on a first date. (Again, preferences.) There really aren't defined rules in who to date or how to date. If you over think it, you won't date anyone. You'll sit there and analyze "how is this person wrong for me" Obviously, if you don't like the person, or don't think there's a future, don't date. But if a not well known acquaintance (or even in some cases a stranger) asks you on a date, just go with it. Say yes or no. Have fun. Or be miserable and decide that this person is certainly not one you could spend forever with. First dates aren't always great (so keep that in mind. my sister once told me that she gave the first guy who asked her out three chances. She didn't really like him on the first date, but after the third one, they were dating. Good thing. They're now married and their second child is due in two months.). But first dates aren't permanent. They're just a chance to get to know someone better. They're not a commitment to that person. (Even if you court, you might find that this person is not the one for you after you hang out a couple of times.) Obviously don't be stupid about it. Use discretion, etc. But don't be scared to accept a date because what if it isn't the person for you.
Anastasia13 Posted September 5, 2012 Author Posted September 5, 2012 [quote name='missionseeker' timestamp='1346801927' post='2478460'] The whole courting dating thing is stupid. people's lives are different. If you can/want to court. GREAT. Nobody else really cares what you call your path of discerning marriage together. If you can't/ don't want to court. THAT'S FINE TOO. Honestly, as long as two people aren't sinning, who cares how they discern marriage. Preferences are preferences. Also, if someone took me to adoration on my first date, I'd probably never go out with them again. Not because I don't like adoration. Because I don't like to go to Adoration in groups or with other people. I find it weird and awkward because prayer is really private. Maybe after a couple months dating, I'd be ok with it. But not on a first date. (Again, preferences.) There really aren't defined rules in who to date or how to date. If you over think it, you won't date anyone. You'll sit there and analyze "how is this person wrong for me" Obviously, if you don't like the person, or don't think there's a future, don't date. But if a not well known acquaintance (or even in some cases a stranger) asks you on a date, just go with it. Say yes or no. Have fun. Or be miserable and decide that this person is certainly not one you could spend forever with. First dates aren't always great (so keep that in mind. my sister once told me that she gave the first guy who asked her out three chances. She didn't really like him on the first date, but after the third one, they were dating. Good thing. They're now married and their second child is due in two months.). But first dates aren't permanent. They're just a chance to get to know someone better. They're not a commitment to that person. (Even if you court, you might find that this person is not the one for you after you hang out a couple of times.) Obviously don't be stupid about it. Use discretion, etc. But don't be scared to accept a date because what if it isn't the person for you. [/quote] So like would going out with a guy three times before saying no unless there is an obvious red flag be a good policy? I haven't have enough experience or something to know for sure the difference between not liking a guy and not giving him a chance. Is it like you take the time to go out a couple times but there is still no chemistry/butterflies/strong desire to be with/around/talking to him, then I move on to the next interested/interesting guy who has no obvious deal-breakers? P.S. Thanks for not judging me.
Winchester Posted September 5, 2012 Posted September 5, 2012 [quote][size="-1"]there was this great woman who lived in my home town, Edith Neisser, dead now, and she wrote terrific books about how we screw up our children - "Brothers and Sisters" was one of her books, "The Eldest Child" was another. Published by Harper. Edith doesn't need the plug, seeing, like I said, as she's no longer with us, but if there are any amongst you who are worried that maybe you're not being perfect parents, pick up one of Edith's books while there's still time. I knew her 'cause her kid Ed got his haircuts from my pop, and she was this writer and by my teens I knew, secretly, that was the life for me too, except I couldn't tell anybody. It was too embarrassing - barber's sons, if they hustled, maybe got to be IBM salesmen, but writers? No way. Don't ask me how, but eventually Edith discovered my shhhhhh ambition and from then on, sometimes, we would talk. And I remember once we were having iced tea on the Neisser porch and talking and just outside the porch was their badminton court and I was watching some kids play badminton and Ed had just shellacked me, and as I left the court for the porch, he said, "Don't worry, it'll all work out, you'll get me next time" and I nodded, and then Ed said, "And if you don't, you'll beat me at something else." I went to the porch and sipped iced tea and Edith was reading this book and she didn't put it down when she said, "That's not necessarily true, you know." I said, "How do you mean?" And that's when she put her book down. And looked at me. And said it: "Life isn't fair, Bill. We tell our children that it is, but it's a terrible thing to do. It's not only a lie, it's a cruel lie. [b]Life is not fair, and it never has been, and it's never going to be.[/b]" Would you believe that for me right then it was like one of those comic books where the light bulb goes on over Mandrake the Magician's head? "It isn't!" I said, so loud I really startled her. "You're right! It's not fair." I was so happy if I'd known how to dance, I'd have started dancing. "Isn't that great, isn't it terrific?" I think along here Edith must have thought I was well on my way to being bonkers. But it meant so much to me to have it said and out and free and flying - that was the discontent I had endured the night my father stopped reading, I realized right then. That was the reconciliation I was trying to make and couldn't. And that's what I think this book's about. All those Columbia experts can spiel all they want about the delicious satire; they're crazy. This book says, "life's not fair" and I'm telling you, one and all, you better believe it. I got a fat spoiled son - he's not gonna nag Miss Rheingold. And he's always gonna be fat, even if he gets skinny he'll still be fat and he'll still be spoiled and life will never be enough to make him happy, and that's my fault maybe - make it all my fault, if you want - the point is, we're not created equal, for the rich they sing, life isn't fair. I got a cold wife; she's brilliant, she's stimulating, she's terrific; there's no love; that's okay too, just so long as we don't keep expecting everything to somehow even out for us before we die. Look. (Grownups skip this paragraph.) I'm not about to tell you this book has a tragic ending. I already said in the very first line how it was my favorite in all the world. But there's a lot of bad stuff coming up, torture you've already been prepared for, but there's worse. There's death coming up, and you better understand this: Some of the wrong people die. Be ready for it. This isn't Curious George Uses the Potty. Nobody warned me and it was my own fault (you'll see what I mean in a little) and that was my mistake, so I'm not letting it happen to you. The wrong people die, some of them, and the reason is this; life is not fair. Forget all the garbage your parents put out. Remember Morgenstern. You'll be a lot happier.[/size] --William Goldman, [i]The Princess Bride[/i][/quote]
Anastasia13 Posted September 5, 2012 Author Posted September 5, 2012 [quote name='Slappo' timestamp='1346790126' post='2478381'] I think when it comes to education and jobs it really depends on if you are being too picky or not. Any wide range "won't date a non-college graduate" type non-negotiable would be too picky I think. It doesn't matter what level their secular education is. What matters is: Can they provide for a family? Can they engage you in intellectually stimulating conversations or does everything you say go way over their head? It doesn't take college education to be brillian or succesful, although the education can certainly help. [/quote] I expect that if I have kids, they may be mildly special need kids but in ways that can be dealt with, with medication and a little more involvement from me. I want my kids to come out in life as well as possible, so I want to be home part-time when they return home from school. Should that be a deal-breaker? Is knowing if a guy will have a kind of career that makes the possible a deal-breaker matter? Is wanting a guy who is ok with his wife working part-time while the kids are in school (instead of homeschooling*) an ok deal-breaker or just a want category? *Not looking to debate the merits of homeschooling.
Anastasia13 Posted September 5, 2012 Author Posted September 5, 2012 (edited) Winchester, what do you mean by that quote? How are you relating this to the topic at hand? Edited September 5, 2012 by Light and Truth
Winchester Posted September 5, 2012 Posted September 5, 2012 [quote name='Light and Truth' timestamp='1346810674' post='2478566'] Winchester, what do you mean by that quote? How are you relating this to the topic at hand? [/quote] Think about it. It's good writing. Good advice.
emmaberry Posted September 5, 2012 Posted September 5, 2012 About the dating non-Catholics thing: the Bible says not to be unequally yolked..of course, it also says that a believing wife sanctifies an unbelieving husband, soo.. That's great that it worked out for all of you who married a non-Catholic, or were the non-Catholic yourselves!
Nihil Obstat Posted September 5, 2012 Posted September 5, 2012 L&T, seriously, read Seraphic's blog. It is exactly the kind of advice and discussions you're asking for right now. [i]Exactly[/i].
Norseman82 Posted September 5, 2012 Posted September 5, 2012 [quote name='emmaberry' timestamp='1346812376' post='2478581'] ..of course, it also says that a believing wife sanctifies an unbelieving husband, soo.. [/quote] That may have been referring to cases where one of the spouses was a convert to Christianity but the other was not.
Groo the Wanderer Posted September 6, 2012 Posted September 6, 2012 As a Catholic married to a Prot (AofG), I recommend against it. Marriage is already hard. Add to that the stresses and pressures of the world. Then throw on top of that the religion thing...our worst fights have been about that. How to raise the kid, the ruckus when said kid proudly announced to her mom that she is Catholic, the arguing about time spent at Church (on both sides). At least if my wife was Catholic, that would have been a unifying force instead of a divisive force early on. We worked through it, but it would really have been nice to not have that to contend with.
Lil Red Posted September 6, 2012 Posted September 6, 2012 i don't necessarily recommend against marrying someone outside the faith, but i think people need to have eyes & heart open to the very real hardships of having a relationship with someone outside the faith or of no faith.
Slappo Posted September 6, 2012 Posted September 6, 2012 [quote name='Light and Truth' timestamp='1346810528' post='2478563'] I expect that if I have kids, they may be mildly special need kids but in ways that can be dealt with, with medication and a little more involvement from me. I want my kids to come out in life as well as possible, so I want to be home part-time when they return home from school. Should that be a deal-breaker? Is knowing if a guy will have a kind of career that makes the possible a deal-breaker matter? Is wanting a guy who is ok with his wife working part-time while the kids are in school (instead of homeschooling*) an ok deal-breaker or just a want category? *Not looking to debate the merits of homeschooling. [/quote] No one can tell you that objectively. It really depends on how important it is to you. For some it may be a deal breaker and for others it may not. Blue collar workers can support a part time or full time SAHM though if you manage money correctly and the individual is able to get promotions/take good job opportunities when they arise. It depends on your level of debt going into marriage too. If you bring 100k in student loans to the table and expect him to pay it off while you stay at home, that's probably an unrealistic expectation.
Winchester Posted September 6, 2012 Posted September 6, 2012 Crazy idea: Find people you like. Go out with them. Decide if you can put up with their inadequacies. It doesn't matter who you pick, you're going to have problems. If religion is important, then just pick up dudes from Church.
Lil Red Posted September 6, 2012 Posted September 6, 2012 [quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1346894088' post='2479178'] Crazy idea: Find people you like. Go out with them. Decide if you can put up with their inadequacies. It doesn't matter who you pick, you're going to have problems. If religion is important, then just pick up dudes from Church. [/quote] i can't prop this post enough.
emmaberry Posted September 6, 2012 Posted September 6, 2012 [quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1346894088' post='2479178'] Crazy idea: Find people you like. Go out with them. Decide if you can put up with their inadequacies. It doesn't matter who you pick, you're going to have problems. If religion is important, then just pick up dudes from Church. [/quote] ..and be prepared to wait a couple years if the dude you pick up is a 12 year old altar server. Priests are also off-limits, for the record.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now