Nihil Obstat Posted September 10, 2012 Posted September 10, 2012 Don't tell me it was the Communist Manifesto.
4588686 Posted September 10, 2012 Author Posted September 10, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Amppax' timestamp='1347244792' post='2480852'] Assumed he'd read that. Is it really? [/quote] I have not read the Communist Manifesto. I read Peter Kreeft's Socrates Meets Marx which was a critical analysis of The Communist Manifesto in High school. But that's as close as I've come. [url="http://www.amazon.com/The-Socrates-Meets-Marx-Cross-Examines/dp/0898709709"]http://www.amazon.co...s/dp/0898709709[/url] Edited September 10, 2012 by Hasan
Nihil Obstat Posted September 10, 2012 Posted September 10, 2012 [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1347245569' post='2480860'] I have not read the Communist Manifesto. I read Peter Kreeft's Socrates Meets Marx which was a critical analysis of The Communist Manifesto. [url="http://www.amazon.com/The-Socrates-Meets-Marx-Cross-Examines/dp/0898709709"]http://www.amazon.co...s/dp/0898709709[/url] [/quote] How was it?
4588686 Posted September 10, 2012 Author Posted September 10, 2012 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1347245608' post='2480861'] How was it? [/quote] I really liked Kreeft. I don't remember being too impressed with this though. Some of it was kind of cheap. For example attacking Marx for not citing 'from each according to his ability, to each according to his need' comes off as a bit petty in retrospect since it was a very popular slogan of socialist movements and I don't think anyone engaged at the time would think that Marx was trying to present himself as the originator of the phrase. It seemed to me that such tactics sort of characterized the text. Taking easy shots that would cause a modern audience not acquainted with the sloganeering of 19th centiry labor movements to think that Marx was of low moral character (which may well be true, I know almost nothing about him, but obviously has little bearing on his economic, political, and philosophical arguments). Marx claimed to be a scientist and there is a ready made criticism of Marxism as 'scientific socialism' in Karl Popper's The Open Society And It's Enemies but I don't recall Kreeft ever really broaching these really substantive criticisms of Marxism in any real depth. So I have to say that I suspect that he was kind of phoning it in and remaining in the shallow end intellectually. It seems like apologetics (in the worst sense of the word) rather than real engagement and argument.
Nihil Obstat Posted September 10, 2012 Posted September 10, 2012 [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1347246226' post='2480865'] I really liked Kreeft. I don't remember being too impressed with this though. Some of it was kind of cheap. For example attacking Marx for not citing 'from each according to his ability, to each according to his need' comes off as a bit petty in retrospect since it was a very popular slogan of socialist movements and I don't think anyone engaged at the time would think that Marx was trying to present himself as the originator of the phrase. It seemed to me that such tactics sort of characterized the text. Taking easy shots that would cause a modern audience not acquainted with the sloganeering of 19th centiry labor movements to think that Marx was of low moral character (which may well be true, I know almost nothing about him, but obviously has little bearing on his economic, political, and philosophical arguments). Marx claimed to be a scientist and there is a ready made criticism of Marxism as 'scientific socialism' in Karl Popper's The Open Society And It's Enemies but I don't recall Kreeft ever really broaching these really substantive criticisms of Marxism in any real depth. So I have to say that I suspect that he was kind of phoning it in and remaining in the shallow end intellectually. It seems like apologetics (in the worst sense of the word) rather than real engagement and argument. [/quote] I will not bother with it then. No point in spending time on a critique like that if other people have already done deeper and more rigorous jobs.
Anastasia13 Posted September 10, 2012 Posted September 10, 2012 [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1347245569' post='2480860'] I have not read the Communist Manifesto. I read Peter Kreeft's Socrates Meets Marx which was a critical analysis of The Communist Manifesto in High school. But that's as close as I've come. [url="http://www.amazon.com/The-Socrates-Meets-Marx-Cross-Examines/dp/0898709709"]http://www.amazon.co...s/dp/0898709709[/url] [/quote] I remember not being impressed with the manifesto when I read it in high school. Of course I read it for fun and may have missed some points with regard to the modern day application of it which in its direct form seemed dumb and I had not yet taken my government and economics class yet. *shrug*
Jesus_lol Posted September 10, 2012 Posted September 10, 2012 I dont know what book it was, but i do know that you got it in an audiobook format, because you don't know how to read. hmmm, can anyone who reads this post phone Hasan and read it to him so he isn't excluded?
4588686 Posted September 10, 2012 Author Posted September 10, 2012 [quote name='Jesus_lol' timestamp='1347254516' post='2480901'] I dont know what book it was, but i do know that you got it in an audiobook format, because you don't know how to read. hmmm, can anyone who reads this post phone Hasan and read it to him so he isn't excluded? [/quote] Why don't you just ask your mother to read it to me when we chat tonight? BAM!
4588686 Posted September 10, 2012 Author Posted September 10, 2012 As J_Lol has already pointed out this is a trick question since I am illiterate.
Anastasia13 Posted September 10, 2012 Posted September 10, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1347257419' post='2480907'] As J_Lol has already pointed out this is a trick question since I am illiterate. [/quote] Well, then what book on tape/CD did you get? Or does the medication make it too hard to pay that much attention to those? Edited September 10, 2012 by Light and Truth
4588686 Posted September 10, 2012 Author Posted September 10, 2012 [quote name='Light and Truth' timestamp='1347257880' post='2480908'] Well, then what book on tape/CD did you get? [/quote] I'm deaf so I find your question very offensive.
Brother Adam Posted September 10, 2012 Posted September 10, 2012 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1347246504' post='2480867'] I will not bother with it then. No point in spending time on a critique like that if other people have already done deeper and more rigorous jobs. [/quote] I would not say that it is a waste of time if you are not familiar with basic philosophy and need a place to start. Kreeft attempts to make the ideas of different philosophers accessible by engaging the 'spirit of Socrates' in a narrative with others. It is meant to be basic and entertaining, which he does. It is very much written for the layman, not for study. It certainly isn't perfect, and Kreeft tries to inject a lot of humor, so there are some pot shots.
Nihil Obstat Posted September 10, 2012 Posted September 10, 2012 [quote name='Brother Adam' timestamp='1347287063' post='2480969'] I would not say that it is a waste of time if you are not familiar with basic philosophy and need a place to start. Kreeft attempts to make the ideas of different philosophers accessible by engaging the 'spirit of Socrates' in a narrative with others. It is meant to be basic and entertaining, which he does. It is very much written for the layman, not for study. It certainly isn't perfect, and Kreeft tries to inject a lot of humor, so there are some pot shots. [/quote] That's fair enough. But for something on that subject, I'd tend towards the 'more serious' works.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now