Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Female Priests?


Recommended Posts

Posted

Today I was in my Theologies of Gender class. We were talking about cultural perceptions of gender, and this girl mentioned that she was part of a "Roman Catholic Female Priest" community.

This may be very naive and ignorant of me, but I had no idea such groups existed. Does anyone know anything about these kinds of communities? Are they very common? Apparently there is a large community of "female priests" near here, and the women get ordained over water because water is not considered part of a diocese. It all seems very bizarre to me, not to mention wrong.

Posted

Inform her that she is goofy as [the word formerly filtered to floopy] and is by no stretch of the imagination a priest.
Also tell her that woman is not supposed to have a y anywhere in it.

Posted

[quote name='Spem in alium' timestamp='1347569623' post='2482094']
It all seems very bizarre to me, not to mention wrong.
[/quote]

because it is.

Posted

[quote name='Spem in alium' timestamp='1347569623' post='2482094']
Today I was in my Theologies of Gender class. We were talking about cultural perceptions of gender, and this girl mentioned that she was part of a "Roman Catholic Female Priest" community.

This may be very naive and ignorant of me, but I had no idea such groups existed. Does anyone know anything about these kinds of communities? Are they very common? Apparently there is a large community of "female priests" near here, and the women get ordained over water because water is not considered part of a diocese. It all seems very bizarre to me, not to mention wrong.
[/quote]

Here we go ...

First of all ... she can't be part of a Roman Catholic Women Priest community that is truly Roman Catholic. By participation in an invalid and illicit ceremony such as ordaining a woman (which is NOT allowed in the Roman Catholic church) they are excommunicated.

She is incorrectly referring to herself as Roman Catholic. But then again the Womenpriest's group does that.

And yes their ordinations occur usually on a boat. That I did read. The ordinations (from what I understood) have been done by Roman Catholic retired Bishops (who, by their actions, excommunicated themselves anyway, so the line of succession was broken).

I agree with USAirwaysIHS. Goofy, goofy doesn't even begin to describe it. Besides -- I also have a feeling that you're at a very liberal school. Part of the reason why I stopped doing a Masters in Theology program was the liberalness of the school I was at ... it was very feminist.

Posted

She is an idiot. Do not address her unless absolutely necessary.

Posted

Thanks everyone. It seemed crazy to me when she said it.

[quote name='cmariadiaz' timestamp='1347570434' post='2482097']
Here we go ...

First of all ... she can't be part of a Roman Catholic Women Priest community that is truly Roman Catholic. By participation in an invalid and illicit ceremony such as ordaining a woman (which is NOT allowed in the Roman Catholic church) they are excommunicated.

She is incorrectly referring to herself as Roman Catholic. But then again the Womenpriest's group does that.

And yes their ordinations occur usually on a boat. That I did read. The ordinations (from what I understood) have been done by Roman Catholic retired Bishops (who, by their actions, excommunicated themselves anyway, so the line of succession was broken).

I agree with USAirwaysIHS. Goofy, goofy doesn't even begin to describe it. Besides -- I also have a feeling that you're at a very liberal school. Part of the reason why I stopped doing a Masters in Theology program was the liberalness of the school I was at ... it was very feminist.
[/quote]

I don't really understand why she would call herself a Roman Catholic if - and she said this herself - she is "out of communion with the Vatican". It sounds super goofy - beyond that, even.
So, do they think that women can actually perform Mass? Is that what they do? How do these kinds of communities even start?

I'm at a liberal arts school. It identifies as Catholic Benedictine, but some of the views expressed and some of what goes on here are far from Catholic.

Posted

Tell her she needs to put Catholic in quotes. i.e. "Catholic"

I know of these groups, and they willing act against Church teachings.

Posted

Just be careful what you say to her, or you'll face harassment charges. It's a bit like calling yourself a vegetarian but still eating steaks every day.

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

burn her at the stake. or turn her into a newt. either way....

Posted

Pagans have priestesses, not Catholics. Sort of like standing in a garage and calling yourself a car...

Posted

Even though I like my prof, I don't really agree with what she said in response to this girl. She made a mention of how female "priests" are not in communion with the Vatican, that they "didn't agree with the hierarchy" and "found a way to get around it". She almost made it sound like it was a good thing to be happening (She is a feminist and a Lutheran, just as a heads up).

And it was funny, immediately after this girl spoke about how great being a "woman priest" is, another girl started talking about how she's from "the most conservative diocese in the United States"...in quite a combative tone. Made me ROFL...inside.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Spem in alium' timestamp='1347589518' post='2482227']
Even though I like my prof, I don't really agree with what she said in response to this girl. She made a mention of how female "priests" are not in communion with the Vatican, that they "didn't agree with the hierarchy" and "found a way to get around it". She almost made it sound like it was a good thing to be happening (She is a feminist and a Lutheran, just as a heads up).

And it was funny, immediately after this girl spoke about how great being a "woman priest" is, another girl started talking about how she's from "the most conservative diocese in the United States"...in quite a combative tone. Made me ROFL...inside.
[/quote]

Is this perhaps the Lincoln Diocese? If so, that diocese is about as conservative as you can be while still being in union with Rome. It is the only diocese in the United States that absolutely forbids female altar servers, and it is home to one of the only two FSSP seminaries in the entire world. If you don't know who the FSSP are, you would probably mistake them for the SSPX at first. They're a great group of Priests who do the Latin Mass but are in union with Rome and love the Pope. Their other seminary is in Germany, if you are curious.

This is not to make a fight about them and the no female altar servers and what-not, I'm just saying if she said "Lincoln diocese" she was spot on.

Edited by FuturePriest387
Posted

[quote name='Spem in alium' timestamp='1347589518' post='2482227']
(She is a feminist and a Lutheran, just as a heads up).
[/quote]

Umm... wait a sec... if she is a Lutheran then where is the problem? And why is she claiming to be a Catholic?

Posted

[quote name='carmenchristi' timestamp='1347630568' post='2482326']
Umm... wait a sec... if she is a Lutheran then where is the problem? And why is she claiming to be a Catholic?
[/quote]

Sorry for the confusion - I am talking about my professor there. A student was claiming to be a priest.

[quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1347600851' post='2482289']
Is this perhaps the Lincoln Diocese? If so, that diocese is about as conservative as you can be while still being in union with Rome. It is the only diocese in the United States that absolutely forbids female altar servers, and it is home to one of the only two FSSP seminaries in the entire world. If you don't know who the FSSP are, you would probably mistake them for the SSPX at first. They're a great group of Priests who do the Latin Mass but are in union with Rome and love the Pope. Their other seminary is in Germany, if you are curious.

This is not to make a fight about them and the no female altar servers and what-not, I'm just saying if she said "Lincoln diocese" she was spot on.
[/quote]

I have no idea. She didn't actually mention her diocese by name. But she did say something about her church not allowing female altar servers, and I think she also mentioned that women aren't permitted to give the readings either.

Posted

[quote name='Papist' timestamp='1347572567' post='2482111']
Tell her she needs to put Catholic in quotes. i.e. "Catholic"
[/quote]

..And that she needs to use air-quotes when she describes herself as such ;)

Posted

[quote name='Spem in alium' timestamp='1347572141' post='2482110']
I'm at a liberal arts school. It identifies as Catholic Benedictine, but some of the views expressed and some of what goes on here are far from Catholic.
[/quote]

First of all ... I question any program that puts a Lutheran professor into a theology course. I mean I figured the prof may well be feminist (and the school, just from the description of the one student, I was taking a big leap and assuming that it was quite feminist), but to put a lutheran professor on a class that is about (supposedly) catholic theology, especially at a Catholic university is way off.

Sorry to sound strong about this ... I had all the intentions of getting through a Masters of Theology program. Got an A in the first class (and I think an A on the 2nd ... I was on a health hold and never got the 2nd grade). But the theology I was being taught really rattled me to the core. That's when I realized how feminist the school was (the 1st class had some traces of it, the intro to theology class (the 2nd) the claws came out full force). It irks me too -- because some of us are really trying to get a solid education, and it is hard to do so in a cost effective manner at a good school.

Don't know what you're studying Spem ... just do what you need to to do well in the course. And use your conscience to decide what is right and wrong.

[quote name='Spem in alium' timestamp='1347572141' post='2482110']
I don't really understand why she would call herself a Roman Catholic if - and she said this herself - she is "out of communion with the Vatican". It sounds super goofy - beyond that, even.
So, do they think that women can actually perform Mass? Is that what they do? How do these kinds of communities even start?
[/quote]

Do a websearch online about Womenpriests (no spacing). That'll give you some history behind it. Yes the women involved actually get some sort of training (don't know if everyone does at least a Masters ... they can't do a MDiv, but they try to get as close as they can to it. There are priests that train these women on the rubrics on how to do the Mass, and these priests usually do it quietly since their actions technically excommunicate them. They are usually ordained on boats. And they do go off and open their own Churches.

You'd be surprized what you can find out there ... I read about womenpriests and other catholic groups in schism (at least) when I considered leaving the Church. Some groups are ultra conservative. Some groups are ultra liberal. And everything in between. The common denominator is that by each group's actions they are no longer under the authority of the Pope.

I made a decision after going through that temptation/trial. I am Roman Catholic. And as such, I choose to be obedient to Church Authority and accept her teachings. Regardless of what my personal opinions are. Period. :)

Posted

if she said anything about it again I might kindly ask why she has not become a "priest" in a religion that actually has women in that role.

Posted

[quote name='cmariadiaz' timestamp='1347640606' post='2482349']
First of all ... I question any program that puts a Lutheran professor into a theology course. I mean I figured the prof may well be feminist (and the school, just from the description of the one student, I was taking a big leap and assuming that it was quite feminist), but to put a lutheran professor on a class that is about (supposedly) catholic theology, especially at a Catholic university is way off.

Sorry to sound strong about this ... I had all the intentions of getting through a Masters of Theology program. Got an A in the first class (and I think an A on the 2nd ... I was on a health hold and never got the 2nd grade). But the theology I was being taught really rattled me to the core. That's when I realized how feminist the school was (the 1st class had some traces of it, the intro to theology class (the 2nd) the claws came out full force). It irks me too -- because some of us are really trying to get a solid education, and it is hard to do so in a cost effective manner at a good school.

Don't know what you're studying Spem ... just do what you need to to do well in the course. And use your conscience to decide what is right and wrong.

Do a websearch online about Womenpriests (no spacing). That'll give you some history behind it. Yes the women involved actually get some sort of training (don't know if everyone does at least a Masters ... they can't do a MDiv, but they try to get as close as they can to it. There are priests that train these women on the rubrics on how to do the Mass, and these priests usually do it quietly since their actions technically excommunicate them. They are usually ordained on boats. And they do go off and open their own Churches.

You'd be surprized what you can find out there ... I read about womenpriests and other catholic groups in schism (at least) when I considered leaving the Church. Some groups are ultra conservative. Some groups are ultra liberal. And everything in between. The common denominator is that by each group's actions they are no longer under the authority of the Pope.

I made a decision after going through that temptation/trial. I am Roman Catholic. And as such, I choose to be obedient to Church Authority and accept her teachings. Regardless of what my personal opinions are. Period. :)
[/quote]

The course examines broader Christian theology, but it is hard for me to align my views with some of the stuff we talk about. I think my prof is also a pastor, she mentioned something along those lines. When this girl started off by saying she was part of a "Roman Catholic female priest community", my mind just went: "WHAAAAAAT?" And after she mentioned her involvement with this community, my prof said something like, "If you're interested or want more information about female priests, just ask." I really do like my prof, she's great, but I think she could have facilitated discussion a little better maybe. These kinds of things can be really offensive for people, and they can lead to arguments.
Thanks for your advice. I will research them. I think it's important to know things, but I prefer to learn in a way that doesn't compromise or threaten my beliefs or morality enough to make me doubt what I hold true.

[quote name='sixpence' timestamp='1347650145' post='2482390']
if she said anything about it again I might kindly ask why she has not become a "priest" in a religion that actually has women in that role.
[/quote]

That's a good point, I'll do that :) Thank you!

Posted

[quote name='cmariadiaz' timestamp='1347640606' post='2482349']
First of all ... I question any program that puts a Lutheran professor into a theology course. [/quote]

Franciscan did it with an Anglican :|. It really depends on the course being taught, and the willingness of the professor to set aside theological differences and teach what the Catholic Church teaches. This particular Anglican was teaching a theology course on C.S. Lewis, so it probably fit better to be taught by an Anglican.

Posted

Our school allows women to study for MDivs. They just take electives instead of the preaching class or the one in saying mass.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...