Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' timestamp='1348099226' post='2484412']
When I was 29 years old, a man stabbed me numerous times, pushed me head first down a marble staircase, then slammed my head repeatedly on to the floor while strangling me into unconsciousness. God wasn't responsible for that. An individual was, and his hate was responsible. I could have allowed hate to ruin my life too. Instead, I forgave him and broke the cycle. That's free will in action too.
[/quote]

No, but God could have stopped it. And he didn't. If I saw a woman being beaten to hell and stabbed and did not a beaver dam thing to stop it then I would rightly be labeled a cretin. When Kitty Gervais was murdered in public view it shocked the national conscious. How could so many people stand by and do nothing to stop it? And yet when God does the very same it's him respecting 'free will.'

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' timestamp='1348099226' post='2484412']
Why not? Who told you that life was going to be easy and everyone was going to like you and be nice to you? So what if someone screwed you over. That has happened to everyone. My husband had a sister steal $200,000 from him. My mom prevented my dad from having life saving surgery. My foster son's older brother stole every possession he had practically except the clothes on his back.

Everyone here has similar stories in their lives. It wasn't that God let it happen, we let it happen because we are human. We are lazy and greedy and self-centered unless we choose to live differently.

When I was 29 years old, a man stabbed me numerous times, pushed me head first down a marble staircase, then slammed my head repeatedly on to the floor while strangling me into unconsciousness. God wasn't responsible for that. An individual was, and his hate was responsible. I could have allowed hate to ruin my life too. Instead, I forgave him and broke the cycle. That's free will in action too.
[/quote]

This. I tried to use an example in my life, but after this post all of them seemed totally lame. The only one that is kind of up there is when an EF5 tornado came through and destroyed 95% of my town. Was this God's fault? No. But he used it for the good. I know I likely wouldn't be here right now if it hadn't been for that tornado. So much good happened in my life after it. So no, God does not stop evil things from happening in the world. He does, however, help you heal and help good outcomes happen from them. People get upset when you say this, but it's true.

Posted

[quote name='Anomaly' timestamp='1348096038' post='2484380']
What was an omnipotent all knowing god doing for the thousands crippled physically and mentally in the tsunamis or for children and innocents maimed in natural disasters. What about the people who are killed in these disaster who aren't quite "right" with the requirements to be "saved".
[/quote]

The best response to this was in a letter to the editor that basically said that others saw a God Who sent or allowed natural disasters, but he (she?) saw a God who sent relief workers.

Posted

the171? What in the world? Not too long ago you were all happy about the Catholic conferences and camps you were attending and before that you were discerning a vocation to the Carmelites. I'm not going to attempt to answer your question until you answer one....Where is all of this doubt coming from? I have read your blog. You are not this elementary or basic in thought. Something has happened to cause you to completely turn 360.

Posted

If God made/forced everyone to be moral and good, we would not be truly free.

Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' timestamp='1348099856' post='2484419']


The best response to this was in a letter to the editor that basically said that others saw a God Who sent or allowed natural disasters, but he (she?) saw a God who sent relief workers.
[/quote]No. God sent a tsunami. People brought help.

Posted

[sup]32 [/sup]When Mary reached the place where Jesus was and saw him, she fell at his feet and said, “Lord, if you had been here, my brother would not have died.”[sup] 33 [/sup]When Jesus saw her weeping, and the Jews who had come along with her also weeping, he was deeply moved in spirit and troubled. [sup]34 [/sup]“Where have you laid him?” he asked. “Come and see, Lord,” they replied.[sup] 35 [/sup]Jesus wept.[sup] 36 [/sup]Then the Jews said, “See how he loved him!”[sup] 37 [/sup]But some of them said, “Could not he who opened the eyes of the blind man have kept this man from dying?”
(John 11)

Posted (edited)

[quote name='the171' timestamp='1348096311' post='2484384']
How can I find happiness in other people when other people are the ones who have screwed me over? While God just say up there and watched. No one is making any sense. I just don't understand. I want to but I can't.
[/quote]
What is your expectation of what God ought to do?

Remember, we are not promised happiness in this world, but the next.

Edited by Papist
Posted

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1348099522' post='2484415']
When Kitty Gervais was murdered in public view it shocked the national conscious. How could so many people stand by and do nothing to stop it?
[/quote]

If you mean Kitty Genovese, there's still a lot of debate as to how aware the neighbors really were, and the newspaper article itself about how everyone just watched is pretty much debunked. Most of the windows that night were closed, meaning her cries weren't readily heard in the ten story apartment building. One neighbor who did see it out of his window actually did start yelling at her attacker to stop, but he assumed it was just one of the many such incidents between bar patrons at a nearby pub that had let out not long before, and closed his window when he saw the man run away.

Her attacker, Mosely, would later return as she tried to get inside her building, and he would kill her. Another neighbor this time saw what was happening and called the police. The official trial and investigation found there had been perhaps six witnesses, as compared to the newspaper's claim of 30-38. Some were drunk, most were drowsy, some assumed another had called the police, and one couple admitted they had known they should do something, but that for whatever reason they hadn't.

That said, this myth still persists, even in higher education institutions, despite the court documents providing evidence to the contrary.

Sources:
http://articles.nydailynews.com/2011-03-13/news/29139732_1_winston-moseley-genovese-murder-kitty-genovese

http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/fulfillment-any-age/201112/the-top-10-psychology-myths

Posted

[quote name='BG45' timestamp='1348100303' post='2484432']
If you mean Kitty Genovese, there's still a lot of debate as to how aware the neighbors really were, and the newspaper article itself about how everyone just watched is pretty much debunked. Most of the windows that night were closed, meaning her cries weren't readily heard in the ten story apartment building. One neighbor who did see it out of his window actually did start yelling at her attacker to stop, but he assumed it was just one of the many such incidents between bar patrons at a nearby pub that had let out not long before, and closed his window when he saw the man run away.

Her attacker, Mosely, would later return as she tried to get inside her building, and he would kill her. Another neighbor this time saw what was happening and called the police. The official trial and investigation found there had been perhaps six witnesses, as compared to the newspaper's claim of 30-38. Some were drunk, most were drowsy, some assumed another had called the police, and one couple admitted they had known they should do something, but that for whatever reason they hadn't.

That said, this myth still persists, even in higher education institutions, despite the court documents providing evidence to the contrary.

Sources:
[url="http://articles.nydailynews.com/2011-03-13/news/29139732_1_winston-moseley-genovese-murder-kitty-genovese"]http://articles.nyda...-kitty-genovese[/url]

[url="http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/fulfillment-any-age/201112/the-top-10-psychology-myths"]http://www.psycholog...sychology-myths[/url]
[/quote]
Don't let the facts blur out the truth.

KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote]
What purpose did God have in making this world? God intended to build a moral universe. He willed from all eternity to build a stage on which people with character would emerge. He might have made a world without morality, virtue or character. He might have made a world in which each one of us would have sprouted good-ness with the same necessity as the sun rising in the east and setting in the west. But He chose not to make a world in which we would be good as fire is hot and ice is cold. He willed to make a moral universe that by the right use of the gift of freedom, people with character might emerge.
What does God care for things piled into an infinity of space,even though they be diamonds? If all the orbits of heaven were so many jewels glittering as the sun, what would their external but undisturbed balance mean to Him in comparison with a single character which could take hold of the tangled stains of a seemingly wrecked and ruined life and weave out of them the beautiful tapes-try of sacredness and holiness? The choice before God in creating the world, therefore, lay between creating a purely mechanical universe,people who were automatons and machines, or creating a spiritual universe in which there would be a choice between good and evil.
Granted, God chose to make a moral universe in which there would be character. What was the condition of such a universe?He had to make us free. He had to endow us with the power to say “yes” and “no” and to be captains of our own fate and destiny.Morality implies responsibility and duty, but these can exist only on condition of freedom. Stones have no morals because they are not free. We do not condemn ice because it is melted by heat. Praise and blame can be bestowed only on those who are masters of their own will. It is only because you have the possibility of saying no that there is so much charm in your character when you say yes. Take the quality of freedom away from anyone and it is no more possible for him to be virtuous than it is for the blade of grass which he treads beneath his feet. Take freedom away from life and there would be no more reason to honor the fortitude of martyrs than there would be to honor the flames, which kindle their branches. Is it any impeachment of God that He chose not to reign over an empire of chemicals? If God has deliberately chosen a kind of empire not to be ruled by force, but by freedom, and if we find His subjects are able to act against His will as stars and atoms cannot, does this not prove He has possibly given to those human beings the chance of breaking allegiance so there might be meaning and purpose in that allegiance when freely chosen?
Here we have a suggestion as to the possibility of evil. It’s bound up with the freedom of man. Man, who is free to love, is free to hate.He who is free to obey is free to rebel. Virtue in this concrete order is possible only in those spheres where it is possible to be vicious A man can be a saint only in a church in which it is possible to be a devil. You say, “If I were God, I would destroy evil!” If you did that you would destroy human freedom! God will not destroy freedom. If we do not want any dictators on this earth, certainly we do not want any dictators in the Kingdom of Heaven. Those who blamedGod for allowing man freedom to go on hindering and thwarting His work are like those who see smudges and errors in the student’s notebook. They would condemn the teacher for not snatching away the book and doing the copy himself. Just as the object of the teacher is sound education and not the production of neat and well-writ-ten notebooks, so the object of God is the development of souls and not the production of biological entities.
You ask, “If God knew I would sin, why did He make me?” God did not make any of us as sinners, we make ourselves! In that sense, we are creators. The greatest gift of God to man, short of grace, is the gift of human freedom and the power to love Him in return.

-[url="http://www.scribd.com/doc/104655108/3/Good-and-Evil"]Bishop Sheen[/url][/quote]

Posted

[quote name='Papist' timestamp='1348101177' post='2484447']
Don't let the facts blur out the truth.
[/quote]


I really appreciated BG's info but it doesn't really have anything to do with my point, which was that people found the story, even if it was incorrectly reported, morally shocking.

Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' timestamp='1348101183' post='2484448']
[/quote]

Thank you for this wonderful quote from an amazing man. I was hoping to find a good quote, but I don't think any quote is as good as this.

Posted

[quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1348101452' post='2484452']
Thank you for this wonderful quote from an amazing man. I was hoping to find a good quote, but I don't think any quote is as good as this.
[/quote]


Now who's the gay one.

Posted

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1348101511' post='2484455']
Now who's the gay one.
[/quote]

I can be a huge fan of a future Saint and be straight just as much as you can love Susan B. Anthony and still be gay.

Posted

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1348101276' post='2484451']
I really appreciated BG's info but it doesn't really have anything to do with my point, which was that people found the story, even if it was incorrectly reported, morally shocking.
[/quote]
You had a point? Please accept my apology.

Posted

Papist, our Lord asked Pilate, "What is Truth?" In an age of social media in addition to how we tend to socially construct crime, I sometimes ask myself the same thing. :|

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1348101276' post='2484451']
I really appreciated BG's info but it doesn't really have anything to do with my point, which was that people found the story, even if it was incorrectly reported, morally shocking.
[/quote]

Oh I figured, I just hate how that myth keeps popping up. The first time I actually heard it was in a rather well selling textbook in my undergraduate criminal justice courses...so after heading to grad school and reading different journal articles and in one class, once, the court records themselves, I have this kneejerk reaction when it comes to that story.

Posted

[quote name='BG45' timestamp='1348101720' post='2484459']
Papist, our Lord asked Pilate, "What is Truth?" In an age of social media in addition to how we tend to socially construct crime, I sometimes ask myself the same thing. :|
[/quote]

The medium is the message, eh? :P

Posted

[url="http://alltheblognamesarealreadytaken.wordpress.com/2008/06/18/cs-lewis-on-why-evil-does-not-disprove-a-good-god/"]http://alltheblognamesarealreadytaken.wordpress.com/2008/06/18/cs-lewis-on-why-evil-does-not-disprove-a-good-god/[/url]

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1348101766' post='2484460']
The medium is the message, eh? :P
[/quote]

More or less. :P

Sorry to have sidetracked your thread the 171, you still definitely are going to have my prayers, as someone else who has asked similar questions before.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...