Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

George Orwell Was A Socialist


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1348705752' post='2487105']
You missed the joke. :(

I quoted you.
[/quote]
Did you know that [color=#000000][font=Arial][size=1]76.6 per cent of Canadians live in cities and towns while 23.4 per cent live in rural areas.[/size][/font][/color]

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1348705752' post='2487105']
You missed the joke. :(

I quoted you.
[/quote]
Did you know that [color=#000000][font=Arial][size=1]76.6 per cent of Canadians live in cities and towns while 23.4 per cent live in rural areas?[/size][/font][/color]

Posted

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1348689753' post='2487022']
Left socialism (which is lower case democratic socialism) has always advocated the abolition of the state. Democratic Socialists (the political parties) tend to be left socialists in their normative outlook but accept the use of the Democratic Socialist party to make the state and capitalism more humane while they work towards the ultimate abolition of the state and capitalism.
[/quote]
You can't abolish the state and abolish property. The 'property is theft' crowd is deranged.

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' timestamp='1348706498' post='2487112']
Did you know that [color=#000000][font=Arial][size=1]76.6 per cent of Canadians live in cities and towns while 23.4 per cent live in rural areas.[/size][/font][/color]
[/quote]

Well I do know that I live in the city. Also my family lives in the city. Based on my data I am forced to extrapolate that 100% of Canadians live in cities, while 0% live in rural areas. I will have to see some hard evidence to back up your rather extraordinary claims to the contrary.

Posted

[quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1348706766' post='2487114']
You can't abolish the state and abolish property. The 'property is theft' crowd is deranged.
[/quote]

Property, in the expanded sense that exists in the modern capitalist system, has no meaning absent a state. Property in the broad sense is absolutely dependent on a state. Which is one reason why anarchism has been an almost universally socialist (in the broad sense) movement.

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' timestamp='1348703107' post='2487086']
Orwell is popularly chiefly known for his novel [i]1984[/i], which contained quite a few prescient observations about totalitarian statism, and the use of twisting of language and other methods to control the thought of the populace, whatever idiocy he might have believed regarding "Democratic Socialism."

Describing something as "Orwellian" or referring to "Newspeak" need not be seen as a ringing endorsement of everything Orwell believed in. Just as saying something is "straight out of a novel by [fill-in-the-blank-author]" does not mean one agrees with everything that particular author believes.

And one can agree with or admire a person's observations on one thing without agreeing with his opinions on another. I'd think even a Hasan would be able to realize this.
[/quote]

No poo. the reason that I find it grating is because I often see here, and in real life, the labeling of an individual as a 'socialist' being a means of automatically discrediting him and treating anything he may say as fruit of the poison tree.

Posted

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1348707858' post='2487120']
Property, in the expanded sense that exists in the modern capitalist system, has no meaning absent a state. Property in the broad sense is absolutely dependent on a state. Which is one reason why anarchism has been an almost universally socialist (in the broad sense) movement.
[/quote]
Property exists prior to the state. It does not require a state to have a greater claim on an object than anyone else.

By modern capitalist system, you mean corporatism, which relies on the violation of property rights.

Posted

[quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1348764641' post='2487255']
Property exists prior to the state. It does not require a state to have a greater claim on an object than anyone else.

By modern capitalist system, you mean corporatism, which relies on the violation of property rights.
[/quote]
An object also exists prior to anyone's claim on it.

Posted

[quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1348764641' post='2487255']
Property exists prior to the state.[/QUOTE]

What is property?

[QUOTE]It does not require a state to have a greater claim on an object than anyone else.[/QUOTE]

Ok. Who says that you get to utilize natural resources? What gives you any claim to take some of the common enviorment and appropriate it to your personal use?

[QUOTE]By modern capitalist system, you mean corporatism, which relies on the violation of property rights.
[/quote]

No. I mean capitalism. Capitalism is different from a mere free market. It's a particular economic system which emerged in the Europe along side the modern European state (by pure coincidence, I'm sure)

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' timestamp='1348764880' post='2487256']
An object also exists prior to anyone's claim on it.
[/quote]
Right.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1348773587' post='2487341']
What is property?[/quote]
That over which one has the highest claim, which is also scarce and rivalrous (thus one cannot own an idea).

A claim higher relative to others could also make something effectively property of one rather than another.


[quote]
Ok. Who says that you get to utilize natural resources? What gives you any claim to take some of the common enviorment and appropriate it to your personal use? [/quote]
Did you make first use of the resource? Did you intend by that use to lay claim to it?

Are you arguing that one cannot own property? All resources are ultimately traced to use of a natural resource.



[quote]No. I mean capitalism. Capitalism is different from a mere free market. It's a particular economic system which emerged in the Europe along side the modern European state (by pure coincidence, I'm sure)
[/quote]
I'm quite happy to use "free markets", but your definition is not absolute, nor is it what an-caps mean when they use the term.

Edited by Winchester
Posted

[QUOTE]Did you make first use of the resource?[/QUOTE]

Who says that anybody has a right to use finite resources. That's an exceptionally extreme place to start from, but I tend to approach these things dialectically so that'd be the more extreme anti-thesis. Everybody needs water, air et cetera. Things produced by the earth. Why does anyone have a right to use common resources for their private advancement?

[QUOTE]Did you intend by that use to lay claim to it?[/QUOTE]

Well, in the case of natural resources I'm using them by being a living being. If a private corporation destroys the entire rain-forest people are going to be severly impacted.

[QUOTE]Are you arguing that one cannot own property? All resources are ultimately traced to use of a natural resource.[/QUOTE]

I don't see how property is anything other than something that labor plus that of the common resources that an individual has appropriated to himself for his private use under the sanction of the state or his own capacity to secure his appropriation through either the threat violence or the consent of everybody else.




[QUOTE]I'm quite happy to use "free markets", but your definition is not absolute, nor is it what an-caps mean when they use the term.
[/quote]

I honestly don't think that anarcho-capitalists and left anarchists are as far apart as the two sides sometimes seem to think. it's been a long time since I really identified as a libertarian socialist but most of the objections I encountered, outside of internet echo chambers, was that anarcho-capitalists tended to focus pragmatically on weakening the state at a time when the bigger danger was corporate domination and the many of the policies of the state which they most vocally opposed, at least seemingly, were policies which were not really the most oppressive functions of the state.

Posted

[quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1348794816' post='2487459']
Who says that anybody has a right to use finite resources. That's an exceptionally extreme place to start from, but I tend to approach these things dialectically so that'd be the more extreme anti-thesis. Everybody needs water, air et cetera. Things produced by the earth. Why does anyone have a right to use common resources for their private advancement? [/quote]
Who has the authority to say we don't?



[quote]Well, in the case of natural resources I'm using them by being a living being. If a private corporation destroys the entire rain-forest people are going to be severly impacted.[/quote]
Why single out corporations?



[quote]I don't see how property is anything other than something that labor plus that of the common resources that an individual has appropriated to himself for his private use under the sanction of the state or his own capacity to secure his appropriation through either the threat violence or the consent of everybody else.
[/quote]
So you believe that everyone owns everything in common?





[quote]I honestly don't think that anarcho-capitalists and left anarchists are as far apart as the two sides sometimes seem to think. it's been a long time since I really identified as a libertarian socialist but most of the objections I encountered, outside of internet echo chambers, was that anarcho-capitalists tended to focus pragmatically on weakening the state at a time when the bigger danger was corporate domination and the many of the policies of the state which they most vocally opposed, at least seemingly, were policies which were not really the most oppressive functions of the state.
[/quote]
This would take too much effort. I don't think it would be worth us arguing.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...