StaroftheSea Posted September 29, 2012 Posted September 29, 2012 So I am taking a high school World Religions class and part of the class involves leading and participating in spiritual practices and/or rituals from other religions. My question is what exactly is meant by "taking an active part" in non-Catholic worship? And, if I should definitely not do this, can I have some advice on how to approach the teacher? She is Catholic, but I'm not quite sure what kind of an answer I would get. Argh, I don't want to commit a possible mortal sin every three weeks! Sorry for the load of questions, but this has been bothering me ever since we did the puja for the Hinduism unit this week. I had thought that it was more of an academic exercise, but during it there was something I couldn't quite justify about it, and then tonight I researched more into the Catechism and found some warning signs. Any advice would certainly be helpful.
Basilisa Marie Posted September 29, 2012 Posted September 29, 2012 You're right that there's a problem here. It's one thing to learn about a religion's spiritual exercise, or even witness that exercise. It's entirely different if you're required to take an active part in it. When you say doing the puja - do you mean actually doing it? With water, thread, incense, food, the whole shebang? If it were me, I'd talk to my teacher and explain that although I'd eager to learn about different religions, I feel very uncomfortable actually performing the different rituals. I wouldn't have a problem giving a presentation about the puja, or even showing a video that demonstrates what it looks like, but actually leading a ritual of another faith is a line I could not cross without violating my own beliefs. And personally, I would find it insulting if a group of non-Catholics said the rosary together just to "see what it's like" or something, especially if it were lead by a non-Catholic.
4588686 Posted September 29, 2012 Posted September 29, 2012 [quote name='StaroftheSea' timestamp='1348897569' post='2487918'] So I am taking a high school World Religions class and part of the class involves leading and participating in spiritual practices and/or rituals from other religions. My question is what exactly is meant by "taking an active part" in non-Catholic worship? And, if I should definitely not do this, can I have some advice on how to approach the teacher? She is Catholic, but I'm not quite sure what kind of an answer I would get. Argh, I don't want to commit a possible mortal sin every three weeks! [/quote] I don't know what they mean. You may be required to participate in the sense of, for example, attend a Jewish Temple during Friday prayers. They cannot make you participate in the sense of praying or actually engaging in religious devotion. If they try to make you pray then tell them you're calling the ACLU.
Nihil Obstat Posted September 29, 2012 Posted September 29, 2012 As Catholics we cannot actually participate in the rites and ceremonies of another religion. Observing is one thing, but participating is something very different.
Vincent Vega Posted September 29, 2012 Posted September 29, 2012 [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1348898550' post='2487924'] I don't know what they mean. You may be required to participate in the sense of, for example, attend a Jewish Temple during Friday prayers. They cannot make you participate in the sense of praying or actually engaging in religious devotion. If they try to make you pray then tell them you're calling the ACLU. [/quote] This. I sincerely doubt that the definition of participation used in the Catechism and the definition of participation used in the syllabus of your class are the same.
StaroftheSea Posted September 29, 2012 Author Posted September 29, 2012 [quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1348898326' post='2487923'] You're right that there's a problem here. It's one thing to learn about a religion's spiritual exercise, or even witness that exercise. It's entirely different if you're required to take an active part in it. When you say doing the puja - do you mean actually doing it? With water, thread, incense, food, the whole shebang? And personally, I would find it insulting if a group of non-Catholics said the rosary together just to "see what it's like" or something, especially if it were lead by a non-Catholic. [/quote] yes, the whole thing. As for the latter, I actually never considered it in that way.
Lil Red Posted September 29, 2012 Posted September 29, 2012 well, i hope you can get some answers from your teacher.
BG45 Posted September 29, 2012 Posted September 29, 2012 Looking forward to hearing what your teacher says, because if this is the United States, then the ACLU would happily jump all over this. A government funded institution, such as a public school, can NOT require you to engage in any sort of religious activity at all, whether it is in line with your faith or not. Students can choose to engage in religious activities themselves, but the teacher, acting on behalf of the state, is not legally allowed to lead students into any form of religious activity.
StaroftheSea Posted September 29, 2012 Author Posted September 29, 2012 erm, sorry, I forgot to mention something. This is a Catholic school, not a public school.
Basilisa Marie Posted September 29, 2012 Posted September 29, 2012 [quote name='StaroftheSea' timestamp='1348932290' post='2488015'] erm, sorry, I forgot to mention something. This is a Catholic school, not a public school. [/quote] Ugh oh. That's even more problematic. I'd still have the same kind of conversation with your teacher. Again, emphasizing that you want to learn about other religions (you're not trying to get out of doing work), but that you really don't feel comfortable actually participating in rituals. At best your teacher might not be Catholic and not realize that this is an issue, and he or she will accommodate you. Really, your teacher could just have you could even just sit quietly and watch while everyone else participates.
BG45 Posted September 29, 2012 Posted September 29, 2012 What BM said, that's just more...sticky as an issue.
Anastasia13 Posted September 29, 2012 Posted September 29, 2012 We will pray this works out for you, and brings wisdom to others.
OnlySunshine Posted September 29, 2012 Posted September 29, 2012 [quote name='StaroftheSea' timestamp='1348897569' post='2487918'] So I am taking a high school World Religions class and part of the class involves leading and participating in spiritual practices and/or rituals from other religions. My question is what exactly is meant by "taking an active part" in non-Catholic worship? And, if I should definitely not do this, can I have some advice on how to approach the teacher? She is Catholic, but I'm not quite sure what kind of an answer I would get. Argh, I don't want to commit a possible mortal sin every three weeks! Sorry for the load of questions, but this has been bothering me ever since we did the puja for the Hinduism unit this week. I had thought that it was more of an academic exercise, but during it there was something I couldn't quite justify about it, and then tonight I researched more into the Catechism and found some warning signs. Any advice would certainly be helpful. [/quote] Having been in the EXACT same position myself by having to attend a Buddhist temple for a final project, I can't tell you how uncomfortable it is. I had to sit and listen while they had a "prayer" service and then write about it later on. They were using prayer beads (a modified rosary, I guess you could say) and chanting prayers over and over. It got really irritating after a while because of the tone in which they were chanting. I really wanted to leave but I was worried that the temple leader (who knew my teacher) would contact my teacher and tell her that I left. It's not something I would ever subject myself to again. I would approach the teacher and just explain to her that it is against your beliefs to lead a non-Catholic worship service. Even if it were a Catholic service, you wouldn't be able to lead it, per se. If she doesn't accept your explanation, go to the dean of her department and explain that you cannot do this. Teachers are not allowed to force things on you that don't mesh with your beliefs. It's the same as dissection in a science class -- they have to provide alternatives. BTW, did you know that this might be a requirement when you signed up for the class? I sure didn't!
OnlySunshine Posted September 29, 2012 Posted September 29, 2012 [quote name='StaroftheSea' timestamp='1348932290' post='2488015'] erm, sorry, I forgot to mention something. This is a Catholic school, not a public school. [/quote] If that's the case, I'd bring your concerns to the principal. I wonder if he/she knows what is occurring in the classroom. What do your parents think about this?
Groo the Wanderer Posted September 30, 2012 Posted September 30, 2012 dont do it. denounce the teacher as a heretic. burn them at the stake in gym class.
StaroftheSea Posted September 30, 2012 Author Posted September 30, 2012 I had heard about the requirement, but it never fully registered in my mind, I guess, until the puja. I'll talk to my teacher tomorrow, so please pray for me!
MeteorShower Posted September 30, 2012 Posted September 30, 2012 Prayers for you! I understand it's a very awkward situation - I went through it myself in my first year of high school. During our Buddhism unit, we all had to do projects on different aspects of Buddhism. One of the girls for her presentation decided to lead the class in meditation. I found it extremely uncomfortable and stopped participating half way through. The year before we had gone on a school trip to a Buddhist temple where we also were led in group meditation. At that time I did participate in the meditation. Although it was very interesting to see the temple and learn about the history and beliefs in Buddhism, I regret doing it and would never go again. This seems to be an issue in many world religion classes. When I was looking into doing a world religion course in university, the website mentioned that the classes visit a variety of places of worship. They didn't go into detail about whether it was just for observation or if one was expected to participate (and if so, to what degree) but I ended up not doing it anyway. I hope that your teacher is respecteful of your views. My world religions teacher in high school was also Catholic, interestingly enough.
sixpence Posted September 30, 2012 Posted September 30, 2012 [quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1348898326' post='2487923'] And personally, I would find it insulting if a group of non-Catholics said the rosary together just to "see what it's like" or something, especially if it were lead by a non-Catholic. [/quote] this!!
Basilisa Marie Posted October 1, 2012 Posted October 1, 2012 (edited) I think it's a bit sad, because I'm a huge fan of World Religions classes and think they're desperately needed in a lot of ways. Not only can they help clear up misconceptions about other religions, but in turn they can help you see why you're Catholic and not Muslim or Buddhist or whatever. Having different religious leaders come in to give a talk and answer questions, and even field trips to different houses of worship can be wonderfully illuminating experiences. I know I would have loved a world religions class in high school, because it would have given me the opportunity to not be the freaky Catholic kid. But by requiring people to participate in religious devotions and rituals, not just observing them, you begin implying that all religions are really just the same, that the differences only matter in that one might "feel" better for you, etc. And that's not doing justice to any religion. If you don't respect the different answers to the big questions in life, you're ultimately saying that those questions don't really matter. Lots of prayers for you, StaroftheSea! I hope the conversation goes well! Edited October 1, 2012 by Basilisa Marie
tinytherese Posted October 1, 2012 Posted October 1, 2012 I took two semesters of world religion courses at a none Catholic school and we simply had to attend a worship service of another faith, but not necessarily participate, then write a reflection on the experience. For that I went to a Reformed Jewish Synagogue one friday night. It was interesting. Ironically, while attending the Catholic university on the Newman Guide, my professor who was a religious sister for Introduction to Sacred Scripture gave us a pamphlet where we would get to select the opening prayer and along with Catholic prayers were Buddhist and pagan Native American prayers.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now