Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Political Question For Catholics.


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1349371780' post='2489965']
Well, obviously Obama is pro-choice and basically told Catholic organizations to take a hike with the HHS mandate, so he's out. Romney may be pro-life, but I'm skeptical as to whether or not he's actually going to do anything about it (defund Planned Parenthood? Maybe? And...what else?), and I don't think this economic policies are good for our country. I don't think they line up with Catholic Social Teaching.

The problem I have with screening candidates solely based on being pro-life is that it pretty much gives them a license to do WHATEVER else they want, regardless of whether it'll be good for our country, just as long as they pay lip service to the pro-life cause. They basically hold our votes hostage, and I can't stand that.

So what's moral? It seems to me that you basically have two options. You see your vote as going toward one of two people, and choose the one who is the lesser of two evils. I'd say that's Romney, in that we [i]know [/i]that as president Obama has given a giant "up yours" to Catholics, pro-lifers, etc, while we don't know what's actually going to happen if Romney becomes president. Or, you can "throw away your vote" by using it to vote for a third party candidate, and express your frustration with the two-party system. Personally I don't think I can rationalize a vote FOR Romney, even if it is against Obama, so I might end up voting third party.
[/quote]


I don't like either candidate ... and honestly I don't know if the lesser of two evils is Romney. I haven't made my decision, but I may just flip a coin on this one.

I was out of the country during the last elections, and felt horrible that I couldn't place a vote, so I have to vote this time. Whoever I vote for, my conscience is clear in that I voted for who I could morally vote for. I refuse though to simply say that because a candidate is prochoice and after analyzing all factors I choose a prochoice candidate that I am in "mortal sin", especially since I am not specifically voting for a candidate because he is prochoice. I am also not saying that I will vote for Obama, or that I will vote for Romney. I honestly haven't decided yet, but I won't let a single issue make the vote decision for me.

Now ... if I was choosing a candidate because he is prochoice then definitely you are talking about something very different, you are then talking about believing in something that goes against Catholic belief. *THEN* I would be voting myself into mortal sin.

dominicansoul
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1349371780' post='2489965']
Well, obviously Obama is pro-choice and basically told Catholic organizations to take a hike with the HHS mandate, so he's out. Romney may be pro-life, but I'm skeptical as to whether or not he's actually going to do anything about it (defund Planned Parenthood? Maybe? And...what else?), and I don't think this economic policies are good for our country. I don't think they line up with Catholic Social Teaching.
[/quote]

Presidents will never do anything and probably can't do anything to [i]stop[/i] abortion on demand. That is our job as Catholic Christians to evangelize our nation and teach the evil of abortion. On the other hand a president can sure do everything in his power to boost the abortion industry and force us to pay for it.

Obama will do everythign he can in his power (and he has) to propagate planned parenthood and abortion on demand here in our country as well as throughout the world. Will Romney do that? I hope not. Obama is saying "up yours" to the church. Will Romney do that? I doubt it. AS far as social justice issues, where has Obama helped the poor? Enslaving the poor and making them dependent on government is not social justice..its socialism. Jesus said, "the poor you will always have with you." Again, this is our job as Catholic Christians to help the poor, not the government....

I am personal friends with several religious. All of them, priests, brothers, sisters and nuns are voting for Romney. Are they happy with that decision? Probably not. But obviously, its not a danger to the soul to vote for the lesser evil. If your conscience doesn't allow it, don't do it, but I think my conscience will bother me more if I help Obama win. I think we need to see that an Obama second term is the worst thing that can happen to our church and our country. We must do all we can to get him out of power.

We also need to become more actively engaged in holding our politicians accountable for their evil policies. Get involved in the grassroots level to stop these evil policies and be a voice against them. St. Catherine of Sienna said, "it is silence that kills the world." Once Mitt is elected, we need to hold him accountable at every turn (i'm sure the media will...)

Edited by dominicansoul
Posted

[quote name='Papist' timestamp='1349372221' post='2489968']
Nice out.
[/quote]
Nice out.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

[quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1349371780' post='2489965']
Well, obviously Obama is pro-choice and basically told Catholic organizations to take a hike with the HHS mandate, so he's out. Romney may be pro-life, but I'm skeptical as to whether or not he's actually going to do anything about it (defund Planned Parenthood? Maybe? And...what else?), and I don't think this economic policies are good for our country. I don't think they line up with Catholic Social Teaching.

The problem I have with screening candidates solely based on being pro-life is that it pretty much gives them a license to do WHATEVER else they want, regardless of whether it'll be good for our country, just as long as they pay lip service to the pro-life cause. They basically hold our votes hostage, and I can't stand that.

So what's moral? It seems to me that you basically have two options. You see your vote as going toward one of two people, and choose the one who is the lesser of two evils. I'd say that's Romney, in that we [i]know [/i]that as president Obama has given a giant "up yours" to Catholics, pro-lifers, etc, while we don't know what's actually going to happen if Romney becomes president. Or, you can "throw away your vote" by using it to vote for a third party candidate, and express your frustration with the two-party system. Personally I don't think I can rationalize a vote FOR Romney, even if it is against Obama, so I might end up voting third party.
[/quote]

In my opinion it is also an entirely valid moral choice to refuse to vote. Refuse to participate in this corrupt, evil system. It may not count for anything, but then again neither does your vote. But it is a moral stand.

Posted

[quote name='MIkolbe' timestamp='1349373847' post='2489981']
Nice out.
[/quote]
You're so hardcore.

eagle_eye222001
Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1349374764' post='2489984']
In my opinion it is also an entirely valid moral choice to refuse to vote. Refuse to participate in this corrupt, evil system. It may not count for anything, but then again neither does your vote. But it is a moral stand.
[/quote]

I disagree a bit with this. Do your best to find a third party candidate who could be worth supporting....that way....your vote will count and go into a percentage that shows your dissatisfaction with the two major contenders. Not voting does not show up as well as voting third party does.

My big qualm with not voting also is that you ignore all the other election races going on. Surely there are local races with a decent person worth supporting or some issue worth taking a side on?

Nihil Obstat
Posted

[quote name='eagle_eye222001' timestamp='1349379058' post='2490000']

I disagree a bit with this. Do your best to find a third party candidate who could be worth supporting....that way....your vote will count and go into a percentage that shows your dissatisfaction with the two major contenders. Not voting does not show up as well as voting third party does.

My big qualm with not voting also is that you ignore all the other election races going on. Surely there are local races with a decent person worth supporting or some issue worth taking a side on?
[/quote]

I understand that viewpoint entirely, but I have moved past it.

The thing about voting is that it explicitly lends your support to the system. By voting, you are acknowledging that the election is just. It is a token action, but action nonetheless.
This just feeds the idea that the system is fundamentally ok, but just needs some minor tweaking. That is untrue. The system is fundamentally broken. We do not need to patch it up and give it a bit of work. We need to rethink it from the ground up.
But if we keep voting, we keep saying "Yeah, this might be ok as long as [i]my guy[/i] gets in this time." That is not how it works. The system exists for its own sake. It exists to keep the elite in power, to let them keep stealing and murdering and lying and cheating. They are not going to make the necessary changes- why would they?
As long as we continue supporting the system that allows them to do this, nothing could possibly ever change.

Basically, if I reject the whole system root and branch, then I do not want to be counted among the people who, by their actions, formally support it.

Like I alluded to, it is not something that is going to effect major change. Not on its own. My non-vote does not count for anything outside of my conscience. Nor does your vote count, in reality. It is a stand on principle alone. And it is one that, for now, my conscience demands from me.

I do respect the position you are coming from. I am just motivated to move past it for now.

Posted

The only moral option is to write yourself in.

eagle_eye222001
Posted

[quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1349371780' post='2489965']
...

The problem I have with screening candidates solely based on being pro-life is that it pretty much gives them a license to do WHATEVER else they want, regardless of whether it'll be good for our country, just as long as they pay lip service to the pro-life cause. They basically hold our votes hostage, and I can't stand that....
[/quote]

This is a major reason why I'm not supporting Romney. I've had it with lip service on being pro-life. From now on, I demand actual strong efforts. Not stupid legislation like the partial birth abortion act or that thing the House passed several months ago. In both instances, there was or would have been very little effect on actual abortions. Nearly all the good abortion restrictions happen from the state level anyway...

[quote name='dominicansoul' timestamp='1349373259' post='2489978']
... Will Romney do that? I [b]hope [/b]not. Obama is saying "up yours" to the church. Will Romney do that? I [b]doubt [/b]it. AS far as social justice issues, where has Obama helped the poor? Enslaving the poor and making them dependent on government is not social justice..its socialism. Jesus said, "the poor you will always have with you." Again, this is our job as Catholic Christians to help the poor, not the government....

I am personal friends with several religious. All of them, priests, brothers, sisters and nuns are voting for Romney. Are they happy with that decision? Probably not. But obviously, its not a danger to the soul to vote for the lesser evil. If your conscience doesn't allow it, don't do it, but I think my conscience will bother me more if I help Obama win. I think we need to see that an Obama second term is the worst thing that can happen to our church and our country. We must do all we can to get him out of power.

[u]We also need to become more actively engaged in holding our politicians accountable for their evil policies[/u]. Get involved in the grassroots level to stop these evil policies and be a voice against them. St. Catherine of Sienna said, "it is silence that kills the world." Once Mitt is elected, we need to hold him accountable at every turn (i'm sure the media will...)
[/quote]

See, I'm not voting for Mitt because I am already holding him accountable for his past. :crusader2: While I fear Obama...I near equally fear Romney. And I fear most people have not taken that into consideration.

I predict Romney will probably win....and he will sell out the pro-life movement. He will weakly attempt to defund Planned Parenthood but will stop as soon as he meets resistance. The judges he appoints will be shaky-pro-life.....but their views will reflect the status-quo on abortion. "[b]But I tried[/b]" he will say when the pro-life movement complains. In 4 years, another democrat will rise........and sadly most of the pro-life movement will not hold Mitt accountable.....but will support him.....because again.....he is the [b]lesser of two evils....and Romney like many before him will again be held unaccountable.[/b]

I hope I am wrong in this prediction. But my gut...and Romney's past says I'm right.

Posted

Abortion by drone is okay.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

[quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1349380459' post='2490006']
Abortion by drone is okay.
[/quote]
Only if they are 'merican drones.

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1349380659' post='2490007']
Only if they are 'merican drones.
[/quote]

[s]And you're not an American citizen.[/s]

Nevermind... :|

Posted

I gave Nihil props, because it's an interesting perspective, but I haven't necessarily gotten to that point yet. I suppose the percent of people that do show up to vote is seen as an approval of the system on some level, and if there were a massive boycott and it was actually reported as such you could begin to establish a lack of credibility for the system; but as it stands refusing to vote is as ineffective as not voting... third party voting or write-in votes that are counted (see this map to see if your write in vote will count; if you are somewhere where it will not count then it sometimes will invalidate your entire ballot: http://imgur.com/EF2bM ... NB, in Maine a write-in for Ron Paul counts because his supporters filed paperwork to make him an official write-in candidate apparently lol; places with sore loser laws will simply not count a write-in vote for someone who ran in the primary, so you would have to vote for someone who did not run in a primary this year for that vote to be counted) I think is the only effective message unless you could organize a massive demonstration on election day that called attention to a voter boycott.

really, I think that would be great, and it's the direction I think the boycott-voting folks should go in. if there were massive Occupy-Wall-Street and Tea-Party size protests organized on election day of people specifically going out to the streets with signs to declare that they were REFUSING to vote in the corrupt system, that would be a powerful message. Basically a voter strike, if there were significant picket-lines and you got the media's attention, it would be quite the event and quite the indictment of the system. without that, simply not going to the polls doesn't actually register as the message Nihil says it registers as.

Of course, if you are in a state where you can write in a candidate and you write in a candidate who does not have a slate of electors in your state set to go to the electoral college if he wins, it is a vote that is actually an indictment against the corruption of the system. :smokey:

also of note that it is likely that Ron Paul will get about 2 or 3 electoral votes this time around... it may be more, and probably more if Romney's going to lose anyway because some electors said they'll only do it if it doesn't affect the outcome (in '76 there were electors that voted Reagan instead of Ford since Ford lost anyway). these types of things need to happen to send the message that the voting public is growing towards a tipping point where they will no longer stand for this kind of stuff; and it needs to not fizzle out the way the Ross Perot movement did (because of all the people who gave up and accepted the blame and offered up their mea culpas for causing Bush Sr. to lose... Bush Sr. deserved to lose that election and all the Ross Perot voters should have doubled down in the next elections and caused a movement for third parties to grow)

as to the topic at hand... honestly anyone who gets too heated up over really wanting Obama to lose I think should step back and realize that Romney is not all that much different and the actual policies that will be put into place will be extremely similar (and the Supreme Court justices that get appointed will generally be appointed to continue the status quo on abortion issues; anyone who thinks Romney will appoint Supreme Court Justices to the point of getting us a majority on the Supreme Court is living in a dream world)

Posted

[quote name='eagle_eye222001' timestamp='1349380359' post='2490005']
This is a major reason why I'm not supporting Romney. I've had it with lip service on being pro-life. From now on, I demand actual strong efforts. Not stupid legislation like the partial birth abortion act or that thing the House passed several months ago. In both instances, there was or would have been very little effect on actual abortions. Nearly all the good abortion restrictions happen from the state level anyway...



See, I'm not voting for Mitt because I am already holding him accountable for his past. :crusader2: While I fear Obama...I near equally fear Romney. And I fear most people have not taken that into consideration.

I predict Romney will probably win....and he will sell out the pro-life movement. He will weakly attempt to defund Planned Parenthood but will stop as soon as he meets resistance. The judges he appoints will be shaky-pro-life.....but their views will reflect the status-quo on abortion. "[b]But I tried[/b]" he will say when the pro-life movement complains. In 4 years, another democrat will rise........and sadly most of the pro-life movement will not hold Mitt accountable.....but will support him.....because again.....he is the [b]lesser of two evils....and Romney like many before him will again be held unaccountable.[/b]

I hope I am wrong in this prediction. But my gut...and Romney's past says I'm right.
[/quote]
I predict Romney's going to lose. He's got no game in the key swing states, OH and FL are almost lost causes for him, his path to electoral victory is very fragile and improbable; though I hear he "did well" in the professional wrestling match they had the other night (I think they call it a "debate" but it's about as fake as professional wrestling) so I suppose if he continues to "do well" in those charades maybe he'll turn it around.

Personally, I think it's better for Romney to lose to give us a chance at a better candidate in four years. Obviously one should not vote for Obama, but one should also not vote for Romney. A vote for Romney puts Romney in charge of the only party where the pro-life movement even has a voice for the next 8 years, ie it silences the pro life movement for eight years (like you illustrated).

Posted

[quote name='Papist' timestamp='1349370440' post='2489955']
So what is the moral choice to make?
[/quote]
After reflecting, I thought this was a very good question.

Upon reflecting on it more, it seems more like a cop out....like asking "There's a burning building and you can only save your Dad or a batch of frozen fertilized eggs..what would you do?" ..... a way of asking a question not to know something.. but to KEEP from knowing something...




So, an honest answer to your question what is the moral choice to make, I say this..

I have no idea.

I am not asking my candidate to be moral is all parts of his/her life (I would prefer that, TBH..and would most likely be a condition of my vote)

What I AM asking is that they not ask me to embrace intrinsic evils like abortion, torture, embrionic stem cell, etc etc. One should not embrace it for the sake of the state (democrats), nor for the sake of the party (republicans).

I am not asking for angels...I am just demanding they not be devils. (pardon the hyperbole)

Nihil Obstat
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1349381273' post='2490011']
I gave Nihil props, because it's an interesting perspective, but I haven't necessarily gotten to that point yet. I suppose the percent of people that do show up to vote is seen as an approval of the system on some level, and if there were a massive boycott and it was actually reported as such you could begin to establish a lack of credibility for the system; but as it stands refusing to vote is as ineffective as not voting... third party voting or write-in votes that are counted (see this map to see if your write in vote will count; if you are somewhere where it will not count then it sometimes will invalidate your entire ballot: [url="http://imgur.com/EF2bM"]http://imgur.com/EF2bM[/url] ... NB, in Maine a write-in for Ron Paul counts because his supporters filed paperwork to make him an official write-in candidate apparently lol; places with sore loser laws will simply not count a write-in vote for someone who ran in the primary, so you would have to vote for someone who did not run in a primary this year for that vote to be counted) I think is the only effective message unless you could organize a massive demonstration on election day that called attention to a voter boycott.

really, I think that would be great, and it's the direction I think the boycott-voting folks should go in. if there were massive Occupy-Wall-Street and Tea-Party size protests organized on election day of people specifically going out to the streets with signs to declare that they were REFUSING to vote in the corrupt system, that would be a powerful message. Basically a voter strike, if there were significant picket-lines and you got the media's attention, it would be quite the event and quite the indictment of the system. without that, simply not going to the polls doesn't actually register as the message Nihil says it registers as.

Of course, if you are in a state where you can write in a candidate and you write in a candidate who does not have a slate of electors in your state set to go to the electoral college if he wins, it is a vote that is actually an indictment against the corruption of the system. :smokey:

also of note that it is likely that Ron Paul will get about 2 or 3 electoral votes this time around... it may be more, and probably more if Romney's going to lose anyway because some electors said they'll only do it if it doesn't affect the outcome (in '76 there were electors that voted Reagan instead of Ford since Ford lost anyway). these types of things need to happen to send the message that the voting public is growing towards a tipping point where they will no longer stand for this kind of stuff; and it needs to not fizzle out the way the Ross Perot movement did (because of all the people who gave up and accepted the blame and offered up their mea culpas for causing Bush Sr. to lose... Bush Sr. deserved to lose that election and all the Ross Perot voters should have doubled down in the next elections and caused a movement for third parties to grow)

as to the topic at hand... honestly anyone who gets too heated up over really wanting Obama to lose I think should step back and realize that Romney is not all that much different and the actual policies that will be put into place will be extremely similar (and the Supreme Court justices that get appointed will generally be appointed to continue the status quo on abortion issues; anyone who thinks Romney will appoint Supreme Court Justices to the point of getting us a majority on the Supreme Court is living in a dream world)
[/quote]
I am not as familiar with the specifics of the American electoral system, so you are going to know a lot more than me on those points. :) For now, all I can talk about is the very basic level, the concept of withholding consent. If I knew more about the specifics, this is a discussion that I would love to have. :smile3:

Nihil Obstat
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1349381694' post='2490015']

Personally, I think it's better for Romney to lose to give us a chance at a better candidate in four years. Obviously one should not vote for Obama, but one should also not vote for Romney. A vote for Romney puts Romney in charge of the only party where the pro-life movement even has a voice for the next 8 years, ie it silences the pro life movement for eight years (like you illustrated).
[/quote]
Just playing devil's advocate here. Do you think this could be interpreted as a form of consequentialism? I only bring this up because of a lot neo-con Catholics are arguing precisely that- not because I agree with it.

eagle_eye222001
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1349381694' post='2490015']
I predict Romney's going to lose. He's got no game in the key swing states, OH and FL are almost lost causes for him, his path to electoral victory is very fragile and improbable; though I hear he "did well" in the professional wrestling match they had the other night (I think they call it a "debate" but it's about as fake as professional wrestling) so I suppose if he continues to "do well" in those charades maybe he'll turn it around.

Personally, I think it's better for Romney to lose to give us a chance at a better candidate in four years. Obviously one should not vote for Obama, but one should also not vote for Romney. A vote for Romney puts Romney in charge of the only party where the pro-life movement even has a voice for the next 8 years, ie it silences the pro life movement for eight years (like you illustrated).
[/quote]

I guess I'm clinging to the fact that the polls are oversampling democrats to the point that Romney is actually winning. However, I am unsure as how much this is so perhaps Romney is legit losing. I don't really know anymore. It's hard to sift through all the trash for valuables.

It can make sense that Romney is losing.......the guy stands for literally nothing! The only reason he has anything going for him is the mere fact he is literally physically not Obama. That is the only reason anyone is rallying around him. Which is an awful reason to support someone....

Yes the debate was a fake...I wonder in general how many people actually change their minds over a one night debate when both candidates have already spent millions (if not billions) spreading their message. I mean....theoretically, their voting records and their views have not changed....so really you should already know.all the good information.

I do agree with your idea of letting Romney lose (and part of me wants him too) so as to get a reasonable worthy candidate in 4 years. Sadly I had the same idea with McCain. While I am sad to say now that I voted for him, I secretly hoped he would lose so that this election would be a slam-dunk with a real conservative republican. However, that didn't happen......we got a shifty moderate.....and the polls say he is losing. So I guess repeat and try again in four. And this time, we'll rally behind Rand Paul!?!

Have to reform the party before you can hope to save the nation.

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1349382801' post='2490024']
Just playing devil's advocate here. Do you think this could be interpreted as a form of consequentialism? I only bring this up because of a lot neo-con Catholics are arguing precisely that- not because I agree with it.
[/quote]
consequentialism would be justifying a bad course of action by the consequences, a consequentialist taking my position would say "it's better for Romney to lose and therefore you should vote for Obama (because a vote for Obama is the best way to make Romney lose), even though the act of voting for him is bad, because ultimately the consequences of Obama winning and Romney losing are good (in giving us a better chance in four years rather than eight)"

what I said was merely an evaluation of the consequences after the fact. I was not using a consequentialist argument to in any way justify a bad action, I specifically said do not vote for Obama. I am also saying don't vote for Romney. I suggest voting for someone that you believe is right for the job regardless of the consequences, the action itself needs to be good--and a vote for a good candidate like a write-in for Ron Paul or someone else that you believe is a good vote is a good action. So I say "Write in Ron Paul or vote for Gary Johnson (on the basis that his policies would allow for the illegalization of abortion which would therefore make him more pro-life than Obama or Romney even if he's less pro-life than a Ron Paul or a Rick Santorum, Gary Johnson is certainly up for debate but I think he's a valid option for Catholics to consider given the field of candidates on the ballots) or vote for Virgil Goode or write in some other good candidate pro-life guy; ultimately the realistic unintended consequence of this intrinsically good action would be an Obama victory rather than a Romney victory, but if you don't have a preference for either side then that's not too much of a problem for you because you were uninvolved in the actual victory" and then I evaluate what consequences an Obama victory would have, ie a chance for a Rand Paul in 2016 with Justin Amash as his vice president, for example :cyclops:

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I am going to hold out for a Napolitano Woods ballot. ;)

Lol, I agree though.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...