Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Mickey's_Girl
Posted (edited)

Former (or nearly-former) protestants--how do you go from being "Christian" and not really relating to Mary much at all, to the whole Catholic understanding of Mary? Did you have trouble? Do you still?

(I'm asking FPs specifically, because I'm assuming they'll know where I'm coming from. I'm not trying to be snobby. :-) )

Thanks!

MG

PS. No, I haven't read Scott Hahn on Mary, but he's on the summer reading list. Any other book suggestions?

Edited by Mickey's_Girl
Brother Adam
Posted

I had an interesting experience with Mary, so it's a bit easier for me, but yeah, its still....a little different.

daugher-of-Mary
Posted

I converted when I was fairly young, so Mary really wasn't much of a problem for me. I do know what you mean though..going from the Virgin with Child at Christmas to the many Marian feastdays in the Catholic Church was quite something. I made the transition by praying the Rosary. Realizing Mary's presence throughout her Son's life, particularly during the Passion, made Christ's life all the more beautiful for me. Being able to look at Him through the eyes of His Mother :o

Posted

I started to pray the rosary and it made me reflect on her complete obedience and trust and faith in God in a way that I had never considered before.......and what an amazing gift she had given us by her agreement to God's plan....

In my protestant understanding she had really only been a 'character' in the nativity scene, but actually I realised that 'reducing' her to this alone meant that I had an incomplete picture of the humanity of Jesus, I 'reduced' Him as a result. (may I be forgiven) It was astounding when I started to think that she had nursed Him and looked after Him when he was a small child.....and of course He would want us to honour her and love her......

It was very easy for me to relate to her as the Mother of the King and understand the difference about being in the position of honour but not 'higher than' He is once I had begun to realise that I had a similar example that I could see here on earth in the UK royal family - the Queen Mother was honoured and loved and respected but was not considered 'higher than' or more important than the Queen. People would go to the Q. mum and ask her advice or ask her to approach her daughter on their behalf.....

It also amazes me when protestants say that catholics worship Mary and place her first above Jesus when every time you look at anything connected to Mary she is always clearly pointing the way to Jesus, not to herself. This was really evident to me when I was at Fatima recently, the Marion shrine in Portugal - it is the Cross which leads the procession and the statue of Mary follows some way behind.

What I can tell you is that the more I know Mary, the more I come to love Jesus.

Posted

MG, we've talked about this before, so you probably know where I am with this ...

I'm still in process with learning how to love Mary well. I'd agree with Ellenita's assessment that my previous understand really limited Mary to being simply a character in the Nativity scene, almost as though she bore him and then had only limited involvement in his life after that.

As I've read and studied, I've found that I understand the Church's teachings on Mary, and agree with them. I think the Protestant characterization of a Catholic's devotion to Mary is quite faulty, and stems in part from the lack of depth in Protestant theology in this and other areas. I also this lack of understanding of Mary contributes to a lack of understanding of the humanity of Christ, as Ellenita pointed out (very astute observation, Ellenita).

As I've learned about Mary, I've developed a deeper intellectual understanding -- and that wasn't really a big hurdle to cross. The slower process has been to allow that intellectual understanding to affect my heart. Praying the rosary does help with this, as does meditating in general on Mary's faith and openness to God's gift.

And, learning about the Theology of the Body has helped me in this area as well.

One of my co-workers, a Catholic, came to Easter Vigil this year when I was received, and she gave me gift, along with a card in which she talked about what Mary has meant to her as a woman, and how great a gift she is to the women of Church (to everyone, of course, but especially to the women).

I think this is another area in which Protestant theology falls short. In order for the church to be strong, there must be well-defined roles, rooted in Scripture and Tradition, for men AND women in the church. In the Protestant churches I've been a part of, I've seen this play out in one of two ways: (1) women have no place in the church other than hospitality and child-care ministries; or (2) women have been in situation (1) and have rebelled, and are taking over as pastors/elders/etc. I think Mary serves as a powerful example, both for women and men, of how a woman should function in the life of the church.

Posted

powerful and wonderful words from both Sojourner and Ellenita.

theculturewarrior
Posted

I had a problem with venerating Mary in my armchair years. I overcame it by simply saying hail mary's. After that I knew Mary was the Mother of God. :)

Mickey's_Girl
Posted

I appreciate all of your thoughtful words. Ellenita, I think what you said about Jesus' humanity is very helpful.

Strangely, I find that "heart-wise", I have less of a problem with Mary than might be expected for someone like me. The idea of the obedient Second Eve and the inconsistent roles for women in Protestantism (Sojourner, I know *exactly* what you mean about diminished/rebellious women) make the Catholic understanding of Mary quite attractive. It's starting to *feel* right.

You all seem to have overcome this, but I guess my greatest fear is that I'm getting comfortable with something that's "wrong". I need to be convinced about Mary *intellectually*, too...I haven't done enough reading yet, but I'll be taking care of that in the months ahead.

I have this weird dual thought process happening: I do not believe that Catholics "worship" Mary--yet I feel *idolatrous* even thinking about her in the way that Catholics do. The idea of asking her for a favor is at once emotionally sustaining and yet totally frightening: AM I DOING SOMETHING WRONG?

Have any of you felt that way?

I'm not yet ready to pray the Rosary. Like going to Mass on a regular basis, that's just too "Catholic" a thing to do before I've really made the plunge. Because Catholicism is an all-or-nothing deal (given the truth claims made by the Church), I want to be fairly certain of the history and theology before I get more emotionally attached. I don't want to make an uninformed decision, or one based solely on emotion.

Thank you for your patience and compassion. I would appreciate your prayers. :-)

MG

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Mickey's_Girl' date='May 21 2004, 07:56 PM']
Have any of you felt that way?
[/quote]
YES!!!

Posted

Mickey's_Girl, I think it's perfectly normal to go through what you're experiencing, that 'duel thought process', especially if you've spent some time within some protestant denominations which deny Mary or make claims about how catholics 'worship' her. (I'm not suggesting that you have - I don't know your background!)

I certainly went through the 'duel thought process' in the early days when I began to think about Mary - it took me quite a while before I was able to meditate on the Assumption and the Coronation of Mary in the Glorious Mysteries for example, even though I was very comfortable about praying the rosary by then. The [i]most[/i] I was able to do at that time was to say in prayer to God, 'I believe all things are possible through You so I trust these Mysteries as I trust the other Mysteries.' I also held onto the fact that without any doubt, praying the rosary had made me reflect on Jesus and His life in a way that I had never done before and also be more disciplined in my prayer life. It occured to me that anything which was making me draw closer to Him had to be good and of course that there would be forces which didn't like that and would equally try to convince me this wasn't OK.

I've seen enormous tangible evidence of positive changes in my life as a result of praying the rosary which I completely wasn't expecting or anticipating, the most important of which for me has been without doubt an increase in my love for Jesus!

Don't feel under pressure to do anything you don't want to! It seems to me that you're doing absolutely the right thing in exploring the Truth which the church contains. By doing that, rather than just relying on an emotional response, will mean that your faith will be solid if you do decide that her claims are Truth. Remember the journey, as exciting as it is, can sometimes feel like two steps forward, one step back!

You said you have Scott Hahn's book 'Hail Holy Queen' - you will find it really helpful in seeing the biblical 'case' for the place in which the Catholic church holds Mary, I'm sure.

You're in my prayers.....

foundsheep
Posted

[quote name='Mickey's_Girl' date='May 21 2004, 06:56 PM'] I appreciate all of your thoughtful words. Ellenita, I think what you said about Jesus' humanity is very helpful.

Strangely, I find that "heart-wise", I have less of a problem with Mary than might be expected for someone like me. The idea of the obedient Second Eve and the inconsistent roles for women in Protestantism (Sojourner, I know *exactly* what you mean about diminished/rebellious women) make the Catholic understanding of Mary quite attractive. It's starting to *feel* right.

You all seem to have overcome this, but I guess my greatest fear is that I'm getting comfortable with something that's "wrong". I need to be convinced about Mary *intellectually*, too...I haven't done enough reading yet, but I'll be taking care of that in the months ahead.

I have this weird dual thought process happening: I do not believe that Catholics "worship" Mary--yet I feel *idolatrous* even thinking about her in the way that Catholics do. The idea of asking her for a favor is at once emotionally sustaining and yet totally frightening: AM I DOING SOMETHING WRONG?

Have any of you felt that way?

I'm not yet ready to pray the Rosary. Like going to Mass on a regular basis, that's just too "Catholic" a thing to do before I've really made the plunge. Because Catholicism is an all-or-nothing deal (given the truth claims made by the Church), I want to be fairly certain of the history and theology before I get more emotionally attached. I don't want to make an uninformed decision, or one based solely on emotion.

Thank you for your patience and compassion. I would appreciate your prayers. :-)

MG [/quote]
Luke chapter 1. The Hail mary Prayer is there. God would not have included it if it was not what he intended. and remember what Mary says "All shall call me Blessed".

Posted

MG,

For me, the way to my heart is almost always through my head, so I may not be of much help.

However, if you examine the claims of the church about Mary, you begin to see how they all fit with scripture, and natural law. Start with some easy ones, and leave the harder ones for later. For example, read the passages in Revalation. See how Mary is given honor by God Himself. Now, examine the honor that the Church gives her.

My advice too would be to stick with authentic Magisterial teachings for now, and approach the apparitions later. That made it much easier for me.

You also might want to look at Mark Shea's "An Evangelical Discovers Mary".

My prayers are with you. If you convert, we can start a whole Alumni club of converts! (The shock factor is worth it!)

peace...

Posted

[quote name='PedroX' date='May 22 2004, 11:24 AM'] My prayers are with you. If you convert, we can start a whole Alumni club of converts! (The shock factor is worth it!)
[/quote]
I'm all about this. I'm sure there are some other TU converts out there! He he!

  • 4 years later...
Posted

I never really had a problem with Mary. I loved the idea of having a Mother, though I felt as if I had to keep it a secret during our days as Fundamentalist Baptists. I prayed the rosary and read about the different apparitions all the time. She really intrigued me. ^_^

Posted

[quote name='Selah' post='1768039' date='Jan 31 2009, 08:59 PM']I never really had a problem with Mary. I loved the idea of having a Mother, though I felt as if I had to keep it a secret during our days as Fundamentalist Baptists. I prayed the rosary and read about the different apparitions all the time. She really intrigued me. ^_^[/quote]
It's YOU that keeps resurrecting old threads!!!
:))

Posted

I never had a real problem with the veneration of Mary (even as a Protestant), because it always seemed to me to be a logical consequence of the incarnation that she was (and is) venerable.

Posted

Mary isn't usually talked about except on Christmas.

Posted

[quote name='Hilde' post='1768677' date='Feb 1 2009, 05:21 PM']Mary isn't usually talked about except on Christmas.[/quote]

Ditto. My old church once did a four Sunday series on her though, and managed to mention Mary less than six times in about two hours worth of sermons supposedly on her...

As to the OP; to an extent I still struggle with the issues of Mary. I've prayed a Decade a day since last Lent began without fail. I've asked for her intercession, I've sat there near statues about her and thought about how none of it could have happened without her saying yes to God. Intellectually knowing all about her and that she is only venerated, not worshiped doesn't necessarily make it entirely easy.

Posted

I'm not a convert myself but I've heard that Archbishop Fulton J. Sheen's book "The World's First Love is a great book.

[url="http://www.amazon.com/Worlds-First-Love-Fulton-Sheen/dp/0898705975/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1234214345&sr=1-1"]http://www.amazon.com/Worlds-First-Love-Fu...4345&sr=1-1[/url]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...