MIKolbe Posted October 20, 2012 Posted October 20, 2012 [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1350717756' post='2495274'] I didn't realize that mentally handicapped people occupied physical space inside women's bodies. [/quote] i think they did at one time. but they didn't count then...
Anastasia13 Posted October 21, 2012 Posted October 21, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Sylvanna Imbris' timestamp='1350754576' post='2495340'] Light and Truth—yes, these are all life issues, and I agree with you that we have responsibilities towards others to help them live better lives, particularly in the cases you mentioned (being able to breathe, money for medical expenses, help overcoming addiction, a home and a job, and freedom from enslavement and abuse). However, there seems to me to be a clear difference between a candidate’s stance on abortion and their stance on these other issues. We agree on the principle—life is precious and should be protected—but the methods we use might differ. On the issues you mentioned, I doubt that many people would disagree with you [i]in principle[/i], but I’m sure that many would argue about the best [i]method [/i]of dealing with these issues, and I think that is legitimate. On the abortion issue, we have people who fundamentally disagree on the [i]principle[/i]. Disagreeing about the [i]method[/i] would be debating things like how to help women in crisis pregnancies, how to protect vulnerable women from family members/boyfriends who don’t want them to be pregnant or doctors who want to profit from their distress at being pregnant.[/QUOTE] Good explanation. I wonder if speaking of the principal of life being what is most important in those issues who help the pro-life side to seem more in accord and highlight the misguided transition of values from life first to liberty first in the leftist/pro-choice side and cause some to re-think their positions/thinking. [quote name='Sylvanna Imbris' timestamp='1350754576' post='2495340']I think neither Biden nor Ryan answered this question well. They both failed on the [i]principle[/i]. They acknowledged that an unborn child is a person, but Biden refused any protection to that person, and Ryan refused protection to that person if he/she were a result of rape or incest or if that person’s existence endangered his/her mother’s life.[/QUOTE] An 11 year old may be able to become pregnant but not have the body shape to safely carry the child to term, for the child's life or the mother's life. Ectopic pregnancies that for some reason are not caught within the first 20 weeks will all but certainly result in death of the mother and consequently the child (unless extra-uterine fetal care has improved enough to keep that kid alive which would still be next to impossible to find in places where such a situation would occur). I have heard of other circumstances but am less familiar with them. If it is a choice between almost certain death for two and saving the life of the mother, plenty of people here and elsewhere may disagree with me. I think Ryan was at least more accurate than some in office. I got an email from Feinstein or someone's office sounding like it should be hard to believe that rape or incest is a form of conception (after all, just cause a sperm meets an egg and fertalizes it does not mean conception has occurred, right? haha.) [quote name='Sylvanna Imbris' timestamp='1350754576' post='2495340']I won’t be voting for either. If I disagree with a candidate’s position in principle, I won’t vote for him/her. If there are several candidates whom I agree with in principle, I’ll chose the best one based on how much I agree with their proposed methods. Unfortunately, I’ve never had the opportunity to choose based on method, only based on principle (and sometimes not even then). [/quote] Choose the lesser of the two evils. One of the two will make it to office. Please don't let it be the greater of the two. Edited October 21, 2012 by Light and Truth
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now