Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Do Catholics Cremate?


Recommended Posts

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1350880557' post='2495832']
I'm going to be launched into space, and burned up on reentry. You will all breathe my corpse.
[/quote]


Than we will be coffin and splutterin'.

Edited by Tab'le Du'Bah-Rye
Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

[quote name='GeorgiiMichael' timestamp='1350972060' post='2496241']
Why is it disrespectful to hold onto the cremains at one's house? Many people have 1st class relics in their homes that they display on a shelf or mantle, how is that any different from holding onto the cremains of a loved one?
[/quote]


Nice one, very interesting.

GeorgiiMichael
Posted

But Nihil, 1st class relics are pieces of the body of the saint, usually a piece of bone.

Posted

[quote name='GeorgiiMichael' timestamp='1351006420' post='2496306']
But Nihil, 1st class relics are pieces of the body of the saint, usually a piece of bone.
[/quote]
Yes, but not all bodies are relics.

GeorgiiMichael
Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1351010394' post='2496332']
Yes, but not all bodies are relics.
[/quote]

That's true, to a point. But a relic is a relic if people venerate it for good reason.

I guess the point I'm trying to make here is that it isn't inherently bad to keep the ashes of a loved one on a shelf or mantle, it only becomes bad when those living stop treating the remains with respect.

Posted

[quote name='GeorgiiMichael' timestamp='1351095910' post='2496981']
That's true, to a point. But a relic is a relic if people venerate it for good reason.

I guess the point I'm trying to make here is that it isn't inherently bad to keep the ashes of a loved one on a shelf or mantle, it only becomes bad when those living stop treating the remains with respect.
[/quote]

Keeping a relic is fundamentally different from keeping a body. I do not think a comparison really holds water here.

GeorgiiMichael
Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1351097164' post='2496991']
Keeping a relic is fundamentally different from keeping a body. I do not think a comparison really holds water here.
[/quote]
Maybe I'm missing something, but I'm not seeing a "fundamental difference". I can see practical differences, especially since many people do just "set and forget" their loved ones in urns. But that's again, not a fundamental difference. I can see the children/grandchildren of a very holy person wanting to venerate the remains. And in that way, it's not different from a relic at all.

Posted

[quote name='GeorgiiMichael' timestamp='1351111502' post='2497089']
Maybe I'm missing something, but I'm not seeing a "fundamental difference". I can see practical differences, especially since many people do just "set and forget" their loved ones in urns. But that's again, not a fundamental difference. I can see the children/grandchildren of a very holy person wanting to venerate the remains. And in that way, it's not different from a relic at all.
[/quote]

I believe you are overthinking this. If a person is not canonized a saint, then their body is a body, not a relic. Bodies must be treated with respect, which, after death, means a quick and dignified burial. Relics are subject to certain extra considerations, since a saint is worthy of veneration, but since it would be inappropriate theologically and pastorally to venerate someone not canonized (or at the very least beatified), those considerations do not apply to a 'regular' dead body.

You are correct in assuming that any body could become a relic, but the simple fact that it is not means that it cannot be treated like one. And that means burial, or at the very least cremation and interment.

Mark of the Cross
Posted (edited)

[quote name='InPersonaChriste' timestamp='1350885820' post='2495868']
And I am planning on being incorruptible....
[/quote]
I'm planning on being incorrigible ! :unsure:

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1351010394' post='2496332']
Yes, but not all bodies are relics.
[/quote]
Mine is an antique!

Edited by Mark of the Cross
Mark of the Cross
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' timestamp='1350867064' post='2495780']
You put them on a shelf, and they may end up getting left behind and tossed out. When we cleaned out an apartment upstairs, a guy had left behind his parent's ashes. We took them to the police who actually have a procedure for it because it happens so often. Cop said most landlords just chuck them out.
[/quote]
My crucifix and Bible is on a shelf and is treated with the utmost of respect. I don't actually read the Bible, my monitor is much easier. The Bible is there for the same reason as the crucifix. It's a focal point and reminder of who and what I believe in. I wonder how many crucifix's and Bibles get tossed out by landlords?


[quote name='Tab'le Du'Bah-Rye' timestamp='1350979369' post='2496247']
Unsure as to whether we resurect in our old bodies or in new glorious body, whatever that means
<edit> although i have toyed with the idea of the resurection being a scintific gift to mankind from GOD where people can be resurected from there d.n.a., like on that movie 5th element. Which than leads me to ask whether there is still D.N.A in the ashes of a cremated body. I vote skyrise crypts with a prayer oasis on the lower floor with like a whole rainforrest setup, kinda like a morgue set up with shelves(or the catacombs) with flower vases attached to the draw and also computers at the oasis that tell you which floor the paticular persons body is on. And maybe even computer screens on the draws that tell you a bit about the persons life. RAZZLE DAZZLE.
[/quote]

[quote]Amen, amen I say to you, unless the grain of wheat falling into the ground die, [[url="http://drbo.org/x/d?b=drb&bk=50&ch=12&l=24#x"]John 12:24[/url]] [[url="http://drbo.org/x/d?b=lvb&bk=50&ch=12&l=24#x"]Latin[/url]] [url="http://www.drbo.org/x/d?b=drb&bk=50&ch=12&l=25#x"][25][/url] Itself remaineth alone. But if it die,[b] it bringeth forth much fruit.[/b][/quote]
Your mortal body replaced it's physical components a number of times throughout your life. The older bodies have more defects than the earlier ones. The body of the resurrection is immortal and free from all defect. It is not the[u] same physical[/u] body! It is the last and eternal body.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' timestamp='1350867064' post='2495780']
You put them on a shelf, and they may end up getting left behind and tossed out. When we cleaned out an apartment upstairs, a guy had left behind his parent's ashes. We took them to the police who actually have a procedure for it because it happens so often. Cop said most landlords just chuck them out.
[/quote]

I guess nobody remembers the "urn scene" from "Meet the Parents"...

Posted

[quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1350880557' post='2495832']
I'm going to be launched into space, and burned up on reentry. You will all breathe my corpse.
[/quote]

Thanks for giving the EPA fair warning...

Mark of the Cross
Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' timestamp='1351120943' post='2497191']
Thanks for giving the EPA fair warning...
[/quote]
A bigger disaster than Exxon Valdez. :unsure: Watch out Canacians!

Posted

That would quite possibly be enough ash to cause another ice age.

Posted

[quote name='Tab'le Du'Bah-Rye' timestamp='1350979369' post='2496247']... Which than leads me to ask whether there is still D.N.A in the ashes of a cremated body. [/quote]
no.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...