Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Would online voting ever work?

My idea was that you register to vote online. Obviously, this would be tied in with your social security number and address, etc. Upon registering, you are sent a confirmation code in the mail (the real mail, not an email). You then have 48 hrs from the time you receive the letter to vote using your unique confirmation code.

Thoughts?

Basilisa Marie
Posted

I feel like there might be issues with stealing someone's code or it not arriving...but then, Washington state does fine with sending everyone absentee ballots. They send them out a few weeks in advance, and you either drop them off at a "polling location" or you send them back in.

Posted

Oh, oh oh oh, you cannot imagine the kinds of abuse that would entail Mr. dUSt. :P

Every self-respecting hacker, every freelancer, the white hats, every hired-gun black hat, and Anonymous would have their hands in that system so fast.

In the end, the internet would elect a talking cat or something.

homeschoolmom
Posted

They should encode your polling district into your state issued picture ID. You'd go to your polling place and scan your card. The computer will print out a ballot for your home location. You vote. The computer reader reads your precinct and tallies the votes according to that precinct. If you are out of town, in the military, in a hospital, nursing home etc. you can vote wherever you happen to be (but for your home precinct). Mobile voting stations can visit the homebound. Since you can only get a ballot using your ID, you can only vote once.

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' timestamp='1352221584' post='2505167']
They should encode your polling district into your state issued picture ID. You'd go to your polling place and scan your card. The computer will print out a ballot for your home location. You vote. The computer reader reads your precinct and tallies the votes according to that precinct. If you are out of town, in the military, in a hospital, nursing home etc. you can vote wherever you happen to be (but for your home precinct). Mobile voting stations can visit the homebound. Since you can only get a ballot using your ID, you can only vote once.
[/quote]

The problem with the electronic systems is, can you secure it? Really really secure it?

Maybe I'm paranoid from reading things like [url="http://krebsonsecurity.com/"]Krebs[/url] and all, but digital systems are nothing even approaching secure.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

I like HSMom's idea...except I would rather everyone get a separate, free voter-id card. That way people don't have to pay to vote, and EVERYONE could have legal personal identification once they turned 18. :)

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1352226160' post='2505203']
I like HSMom's idea...except I would rather everyone get a separate, free voter-id card. That way people don't have to pay to vote, and EVERYONE could have legal personal identification once they turned 18. :)
[/quote]
That would be fine-- it would still be (in my mind) a government issued picture id. ;)

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Hey look! A CNN article about online voting!

[url="http://money.cnn.com/2012/11/06/technology/innovation/online-voting-election/index.html?hpt=hp_t2_6"]http://money.cnn.com/2012/11/06/technology/innovation/online-voting-election/index.html?hpt=hp_t2_6[/url]

Posted

The Only way I could see this working is if you had a webcam, and holding up identification to the camera with a live person checking it at the other end. Even then there could be some flaws

Posted

I don't think it's a good idea. Way too prone to hacking. Anyone unable to take the effort to go to the polling place in person or to take the necessary steps for an absentee ballot if they are unable to do so simply should not be voting anyway.

There's actually, IMO, a certain threshold of technology beyond which we should never cross in voting; and actually, I think we've already crossed that line with the electronic voting machines that we have now. I think that every election should have to have a paper trail--using machines for counting purposes is all well and good and could actually open us up to voting possibilities that may have been too cumbersome before (ie the preferential voting idea I just posted about in another thread), but those machines should be reading votes that were cast on physical paper ballots, and keeping those paper ballots as the physical record, the physical paper trail, that is also counted by hand afterwards to ensure that no one had messed with the software of the machines to tamper with the results. The minute we stop having a paper trail, we surrender the vote to the uncertainty of a digital reality that's much more easily manipulated.

carmenchristi
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' timestamp='1352231561' post='2505243']
I don't think it's a good idea. Way too prone to hacking. Anyone unable to take the effort to go to the polling place in person or to take the necessary steps for an absentee ballot if they are unable to do so simply should not be voting anyway.

There's actually, IMO, a certain threshold of technology beyond which we should never cross in voting; and actually, I think we've already crossed that line with the electronic voting machines that we have now. I think that every election should have to have a paper trail--using machines for counting purposes is all well and good and could actually open us up to voting possibilities that may have been too cumbersome before (ie the preferential voting idea I just posted about in another thread), but those machines should be reading votes that were cast on physical paper ballots, and keeping those paper ballots as the physical record, the physical paper trail, that is also counted by hand afterwards to ensure that no one had messed with the software of the machines to tamper with the results. The minute we stop having a paper trail, we surrender the vote to the uncertainty of a digital reality that's much more easily manipulated.
[/quote]


Couldn't agree more.

Posted

I'm with Arfink. Anonymous hits the polls:

"And the online vote is tallied. The next President of the United States of America is 'Adolph Hitler'."

(Taken from how Mountain Dew pulled a promotion for their next big flavor after 4chan piledrived on the voting to get "Hitler Did Nothing Wrong" as the number one flavor.)

Posted

[quote name='BG45' timestamp='1352325124' post='2506024']
I'm with Arfink. Anonymous hits the polls:

"And the online vote is tallied. The next President of the United States of America is 'Adolph Hitler'."

(Taken from how Mountain Dew pulled a promotion for their next big flavor after 4chan piledrived on the voting to get "Hitler Did Nothing Wrong" as the number one flavor.)
[/quote]
His VP would be Carl Sagan, probably.

Posted

Or Neil Tyson deGrasse. :|

Are we sure it wouldn't be Keyboard Cat, as was suggested before?

Posted

[quote name='BG45' timestamp='1352326123' post='2506050']
Or Neil Tyson deGrasse. :|

Are we sure it wouldn't be Keyboard Cat, as was suggested before?
[/quote]
No, but they would mod the system such that every time you press a button, Keyboard Cat appears on the screen.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...