Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Really? No threads on the latest installment of Israel's ongoing series "How To Piss Off Arabs and Kill Palestinians?"

Roamin Catholic
Posted (edited)

Right, and Hamas is completely innocent in this.

Edited by Roamin_Catholic
Posted

sorry, haven't been following the news lately so I don't know what's going on.

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' timestamp='1353085549' post='2511297']
sorry, haven't been following the news lately so I don't know what's going on.
[/quote]Quick synopsis.
Israel exists after being created by outside nations and there is conflict with how Palistinians are treated.
Hamas has gained political power in the PLA (Palistinian Authority) in the mid 2000's.
As you probably know, Hamas denies the right of Israel to exist and has been involved in terroist/military attacks agains Israel and that complicates any settlement between Israel and Palistinians.

Fast foward to this month:
Israel bombed a military leader of Hamas.
Hamas started shooting rockets into Isreal.
Israel has started shooting/bombing back.
Egypt(Russia) is getting interested.
Syria(Iran) is getting interested.

Expect WAR before 2013.

PhuturePriest
Posted

[quote name='Anomaly' timestamp='1353086321' post='2511309']
Quick synopsis.
Israel exists after being created by outside nations and there is conflict with how Palistinians are treated.
Hamas has gained political power in the PLA (Palistinian Authority) in the mid 2000's.
As you probably know, Hamas denies the right of Israel to exist and has been involved in terroist/military attacks agains Israel and that complicates any settlement between Israel and Palistinians.

Fast foward to this month:
Israel bombed a military leader of Hamas.
Hamas started shooting rockets into Isreal.
Israel has started shooting/bombing back.
Egypt(Russia) is getting interested.
Syria(Iran) is getting interested.

Expect WAR before 2013.
[/quote]

What do you mean "expect war"? War is already going on. I assure you Obama's phone hand is twitching to make the call and send the troops there.

Posted

[quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1353086428' post='2511313']

What do you mean "expect war"? War is already going on. I assure you Obama's phone hand is twitching to make the call and send the troops there.
[/quote]I'm sure the only Obama "twitching" is his smirk because this didn't happen before Nov. 6th. It's an escalation of an on going conflict now, it'll be WAR when troops and tanks start crossing borders and other countries start taking sides. There is little political gain for American politicians if war in Israel starts because it's going to likely lead to a confronttion with Iran/[i]Russia[/i] and dealing with Iran seeking nuke capability and more Arabs/Muslims getting even more butt hurt.

PhuturePriest
Posted

[quote name='Anomaly' timestamp='1353087132' post='2511322']
I'm sure the only Obama "twitching" is his smirk because this didn't happen before Nov. 6th. It's an escalation of an on going conflict now, it'll be WAR when troops and tanks start crossing borders and other countries start taking sides. There is little political gain for American politicians if war in Israel starts because it's going to likely lead to a confronttion with Iran/[i]Russia[/i] and dealing with Iran seeking nuke capability and more Arabs/Muslims getting even more butt hurt.
[/quote]

I don't really see this ending well with the whole Russia thing. They hate us enough already. One little thing could set them off.

Posted

I thought that Israel took out the Hamas leader in response to an increase in rockets from Gaza.

Posted

[quote name='Adrestia' timestamp='1353090465' post='2511357']
I thought that Israel took out the Hamas leader in response to an increase in rockets from Gaza.
[/quote]Not exactly. The motivation for assisnating Jabari seems to include retalition for recent attacks, response to increased military capabilities of hamas, political purposes, and retribution for Jabari's involvement in past terrorist attacks and kidnappings. The following is from Saudi Arabia's "Arab News"

[color=#0000cd]Israel’s intelligence agency Shin Bet said Jabari was responsible for Hamas’ takeover of the Gaza Strip in 2007, when the group ousted fighters of the Fatah movement of its great rival, the Western-backed Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas.[/color]
[color=#0000cd]It said Jabari instigated the attack that led to the capture of Israeli corporal Gilad Shalit in a kidnap raid from Gaza in 2006. Jabari was also the man who handed Shalit over to Israel in a prisoner exchange five years after his capture.[/color]
[color=#0000cd]Israel holds a general election on Jan. 22 and conservative Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has come under pressure to respond firmly against Hamas, with residents of southern Israel complaining bitterly about repeated missile strikes[/color]
[color=#0000cd]Some 1,400 Palestinians and 13 Israelis died in the 2008-2009 conflict. There was a lull in hostilities after that, but the violence has flared again in recent months and Israel has repeatedly warned of dire consequences unless Hamas and its fellow fighters stopped rocket attacks.[/color]
[color=#0000cd]In the latest confrontation, which appeared to have ended on Tuesday, more than 115 missiles were fired into southern Israel from Gaza and Israeli planes launched numerous strikes. Seven Palestinians, three of them gunmen, were killed. Eight Israeli civilians were hurt by rocket fire and four soldiers wounded by an anti-tank missile.[/color]
[color=#0000cd]Helped by Iran and the flourishing contraband trade through tunnels from Egypt, Gaza militias have smuggled in better weapons since the war of 2008-09, including longer-range Grad rockets and anti-tank missiles of the type they fired last week at an IDF patrol vehicle.[/color]

Posted

[quote name='Anomaly' timestamp='1353086321' post='2511309']
Quick synopsis.
Israel exists after being created by outside nations and there is conflict with how Palistinians are treated.
Hamas has gained political power in the PLA (Palistinian Authority) in the mid 2000's.
As you probably know, Hamas denies the right of Israel to exist and has been involved in terroist/military attacks agains Israel and that complicates any settlement between Israel and Palistinians.

Fast foward to this month:
Israel bombed a military leader of Hamas.
Hamas started shooting rockets into Isreal.
Israel has started shooting/bombing back.
Egypt(Russia) is getting interested.
Syria(Iran) is getting interested.

Expect WAR before 2013.
[/quote]

hmmm. i don't know what to think about all this.

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' timestamp='1353094252' post='2511394']

hmmm. i don't know what to think about all this.
[/quote]Yeah, you and millions of others.

It's hard to imagine how a win-win scenario could come about or even exist. Other countries (mostly Britan who occupied the area) forced the creation of Israel after the Holocaust because they'd been persecuted AND it was a convenient way to get Jews out of their countries. Palistinians were screwed and maltreated by these other Countries and now have to deal with Jews who they consider as occupiers. The Israelis have often crossed the line in their treatment of Palistinians because of often justified fear, as well as purely selfish reasons. There is plenty of blame for inflicting intentional harm for all parties and we now have this never ending fued constantly fueled by retaltiation and aggression by Israelis, Palistinians, Arabs, and their allies who have their own alliances with these factions.

In addition to the realities of political and sociological conflicts, throw in the theological conflicts of Islam and the Jewish faiths. They'll be killing each other until one side is obliterated and forgotten by their allies.

Posted

I have a friend who lives outside Tel Aviv who spent the night in the basement of his apartment building. Sounded a bit like the London Blitz.

Posted

It's going to be a short war since it all ends on Dec 21 anyway.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I've been following it.

But at the same time, I don't know if you guys remember that old "doodie" website -- crowded in the toilet humor corner of the internet...one of the animations just had an Israeli and a Palestinian crapping back and forth on an area of land, and it was a looping animation that had no end.

So... yeah. I can't help but think of that when I read the news.

Posted

This is the first war in Israel since I became a Catholic, and I have to say: I'm kinda' shocked there's been no word on it from the Church (aside from the Jerusalem patriarch). Am I just missing the talk, or has the Church really said nothing? I don't expect that the Church will have something to say about absolutely every event I care about, just because I care about it, but war in the Holy Land...? You'd really think she'd have something to say.

Can anyone explain this to me?

Posted

[quote name='Adrestia' timestamp='1353090465' post='2511357']
I thought that Israel took out the Hamas leader in response to an increase in rockets from Gaza.
[/quote]

Yes, precisely. If you want to watch the rocket counts rise, see here: http://www.idfblog.com/2012/11/15/idf-disperses-leaflets-above-gaza-strip/

Posted

[quote name='curiousing' timestamp='1353129865' post='2511673']
This is the first war in Israel since I became a Catholic, and I have to say: I'm kinda' shocked there's been no word on it from the Church (aside from the Jerusalem patriarch). Am I just missing the talk, or has the Church really said nothing? I don't expect that the Church will have something to say about absolutely every event I care about, just because I care about it, but war in the Holy Land...? You'd really think she'd have something to say.

Can anyone explain this to me?
[/quote]
The Melkite patriarch, Gregory III Laham, supports Palestinian statehood.

[url="http://ncronline.org/blogs/ncr-today/statehood-palestine-now-patriarch-tells-pope"]http://ncronline.org/blogs/ncr-today/statehood-palestine-now-patriarch-tells-pope[/url]

[size=4]
[size=4]
[b]BEIRUT[/b] -- One of Lebanon’s most senior Christian leaders tonight told Pope Benedict XVI that recognition of Palestinian statehood would be “the most precious good the Arab world can obtain” for both Christians and Muslims, but stopped short of directly calling on the Vatican to extend that recognition unilaterally.

Patriarch Gregorios III Laham spoke tonight while welcoming Benedict to the Greek Melkite Basilica of St. Paul, where the pope was to formally sign the concluding document from a 2010 Synod of Bishops on the Middle East.[/size] [size=4]
An advance text of Laham’s welcome was briefly placed on the official Lebanese web site for the papal visit two weeks ago, then quickly taken down. In it, Laham called on the pope to recognize Palestine, ahead of an expected push for Palestinian statehood at the United Nations General Assembly later this month.[/size] [size=4]
Tonight, Laham didn’t go quite that far, but he made his support for the Palestinian cause abundantly clear.[/size] [size=4]
“[b]The recognition of a Palestinian state is the most precious good that the Arab world can obtain in all its confessions, Christian and Muslim[/b],” Laham said.[/size] [size=4]
“It can guarantee the realization of the orientations expressed in the post-synodal exhortation,” referring to the pope’s document, “for which we express our most lively gratitude.”[/size] [size=4]
Statehood for Palestine, Laham said, “would prepare the way for a true Arab Spring, true democracy, and a real revolution capable of changing the face of the Arab world and of bringing peace to the Holy Land, the Middle East, and the world.”[/size] [size=4]
In general, [b]Christian leaders in the Middle East tend to be sympathetic to the Palestinian cause[/b], in part because many of them are Arabs themselves, and in part because they believe Christians in Israel and Palestine suffer the same injustices as Arab Muslims.[/size] [size=4]
Though never officially confirmed, it was widely believed that Laham's original text, asking the pope to recognize Palestine himself, was taken down because it could embarrass Benedict during his three-day stop in the Middle East. [b]Officially, the Vatican's line on the Israeli/Palestinian conflict favors a negotiated two-state solution without unilateral gestures on either side.[/b][/size]
[/size]
[size=4]
[list]

[/list][/size]

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1353131242' post='2511690'][size=4][size=4] [b]Officially, the Vatican's line on the Israeli/Palestinian conflict favors a negotiated two-state solution without unilateral gestures on either side.[/b][/size] [/size]
[/quote]
I stand with Israel and Rome on this one.

Ideally, the deal would be stacked in Israel's favor. It's not as though there aren't other Arab states in the area...

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Anomaly' timestamp='1353086321' post='2511309']
Fast foward to this month:
Israel bombed a military leader of Hamas.
Hamas started shooting rockets into Isreal.
Israel has started shooting/bombing back.
Egypt(Russia) is getting interested.
Syria(Iran) is getting interested.
[/quote]

Correction:

Hamas has been shooting rockets into Israel for 12 years. In 2012 alone, they've fired almost 1,200 rockets into Israel. On Wednesday, Israel carried out a targeted assassination of Ahmed Jabari, the head of Hamas' military wing. Since then, over 400 rockets have been fired into Israel from Gaza. The most recent ones were made in Iran. Israel has been launching a full-on attack in Gaza since then, targeting the rocket-launch sites.

It's not just Hamas firing rockets. There are by now so many terrorist organizations inside Gaza that it's hard to tell who's firing what, and Hamas hardly has control over the region. But I guarantee you the IDF knows which groups are firing from where. And they've dropped leaflets over Gaza and sent text messages to all residents telling them to stay away from Hamas operatives (whom they are bombing), so they clearly believe that Hamas holds the majority of the responsibility in the recent ramping up of rocket fire.

Also on Wednesday, rockets from Syria entered the Golan Heights for the first time since 1967. Israel fired warning shots back, but it was then determined that the rockets were not intended to target Israel, but merely strays from the internal conflict in Syria. I'm sure the IDF is watching Syria, but it's not presently considered a threat.

Egypt is now run by militant Islamists. The rhetoric of the Egyptian PM, Hesham Kandil, has been very aggressive and threatening toward Israel in the last few days. It's along the lines of, "Since the Arab Spring, Egypt is no longer the same country. Israel can no longer expect us to sit back and take this." Egypt is being watched. The IDF declared a brief ceasefire on Gaza when Kandil visited there this week. Kandil used the visit to threaten Israel. He has already withdrawn the Egyptian ambassador to Israel.

In brief: Things are not looking good. Please pray for peace and safety for all.

Edited by curiousing
dominicansoul
Posted

I watched the documentary [i]Promises[/i] when it first came out. Jews and Arabs have a long history of violence against one another. One group attacks the other and the other retaliates and vice versa. The documentary film maker introduces you to seven children, some arab, some jewish. He follows each child, filming them for three years. He talks to the arabs about the jews and the jews about the arabs. At the end, he introduces them to each other. The documentary shows that this cycle of violence could be broken if the Israeli and Palestinian children were not indoctrinated into the hatred.


Prayers for both peoples, and an end to the hatred and violence...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...