Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

I Need Advice - Urgently


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='AnneLine' timestamp='1353384716' post='2513448']
I really like the idea of being just plain honesy with the Bro Bonaventure about what happened when you were at the seminary, and how you just are filling a little unsure right now. I also think you did a 180 degree turn pretty quickly -- this would give you a chance to add a little more real info into your discernment process.

PROCESS -- it takes time, like a 'procession'.

[b]Discernment isn't a one time decision -- we aren't angels, we don't make our decisions as yes/no and live with it forever. Humans have to look at all sides, weigh options and make moves one step at a time. [/b] If your parents & director & Bro. Bonaventure agree, I'd let the benefactor help you with your discernment by going to visit them..... but let's put this in the Hand of the Holy Spirit and take it one step at a time.

Will be praying for you!!!!!
[/quote]

This. OH SO MUCH THIS!

PhuturePriest
Posted

[quote name='AnneLine' timestamp='1353384716' post='2513448']
I really like the idea of being just plain honesy with the Bro Bonaventure about what happened when you were at the seminary, and how you just are filling a little unsure right now. I also think you did a 180 degree turn pretty quickly -- this would give you a chance to add a little more real info into your discernment process.

PROCESS -- it takes time, like a 'procession'.

Discernment isn't a one time decision -- we aren't angels, we don't make our decisions as yes/no and live with it forever. Humans have to look at all sides, weigh options and make moves one step at a time. If your parents & director & Bro. Bonaventure agree, I'd let the benefactor help you with your discernment by going to visit them..... but let's put this in the Hand of the Holy Spirit and take it one step at a time.

Will be praying for you!!!!!
[/quote]

I actually did kind of tell him. I told him that I went to the seminary and discerned out of diocesan Priesthood, but the religious life was still a possibility, and I mentioned that I was having a hard time discerning between it and the married life. I think that since everyone believes I should, I will go. I'm making the call tomorrow.

Posted (edited)

So far as I understood, you discerned NOT being called to the priesthood. Did you (affirmatively) discern being called to marriage, or just assume that as the default in the absence of a priestly vocation? If you didn't affirmatively discern marriage, then go. Even if only to rule it all out so you can be sure marriage is where you're called.

As I see it, this event is itself a big discernment wake-up call. It could have three sources: God (likely), the devil (likely, though possibly less, given that it came through a brother), and chance (which I personally think is a load of croutons). So, if I were you, I'd take all these other good people's advice (talk to the community, talk to your parents, etc.), but focus on discerning (quickly, of course) who you think the source of this opportunity is.

Not to sway you one way or the other, but...: I have heard it said by several sisters that God never puts on the pressure. He doesn't rush. My spiritual advisor likes to say (A LOT): "God is never late. But he's never early, either."

Best of luck to you, man.

Edited by curiousing
PhuturePriest
Posted

[quote name='nunsense' timestamp='1353384273' post='2513441']
Have you discussed all of your recent interior changes (and decisions) with your SD or even with the community you were discerning with? Perhaps they could help you to make this decision. You changed your mind kind of suddenly and it could change again just as suddenly because (believe it or not) that is what happens when one is young (and sometimes when one is old too! :) ). Seriously, ask those who are supposed to be giving you advice - your SD or your vocations director.

PS - and of course your parents!
[/quote]

I wish I had the time to tell him everything, but it looks like I will not have the opportunity. I am going to see him this Sunday, I think, but it will not be for a meeting, it will be us helping him move some organs.

Ha. Yes, telling my parents [i]may [/i]be important. I don't think my mother will take it well, but we will see how it goes. My dad will not like the idea of a benefactor, but I can tell him he can pay half or something. That may work.

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

I understand you sudden change in vocational feelings, I am a sudden change personality as well. Sometimes it takes only one small thing to make a inner working we were not quite aware of click. With that said, based on what you shared in other threads I am not convinced you are not called to Religious Life, just not Conception. I would talk with you parents in the morning, call your SD and then call Br and see what they have to say, it may indeed not be the vocation nor you but as long as you are approaching the situation honestly and seeking God then the benefactor's money will not be waisted. Most benefactors I have met understand that not every dollar will go to a future Br, Sr, or Fr, but that every dollar is still used in the work of God.

Posted

And I just want to say: Man, are you blessed to have a benefactor! What I wouldn't give...!!!

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

[quote name='PadrePioOfPietrelcino' timestamp='1353389249' post='2513478']
I understand you sudden change in vocational feelings, I am a sudden change personality as well. Sometimes it takes only one small thing to make a inner working we were not quite aware of click. With that said, based on what you shared in other threads I am not convinced you are not called to Religious Life, just not Conception. I would talk with you parents in the morning, call your SD and then call Br and see what they have to say, it may indeed not be the vocation nor you but as long as you are approaching the situation honestly and seeking God then the benefactor's money will not be waisted. Most benefactors I have met understand that not every dollar will go to a future Br, Sr, or Fr, but that every dollar is still used in the work of God.
[/quote]

I am definitely a sudden change personality. But I know what happened in front of the tabernacle at Conception was not just my annoying personality acting up again.

So you object because you believe I am called to religious life? Well, I discerned out of diocesan Priesthood (Or Conception, at the very least. It was nice and I loved it, but the mere thought of ever going back is nauseating for some reason), but the religious life is still up for grabs. I think I'll go, if my spiritual director and Brother Bonaventure (And talk to my parents about it, if you all feel this is an important detail. :P ) think I should, and I will see what everyone has to say.

But can you tell me why you think I am called to religious life?

And I don't technically have a benefactor. The Franciscan Brothers Minor just have benefactors that give money for vocations.

Edited by FuturePriest387
Posted

Just be careful about 'mixing discernments'. :P It is really not appropriate, and not fair to anyone involved, if you try to actively discern religious life simultaneously with discerning marriage. At the very least, if you are actively discerning religious life you should not be getting involved with any girls. Even Hermione.

PhuturePriest
Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1353389997' post='2513487']
Just be careful about 'mixing discernments'. :P It is really not appropriate, and not fair to anyone involved, if you try to actively discern religious life simultaneously with discerning marriage. At the very least, if you are actively discerning religious life you should not be getting involved with any girls. Even Hermione.
[/quote]

As I said before, I am not getting involved in dating until I am of college age anyway.

This whole situation has me thinking so hard about religious life. It's suddenly appealing again. Why do all things have to appeal to me... <_<

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

[quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1353389757' post='2513485']

But can you tell me why you think I am called to religious life?

[/quote]

It's not that I think you have a religious vocation, I just plain lack a lot of information ( and charism of a Bishop) to make that kind of call. However I know that Diocesan vs Religious life was a debate you were working with, you went to one Seminary and was able to find an answer for you there, and I find it providential that shortly after you are invited to visit the Brs. Perhaps God is trying to give you an opportunity to find even more clarity for your life.

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted (edited)

Grr double post. But props for getting a two for one on the post count :)

Edited by PadrePioOfPietrelcino
PhuturePriest
Posted

[quote name='PadrePioOfPietrelcino' timestamp='1353390316' post='2513492']
It's not that I think you have a religious vocation, I just plain lack a lot of information ( and charism of a Bishop) to make that kind of call. However I know that Diocesan vs Religious life was a debate you were working with, you went to one Seminary and was able to find an answer for you there, and I find it providential that shortly after you are invited to visit the Brs. Perhaps God is trying to give you an opportunity to find even more clarity for your life.
[/quote]

I see. Well, I think it would be beneficial to go. I just want to make sure I'm not wasting anyone's time or money. If they don't think I am doing either of these things, then I cannot see a good reason not to go. The timing is a little perfect, so God is either trying to pull me in this direction or let me know with absolute certainty that I am called to marriage.

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

[quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1353391474' post='2513508']


I see. Well, I think it would be beneficial to go. I just want to make sure I'm not wasting anyone's time or money. If they don't think I am doing either of these things, then I cannot see a good reason not to go. The timing is a little perfect, so God is either trying to pull me in this direction or let me know with absolute certainty that I am called to marriage.
[/quote]

Or the generous single life, don't forget that as men we have 5 different vocations to figure between women have three. Discernment is soo easy peesie for them.

PhuturePriest
Posted

[quote name='PadrePioOfPietrelcino' timestamp='1353391862' post='2513511']
Or the generous single life, don't forget that as men we have 5 different vocations to figure between women have three. Discernment is soo easy peesie for them.
[/quote]

Of course. I was actually thinking about that. And it is of course very unfair that women get such an easy ride. With us you have to discern the priesthood, priesthood + Religious life, religious life, deacon, married life, OR the single life. They get to take deacon and priest right out of the equation!

DiscerningCatholic
Posted

Go.

Go.

Go.

Posted

For what it's worth, speaking from experience, marriage is dumb.

PhuturePriest
Posted

[quote name='dUSt' timestamp='1353393701' post='2513527']
For what it's worth, speaking from experience, marriage is dumb.
[/quote]

Well that just settles everything.

Posted

FP, just think about it, what are the chances someone is going to pay for a plane ticket again? These are rare opportunities, you have to take them with both hands. You're absolutely not sure about your vocation at this moment, so keep checking your options when possible. If religious life is still an option, this is a major chance to check it out. If God wants you somewhere, He'll get you there. Maybe He wants you to discover the religious life. Or He wants you to check it out so you can decide it's not the life for you. Either way, you're given the chance to have a nice week with the Brothers, take it and enjoy it!

It happened to me too. The motherhouse of my congregation is just too far from where I live, and it's a little bit too expensive to get there on my own. But one of their priests wanted to go back for a few days, and gave me the opportunity to go with him. Two months ago exact the same thing. They had ordinations and he wanted some company in the car. I'm just happy I visited, it was very nice every time, even without thinking about a vocation (but in my case I was thinking about it, and these visits only made me want to go back as soon as possible).

Posted

[quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1353390160' post='2513488']
This whole situation has me thinking so hard about religious life. It's suddenly appealing again. Why do all things have to appeal to me... <_<
[/quote]

;) In the brief times I have seen your posts on Phatmass, this is what I have gathered. You're a teenager, no? Teenagers tend to be guided by, well, feelings. God [i]does[/i] use our feelings and desires to guide us to where He wants us, but that requires some maturity in discernment, and this is (in my opinion) different. You seem to be in the middle of the typical wavering between, "Wow being a priest would be cool," to "Wow, marriage would be cool." I know it, I experienced it a whole lot myself when I was in high school. Taking time to go on a discernment retreat would be beneficial, if only to help give you maturity in discernment. It will help make your vocational path that much clearer. (Note that I'm not saying you're not mature or that you haven't discerned well, just that this would be a good way to help you discern. I don't think that's wasting time or money. You might come out of it [i]really really[/i] liking it. Or you might decide it's not for you. Either way, you're getting closer to figuring out exactly what God wants from you, and that's always a good thing. If you were in the middle of dating, I'd say no. But as it is, I say go.

So yeah. Go.

Posted

[quote name='MIkolbe' timestamp='1353379770' post='2513380']
Go
[/quote]
[quote name='FuturePriest387' timestamp='1353380457' post='2513396']
Well, I want to go. [/quote]

good, then go.

The rest of this is smoke filled, palor house junk.

you want to know what to do?

someone invites you..

you want to go.

then go.

'oh but my reasoning may not be right or perfect or whatever!!"

to which I respond, you're 16. you are not going to have it figured out.

stop hemming and hawing and go. if it ain't meant to be, then it ain't meant to be. stop trying to out-think God.

He calls. You listen.

it's only as simple or as hard as you make it.

and quite frankly... your constant threads about who you have a crush on, and who you're dating...or emily.. or pictures at a wedding... these all seem to reek of someone trying to convince themselves of something...

so when there is talk of 'oh golly gee, i really am unsure of my reasonings for going on this trip' it just reaffirms you're trying to convince yourself of something.....but i guess just my take, little man.

to put this in terms you seem to want to believe....what if this event will cement and affirm that you are [b]not[/b] meant to be a priest? Maybe He is trying to tell you to come a little closer, cause He's gotta talk louder and directly in your ear that this ISN'T meant for you.

The fact is, you don't know. So go and maybe you'll find out..

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...