Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Question About Gay Marriage


Recommended Posts

theculturewarrior
Posted

Okay, but let's do it at the Debate Table, because I still see the world through Catholic eyes.

theculturewarrior
Posted

I should elaborate by saying that I do not believe that this is the root of the stigma.  As a disabled American I have experienced my fair share of stigma.  It is because I am different, not because of my sins.

Posted

I should elaborate by saying that I do not believe that this is the root of the stigma. As a disabled American I have experienced my fair share of stigma. It is because I am different, not because of my sins.


What does that have to do with the root of stigma towards gay people?
Posted

Gary Johnson ....came so close to voting for him as I agree with virtually everything else but his weird seeming support for gay marriage on a federal level? :blink:

I think he was just trying to get the message across to Liberals that, even though Libertarians are fiscally conservative, they are in fact socially "liberal". I sincerely hope he wouldn't make any new legislation regarding marriage at the federal level! Just nix it...

Posted

Libertarians had a respectable reputation.  No need to sully it y associating the term with a bunch of politician hacks who want us to believe that the gold standard is at the heart of the struggle for human freedom.  

 

 

You all are republicans.  Just embrace it.  

 

Not all Libertarians rant so much about the gold standard as Ron Paul, who, technically, IS a Republican. I do think, however, that the gold standard IS central to human freedom, in the sense that financial stability and solvency are central to human freedom.

 

I am most definitively not a Republican. But that doesn't mean I wouldn't vote for one, just like I occasionally vote for a Democrat. My principles, however, are staunchly Libertarian. As far as I see it, there's not much difference between Republicans and Democrats. They're both in the pocket of big business, not the people they're supposed to represent.

Posted (edited)

Not all Libertarians rant so much about the gold standard as Ron Paul, who, technically, IS a Republican. I do think, however, that the gold standard IS central to human freedom, in the sense that financial stability and solvency are central to human freedom.

 

I am most definitively not a Republican. But that doesn't mean I wouldn't vote for one, just like I occasionally vote for a Democrat. My principles, however, are staunchly Libertarian. As far as I see it, there's not much difference between Republicans and Democrats. They're both in the pocket of big business, not the people they're supposed to represent.

 

Unlike libertarians, who are not funded by the corporate class.  The Koch brothers don't even exist.  

http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=Reason_Foundation

 

The idea that the gold standard is central to human freedom is astounding.  The gold standard is a scam to benefit the hyper-wealthy and to get people to buy bullpoopy 'gold investment kits.'  

 

It's a nearly useless metal and fixing our currency to it makes no sense at all.  Unless you're a plutocrat.  In which case supporting the gold standard makes a lot of sense since you can benefit from it immensely   

Edited by Hasan
theculturewarrior
Posted (edited)

What does that have to do with the root of stigma towards gay people?

 

 

Morality is just a pretext to discriminate.  It is putting a pretty face on the sociopathic demand for conformity.  Married heterosexuals commit all kinds of heterosexual sins.  But if they're not disabled, they don't stand out in a crowd the way we do.

Edited by theculturewarrior
Posted

Morality is just a pretext to discriminate.  It is putting a pretty face on the sociopathic demand for conformity.  Married heterosexuals commit all kinds of heterosexual sins.  But if they're not disabled, they don't stand out in a crowd the way we do.

 

 

I still don't see where your argument makes sense.  The discrimination that the disabled face isn't just because they are different.  There are all sorts of differences that aren't stigmatized.  

theculturewarrior
Posted (edited)

I still don't see where your argument makes sense.  The discrimination that the disabled face isn't just because they are different.  There are all sorts of differences that aren't stigmatized.  

 

It is more of an observation than an argument.  All men struggle with sexual sin and most women too, sooner or later, to some extent.  If forcing a homosexual to have lobotomy or to undergo aversive shock therapy is considered moral, what about having a mistress?  At that time in American history it was considered prestigious to have a mistress in many circles.  There are cultures in the world where having a mistress is socially acceptable and being a homosexual can get you killed whether you play by the Church's rules or not.  This happens in many predominately Catholic countries.  That famous bible quote, that homosexuality is an abomination to the Lord, that same chapter prescribed death by stoning as the punishment for adultery.  Morality is not the issue, it is just an excuse to rid the world of people who think differently.  It is hypocrisy insofar as the stigma is concerned.

Edited by theculturewarrior
Posted

It is more of an observation than an argument.  All men struggle with sexual sin and most women too, sooner or later, to some extent.  If forcing a homosexual to have lobotomy or to undergo aversive shock therapy is considered moral, what about having a mistress?  At that time in American history it was considered prestigious to have a mistress in many circles.  There are cultures in the world where having a mistress is socially acceptable and being a homosexual can get you killed whether you play by the Church's rules or not.  This happens in many predominately Catholic countries.  That famous bible quote, that homosexuality is an abomination to the Lord, that same chapter prescribed death by stoning as the punishment for adultery.  Morality is not the issue, it is just an excuse to rid the world of people who think differently.  It is hypocrisy insofar as the stigma is concerned.

 

 

 

Right.  Most people are straight so they excuse heterosexual sin.  That says nothing about the dominate religious institutions in the west denouncing homosexuality as 'objectively disordered' not being a major cause of stigmatizing homosexuality.  

theculturewarrior
Posted

Right.  Most people are straight so they excuse heterosexual sin.  That says nothing about the dominate religious institutions in the west denouncing homosexuality as 'objectively disordered' not being a major cause of stigmatizing homosexuality.  

 

The Catholic Church considers masturbation objectively disordered and gravely sinful.  It is the norm among prehensile animals.

Posted

The Catholic Church considers masturbation objectively disordered and gravely sinful.  It is the norm among prehensile animals.

 

So?

theculturewarrior
Posted

So?

 

So if the status quo, heteosexuals, identify homosexuality as the immorality that is plaguing society, when the overwhelming majority of heterosexual men and most heterosexual women do or have commited objectively disordered sins throughout the course of their lives, then the moral indignation is just hypocrisy.  Morality is just a pretext to exclude and discriminate.

Posted

So if the status quo, heteosexuals, identify homosexuality as the immorality that is plaguing society, when the overwhelming majority of heterosexual men and most heterosexual women do or have commited objectively disordered sins throughout the course of their lives, then the moral indignation is just hypocrisy.  Morality is just a pretext to exclude and discriminate.

 

 

 

The fact that it is hypocritical doesn't change the fact that the moral claims surrounding homosexuality are the cause of the stigma.  People excuse their own sins.  But where does that idea that homosexuality is a sin or wrong or unnatural come from?  Is it just religion?  No.  But if your denying that Christianity hasn't been a major force in shaping the negative view of homosexuality in the west then I don't think you have a serious position.  

theculturewarrior
Posted

The fact that it is hypocritical doesn't change the fact that the moral claims surrounding homosexuality are the cause of the stigma.  People excuse their own sins.  But where does that idea that homosexuality is a sin or wrong or unnatural come from?  Is it just religion?  No.  But if your denying that Christianity hasn't been a major force in shaping the negative view of homosexuality in the west then I don't think you have a serious position.  

 

I don't deny that Christianity has had a very sick role in this.  Christianity has been used as a pretext to do some very terrible things throughout the past two thousand years.  I disagree that it is a fundamentally doctrinal issue, and I think I have given a serious argument for that.  I really don't see how I have been illogical at all.  And as a disabled American, this is probably as important to me as it is to you.

Posted

I don't deny that Christianity has had a very sick role in this.  Christianity has been used as a pretext to do some very terrible things throughout the past two thousand years.  I disagree that it is a fundamentally doctrinal issue, and I think I have given a serious argument for that.  I really don't see how I have been illogical at all.  And as a disabled American, this is probably as important to me as it is to you.

 

I don't understand what your argument is beyond that disabled people are also viewed with contempt in some situations and contexts.  

theculturewarrior
Posted

I don't understand what your argument is beyond that disabled people are also viewed with contempt in some situations and contexts.  

 

You are much too intelligent to actually mean that.

Posted

I'll throw my 2 cents in the ring.

 

As Catholics we need to be on the bandwagon 100 percent with the Church's teachings, otherwise we'll just have more people like dear old Hasan here telling us off for being hypocrites, and rightly so. However we also cannot simply refuse to aid the sinful, simply because we ourselves also sin.

 

I have seen priests and lay people respond with the utmost charity and care for people with homosexual inclinations or any other kind of sinful inclination. This charity, as I have sen it, isn't the cruel condemnation to failure and rejection that so many in the past have experienced from the Church. I know many in the Church have done and said horrible things to sinners, especially those who struggle with sexual sins. But it doesn't need to be so.

 

Sadly, America is a land still rich in the old Puritanical tradition of condemnation. The solution proposed by Hasan and those like him, of simply following a laissez-faire notion of sexuality, is attractive because it seems to remove all possibility of condemnation. I believe that such a solution would not only do a great disservice to all human beings by encouraging degrading and destructive behavior, but it would also likely fail to eliminate sexually-based condemnation. In a world with no sexual morality there will still be norms, fashions, and herd-preferences, and where those exist there will still be condemnation.

 

I think it's a mistake to assume that condemnation of people with same-sex attraction is necessarily tied to our beliefs about what sex is for.

Posted

Please do not debate.

 

Request denied. Even though I didn't read the OP and probably wouldn't debate, anyway because lazy.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...