Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted
 Pre-conception abortion is the spilling of ones seed with the intention of not procreating, ie; condoms, masturbation and act of lust(sex) that is not in communion with God with the intent to procreate.

As I said, it is not correct to call this abortion because a human being does not yet exist in any sense of the word.

Posted (edited)

As to the rest of what you are saying...... I honestly do not know what you are trying to tell me. I objected to a couple very specific mistakes you made. I do not need a theology of the body lesson.

 

 

Is not Birth control, in the form of the pill, morning after, RU248, condoms etc all the halting of the procreation process, therefore the intent of the people that use birth control is to not procreate?

 

 

Does this not lead to then the aborting of a potentially fertilized fetus?

 

So I contend that if a married couple in the Catholic church uses any form of contraception, they are then aborting of a viable child, whether it be the actual fertilized egg or never fertilized because of the contraception, as the couple is outside of the "Marriage act", an act in communion with God so as to procreate.

 

I am just going by what the Church teaches us:

 

 

 

Many (all, perhaps?) hormonal contraceptives are abortifacient, in that a fertilized ovum, a zygote, is not allowed to implant in the uterus (in those cases where the hormonal action of the contraceptive failed to prevent ovulation). In this case it is properly called abortive.

However, a condom, spermicide, masturbation, all your previous examples, are not abortive, because a human being does not yet exist. You are incorrect to refer to "never fertilized" eggs as being aborted, because they are not human beings. That is what the Church, as well as science, teaches.

It is not correct to call an interruption of the process of conception an abortion. If conception is actually interrupted, i.e. conception is not allowed to occur, then this is contraception. It is definitively not abortion.

It remains gravely wrong, but it is not abortion.

Edited by Nihil Obstat
Basilisa Marie
Posted

"Pre-conception abortion" is like saying punching myself in the face is the same as murdering my sister. 

 

Posted (edited)
"Pre-conception abortion" is like saying punching myself in the face is the same as murdering my sister. 

 

Or like saying you got into a fatal car crash when you stub your toe.

Edited by Nihil Obstat
Posted (edited)

Just to clarify something that mark said. Procreation is not the only purpose of intercourse but is the primary purpose of intercourse. Union with one's spouse is a secondary purpose. If procreation was the only purpose of sex then we wouldn't have sex during pregnancy or infertile times.

I did my theological seminar for my degree on this topic and it was very clearly written in church documents that although procreation is the primary purpose to intercourse it is not the only purpose

Edited by Slappo

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...