dominicansoul Posted January 18, 2013 Posted January 18, 2013 (edited) Hm. So the woman he loves and wants to marry offended you and now your friend should break up with her to bandage up your very, very thin skin? I guess St. Narcissus was your confirmation saint. What would your reaction be if a dear friend of yours, someone like a brother to you was going to marry a woman who told you, "homos deserve to die of AIDS?" My guess is, you wouldn't take that so well... you'd want to see your dear friend with someone more respectful and not homophobic and hateful... its the same situation with blacksheep here...he and his best friend are like brothers... I understand blacksheep's reaction... Edited January 18, 2013 by dominicansoul
4588686 Posted January 18, 2013 Posted January 18, 2013 What would your reaction be if a dear friend of yours, someone like a brother to you was going to marry a woman who told you, "homos deserve to die of AIDS?" My guess is, you wouldn't take that so well... you'd want to see your dear friend with someone more respectful and not homophobic and hateful... its the same situation with blacksheep here...he and his best friend are like brothers... I understand blacksheep's reaction... Probably because there is a huge difference between wishing death on a class of people and thinking that a set of beliefs are ridiculous. I consider Winchester, J-Lol, MIKolbe, Lil Res, MT, Ardill, Nihil et cetera friends despite the fact that they consider many of my beliefs to be wrong and morally appalling and vica versa.
PhuturePriest Posted January 18, 2013 Posted January 18, 2013 Probably because there is a huge difference between wishing death on a class of people and thinking that a set of beliefs are ridiculous. I consider Winchester, J-Lol, MIKolbe, Lil Res, MT, Ardill, Nihil et cetera friends despite the fact that they consider many of my beliefs to be wrong and morally appalling and vica versa. Who is Lil Res?
Gabriela Posted January 18, 2013 Posted January 18, 2013 (edited) I understand your reaction, too, blacksheep. But I think that, given a few days to cool down, you'll probably look back on it and just shrug with resignation. It's not like you didn't know this kind of person was out there. The fact that it's your best friend's girlfriend is more difficult... I should think that, if you try to give the guy an ultimatum, he'll stick with the girl over the friend. So I wouldn't do that. Unless you're prepared to lose the friendship over this. Try getting to know her sober. The thing I hear most often is "Oh, you're religious? But you're so intelligent..." Which requires ENORMOUS WILLPOWER not to respond to with a reflexive punch to the face. I've heard it from professors, friends, total strangers... Last time was in a Panera in West Virginia. Really, what right did that guy have? I've learned to roll my eyes and walk away. Arguing with people who are so stupid AND arrogant that they think intelligence necessitates a particular worldview is futile, maddening, and a near occasion to murder. Edited January 18, 2013 by curiousing
4588686 Posted January 18, 2013 Posted January 18, 2013 I understand your reaction, too, blacksheep. But I think that, given a few days to cool down, you'll probably look back on it and just shrug with resignation. It's not like you didn't know this kind of person was out there. The fact that it's your best friend's girlfriend is more difficult... I should think that, if you try to give the guy an ultimatum, he'll stick with the girl over the friend. So I wouldn't do that. Unless you're prepared to lose the friendship over this. Try getting to know her sober. The thing I hear most often is "Oh, you're religious? But you're so intelligent..." Which requires ENORMOUS WILLPOWER not to respond to with a reflexive punch to the face. I've heard it from professors, friends, total strangers... Last time was in a Panera in West Virginia. Really, what right did that guy have? I've learned to roll my eyes and walk away. Arguing with people who are so stupid AND arrogant that they think intelligence necessitates a particular worldview is futile, maddening, and a near occasion to murder. That's really sad that hearing an opinion tempts you to that sort of violence.
blacksheep Posted January 18, 2013 Author Posted January 18, 2013 Probably because there is a huge difference between wishing death on a class of people and thinking that a set of beliefs are ridiculous. I consider Winchester, J-Lol, MIKolbe, Lil Res, MT, Ardill, Nihil et cetera friends despite the fact that they consider many of my beliefs to be wrong and morally appalling and vica versa. Homophobia and aids is a bad analogy here... I'll put it this way. It's was as if i was talking to her and she told me "You know your mom. I'm sorry but she's full of sh*t." Afterall we call the church our mother church.
blacksheep Posted January 18, 2013 Author Posted January 18, 2013 Hm. So the woman he loves and wants to marry offended you and now your friend should break up with her to bandage up your very, very thin skin? I guess St. Narcissus was your confirmation saint. Actually it was st. luke. The patron saint of writers and artists....and they do tend to be full of themselves at times...so hey good eye.
Winchester Posted January 18, 2013 Posted January 18, 2013 Homophobia and aids is a bad analogy here... I'll put it this way. It's was as if i was talking to her and she told me "You know your mom. I'm sorry but she's full of sh*t." Afterall we call the church our mother church. My mom is full of sh*t. Are you saying that's a bad thing? Why are you judging my mom?
blacksheep Posted January 18, 2013 Author Posted January 18, 2013 after taking a deep hard look at this...if my friend and I discuss it I will layout how i felt. But will iterate that I care for him like a brother and will support his choice of who he loves. This may just be a great lesson for me to just learn to love her like a sister, since no matter what she believes or says God still loves her....but if the subject does come up again I will defend myself...not with fists but with words and reason. And if the disrespect continues...i will just not hang out with her around....
Debra Little Posted January 18, 2013 Posted January 18, 2013 Believing in God without religion is like believing in America without a constitution or a government. I uinderstand this kind of thing very well, having been there myself. I was so hurt by the church, things the church had done to me. For a long time I attended no church at all. I love the Lord but hated religion with a passion. But it got bad. It got to the point where I hated Christians as well. None of it Catholic. Other Protestant religions. The things I was taught in these churches that did a lot to mess up my head. The way I saw other Christians behaving. Hurting their brothers and sisters. This was not only me. I couldn't tolerate it anymore and left. Later I converted to the Catholic church. Have not been disappointed with it ever. At one point I did stop attending Mass. This was after the stuff about the priests came out in '90. For me this was a personal thing as I had suffered a lot of sexual abuse, though not as a child and not at the hands of the church. I didn't trust the church anymore and was afraid to be there. It is very easy to understand why so many love the Lord and hate religion. The church, all churches have treated them so badly. They saw hypocritical, not Christian behavior. If it weren't for some of God's kids I think more would believe in Him.
dUSt Posted January 18, 2013 Posted January 18, 2013 And if the disrespect continues...i will just not hang out with her around.... If we alienate ourselves from everyone who is hostile to our faith we will never change the world. Engage and influence. Words are great. Example is better.
blacksheep Posted January 18, 2013 Author Posted January 18, 2013 If we alienate ourselves from everyone who is hostile to our faith we will never change the world. Engage and influence. Words are great. Example is better. phew...well then this is going to be tough. Ok...Example then...
dUSt Posted January 18, 2013 Posted January 18, 2013 I have a good friend who is agnostic. He is very hostile towards the church. I don't avoid him. I hang out with him. I drink beer with him. I enjoy his company and respect him for his humanity. Does religion come up? Sometimes. Does he say things that offend me? If I let them. I will of course, defend the Church, when needed. Never in anger. Always in love. My hope is that he will see happiness and joy in me, and some day see that this happiness and joy is rooted in my faith. Nobody converts because they get beat in an argument.
PhuturePriest Posted January 18, 2013 Posted January 18, 2013 I have a good friend who is agnostic. He is very hostile towards the church. I don't avoid him. I hang out with him. I drink beer with him. I enjoy his company and respect him for his humanity. Does religion come up? Sometimes. Does he say things that offend me? If I let them. I will of course, defend the Church, when needed. Never in anger. Always in love. My hope is that he will see happiness and joy in me, and some day see that this happiness and joy is rooted in my faith. Nobody converts because they get beat in an argument. Did your wife give you permission to be happy?
Ash Wednesday Posted January 18, 2013 Posted January 18, 2013 (edited) In my experience, religious discussion and booze often do not mix well when it involves two or more with very differing views on it. When I was studying in London I got a lot of b.s. at a party from a couple from Iceland, neither believed in God and they were pretty obnoxious about it. Fortunately it avoided ugliness because I am a pretty chill boozer despite very much disagreeing with them... Hilarious the next day she joked about what a great time we had but suggested I "leave religion out of it"... funny considering they're the ones that initiated the debate. Just remember how bold and smart people magically become when they are drunk....and most of all, when you are christened as a child mostly out of family habit and went to church a couple of times growing up, you know everything there is to know about Christianity and ALL religion, amirite? :| Pray for all our friends. Edited January 18, 2013 by Ash Wednesday
Winchester Posted January 19, 2013 Posted January 19, 2013 I have a friend who has bitten several priests. He is a wolverine. But I will not abandon our friendship, or stop taking him to Mass. Nor will I stop hiding chunks of fish on the priests. I am convinced that this will eventually build a positive association with the Mass, leading in time to the conversion of all wolverinedom.
Nihil Obstat Posted January 19, 2013 Posted January 19, 2013 I have a friend who has bitten several priests. He is a wolverine. But I will not abandon our friendship, or stop taking him to Mass. Nor will I stop hiding chunks of fish on the priests. I am convinced that this will eventually build a positive association with the Mass, leading in time to the conversion of all wolverinedom. /thread
beatitude Posted January 19, 2013 Posted January 19, 2013 Today I read something by St Francis de Sales about believing the best of people. Perhaps she has had very bad or painful experiences of Catholicism that have led her to think this way. It may be that she's already sorry for what she said and is wishing she hadn't been so rude. Only this afternoon I was thinking of something I did as a young undergraduate (a snarky article I wrote for the college newspaper) and wishing that I could take those words back. But I have no way to do that. Instead I have to rely on people who read the article to do their best to think of me kindly. Try not to focus on how offended you feel and instead try to focus on how similar she is to you in terms of shared humanity and shared weakness - and shared value in God's sight. Why feel hostile to someone loved by Jesus? Your faith is important to you, and this is what your faith demands that you do.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now