LadyOfSorrows Posted February 6, 2013 Posted February 6, 2013 I have experience at both Ave Maria and the Mount. Both take different approaches to their Theology programs. They are both solid, but it's more of a hit or miss at the Mount with some courses/professors. If you're looking for orthodoxy, I'd go for Ave Maria. PLUS, you get great "bang for your buck." They give fantastic scholarships and I paid half as much as I paid to go to Mount. The professors there are rock solid and are bold because they know that their students are bold. It is a different environment from the Mount in that almost everyone is a practicing Catholic and knew that when they applied. Even in theology classes with non-majors, the students are respectful, interested, kind, willing to learn and contribute. They have some incredible professors who are world renowned. One translated the Theology of the Body into English and another one wrote the popular book "Salvation is from the Jews," and often appears on EWTN. There are "households" on campus that you can join, each taking on a Catholic theme where you can grow in community and do things together. I briefly visited the St. Gianna Household, which is mainly a pro-life group of girls that put on fun events and get together after Mass on Sundays. There is a 24-hour adoration chapel on campus, and the students know how to have good fun on the weekends that isn't overly crazy and done in good taste. The Mount has a good theology program as well, but it's different due to the make-up of the students. It's more like a typical college campus-- although a really beautiful environment due to its history (much more history than Ave Maria). Although I do appreciate the education I've received from the Mount, I can definitely say that in terms of what I've read and been exposed to during my short time at Ave Maria, I would definitely recommend Ave over the Mount for that particular program. If you would like more detailed information about why this is, I could explain it to you over a message... Another poster pointed out that the Philosophy program at the Mount is very good as well. Many Theology majors choose to also major in Philosophy at the Mount. If you were to look at the Mount, that may be a good idea.
LadyOfSorrows Posted February 6, 2013 Posted February 6, 2013 Theology: This follows with the campus culture. The Mount's theology department assumes you've already gotten a sound catechetical education, so theology majors are plunged into "doing" more academic theology than just learning about the catechism. There are some professors at the Mount that are at the forefront of current Catholic moral theology, particularly virtue ethics. The professors take a strong interest in making sure the majors are doing well as a whole person, and some offer spiritual direction if they don't currently have you in class. You can also take some upper-level theology electives at the seminary, if you get permission. The ministry classes are really good, too, and their goal is to prepare you so you can get a job. The philosophy department is very orthodox, and have a strong medieval/patristics focus. It's very Catholic. The Mount theology department doesn't just assume that you can have a sound catechetical education before going to college. I don't believe this is true and it certainly doesn't seem as if many of the theology grads came in knowing their catechism, and it probably isn't true that any other major would come to college knowing their field.
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted February 6, 2013 Posted February 6, 2013 Many have mentioned finances - I've heard good things about the University of Mary in Bismarck, North Dakota. They're striving to offer a really inexpensive annual rate, check it out: http://www.umary.edu/finances/undergraduate/tuition.php Also, there are a few state universities that offer minors in Catholic theological studies, in cooperation with a Newman center, etc. off campus. You might major in philosophy or history, etc. while studying the minor.
Basilisa Marie Posted February 6, 2013 Posted February 6, 2013 The Mount theology department doesn't just assume that you can have a sound catechetical education before going to college. I don't believe this is true and it certainly doesn't seem as if many of the theology grads came in knowing their catechism, and it probably isn't true that any other major would come to college knowing their field. Well, technically I never said it was a completely accurate assumption - for what it's worth, I included the need for a mandatory catechism-style class as a 100 level for all majors in my exit interview comments. I do think you can get a better experience from the program if you already know your catechism. And I would argue that there's a big difference between "knowing your field" and knowing what the Catechism says... But you probably already knew I'd say something like that. :saint2:
OnlySunshine Posted February 6, 2013 Posted February 6, 2013 (edited) What about Aquinas College in Nashville, TN? It's run (and was founded by) the Nashville Dominicans. It's actually cheaper than FUS and Ave Maria. Their theology program is rock-solid and they are a liberal arts school. They are recommended by the Newman Guide. http://thenewmanguide.com/TheNewmanGuide/RecommendedColleges/AquinasCollege.aspx Edited February 6, 2013 by MaterMisericordiae
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted February 6, 2013 Posted February 6, 2013 (edited) Many have mentioned finances - I've heard good things about the University of Mary in Bismarck, North Dakota. They're striving to offer a really inexpensive annual rate, check it out: http://www.umary.edu/finances/undergraduate/tuition.php Also, there are a few state universities that offer minors in Catholic theological studies, in cooperation with a Newman center, etc. off campus. You might major in philosophy or history, etc. while studying the minor. If my math is right, the University of Mary is $13,600 per year. Ave Maria is $20,800; FUS is $21,740. They're also on the Newman Guide: http://thenewmanguide.com/TheNewmanGuide/RecommendedColleges/UniversityofMary.aspx Edited February 6, 2013 by thedude
homeschoolmom Posted February 6, 2013 Posted February 6, 2013 If my math is right, the University of Mary is $13,600 per year. Ave Maria is $20,800; FUS is $21,740. They're also on the Newman Guide: http://thenewmanguide.com/TheNewmanGuide/RecommendedColleges/UniversityofMary.aspx Also, if you graduated from a Catholic HS, you can look into having room and board covered at U of Mary in Bismarck.
Papist Posted February 6, 2013 Posted February 6, 2013 Belmont Abbey College located in Belmont, NC, which borders Charlotte. Great school with a great Catholic culture. http://www.belmontabbeycollege.edu/
FutureCarmeliteClaire Posted February 6, 2013 Posted February 6, 2013 I can't really be of much help or offer much advice on this. I'm looking into secular schools because I've found good programs in various specialty fields of medicine sorely lacking in most private Catholic schools. Or at least for what I'm looking for. Cognitive neuroscience with a compatible psychology program is just not something I've been able to find in a Catholic school so far. ;) Anyway, before I started seriously considering the neuropsychology route, I was really interested in Ave Maria. I've heard really great things about the school.
Basilisa Marie Posted February 6, 2013 Posted February 6, 2013 For what it's worth, if you're really serious about saving money, there are a lot of state schools that have a great Newman center, so you can still be involved with a good Catholic culture on campus. Because for a lot of places, the reality is that you can either go to a Catholic college, or save money. It's really, really hard to find both.
OnlySunshine Posted February 6, 2013 Posted February 6, 2013 I can't really be of much help or offer much advice on this. I'm looking into secular schools because I've found good programs in various specialty fields of medicine sorely lacking in most private Catholic schools. Or at least for what I'm looking for. Cognitive neuroscience with a compatible psychology program is just not something I've been able to find in a Catholic school so far. ;) Anyway, before I started seriously considering the neuropsychology route, I was really interested in Ave Maria. I've heard really great things about the school. This is off-topic, but you might try UCLA. When I visited there with my mom, we stumbled into the neuropsychiatry wing while we were trying to find her doctor. We were in the wrong building. :hehe2: Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, MD is also another great school with both programs. BTW, College Board's College Search is a very helpful resource. You can put in the major or majors that you want and what type of school, tuition rate, etc. and it brings up a list of matching schools. https://bigfuture.collegeboard.org/college-search
FutureCarmeliteClaire Posted February 6, 2013 Posted February 6, 2013 This is off-topic, but you might try UCLA. When I visited there with my mom, we stumbled into the neuropsychiatry wing while we were trying to find her doctor. We were in the wrong building. :hehe2: Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, MD is also another great school with both programs. BTW, College Board's College Search is a very helpful resource. You can put in the major or majors that you want and what type of school, tuition rate, etc. and it brings up a list of matching schools. https://bigfuture.collegeboard.org/college-search I haven't thought about UCLA, but thanks!! :) I will look into it. Haha, that's funny. JHU is my top pick right now. I basically have a few years to become a genius in order to get in... Lol :)
ToJesusMyHeart Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 What about Aquinas College in Nashville, TN? It's run (and was founded by) the Nashville Dominicans. It's actually cheaper than FUS and Ave Maria. Their theology program is rock-solid and they are a liberal arts school. They are recommended by the Newman Guide. http://thenewmanguide.com/TheNewmanGuide/RecommendedColleges/AquinasCollege.aspx If I could choose my college over again, I'd go here.
Tufsoles Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 I wouldn't suggest UD. I have meet some grads from there and they seems a little social inept and a little off the wall. I think that it is real important for people degrees in theology have some great social skills. But maybe I ran into the wrong people. I also found they can't write well. I.E. worse than I do. And the tuition isn't all that great either. This was just a personal experience.
Amppax Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 I can comment on Student/Res Life here at Franciscan, considering it's my job. You have to live in the dorms, basically. It's really hard to get an exemption to live off campus unless you're a senior. So if finances are a worry, please take that into account. It's really about $28K a year to go here, and there aren't many scholarships. That being said, it is possible to make it work financially, you just really have to work hard to do so. I'm currently an RA and receiving several scholarship/grants and a tiny bit of loans. I'll graduate a year early with (hopefully) very little debt. There are ways to make it work, you just have to get creative. The household system which LadyofSorrow mentioned Ave has is modeled off of the one here at Franciscan. I'd try to explain households, but the university does a solid job of that so here's a link. http://franciscan.edu/Households/ I'm in a household (actually it's the one in the video on the website where the people look like their in a living room) and I believe Slappo was as well. Households do a great job of providing community in the dorms and on campus. There really are a million and one things to do on campus; there's almost always something going on. Steubenville isn't a great place to hang out, but Pittsburgh's not far. I hardly ever left campus last year, and I usually wasn't bored. The Res Life policy's take a little getting used to, especially if you're familiar with other colleges. We have a fairly strict policy regarding visitation, but it's fairly reasonable in my opinion. I could answer specific questions about what its like to live in the dorms. I'm sure I could say much more. I love it here, and would really recommend it. I wasn't a fan of Ave when I visited, but I can't really comment beyond that because I haven't spent much time there. I've visited the Mount, but never for classes. It's a beautiful campus. Other than that, I haven't heard of the other one's on your list, so I can't comment.
tinytherese Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 (edited) I haven't been to these schools, but have you considered Newman University which is in Wichita, KS or Holy Cross College in South Bend, IN? I highly DO NOT recommend St. Gregory's University in Shawnee, OK. I know that it's on the Newman Guide, but that in and of itself doesn't that it's a good school. I could write a long rant about their bad theology program, campus ministry, and other aspects of the school. I got my BA in theology there and wish I would have gone elsewhere. Edited March 5, 2013 by tinytherese
tinytherese Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 I wouldn't suggest UD. I have meet some grads from there and they seems a little social inept and a little off the wall. I think that it is real important for people degrees in theology have some great social skills. But maybe I ran into the wrong people. I also found they can't write well. I.E. worse than I do. And the tuition isn't all that great either. This was just a personal experience. Maybe you met people on the autism spectrum. Perhaps even they don't know that they're on it. Speaking as someone on the spectrum myself, I can say that what many people think is common sense in behaving socially isn't typically obvious to us. Not a lot of people are well-informed about it and know how to properly address it, sadly this can happen a great deal in schools and colleges are no exception.
ToJesusMyHeart Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 Maybe you met people on the autism spectrum. Perhaps even they don't know that they're on it. Speaking as someone on the spectrum myself, I can say that what many people think is common sense in behaving socially isn't typically obvious to us. Not a lot of people are well-informed about it and know how to properly address it, sadly this can happen a great deal in schools and colleges are no exception. I have a friend who(m?) I think might be autistic, but she has never told me outright. Would it be rude of me to ask? I don't plan or need to ask but I'm just curious if you would be offended if someone asked you. I'm sorry if this seems intrusive! If you don't want to answer that's totally fine. :)
GeorgiiMichael Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 I can't speak much on the Theology program at the Mount, and I definitely can't add anything to what Basilia has said. All of my best friends have theology degrees from the Mount, and despite some more different-thinking professors, they are all extremely orthodox. From what I can discern, the Mount doesn't shy away from the more "liberal" theologies; rather they get you acquainted with them, which allows you to have a better understanding of the whole of current theology, which would give you a leg up in defending orthodoxy. The Mount led me to my conversion and has a host of orthodox students and a vibrant community of good Catholic students.
the171 Posted March 6, 2013 Author Posted March 6, 2013 Ok y'all. I really think I want to apply to the Mount.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now