Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Orthodox Metropolitan Blasts Anglicans For Renouncing The Faith


Recommended Posts

Posted

The vast majority of the hierarchs in the Russian Orthodox Church have been ordained since the fall of communism, and so once again your generalization is just that, a prejudiced and useless statement.

 

On the other hand, large numbers of Roman Catholic bishops in America have been involved actively and passively in allowing the sex abuse of children.  I think the Russian Orthodox bishops look tame in comparison.  

 

Worst of all the Roman bishops did their acts without facing state organized persecution.

 

I find it interesting how often you go after Rome, her theology, her bishops (horrifying lot by the looks of 'em), etc and get no push back from Catholics here. This is not an attempt to start a fight, just find it a curious thing.



"Cooperation on moral issues is possible, although who knows where the
vast majority of Roman Catholic bishops will be on those issues in ten
or twenty years time.  The Roman Catholic Church is not used to state
organized persecution and it may cave in quickly.  Heck the Roman
hierarchs have been caving in to the secular culture and the state in
America for around 50 years now without any persecution."

 

And this I'd like to disagree with, but it's true.

 

Now tell us all about divorce, icons, and the pill in Orthodoxy. :)

Posted (edited)

I find it interesting how often you go after Rome, her theology, her bishops (horrifying lot by the looks of 'em), etc and get no push back from Catholics here. This is not an attempt to start a fight, just find it a curious thing.

I see it from both sides, because I was a Roman Catholic for 18 years, and have been Byzantine Catholic for 8 years now.  As a Byzantine Catholic (Melkite) I have seen the impact of the Roman Church's ecclesial imperialism.  One of the Churches I attended while in the process of changing from one jurisdiction to another had only had an iconostasis for ten years, and that same parish (and all the others in its sui juris grouping) only restored the full mysteries of initiation to children two years after my ritual change of Churches was completed.  Rome tends to see itself as a standard, but it is only one apostolic Church among many, and the days during which the theory of praestantia ritus latini was passively accepted by Eastern Catholics are over.  

 

Eastern Catholics are restoring their traditions - some of which were lost due to forced Latinizations by the Roman Church, and some voluntarily suppressed in order to be more "catholic" - and sadly many Roman Catholics do not even know that their Church has acted in the past as a bully.  Why did Cardinal Keeler apologize to Eastern Catholics?  Because he knew the historical truth of the matter, which is that the Latin Church in America (and other places) forced its theology and discipline on Eastern Catholics.  An action that caused the conversion of more than half of all Eastern Catholics then living in the United States to Orthodoxy.  The apology was welcome, but a little late.



Postscript:  I defend Rome when it is doing the right thing, but I see no reason why a person cannot be critical of the pope or the Roman Curia when they are wrong.  That said, I hope that the pope speaks out on the "plan b" pill issue, and condemns any use of the drug.  

Edited by Apotheoun
Posted

I find it interesting how often you go after Rome, her theology, her bishops (horrifying lot by the looks of 'em), etc and get no push back from Catholics here. This is not an attempt to start a fight, just find it a curious thing.



"Cooperation on moral issues is possible, although who knows where the
vast majority of Roman Catholic bishops will be on those issues in ten
or twenty years time.  The Roman Catholic Church is not used to state
organized persecution and it may cave in quickly.  Heck the Roman
hierarchs have been caving in to the secular culture and the state in
America for around 50 years now without any persecution."

 

And this I'd like to disagree with, but it's true.

 

Now tell us all about divorce, icons, and the pill in Orthodoxy. :)

 

The last sentence of this is not snark. Although I can see how someone might read it that way.
 

Posted (edited)

I read a tremendous amount a pre-Vatican II material that and my grandmother's fixation on some visionary are why I came to phatmass. I can see how the Roman Church carried on an honestly abusive relationship with "the Uniates." I also can get an idea of what you mean about the loss of Eastern distinctiveness from my limited experience with Maronites. Still though, I have become what hopefully with God's grace I'll remain: a son of the Roman Church and a sword, men, heart, mind, and soul ready for the defense of the Papacy's Unique, August, and Universal role. A Papist in short.

Edited by Evangetholic
Posted

I read a tremendous amount a pre-Vatican II material that and my grandmother's fixation on some visionary are why I came to phatmass. I can see how the Roman Church carried on an honestly abusive relationship with "the Uniates." I also can get an idea of what you mean about the loss of Eastern distinctiveness from my limited experience with Maronites. Still though, I have become what hopefully with God's grace I'll remain: a son of the Roman Church and a sword, men, heart, mind, and soul ready for the defense of the Papacy's Unique, August, and Universal role. A Papist in short.

 


Not at all certain what I mean by "men." Bah. I'm a Christian. The Bible says Christians are fools.

Posted

The vast majority of the hierarchs in the Russian Orthodox Church have been ordained since the fall of communism, and so once again your generalization is just that, a prejudiced and useless statement.

 

This would make sense if the Russian church swept out the hierarchy when the Soviet Union fell, instead the KGB collaborators and informants became heads of the church. The church is an institution of the state, defending Putin and being an extension of his beauracracy. The rulers of this ecclesiastical institution and new appointees must conform to the rules and customs. This is really no different than with what happens to traditional minded Catholic men who attempt going into an American seminary. The process of conformity is the same despite any time gap.

 

Patriarch Kirill by the way was estimated to possess a personal wealth of $4 billion dollars, how he came to obtain such vast wealth is another story.

 

On the other hand, large numbers of Roman Catholic bishops in America have been involved actively and passively in allowing the sex abuse of children.  I think the Russian Orthodox bishops look tame in comparison.  

 

Worst of all the Roman bishops did their acts without facing state organized persecution.

 

Yes this was a problem

 


Cooperation on moral issues is possible, although who knows where the vast majority of Roman Catholic bishops will be on those issues in ten or twenty years time.  The Roman Catholic Church is not used to state organized persecution and it may cave in quickly.  Heck the Roman hierarchs have been caving in to the secular culture and the state in America for around 50 years now without any persecution.

 

The Church in America has been attacked for quite some time. I think you forget that propaganda is to Democracy what force is to Tyranny, so sure the the Church has not faced physical persecution, but there has been an extremely heavy onslaught in the media, public education, and popular culture, all clandestinely guided by the state-corporate nexus. The casualties have been enormous but that is not to say the Church has succumb. There is still a very strong and vibrant remnant, keeping the pulse of the Church beating.



I find it interesting how often you go after Rome, her theology, her bishops (horrifying lot by the looks of 'em), etc and get no push back from Catholics here. This is not an attempt to start a fight, just find it a curious thing.

 

What you will discover is that most Roman Catholics are apathetic towards such things. It's a rather unique phenomena among ourselves, I've never seen such a lack of zeal among other religious folk or Christians of other denominational persuasions. 
 

Posted (edited)

This would make sense if the Russian church swept out the hierarchy when the Soviet Union fell, instead the KGB collaborators and informants became heads of the church. The church is an institution of the state, defending Putin and being an extension of his beauracracy. The rulers of this ecclesiastical institution and new appointees must conform to the rules and customs. This is really no different than with what happens to traditional minded Catholic men who attempt going into an American seminary. The process of conformity is the same despite any time gap.

The same could have been said of the Church after the persecution carried out by Diocletian.  Clearly you would make an excellent Donatist.  

 

Evidently the hierarchs, most ordained since the fall of communism, and some, who - like Hilarion - was only 25 when the Soviet Union collapsed, did not agree with your assessment of Kirill.  Tough luck for those who share your opinion.  I suppose, since we know now that many hierarchs in Poland cooperated with the Communist authorities, that they should all have stepped down, but they didn't.  I guess it could also be argued that the vast majority of hierarchs in the American and European (especially Irish) Churches should step down because of their complicity in the sex abuse scandal, but so far they haven't done that, and nor has the Vatican taken any action to bring about that end.  In fact, the Vatican Curia has protected some of the worst hierarchs (e.g., Cardinal Law) by giving them positions that remove them from American jurisdiction.

 

It is interesting how some members of the Roman Church fail to see the beam in their own Church's eye, but they are more than ready to attack the Russian Church, which suffered more than 70 years of active persecution.

Edited by Apotheoun
Posted

The same could have been said of the Church after the persecution carried out by Diocletian.  Clearly you would make an excellent Donatist.  

 

Not at all, I'm not saying the Patriarch or Moscow and his ilk does not perform valid sacraments, rather I have little to no respect for him. And sadly, despite all his pompt and crimes against the Russian people, he has not apologized of made ammends, instead he continues to serve the same State institution that existed in the Soviet era.

 

 

Evidently the hierarchs, most ordained since the fall of communism, and some, who - like Hilarion - was only 25 when the Soviet Union collapsed, did not agree with your assessment of Kirill.  Tough luck for those who share your opinion.  I suppose, since we know now that many hierarchs in Poland cooperated with the Communist authorities, that they should all have stepped down, but they didn't.  I guess it could also be argued that the vast majority of hierarchs in the American and European (especially Irish) Churches should step down because of their complicity in the sex abuse scandal, but so far they haven't done that, and nor has the Vatican taken any action to bring about that end.  In fact, the Vatican Curia has protected some of the worst hierarchs (e.g., Cardinal Law) by giving them positions that remove them from American jurisdiction.

 

Polish Clerics who conspired with the Communist regime continued in their offices until the government exposed decades old files revealing who the collaborators were. You may recall the news of Warsaw's Archbishop Stanislaw Wielgus resigning hours before his inauguration Mass, admitting to his collaboration with the Communists. Kirill on the other hand gets a promotion to Patriarch and continues to rule.

 

It is interesting how some members of the Roman Church fail to see the beam in their own Church's eye, but they are more than ready to attack the Russian Church, which suffered more than 70 years of active persecution.

 

The same goes to you brother. But to make a distinction, I'm not attacking the people of sincere belief, rather I hold disdain for the hierarchs who assisted the Soviet regime against these same people, and all for the sake of profit.

Posted

It is interesting how some members of the Roman Church fail to see the beam in their own Church's eye, but they are more than ready to attack the Russian Church, which suffered more than 70 years of active persecution.

 

The Church Hierarchy was actively involved in providing moral legitimacy to one of the most despotic governments in the world for centuries before the Bolsheviks.  So it's a little hard to feel awful when that very Church hierarchy was subject to the same violence and arbitrary cruelty that it had surrendered its flock to for centuries and was actively doing so when the Bolsheviks seized power.  A lot of ordinary Russian faithful were also brutally persecuted and that is another matter entirely.  Moreover, the persecution was not continuous or even.  The good Priests were persecuted pretty badly.  But plenty of individuals like Krill were not persecuted because they were happy to collaborate with the authoritarian Soviet Union.  Stalin, being a good former seminarian, harnessed Russian nationalism and the Russian Church to drive Russians onwards during the Second World War and brought the Church back into the folds of power, a position the Church hierarchy was pretty happy to seize onto.  

Posted

It is interesting how some members of the Roman Church fail to see the beam in their own Church's eye, but they are more than ready to attack the Russian Church, which suffered more than 70 years of active persecution.

 

You mean how if someone criticizes the Roman Catholic Church it's "Anti-Catholic" but if it's the Orthodox Church or Eastern Catholics that are criticized, it's perfectly okay? 

 

I think Apo made a great point bringing up that example. Take the beam out of your own eye before your remove the speak in your brother's (this is just a general statement, not directed at you).

Posted (edited)

I think a casual perusal of statements on this website that says it is loyal to the Magisterium of the Universal Church of Almighty God will not reveal very many moments where the Eastern Orthodox Church has been criticized, but a very great many where the Sacred Magisterium of the One True Faith has been criticized and there have been no harsh responses or even responses at all to denials of Papal Infallibility (a dogma of the faith), the Immaculate Conception (another dogma). And no one has even dared point out that recalcitrant Bishops (in communion with the Earthly Head of God's Church) even if they are called Patriarchs, and even if Rome is silent in response to their heterodoxy (in defiance of dogma and of canon law), are objectively guilty of grave sin. This is not a general statement. It is directed in a particular direction in response to particular circumstances that I'd be glad to devote my time to listing for you if you would like Selah. :)

 

 

Edited by Evangetholic
Posted

I think a casual perusal of statements on this website that says it is loyal to the Magisterium of the Universal Church of Almighty God will not reveal very many moments where the Eastern Orthodox Church has been criticized, but a very great many where the Sacred Magisterium of the One True Faith has been criticized and there have been no harsh responses or even responses at all to denials of Papal Infallibility (a dogma of the faith), the Immaculate Conception (another dogma). And no one has even dared point out that recalcitrant Bishops (in communion with the Earthly Head of God's Church) even if they are called Patriarchs, and even if Rome is silent in response to their heterodoxy (in defiance of dogma and of canon law), are objectively guilty of grave sin. This is not a general statement. It is directed in a particular direction in response to particular circumstances that I'd be glad to devote my time to listing for you if you would like Selah. :)

 

Actually, if you look at archives, you'll find a few instances where this has happened, including one moment where the Coptic Pope of Alexandria was called an "anti-pope." 

 

As a Catholic, you are more than welcome to disagree with Eastern theology. But I do get upset when I see scandals going on in the Roman Catholic Church and people commenting on status updates, "I'm so sick of the attacks on my church". Attacks on your church? Are you serious? And that somehow makes you Anti-Catholic...

 

...Then, some Catholics turn around and criticize the Orthodox Church, like it's the only Church in history to ever persecute or victimize people or do something stupid. 

 

If Mortify wants to lump all Russian hierarchs together, am I allowed to lump all priests together? Or does that make me Anti-Catholic? And if it does, is Mortify also Anti (At least Russian) Orthodox? Or is it "justified" somehow?

Posted

Actually, if you look at archives, you'll find a few instances where this has happened, including one moment where the Coptic Pope of Alexandria was called an "anti-pope." 

 

As a Catholic, you are more than welcome to disagree with Eastern theology. But I do get upset when I see scandals going on in the Roman Catholic Church and people commenting on status updates, "I'm so sick of the attacks on my church". Attacks on your church? Are you serious? And that somehow makes you Anti-Catholic...

 

...Then, some Catholics turn around and criticize the Orthodox Church, like it's the only Church in history to ever persecute or victimize people or do something stupid. 

 

If Mortify wants to lump all Russian hierarchs together, am I allowed to lump all priests together? Or does that make me Anti-Catholic? And if it does, is Mortify also Anti (At least Russian) Orthodox? Or is it "justified" somehow?

No one should have called the Coptic Pope an anti-pope, that's frankly, well, no I will not be frank.

 

I am quite aware that I am free to disagree with Eastern theology. Pleased to see the lucid depths of our agreement.

 

Yes when people say they are sick of attacks on the Universal Church in response to the actions of a few horrifically monstrous priests and careerist bishops they are most likely quite serious. And yes attacking the Catholic Church does indeed make you anti-Catholic. And just for clarity's sake neither accurate coverage of this never-ending and well-deserved scandal nor just and reasonable outrage in response to it constitutes "Anti-Catholicism."

 

I have no response to the rest of your statements as they do not involve me. (I will clearly state that I have no quarrel with the East as such. Both lungs you know.)
 

Posted

and yes attacking the Catholic Church does indeed make you anti-Catholic.

 

But I'm not! A disagreement and sadness at the fact that the Catholic Church isn't dealing properly with the sex scandal does not make me Anti-Catholic. It makes me human. I'm just sick of the victimization so many Catholics show. "Oh my gosh, someone is upset about the sex scandal! Anti-Catholic!" 

 

 

I am quite aware that I am free to disagree with Eastern theology. Pleased to see the lucid depths of our agreement.

 

And please note that I won't consider you Anti-Orthodox for disagreeing, or thinking that persecutions lead by the Orthodox Church in the past (such as on the Old Believers) are wrong :)

Posted (edited)

My "you" for the Anti-Catholic statement was a general you. Not you Selah who I've never experienced as anything other than lovely. English is woefully impoverished.  Please don't assign me opinions though. I think the Russian Orthodox Church handled the Old Believers (look at the non-priestly sects) perfectly.

Edited by Evangetholic
Posted

English is woefully impoverished. 

 

Yes, I agree. Which is why I prefer Spanish. A little more specific. It's not my native tongue, but I love to learn it and speak it. 

 

/offtopic

Posted

We have this in common. Spanish, after godly things, is my passion.Though it's more fitting for me to pepper my English with pretentious little French trifles. (It fits my general cold unsociableness. :p )

Posted

You mean how if someone criticizes the Roman Catholic Church it's "Anti-Catholic" but if it's the Orthodox Church or Eastern Catholics that are criticized, it's perfectly okay? 

 

I think Apo made a great point bringing up that example. Take the beam out of your own eye before your remove the speak in your brother's (this is just a general statement, not directed at you).

 

 

That'd be a good point if the very purpose of this thread was not about the Orthodox hierarchy criticizing the Anglicans for being spiritually feckless.  In which case I think that pointing out that the Anglicans have been less supportive of murderous, authoritarians thugs than the Orthodox hierarchy is very, very fair.  

KnightofChrist
Posted

Actually, if you look at archives, you'll find a few instances where this has happened, including one moment where the Coptic Pope of Alexandria was called an "anti-pope." 

 

As a Catholic, you are more than welcome to disagree with Eastern theology. But I do get upset when I see scandals going on in the Roman Catholic Church and people commenting on status updates, "I'm so sick of the attacks on my church". Attacks on your church? Are you serious? And that somehow makes you Anti-Catholic...

 

...Then, some Catholics turn around and criticize the Orthodox Church, like it's the only Church in history to ever persecute or victimize people or do something stupid. 

 

If Mortify wants to lump all Russian hierarchs together, am I allowed to lump all priests together? Or does that make me Anti-Catholic? And if it does, is Mortify also Anti (At least Russian) Orthodox? Or is it "justified" somehow?

 

Judging and lumping all the Russian Orthodox hierarchy together is Anti-Orthodox, maybe even a bit bigoted.
 

Posted

Does admitting lack of respect for most hierarchs, regardless of Rite or denomination, alter the situation in our dialogue?

 

 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...