Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Would you eat a meal cooked specifically for you on a Friday in lent if it contained meat?  

40 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Anastasia13
Posted

If a meal was prepared specifically with you in mind out of love for you, but it contained meat products and was prepared on a Friday in lent, would you eat the meal or decline? Why or why not?

 

This is not a scenario where you could eat parts of the meal (for instance meat lasagna where the meat cannot be separated from the dish)

 


Assuming I was able to fast., if it is an act of love to the other, I would find a way to eat it.

Posted

But it IS important.  This is not some stranger, as someone pointed out this is your wife, your pregnant wife at that, one flesh and that whole deal.  She made a mistake.    Call the Bishop if you must but eat the meal.

 

Look at it on the other side:

 

This is not some stranger. This is someone who knows me intimately and is extremely understanding and knowledgeable of my desire to fulfill the laws of fasting and abstinence. One of her biggest goals in life is to help me to get to heaven. She knows that I would love to eat the meal if it weren't friday, and that my choosing not to eat the meal is no reflection on her cooking or my gratitude for her act of service. So why is declining the meal such a rude and awful thing to do? If anyone in the world could understand that I can't eat the meal for religious reasons it would be her, my wife who knows me extremely well.

 

 

If it were a Friday outside of lent, I would certainly make another act of penance or fasting as permitted by the USCCB, but during lent there is no such exception given.

Posted

Tact is also fairly clear -- at least in my mind.

I know at least one other person has said it: eat what is set before you and give thanks to God for the nourishment of your body. The disposition of your heart is of greater importance than your scrupulous following of every law and command.

 

Scrupulosity in such a case would more be in line with going to confession because while eating your single piece of broccoli you permitted yourself to eat on a friday, a piece of dried and cracked skin from your lips entered your mouth and you were afraid that skin cells would be considered meat and you might now be in mortal sin.

 

 

Declining a meal that clearly has unavoidable meat products in it on a Friday in lent is not in any way scrupulous.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Look at it on the other side:

 

This is not some stranger. This is someone who knows me intimately and is extremely understanding and knowledgeable of my desire to fulfill the laws of fasting and abstinence. One of her biggest goals in life is to help me to get to heaven. She knows that I would love to eat the meal if it weren't friday, and that my choosing not to eat the meal is no reflection on her cooking or my gratitude for her act of service. So why is declining the meal such a rude and awful thing to do? If anyone in the world could understand that I can't eat the meal for religious reasons it would be her, my wife who knows me extremely well.

 

 

If it were a Friday outside of lent, I would certainly make another act of penance or fasting as permitted by the USCCB, but during lent there is no such exception given.

I think this is extremely reasonable.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Look at it on the other side:

 

This is not some stranger. This is someone who knows me intimately and is extremely understanding and knowledgeable of my desire to fulfill the laws of fasting and abstinence. One of her biggest goals in life is to help me to get to heaven. She knows that I would love to eat the meal if it weren't friday, and that my choosing not to eat the meal is no reflection on her cooking or my gratitude for her act of service. So why is declining the meal such a rude and awful thing to do? If anyone in the world could understand that I can't eat the meal for religious reasons it would be her, my wife who knows me extremely well.

 

 

If it were a Friday outside of lent, I would certainly make another act of penance or fasting as permitted by the USCCB, but during lent there is no such exception given.

 

I think it really just depends on your wife's reaction.  She knows you well, but you also know her well.  If not eating the meal isn't a big deal to her, if you kindly say that you appreciate her effort and you'd like to put it in the fridge for tomorrow night or tomorrow's lunch, I definitely see how you can refuse and it be okay.  If she spent a normal amount of time making dinner and just forgot it was Friday, that's one thing.  But like, if she spent her whole day slaving over a turduckin lasagna because it's your absolute favorite and you guys were having a rough week so she was trying to do something especially nice for you but completely forgot it's a Friday...then that's a situation where I'd say to suck it up for the good of the relationship and do another penance or sacrifice.  

Maybe one reason why some people are getting so frustrated with your refusal is because "made a meal especially for you" kinda sounds more like the turduckin lasagna than nuking a beef and bean burrito in the microwave for you...ya know?  

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Turducken is overrated. We did one for Thanksgiving once years ago.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Turducken is overrated. We did one for Thanksgiving once years ago.

 

Ah, but Turducken Lasagna?  That, my friend, takes talent.   :hehe2:

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Ah, but Turducken Lasagna?  That, my friend, takes talent.   :hehe2:

Hm, perhaps. Perhaps.

Posted

  Maybe one reason why some people are getting so frustrated with your refusal is because "made a meal especially for you" kinda sounds more like the turduckin lasagna than nuking a beef and bean burrito in the microwave for you...ya know?  

Maybe I'll clarify that a bit then, good point. I'm not talking prime rib, yorkshire pudding, a glass of red wine and a nice salad that's for sure!

 

 

It was frozen hashbrowns, cheese, and one other thing that I forget all mixed together with cream of chicken (not fake chicken broth bullion cubes, but cream of chicken containing bits of chicken meat) and thrown in the oven to bake for a bit. She had me in mind when making it and wouldn't have cooked it otherwise. My guesstimate is prep time 10-15 minutes bake time 20-30 minutes.

Posted (edited)

Shut up and eat your dinner.
Don't forget to thank God and kiss your wife for taking such good care of your sorry rear end

Of course if you are served a home cooked meal you like it. (And show a little gratitude)

Edited by add
OnlySunshine
Posted

Maybe I'll clarify that a bit then, good point. I'm not talking prime rib, yorkshire pudding, a glass of red wine and a nice salad that's for sure!

 

 

It was frozen hashbrowns, cheese, and one other thing that I forget all mixed together with cream of chicken (not fake chicken broth bullion cubes, but cream of chicken containing bits of chicken meat) and thrown in the oven to bake for a bit. She had me in mind when making it and wouldn't have cooked it otherwise. My guesstimate is prep time 10-15 minutes bake time 20-30 minutes.

 


If it was just bits of chicken like in chicken noodle soup and not great big pieces, wouldn't that be OK?

 

http://www.americancatholic.org/features/lent/lentrules.aspx

 


Abstinence forbids the use of meat, but not of eggs, milk products or condiments made of animal fat.

Abstinence does not include meat juices and liquid foods made from meat.
Thus, such foods as chicken broth, consomme, soups cooked or flavored
with meat
, meat gravies or sauces, as well as seasonings or condiments
made from animal fat are not forbidden. So it is permissible to use
margarine and lard. Even bacon drippings which contain little bits of
meat
may be poured over lettuce as seasoning.

 

 

Posted


If it was just bits of chicken like in chicken noodle soup and not great big pieces, wouldn't that be OK?

 

http://www.americancatholic.org/features/lent/lentrules.aspx

 


 

 

I've seen that off of American Catholic before, but I've never seen a source from an authoritative figure on the matter (I.E, USCCB according to Canon Law). I don't see how pieces of bacon can be seen as not a meat product. With that same logic, you can have meat on Friday as long as the amount of meat is insubstantial to the overall meal.

 

Throw some minced chicken in some cheese and use the cheese on your nacho's, call the chicken a part of the cheese sauce and you can get away with it? Doesn't seem to be line with Canon Law on abstinence.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I've seen that off of American Catholic before, but I've never seen a source from an authoritative figure on the matter (I.E, USCCB according to Canon Law). I don't see how pieces of bacon can be seen as not a meat product. With that same logic, you can have meat on Friday as long as the amount of meat is insubstantial to the overall meal.

 

Throw some minced chicken in some cheese and use the cheese on your nacho's, call the chicken a part of the cheese sauce and you can get away with it? Doesn't seem to be line with Canon Law on abstinence.

I am also a little skeptical. I would like to know where they get that from, at the very least.

CatholicCid
Posted

The previous link is extrapolating on a Q&A from the USCCB.  

Q.  I understand that all the Fridays of Lent are days of abstinence from meat, but I'm not sure what is classified as meat.  Does meat include chicken and dairy products?

A.  Abstinence laws consider that meat comes only from animals such as chickens, cows, sheep or pigs --- all of which live on land. Birds are also considered meat. Abstinence does not include meat juices and liquid foods made from meat.  Thus, such foods as chicken broth, consomme, soups cooked or flavored with meat, meat gravies or sauces, as well as seasonings or condiments made from animal fat are technically not forbidden.  However, moral theologians have traditionally taught that we should abstain from all animal-derived products (except foods such as gelatin, butter, cheese and eggs, which do not have any meat taste).  Fish are a different category of animal.  Salt and freshwater species of fish, amphibians, reptiles, (cold-blooded animals) and shellfish are permitted.

http://www.usccb.org/prayer-and-worship/liturgical-resources/lent/questions-and-answers-about-lent.cfm

 

I would believe their interpretation of "bacon drippings which contain little pieces of meat" is at best ambiguous and, most likely strays from the generous allowance of "meat juices and liquid foods made from meat."

Nihil Obstat
Posted

The previous link is extrapolating on a Q&A from the USCCB.  
http://www.usccb.org/prayer-and-worship/liturgical-resources/lent/questions-and-answers-about-lent.cfm
 
I would believe their interpretation of "bacon drippings which contain little pieces of meat" is at best ambiguous and, most likely strays from the generous allowance of "meat juices and liquid foods made from meat."

That USCCB quote also seems to indicate that, while soups flavoured from meat and whatnot, while perhaps not "technically" breaking the fast, also do not truly keep the spirit of the fast. That is what I took from it, at least.

I agree that extrapolating drippings with pieces of meat in it is a bit of a stretch.

CatholicCid
Posted (edited)

(Took too long to edit)

 

 

Edit: This portion from the USCCB Q&A might also be of use to this topic.

Q.  Are there exemptions other than for age from the requirement to fast on Ash Wednesday and Good Friday?

A.  Those that are excused from fast and abstinence outside the age limits include the physically or mentally ill including individuals suffering from chronic illnesses such as diabetes.  Also excluded are pregnant or nursing women.  In all cases, common sense should prevail, and ill persons should not further jeopardize their health by fasting.

 

That being said, the Q&A also makes it clear that the "prescribed days of fast and abstinence on Ash Wednesday and Good Friday, and the days of abstinence every Friday of Lent" are regulated by the Church.

 

So, to the general poll question, I selected "No", but a "No" that would be done in all charity, goodwill, and catechesis. At the same time, common sense should prevail. Given the more specific knowledge Slappo has provided, I don't think it is necessary to abstain from meat if, as some seem to suggest, it could risk upsetting one's marriage. At the same time, the rules of the fast aren't flippant suggestions from the Church, but are things which are to be taken with the most seriousness. We mustn't be overly scrupulous, but we mustn't also fall into laxity. 

 

So, a "No" it is for me. While we should be thankful for what is set before us, this thankful-ness should include the opportunity the Church has set before us and bound us to in uniting in a common sacrifice as one Church in union with Christ on the cross.

 

[edit II]

Nihil,

I would agree. The Q&A seems to provide us with the legalistic approach. But, in doing so, it also reminds us of the spirit of the matter. The question following the one I original quoted addresses this somewhat in it's answer: "Abstaining from meat and other indulgences during Lent is a penitential practice.  On the Fridays of Lent, we remember the sacrifice of Christ on Good Friday and unite ourselves with that sacrifice through abstinence and prayer."

Edited by CatholicCid
Nihil Obstat
Posted

I feel that that "common sense" passage there applies more specifically to health, and those who are exempt from fasting for those reasons.

Posted

Maybe I'll clarify that a bit then, good point. I'm not talking prime rib, yorkshire pudding, a glass of red wine and a nice salad that's for sure!

 

 

It was frozen hashbrowns, cheese, and one other thing that I forget all mixed together with cream of chicken (not fake chicken broth bullion cubes, but cream of chicken containing bits of chicken meat) and thrown in the oven to bake for a bit. She had me in mind when making it and wouldn't have cooked it otherwise. My guesstimate is prep time 10-15 minutes bake time 20-30 minutes.

 


that sounds really good to me. 

CatholicCid
Posted (edited)

I feel that that "common sense" passage there applies more specifically to health, and those who are exempt from fasting for those reasons.

 

Yes, I was being a bit loose with that passage and extrapolating a little of my own  :hehe2:

Perhaps an argued could be made for the "spiritually" ill, or the couple in a marriage where this decision (husband eating a meal, prepared by the wife, with meat on a Lenten Friday) risks actually destroying the marriage. This is where the common sense would come in, I think.

 

[In my previous post, when I said "upsetting one's marriage", this was the scenario I was imagining]

Edited by CatholicCid
OnlySunshine
Posted

To me, eating chicken soup or chicken broth is kind of cheating, too.  I'm just going by what the guidelines say.  I eat eggs, cheese, butter, and milk but I don't eat chicken soups or broths on Fridays.  I LOVE fish, though!  I had grilled tilapia tonight.  :)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...