Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Basilisa Marie
Posted

The Eastern Churches have had married clergy for 2,000 years and seem to be able to make it work.

 

Yeah, they've got 2000 years of practice on us. 

Posted

The homosexual issue, that is magnified by 1000% when it comes to the way the media handles the Church really began, from what I have been told by clergy, after Vatican II. The seminary became a place where homosexual men were able to hide as the social mores of the time questioned why a man at the age of 22 or 25 or 30 was still unmarried. 

 

The seminaries went from devotion to Church to self actualization. I know a few men who entered the seminary in the late 60's/ 70's for this reason. They left, married, had children and then left their families to pursue what they couldn't in those times. One man I know was in the seminary in the late 70's in Italy. He came to the US, had an extremely successful career and then out of nowhere, left his wife and 3 children to be "himself."

 

The other issue we have today is men becoming Priests as a step up from poverty, especially in 3rd world countries. You are guaranteed 3 squares, money, clean clothing, education, etc. We have seen this happen over and over again, as in the case of the Pastor of Our Lady of Las Vegas a few years back.

 

The bar, prior to Vatican II, was very high to join the Priesthood. With the move to open the church it allowed far more in than it bargained for.

 

As for why Priests cannot marry. For the 1st 400 years they were allowed. The issue was that their dedication to the flock was distracted by the need to be dedicated to their own families. So for the last 1600 years or so, this was ended as you had Pastors willing Church property to their families.

 

This is not a bash on Vatican II, but in so many cases we have an entire generation not even knowing what a Nun is. Before Vatican II Nuns were dedicated to education, healthcare and then after Vatican II it was opened up to almost anything. You have children in Catholic schools who have never, ever seen a Nun. They are taught by lay people who in many cases are not excellent or even good representatives of the Church. This saddens me to no end. 

 

 

Posted

Very informative post...Thanks St. Michael...Godbless pham...

Posted

The early Church did have married bishops, and some of those bishops had children after their elevation to the episcopate (e.g., the father of St. Gregory of Nazianzus).  The Eastern Churches only restricted the office of bishop to monastics at the Quinisext Council, while in the same canons affirming the right of presbyters and deacons to live with their wives and to continue conjugal relations subject only to the marital fast.

 

What is "the marital fast"?



The life of a US diocesan priest is pretty unusual as priesthood goes.

 

How so?

Posted (edited)

^^ Abstinence isn't just for meat...

 

As for the life of US diocesan priests being unusual... do some reading about guys like Archbishop Ireland from my own state of Minnesota, and how his influence radically changed the church in the US. You'll begin to see how our presbyterate is very different. This "Americanism" was more or less informally regarded as heretical, and was responsible for the mass exodus of Eastern Catholics to the Orthodox churches.

 

In effect a number of the bishops here decided they wanted their own unique church rather than a collection of other churches and traditions coming over from Europe. Rather than simply wait and let the faith in America develop organically, they chose to restructure almost everything, including how church property works, tinkering with Canon law, and forcing uniform practice on Eastern Catholics in particular. As such, the life of priests in the US has been pretty different. It was a very rough transition.

Edited by arfink
Posted

^^ Abstinence isn't just for meat...

 

Obviously. But "THE marital fast" makes it sound like there are certain times that couples are supposed to abstain. Are there? What are the reasons? I've never heard of this.

 

As for the life of US diocesan priests being unusual... do some reading about guys like Archbishop Ireland from my own state of Minnesota, and how his influence radically changed the church in the US. You'll begin to see how our presbyterate is very different. This "Americanism" was more or less informally regarded as heretical, and was responsible for the mass exodus of Eastern Catholics to the Orthodox churches.

 

Dude, I come in here so people can explain things to me. It's a way of socializing while also learning. I've got enough reading to do for my thesis/diss! I might get to this in 5 or 6 years... In the meantime, I'll likely die of curiosity.

Posted

Obviously. But "THE marital fast" makes it sound like there are certain times that couples are supposed to abstain. Are there? What are the reasons? I've never heard of this.

 

 

Dude, I come in here so people can explain things to me. It's a way of socializing while also learning. I've got enough reading to do for my thesis/diss! I might get to this in 5 or 6 years... In the meantime, I'll likely die of curiosity.

 

My bad.

 

The US diocesan priest is more isolated than other priests, especially today. They are isolated from fellow priests, from the bishop, from their own congregations, from the Universal church. The diocesan priesthood here has become a very lone wolf kind of approach. It's taken a while to get to this point, and it's not that way in other countries and not that way for Eastern Catholics. I know a couple of priests in Ghana who are far more deeply connected with their people than most US diocesan priests are, and who know their bishop on a very personal level. The US presbyterate has a reputation for not being like this. Priests are given orders from the chancery, who get their orders from the bishop. The repeated scandals have made priests largely inaccessible: they fear false accusation in the course of their duties, and the people in the parish suffer as the isolation continues to grow.

 

This comes from the desire to have a very uniform notion how priests and parishes ought to be. Sure, uniformity is nice, but people can go nuts over this stuff. Of course, this is just my understanding, based on my time in seminary. It comes from talking with men in formation, talking with priests in connection with the seminary program, talking with priests who are just friends. The diocesan life in the US is just very different from all other kinds of priesthood.

Posted

My bad.

 

The US diocesan priest is more isolated than other priests, especially today. They are isolated from fellow priests, from the bishop, from their own congregations, from the Universal church. The diocesan priesthood here has become a very lone wolf kind of approach. It's taken a while to get to this point, and it's not that way in other countries and not that way for Eastern Catholics. I know a couple of priests in Ghana who are far more deeply connected with their people than most US diocesan priests are, and who know their bishop on a very personal level. The US presbyterate has a reputation for not being like this. Priests are given orders from the chancery, who get their orders from the bishop. The repeated scandals have made priests largely inaccessible: they fear false accusation in the course of their duties, and the people in the parish suffer as the isolation continues to grow.

 

This comes from the desire to have a very uniform notion how priests and parishes ought to be. Sure, uniformity is nice, but people can go nuts over this stuff. Of course, this is just my understanding, based on my time in seminary. It comes from talking with men in formation, talking with priests in connection with the seminary program, talking with priests who are just friends. The diocesan life in the US is just very different from all other kinds of priesthood.

 

Aha. Very informative. Thank you!

 

I can see how that would be an "Americanized" version of the priesthood, given our obsession with standardization, bureaucracy, and assembly-line-like efficiency.

 

I thought, however, that I'd heard stories of European priests in times past being assigned to rather isolated posts. Like St. John Vianney, for example. Was that just more rare there/then? Maybe they only sent the super-strong to such posts, whereas in the US essentially every priest is expected to endure in such isolation?

Posted

Aha. Very informative. Thank you!

 

I can see how that would be an "Americanized" version of the priesthood, given our obsession with standardization, bureaucracy, and assembly-line-like efficiency.

 

I thought, however, that I'd heard stories of European priests in times past being assigned to rather isolated posts. Like St. John Vianney, for example. Was that just more rare there/then? Maybe they only sent the super-strong to such posts, whereas in the US essentially every priest is expected to endure in such isolation?

 

I'm not saying there were no isolated priests before the American trends got going. It just wasn't the norm, and people knew it should not be. Here it's the norm to be isolated.

Debra Little
Posted

it has been old for a long long time.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

^^ Abstinence isn't just for meat...

 

As for the life of US diocesan priests being unusual... do some reading about guys like Archbishop Ireland from my own state of Minnesota, and how his influence radically changed the church in the US. You'll begin to see how our presbyterate is very different. This "Americanism" was more or less informally regarded as heretical, and was responsible for the mass exodus of Eastern Catholics to the Orthodox churches.

 

In effect a number of the bishops here decided they wanted their own unique church rather than a collection of other churches and traditions coming over from Europe. Rather than simply wait and let the faith in America develop organically, they chose to restructure almost everything, including how church property works, tinkering with Canon law, and forcing uniform practice on Eastern Catholics in particular. As such, the life of priests in the US has been pretty different. It was a very rough transition.

I say it whenever it comes up, Archbishop Ireland had a lot to answer for after he passed. It makes me extremely mad reading about how he treated Alexis Toth.

Posted

Obviously. But "THE marital fast" makes it sound like there are certain times that couples are supposed to abstain. Are there? What are the reasons? I've never heard of this.

All married couples (and not just a priest and his wife) are supposed to abstain from sexual relations during the Church's four fasting seasons, as well as on the weekly Wednesday and Friday fasts, and during the paschal season of Great and Holy Week. Married couples are also supposed to fast from marital relations during the 24 hours prior to the reception of Holy Communion.



The marital fast is about dedicating oneself to prayer, and is founded upon the teaching of St. Paul in scripture (1 Cor. 7:5).

Posted (edited)

All married couples (and not just a priest and his wife) are supposed to abstain from sexual relations during the Church's four fasting seasons, as well as on the weekly Wednesday and Friday fasts, and during the paschal season of Great and Holy Week. Married couples are also supposed to fast from marital relations during the 24 hours prior to the reception of Holy Communion.



The marital fast is about dedicating oneself to prayer, and is founded upon the teaching of St. Paul in scripture (1 Cor. 7:5).

 

OMG!!! What if you go to daily Mass?!?!?!

 

And if you observe NFP, you abstain for half the month already. People doing this and NFP would be able to have sex less than half the year!

 

EDIT: You know, dUSt, "O.M.G." can just as easily abbreviate "oh my gosh!" as "oh my G—". I find that philter incredibly annoying!

Edited by curiousing
Posted

OMG!!! What if you go to daily Mass?!?!?!

 

And if you observe NFP, you abstain for half the month already. People doing this and NFP would be able to have sex less than half the year!

 

EDIT: You know, dUSt, "O.M.G." can just as easily abbreviate "oh my gosh!" as "oh my G—". I find that philter incredibly annoying!

 

Assuming people have sex 3 times a week, that's 156 times a year...less than half the year.

Posted (edited)

OMG!!! What if you go to daily Mass?!?!?!

 

And if you observe NFP, you abstain for half the month already. People doing this and NFP would be able to have sex less than half the year!

If you go to daily mass, which by the way is not an Eastern custom, you would be abstaining from marital relations a lot.  As far as NFP is concerned, its motivation (i.e., spacing births) is not an Eastern Christian concern; and moreover, it is not a practice founded upon the dominical or patristic tradition.  The marital fast is not about spacing births or avoiding the responsibility of having children; instead, it is about dedicating oneself to prayer and uniting oneself to the liturgical cycles of the Church.  People simply keeping the marital fast will have sex less than half the year without doing NFP, because there are over 200 days of fasting in the Byzantine liturgical calendar.

Edited by Apotheoun
Posted

 

Assuming people have sex 3 times a week, that's 156 times a year...less than half the year.

 

1) What an assumption. :-P

 

2) Now do the math to subtract all the weeks one wouldn't be allowed to have marital relations if observing both marital fasts and NFP. Less than a quarter? Big difference!

 

3) There's also a big difference to the couple in only actually doing it less than half the year and being ALLOWED to do it less than half the year. I'm not saying it's necessarily a bad thing, but marital fasts + NFP seems like it might be overkill.



If you go to daily mass, which by the way is not an Eastern custom, you would be abstaining from marital relations a lot.  As far as NFP is concerned, its motivation (i.e., spacing births) is not an Eastern Christian concern; and moreover, it is not a practice founded upon the dominical or patristic tradition.  The marital fast is not about spacing births or avoiding the responsibility of having children; instead, it is about dedicating oneself to prayer and uniting oneself to the liturgical cycles of the Church.  People simply keeping the marital fast will have sex less than half the year without doing NFP, because there are over 200 days of fasting in the Byzantine liturgical calendar.

 

Wait. I thought this marital fast thing was in the Roman Catholic tradition. Are you saying it's not? It's only Eastern Orthodox?

 

And what is the point of fasting over half the year? That seems like overkill to me, too. Fasts—or anything, for that matter—lose their "specialness", i.e., their ability to "lift" a person spiritually, if they're done all the time. They just become routine...

Posted

1) What an assumption. :-P

 

Yeah, I imagine it's a little too generous of an assumption on average.

Posted

If you go to daily mass, which by the way is not an Eastern custom, you would be abstaining from marital relations a lot.  As far as NFP is concerned, its motivation (i.e., spacing births) is not an Eastern Christian concern; and moreover, it is not a practice founded upon the dominical or patristic tradition.  The marital fast is not about spacing births or avoiding the responsibility of having children; instead, it is about dedicating oneself to prayer and uniting oneself to the liturgical cycles of the Church.  People simply keeping the marital fast will have sex less than half the year without doing NFP, because there are over 200 days of fasting in the Byzantine liturgical calendar.

 


glad i'm not an Eastern Christian.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Latin Catholics are not bound to observe a marital fast. :)

Posted

. . .

 

Wait. I thought this marital fast thing was in the Roman Catholic tradition. Are you saying it's not? It's only Eastern Orthodox?

 

And what is the point of fasting over half the year? That seems like overkill to me, too. Fasts—or anything, for that matter—lose their "specialness", i.e., their ability to "lift" a person spiritually, if they're done all the time. They just become routine...

The marital fast was common to both East and West, but - to my knowledge - it is no longer officially observed in the West.

 

Evidently the Church Fathers, and the overall tradition of the Church, which set aside over half the year for fasting did not see it as overkill. I guess the Church Fathers would be out-of-step with today's culture.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...