StMichael Posted March 4, 2013 Posted March 4, 2013 Somewhat stumped on what to advise. Here is the situation. A friend has asked for advice regarding their children. The parents attend a Church that is very much in keeping with the practice of mass that by all accounts is orthodox, their children, however attend a Catholic school that the Church associated with that school is very disobedient. The children attend mass at the, best way to put it, orthodox church but every Friday the children attend mass at the disobedient church where they are forced to hold hands during the Lord's Prayer, etc. One of their children will be receiving their first Holy Communion this year and it is creating an issue for the child where they are forced at their school to do one thing and then other Churches are not. My advice at first was for the parents to speak to the Pastor of the disobedient Church and see why they function in ways that is not outlined, etc. But I am not sure this is the right path. The other is to find another Catholic school, but that would mean leaving a good school, the children's friends, etc I have been exposed to these Churches that act more protestant than anything else, and my thoughts is that the Pastor will not change the behavior of altar servers holding hands with the Priest during the Lord's Prayer, etc. Really want to advise them properly and hope some of you can help.
Autumn Dusk Posted March 4, 2013 Posted March 4, 2013 If the only problem is holding hands during the Our Father the parents need to "suck it up". Also, the parents should teach their children to fold their hands during the Our Father and not let other children persuade them to hold hands, if that's what the parents want. This shouldn't be a problem if they go as a family. They could also go to the Bishop with their concerns. The church and the school isn't going away, if the kids are otherwise happy and well educated then the minor changes in Mass are something to deal with secondary. I don't buy the whole "confused kid" thing. If the kid isn't autistic or under duress of some other mental problem then they will be fine.
franciscanheart Posted March 4, 2013 Posted March 4, 2013 Leaving the church helps no one. I'd suggest they talk with the priest (emphasis on talk WITH) and simply advise their children not to hold hands.
StMichael Posted March 5, 2013 Author Posted March 5, 2013 The family attends, as a family, Church every Sunday. The children are not seeking to hold hands, but when they are at mass on Friday in their school, which is not with the parents, their teachers are forcing them to hold hands. The children have been corrected by the teacher to do so, in a public way. The Priest stands behind the altar holding hands with the altar servers and encourages standing in the aisle to hold hands. It has become an issue for the family and just seeing what I can offer them other than arming themselves with information on the mass and speak with the Pastor. If the only problem is holding hands during the Our Father the parents need to "suck it up". Also, the parents should teach their children to fold their hands during the Our Father and not let other children persuade them to hold hands, if that's what the parents want. This shouldn't be a problem if they go as a family. They could also go to the Bishop with their concerns. The church and the school isn't going away, if the kids are otherwise happy and well educated then the minor changes in Mass are something to deal with secondary. I don't buy the whole "confused kid" thing. If the kid isn't autistic or under duress of some other mental problem then they will be fine.
Autumn Dusk Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 The family attends, as a family, Church every Sunday. The children are not seeking to hold hands, but when they are at mass on Friday in their school, which is not with the parents, their teachers are forcing them to hold hands. The children have been corrected by the teacher to do so, in a public way. The Priest stands behind the altar holding hands with the altar servers and encourages standing in the aisle to hold hands. It has become an issue for the family and just seeing what I can offer them other than arming themselves with information on the mass and speak with the Pastor. Forcing the children to hold hands is problematic besides Mass. For any issues other than safety children should not be forced to hold hands. Public admonishment is utterly unacceptable for any reason!!!!! I don't think this has much to do with Mass but how the children are treated in general.
Lilllabettt Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 Public admonishment is utterly unacceptable for any reason!!!!! lol. for real? how long since you were in school? I agree that apart from safety children should not be required to touch each other.
Autumn Dusk Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 lol. for real? how long since you were in school? I agree that apart from safety children should not be required to touch each other. I should of said public embarassment. Still, around here, and with all my education major friends, it was correct in person, praise in pubic. Poster makes it sound like they are being shamed
Slappo Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 The family attends, as a family, Church every Sunday. The children are not seeking to hold hands, but when they are at mass on Friday in their school, which is not with the parents, their teachers are forcing them to hold hands. The children have been corrected by the teacher to do so, in a public way. Sounds like the family needs to talk to the teacher as well, not just the priest. As Autumn Dusk said, it is highly inappropriate for the teacher to force the children to hold hands.
StMichael Posted March 5, 2013 Author Posted March 5, 2013 Yes, the children are being shamed into holding hands. I should of said public embarassment. Still, around here, and with all my education major friends, it was correct in person, praise in pubic. Poster makes it sound like they are being shamed
Tufsoles Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 (edited) This is happening at school in where I live. I do suggest like everyone else talk to your priest and write to your bishop with your concerns. It does help. I have had to do with a particular person( he wasn't running a particular program in a certain manner) in the diocese and it fixed the issue and it does make people "play nice" Also talk to the head of the school about the issue because the more involved the better educated we become and prevent something like this to happen again. Edited March 5, 2013 by Tufsoles
Apotheoun Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 Sounds like the family needs to talk to the teacher as well, not just the priest. As Autumn Dusk said, it is highly inappropriate for the teacher to force the children to hold hands. I agree, it sounds like they should talk to the teacher.
Honour Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 I can't believe so many people are against children holding hands in general. I don't get it.
Nihil Obstat Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 I can't believe so many people are against children holding hands in general. I don't get it. I see nothing in the missal directing this practice.
cmotherofpirl Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 We don't add things to the Mass because it makes some people feel good. We are not protestants. Hand-holding is not part of the Catholic Mass. http://wdtprs.com/blog/2011/05/quaeritur-our-father-hand-holding-fr-z-rants/ and Concerning holding hands in the Eucharistic Liturgy the Congregation for Divine Worship in Rome responded as follows: QUERY: In some places there is a current practice whereby those taking part in the Mass replace the giving of the sign of peace at the deacon’s invitation by holding hands during the singing of the Lord’s Prayer. Is this acceptable? REPLY: The prolonged holding of hands is of itself a sign of communion rather than of peace. Further, it is a liturgical gesture introduced spontaneously but on personal initiative; it is not in the rubrics. Nor is there any clear explanation of why the sign of peace at the invitation: “Let us offer each other the sign of peace†should be supplanted in order to bring a different gesture with less meaning into another part of the Mass: the sign of peace is filled with meaning, graciousness, and Christian inspiration. Any substitution for it must be repudiated: Notitiae 11 (1975) 226. [Notitiae is the journal of the Congregation in which its official interpretations of the rubrics are published.]
morostheos Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 (edited) Honestly, holding hands during the Our Father is not a grave sacrilege. Sure, it's not in the GIRM, but I can think of many worse abuses I have seen at school Masses. While it is not an official posture/action within the missal, what is in the missal in the importance of the faithful avoiding any appearance of singularity or division. I personally think the parents should explain that the preferred posture is to keep their hands folded in prayer during the Lord's Prayer, but out of respect for the authority of their teachers and priest at school they should follow the instructions of their teacher while they are at school. Edited to add: I do think it would be appropriate for the parents to voice their concern to the teacher and priest, but I think that should be done separate from the children and their immediate actions. The ideal situation would be catechesis of the school administration and the priest regarding the topic so that they choose to discontinue holding hands and explain to the children why they are doing so. Getting in a battle about what is the proper posture and involving the children will not accomplish this. Edited March 6, 2013 by morostheos
Basilisa Marie Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 (edited) There are so many bigger, more important things than holding hands during the Our Father. If that's the only problem, I personally find it a rather ridiculous thing to pull your kids out of school over. I also don't think one parent complaint is going to change the practice in the church. That being said, if it's a really big deal to the parents, I'd first talk to the teacher, and let her or him know that their kid feels uncomfortable holding hands during the Our Father, and since it's not a required liturgical posture (i.e. it's not in any missal ever), they'd prefer that the kid was allowed to quietly fold his hands instead of holding hands. If the teacher refuses, then go to the priest. The teacher shouldn't be forcing the kid to hold hands during the Our Father, but it's not something to go to the priest over unless you can't resolve it between parents and teacher. Edit: Also - I think it's also important to make sure the authority of the teacher isn't being undermined in the mind of the kid. It wouldn't be good for the kid to think that anytime the teacher does something he or she doesn't like he can go to mom and dad and get the teacher overruled. Edited March 6, 2013 by Basilisa Marie
Autumn Dusk Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 I can't believe so many people are against children holding hands in general. I don't get it. Children should be allowed to show affection at will, and I think they don't do it enough these days. HOWEVER forcing children to hold hands against their will breaks just about every rule of good teaching and probably some "protecting God's children" rules, too.
StMichael Posted March 6, 2013 Author Posted March 6, 2013 (edited) This isn't an issue of affection or dislike for their classmates, etc. This is about being forced to hold hands during the Our Father which is not prescribed. It is not mandated by Rome and is an addition to the mass that is against Canon law. Furthermore, the children are being raised Roman Catholic, in practice as well as word. This is not instilling "universal" whatsoever as you have 2 churches acting very differently, one respectful and solemn, the other like a party. To witness this is to believe you are not at a Catholic Church. The Priest stands behind the altar holding hands with some 4 altar servers. All facing forward. The congregants are encouraged to stand in the aisle and hold hands during the prayer. Then at the conclusion, in unison, these embraced hands are lifted in the air. I will not attend a Church that is so disobedient. And have witnessed this abuse in the West far too much, including a deacon presiding over the Mass while the Priests sat with the congregants and this guy self-communicated. I could go on. Thankfully, I found other Churches that have said to the congregants not to hold hands, etc. While I bite my lip on this one, the parents don't know what to do. And quite frankly it shouldn't be this difficult, nor dismissed as folly, but will share some of your thoughts with them and hope that some resolution can be found. (EDIT) And thank you all for chiming in. Children should be allowed to show affection at will, and I think they don't do it enough these days. HOWEVER forcing children to hold hands against their will breaks just about every rule of good teaching and probably some "protecting God's children" rules, too. Edited March 6, 2013 by StMichael
Autumn Dusk Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 This isn't an issue of affection or dislike for their classmates, etc. This is about being forced to hold hands during the Our Father which is not prescribed. It is not mandated by Rome and is an addition to the mass that is against Canon law. Furthermore, the children are being raised Roman Catholic, in practice as well as word. This is not instilling "universal" whatsoever as you have 2 churches acting very differently, one respectful and solemn, the other like a party. To witness this is to believe you are not at a Catholic Church. The Priest stands behind the altar holding hands with some 4 altar servers. All facing forward. The congregants are encouraged to stand in the aisle and hold hands during the prayer. Then at the conclusion, in unison, these embraced hands are lifted in the air. I will not attend a Church that is so disobedient. And have witnessed this abuse in the West far too much, including a deacon presiding over the Mass while the Priests sat with the congregants and this guy self-communicated. I could go on. Thankfully, I found other Churches that have said to the congregants not to hold hands, etc. While I bite my lip on this one, the parents don't know what to do. And quite frankly it shouldn't be this difficult, nor dismissed as folly, but will share some of your thoughts with them and hope that some resolution can be found. (EDIT) And thank you all for chiming in. You may not want to go, but all things considered holding hands during the Our Father, even if the priest does is NOT the end of the world. What IS of concern to most of us is the disregard the teachers are giving to the children by having them hold hands. If, as a first grader, I did something at school that my parent didn't want for a religious reason...and that I, as a child also felt uncomfortable with, then the instructor should respect that. Their are jewish, athiest and protestant children in my friend's daughter's Catholic school. They are respectful but often choose to sit quietly rather than kneel. The church respect that they are a different religion and doesn't force them into positions that they are not comfortable with EVEN IF IT IS RUBRICS. Not only that, but they often arrange the students boy-girl to avoid problems. I would of died before holding hands with a boy as a 1st grader
StMichael Posted March 6, 2013 Author Posted March 6, 2013 Autumn, none of this might be end of the world, but this starts with the Pastor, otherwise why else would 1st grade, 2nd grade teachers see the need to indoctrinate these children into a way not the way of the Church. This starts at the top, not the bottom and if it were me, I would simply have a talk with the Pastor as to where is this directive coming from with documentation showing otherwise. I don't believe these children, practicing Catholics, need to be treated as if they were protestants or jewish, etc. They are Roman Catholic and should not feel shunned in their own Church because the Church they are in decides to change the Mass without any approval or directive by Rome. Regardless, will share all thoughts with the parents and hope they can find a way to fix this. You may not want to go, but all things considered holding hands during the Our Father, even if the priest does is NOT the end of the world. What IS of concern to most of us is the disregard the teachers are giving to the children by having them hold hands. If, as a first grader, I did something at school that my parent didn't want for a religious reason...and that I, as a child also felt uncomfortable with, then the instructor should respect that. Their are jewish, athiest and protestant children in my friend's daughter's Catholic school. They are respectful but often choose to sit quietly rather than kneel. The church respect that they are a different religion and doesn't force them into positions that they are not comfortable with EVEN IF IT IS RUBRICS. Not only that, but they often arrange the students boy-girl to avoid problems. I would of died before holding hands with a boy as a 1st grader
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now