Nihil Obstat Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 Interested to hear what you guys think. "The Church is intolerant in principle because she believes; she is tolerant in practice because she loves. The enemies of the Church are tolerant in principle because they do not believe; they are intolerant in practice because they do not love." I heard it sourced to a certain [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reginald_Garrigou-Lagrange"]Fr. Reginald Garrigou-Lagrange[/url], considered by some to be the best 20th century Thomistic theologian/philosopher. [img]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/e1/Garrigou1.jpeg[/img]
Nihil Obstat Posted March 5, 2013 Author Posted March 5, 2013 Sorry about the double post. Had a driver error with the forum.
Era Might Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 (edited) The church was intolerant because it had to hold on to its power. Now that that church has no power, it is quite tolerant (now it wants to hold on to its prestige). Edited March 5, 2013 by Era Might
Era Might Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 I'd draw a distinction between being uncompromising and being intolerant. When you're uncompromising, as the early Christians were, you give yourself up to be burned at the stake. When you're intolerant, you're the one doing the burning.
Nihil Obstat Posted March 5, 2013 Author Posted March 5, 2013 I'd draw a distinction between being uncompromising and being intolerant. When you're uncompromising, as the early Christians were, you give yourself up to be burned at the stake. When you're intolerant, you're the one doing the burning. You know as well as I do that when we talk about the Church we make a distinction between the Church as a divine reality, and the people who make it up. I know you do not believe that anymore, but your criticisms only apply to people.
Era Might Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 You know as well as I do that when we talk about the Church we make a distinction between the Church as a divine reality, and the people who make it up. I know you do not believe that anymore, but your criticisms only apply to people. I'm not sure then who is being referred to as "intolerant in practice"...
Evangetholic Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 This quote is true. I also think the Inquisition was quite a good idea.
Era Might Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 Anyway, I still think the quote takes a rose-colored view of things, though when I read it I thought it said "intolerant" on both sides of the statement.
Nihil Obstat Posted March 5, 2013 Author Posted March 5, 2013 Anyway, I still think the quote takes a rose-colored view of things, though when I read it I thought it said "intolerant" on both sides of the statement. :idontknow: I could say that your statements are unrealistically cynical, and all we would have are a pair of disagreeing opinions.
Era Might Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 (edited) :idontknow: I could say that your statements are unrealistically cynical, and all we would have are a pair of disagreeing opinions. Well of course, but I didn't ask what you think of my opinion, you asked what we think of Garrigou-Lagrange's. :P Edited March 5, 2013 by Era Might
Nihil Obstat Posted March 5, 2013 Author Posted March 5, 2013 (edited) I should have said that I want other Catholics' opinions of it. ;) Nah, seriously though. I do respect your opinions. I just feel that I have almost no common ground with you. We have radically different perspectives on nearly everything. Edited March 5, 2013 by Nihil Obstat
Era Might Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 (edited) Probably not as different as you think. I'm actually quite conventional in my day to day spiritual life. I just have a hard time keeping my mouth shut when a topic comes up that angers me, as matters of a historical and social nature tend to. I get angry because I do care about the church...if I didn't care I would just stop thinking about it. I've been thinking about restricting my Phatmass comments to things of a spiritual nature...I started a thread on Tantum Ergo today, I'm trying! Edited March 5, 2013 by Era Might
Nihil Obstat Posted March 5, 2013 Author Posted March 5, 2013 Probably not as different as you think. I'm actually quite conventional in my day to day spiritual life. I just have a hard time keeping my mouth shut when a topic comes up that angers me, as matters of a historical and social nature tend to. I get angry because I do care about the church...if I didn't care I would just stop thinking about it. I've been thinking about restricting my Phatmass comments to things of a spiritual nature...I started a thread on Tantum Ergo today, I'm trying! Are you considering yourself Catholic right now?
Era Might Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 Are you considering yourself Catholic right now? I never stopped considering myself Catholic, though i don't define that in institutional terms. I'm learning to live on the margins of the church...I don't take much interest in the institution, though in Christ I have never lost my interest.
Nihil Obstat Posted March 5, 2013 Author Posted March 5, 2013 I never stopped considering myself Catholic, though i don't define that in institutional terms. I'm learning to live on the margins of the church...I don't take much interest in the institution, though in Christ I have never lost my interest. I see. But do you believe?
Era Might Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 I see. But do you believe? No, I can't say that I do, but I still pray, I still go to Mass. I've taken a variant of Pascal's Wager...if nothing else, I see religion as the embodiment of human values and struggles, and Christianity is the context in which I seek those values and struggles. I believe in the idea of Christ, if not in the person. Prayer is an orientation in life...whether anyone is actually listening is beside the point for me, though I have not discarded the possibility. The spiritual struggle is a way of being in the world...it is not, to me, dependent on whether the theology is true or not.
Nihil Obstat Posted March 5, 2013 Author Posted March 5, 2013 No, I can't say that I do, but I still pray, I still go to Mass. I've taken a variant of Pascal's Wager...if nothing else, I see religion as the embodiment of human values and struggles, and Christianity is the context in which I seek those values and struggles. I believe in the idea of Christ, if not in the person. Prayer is an orientation in life...whether anyone is actually listening is beside the point for me, though I have not discarded the possibility. The spiritual struggle is a way of being in the world...it is not, to me, dependent on whether the theology is true or not. That is another example of how different our perspectives are. I cannot imagine the faith and the religion not going together. By which I mean that I cannot imagine myself believing in the Church but not being Catholic, or being Catholic but not believing in the Church. If I did not believe Catholicism to be true, I would much rather be Shinto or Zen Buddhist or something. Rofl. And of course that is a conditional statement not meant to be taken seriously in any meaningful way.
Amppax Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 One of my favorite quotes, although I've heard it attributed to someone else, who I can't remember for the life of me.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now