MissyP89 Posted March 4, 2013 Posted March 4, 2013 A question for possible discussion -- Franny, if you want me to make a new thread on this (or want to stop me completely, lest I create a monster that you'll have to deal with) let me know: What do you guys think about gay priests and some of the numbers that get thrown around re: straight and gay priests? The Church typically says being gay/"having SSA" is an impediment to the priesthood. Do you agree? Should priests come out? What could the impact be on the Church if they did? I look at what happens here in the phamily when someone comes out about something tricky, and how often it inspires really great conversations and new freedom to be honest. Sometimes, I think our priests aren't permitted that same honesty. We can be open about struggle, but it seems to me they never can. I wish that weren't the case. Note well before replying: this is NOT a question about abuse or sexual sin of any kind. I'm referring simply to a priest who recognizes he is gay or bi but remains faithful to the Church.
franciscanheart Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 I just made a new thread with your initial post. ;)For the record, the end of my discernment came with my understanding that because I am queer, I can never enter a faithful religious order. I am almost certain the same is true for men who feel called to priesthood. I had to accept that, though I feel called, the Church on earth cannot permit me to live my life in community with other women religious.*queer = queer
Tufsoles Posted March 5, 2013 Posted March 5, 2013 I agree with Franny especially with the theological and several other aspects. Once again I am hoping that a scholar may come down and give some back up.
Papist Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 Instruction Concerning the Criteria for the Discernment of Vocations with regard to Persons with Homosexual Tendencies in view of their Admission to the Seminary and to Holy Orders The candidate to the ordained ministry, therefore, must reach affective maturity. Such maturity will allow him to relate correctly to both men and women, developing in him a true sense of spiritual fatherhood towards the Church community that will be entrusted to him. I see these two qualities being very problematic for a man with homosexual tendencies.
franciscanheart Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 [quote name="Papist" post="2552349" timestamp="1362588210"] [url="http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/ccatheduc/documents/rc_con_ccatheduc_doc_20051104_istruzione_en.html#_ftnref7"]Instruction Concerning the Criteria for the Discernment of Vocations with regard to Persons with Homosexual Tendencies in view of their Admission to the Seminary and to Holy Orders[/url] I see these two qualities being very problematic for a man with homosexual tendencies.[/quote]I don't see how his ability to mature is any different than a heterosexual man, but do not question the Church's ruling on keeping the homosexual population out of the priesthood. Certainly their burden is different, but I do not believe it hinders them from proper maturity.
Papist Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 I don't see how his ability to mature is any different than a heterosexual man, but do not question the Church's ruling on keeping the homosexual population out of the priesthood. Certainly their burden is different, but I do not believe it hinders them from proper maturity. I don't know about this "proper" maturity. But affective maturity makes sense to me.
MissyP89 Posted March 6, 2013 Author Posted March 6, 2013 I can definitely understand why the Church would hold the position she does about gay men entering the priesthood in the first place. The same can be said for women seeking to enter religious life, but that's not the topic for today. I just wonder more about the population of gay men already in the priesthood. Whether or not they should be there, they are there now. I wonder what it would be like if some were to come out as a voice of strength and chastity to GLBT Catholics. I think it could do an immeasurable amount of good. But I also wonder if the Church is more concerned with keeping difficult things quiet in the name of preventing "scandal." Personally, I am for honesty and openness, no matter what the consequences are from the media or the folks in the pews.
franciscanheart Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 I don't know about this "proper" maturity. But affective maturity makes sense to me.I guess I don't see where a homosexual's sexuality has any effect on sex drive. Maybe I misunderstand the point you're attempting to make, but it would seem to me that homosexuals are just as capable of affective maturity as heterosexuals.
PhuturePriest Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 From what I have understood, men with same-sex attraction are allowed to become Priests, but not actively gay men. I could be wrong though. Either way, it would be difficult, but my spiritual director has same-sex attraction (Not openly. Most people don't know, and he's a huge traditionalist) and he's one of the best Priests I have ever known. I don't see why just because he has same-sex attraction that should stop him from being a Priest.
franciscanheart Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 From what I have understood, men with same-sex attraction are allowed to become Priests, but not actively gay men.That's not how I've understood it, but I, also, may be mistaken.
Papist Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 Can a man with homosexual tendencies function as a good priest? Yes. However, looking at the priesthood as a whole, I see the priest has a spousal relationship with the Church and in spiritual paternity. Also he needs to be free of everything that would harm the fruitful exercise of his ministry. The spousal relationship and spiritual paternity are strange to homosexuality and cannot in person nor represent conjugal life and priestly life. This is a counter indication for priesthood for which only men and stable men, mature in their masculinity, have to be call to act in persona Christi. This might be my paradigm of thinking or just my plain ignorance, but I can't get over what I see as inharmoniousness.
Nihil Obstat Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 I have a certain intuition that the best priests would have made the best husbands and fathers, and vice versa. That the same fundamental sacrifices and dispositions are required in each vocation, albeit differently expressed. So if one could not or should not be a husband and father, then he also could not or should not be a priest. I think this follows nicely from the concept in which the Church is the bride of Christ, and a man, when ordained, becomes an alter Christus, effectively 'marrying' the Church.
franciscanheart Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 Can a man with homosexual tendencies function as a good priest? Yes. However, looking at the priesthood as a whole, I see the priest has a spousal relationship with the Church and in spiritual paternity. Also he needs to be free of everything that would harm the fruitful exercise of his ministry. The spousal relationship and spiritual paternity are strange to homosexuality and cannot in person nor represent conjugal life and priestly life. This is a counter indication for priesthood for which only men and stable men, mature in their masculinity, have to be call to act in persona Christi. This might be my paradigm of thinking or just my plain ignorance, but I can't get over what I see as inharmoniousness.Can you expound upon the bold part? This is where we begin to see things differently, though I've no doubt it's my ignorance which causes our division of thought.I also think that homosexual men often are or can be mature in their masculinity. It's not that they're ALL feminine; some are attracted on a deeper / different level to the masculinity they see in others.
franciscanheart Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 I guess what I'm ultimately saying is that I don't think it's fair to classify all homosexual men the same way. They are as varied in their characteristics / maturity / capability as straight men.
Papist Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 Can you expound upon the bold part? This is where we begin to see things differently, though I've no doubt it's my ignorance which causes our division of thought. I also think that homosexual men often are or can be mature in their masculinity. It's not that they're ALL feminine; some are attracted on a deeper / different level to the masculinity they see in others. It is very difficult for me to articulate my thinking here. But the root of it is that the priest/Church relationship is to emulate the Christ/Church spousal relationship and be our spiritual father (fathers have spouses).
MissyP89 Posted March 6, 2013 Author Posted March 6, 2013 Papist...is it that a gay man would somehow be less able to love the Church as his Bride because he's attracted to men? I would contend that everyone is capable of entire self-donation through love. Is it something to do with the Church being mystically viewed as female?
Papist Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 (edited) Me having tendencies towards homosexual acts, would be an impediment to me fulfilling my spousal relationship with my wife. Which would cause harm to me fulfilling my paternal relationships. Also, this is not about the individual person. I am trying speak to the priesthood as a whole. Not a case by case evaluation on each man with homosexual tendencies. Edited March 6, 2013 by Papist
franciscanheart Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 Me having tendencies towards homosexual acts, would be an impediment to me fulfilling my spousal relationship with my wife. Which would cause harm to me fulfilling my paternal relationships. Also, this is not about the individual person. I am trying speak to the priesthood as a whole. Not a case by case evaluation on each man with homosexual tendencies.I see the problem with a homosexual man trying to be sexually intimate with a woman. I do not see, however, the same issues with homosexual men being non-paternal, in the sense of proper relation to children.
beatitude Posted March 6, 2013 Posted March 6, 2013 I just made a new thread with your initial post. ;) For the record, the end of my discernment came with my understanding that because I am qwerty, I can never enter a faithful religious order. I am almost certain the same is true for men who feel called to priesthood. I had to accept that, though I feel called, the Church on earth cannot permit me to live my life in community with other women religious. *qwerty = queer Franciscanheart, I wanted to pick up on this with a point that I never see being raised. Sexuality isn't set in stone. There is some research to suggest that people (especially women) may experience different attractions over the course of their lifespan. For a long time I thought I was asexual, as I never experienced any physical desire for anyone of any sex until I reached the age of twenty-five. Then I found myself attracted to a guy, which has been completely unexpected (and interesting - I have been observing this weird phenomenon in the same way an anthropologist might. :P ). In the same way, a woman who has only ever been attracted to men could theoretically find herself in her mid-thirties feeling attracted to another woman. If she's a nun, what does she do then? How does she deal with it? I don't think it's possible to say, if you're LGBT, stay out of the religious life, because there are no two sharply delineated boxes labelled 'LGBT' and 'straight'. Thinking of sexuality in this restrictive way actually harms our understanding of chastity and what it means to live it, in my view.
PhuturePriest Posted March 7, 2013 Posted March 7, 2013 Can a man with homosexual tendencies function as a good priest? Yes. However, looking at the priesthood as a whole, I see the priest has a spousal relationship with the Church and in spiritual paternity. Also he needs to be free of everything that would harm the fruitful exercise of his ministry. The spousal relationship and spiritual paternity are strange to homosexuality and cannot in person nor represent conjugal life and priestly life. This is a counter indication for priesthood for which only men and stable men, mature in their masculinity, have to be call to act in persona Christi. This might be my paradigm of thinking or just my plain ignorance, but I can't get over what I see as inharmoniousness. So are you saying a man with same-sex attraction shouldn't get married, either? Because there are a lot of great men who love their wives more than anything else in the world who have same-sex attraction.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now